The Supreme Court has decided to rule on whether federal judges can mandate the release of detainees at Guantanamo Bay who represent no terrorist threat into the United States, over objections from the Obama Administration.
The case could set up a major separation of powers battle before the court, which decided more than a year ago that detainees had the right to challenge in federal court their continued detention. But it also might be avoided if the administration finds a way to relocate the prisoners involved in the case, a group of Chinese Muslims known as Uighurs.
The Bush administration agreed that the men, captured in Pakistan and Afghanistan in 2001, were not enemy combatants. However, returning them to their home country would put them at risk of torture.
A federal judge ruled that the 17 prisoners could be released into the United States. But a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District overruled, saying only the legislative and executive branches had the power to exclude or admit foreigners to the country.
The Obama administration had asked the Supreme Court not to review the decision.
This reads more like an immigration case than a civil liberties case. However, the Administration has delayed justice for the Uighurs, preferring to find countries willing to take the remaining detainees instead of allowing them to settle in the US. This has hampered the prospects for closing the prison at Guantanamo within a year, as the President promised. In addition, the remaining Uighurs have essentially been unlawfully imprisoned in contravention of a court order since February.
The last time the Supreme Court agreed to hear a case on Obama’s detention policy, in the case of Ali al-Marri, the White House quickly moved to transfer him to a civilian court, making the case irrelevant. One suspects they will try to swiftly transfer the Uighurs abroad now and pre-empt this case, Kiyemba v. Obama, as well.
A group of retired generals and groups like VoteVets released an ad today calling on Congress to “lift the cloud” hanging over Washington by closing Guantanamo now (they have a petition drive at CloseGitmoNow.org). So there is pressure on both the legislative and executive branches to reach a solution to the Guantanamo problem.
25 Comments
Spotlight



Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Advanced search
Thanks David. A sorry chapter of American history.
End unlawful detentions now.
What new/old tragedies with SCOTUS now impose on the U.S.?
Reid on KO is completely incoherent. Wadda jerk. 86 him. NOW.
What countries will take the Vighur’s How will they live not many countries speak their language so how will they find work? Are we giving them any cash for their years in jail lost wages plus their familes losing a bread winner all those years?
WRT Uigurs, how much tsoris does the U.S. have to impose on them? Perhaps O would like a public flogging, or dunking would satisfy him? Sending Uigers to exhotic locations, when they are in Gitmo only because the stoopid U.S. collared them out of total ignorance, makes me profoundly ashamed of the U.S.
Details Girl don’t leave us hangin!
Agreed but tsoris?
Surely you jest. The whole exercise seems to impose even more punishment on people who, for all we know, were completely innocent from the getgo. It’s the U.S. way.
Sending Uighers to the Balkans? To Pacific Islands? Geez. No shame whatsoever.
Don’t know whether there should or shouldn’t be a PO. Still “under discussion.”
Were the Vighurs even the same religion as Ossama? he is a fundi after all. If not why did we hold them?
tsoris
That just makes what we did worse:(
Learn something new every day helps keep the mind from getting old:)
The Uighurs are central Asian people who are Islamic. The Chinese claim the region to the west of China where the Uighurs live. Persecution by the Chinese is said to be terrible.
You want to learn. I want to bloviate. A marriage made in heaven. :-)
Vighurs belong to the Turkish language subset of the Aryan languages same as German and Iran (Ayran) notice the similarity Change I for A same word even after thousands of years apart.
This language group is mainly between Turkey between Russia and China Proper. I do not think this story wins us any friends in many of the former Soviet States.
Nobody at the State Dept went to Public School and College I take it? This story cannot be playing well there!
I bloviate enough too much on my own but I think we both like to listen and have our ideas be challenged by facts. Face it we both like Fighting:)
What no angry Troll Comments about how Iranians are not Aryans?
I read “Shadow of the Silk Road”, & I believe the Uighurs are considered to be descendants of ancient non-Chinese traders along the Silk Road, when it stretched from the Turkish Mediterranean coast to China. They don’t blend in with the Han Chinese & have been long denied opportunity.
Well not Han Chinese for sure different Language group entirely Chinese in not related to Ayran. I think they found ancient Caucasian graves there maybe red heads can’t remember and the last time they were part of China I think was when Genghis Khan conquered China.
I don’t think they were traders remember the Iranians, Germans Greeks etc they all migrated from somewhere else first the mythical Aryan homeland probably was central Asia.
However there are competing theories mostly racist ones.
Sad when a Mexican and eChan (don’t no your Nationality ) know more than the State Dept experts.
Cognitive Dissonance dismissing out of hand the facts the Trolls don’t like? Come on trolls dig up facts to support your ideas. Its what we do reputable sources only please.
Eli is upstairs!
Keep Me Secret, Keep Me Safe
What a disgrace. Anyone who wonders how FDR could have allowed internment camps–here’s Obama doing it more than 70 years later.