After months of a general hands-off approach in public to members of the Democratic Party who have grumbled and griped about health care reform, the Obama Administration has finally lashed out at one of its own party members for attempting to block the bill.
Not Joe Lieberman, who held up the bill for weeks on the public option.
Not Ben Nelson, who is still threatening a filibuster because of the abortion language.
Not Blanche Lincoln, Jim Webb, Evan Bayh, Mary Landrieu (who’s on board now), or any of the other Senators who have publicly trashed elements of the bill at various points, parts that the White House claimed to support.
No, the first time they use this tactic is to go after unelected public citizen Howard Dean.
Recently, a somewhat perplexing new line of argument has emerged about health insurance reform, with some folks suggesting the Senate bill is a “dream” for insurance companies.
If that’s the case, though, it must be news to them. The insurance industry has been leveraging its considerable resources in a ferocious effort to defeat this bill, including producing a report the day before the Senate Finance Committee vote that was so misleading the firm behind it had to walk away from it. And that’s not surprising, because this bill will finally wrest power away from the insurance industry and put it in the hands of American consumers [...]
It’s also important to remember that, while none of us are shedding any tears for the insurance industry, the primary goal of health insurance reform isn’t to punish insurers – it’s to give every American the ability to find affordable coverage while controlling the unsustainable cost growth in our current health care system that is crushing families and businesses. On that front, this bill is hugely successful. This bill will bring stability and security to people who have insurance and provide affordable options to those who don’t. It will protect against arbitrary insurance company rules and will lower premiums for American families and businesses. And it will take a big chunk out of the national deficit.
You can argue about whether the bill does enough to promote sound insurance company practices, and whether the bill will provide affordable coverage for all Americans (I think it’s incredibly arguable). What you cannot argue is that this is virtually the first instance of the White House attacking a prominent Democrat in public. They did not pressure Joe Lieberman to any degree, according to him. They vociferously denied pressuring Ben Nelson over a military base in his state.
But Dean caused the White House great displeasure. Not because he was actively working as a member of the US Senate to undermine what were described as key priorities in the health care bill, but because he was stating his opinion on the legislation after the fact, in a way that could deny the President his “win” on health care.
I’m assuming Russ Feingold is next.
“This bill appears to be legislation that the president wanted in the first place, so I don’t think focusing it on Lieberman really hits the truth,” said Feingold. “I think they could have been higher. I certainly think a stronger bill would have been better in every respect.”
The President didn’t leverage Democrats working against his stated policy, one has to conclude, because they weren’t working against his policy in any substantive way. They were facilitating it.




6 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I get the impression that many Democrats like Paul Krugman and Paul Starr think that health care reform will be an election maker-or-breaker for 2010 and 2012. So they are probably thinking that if the health care bill doesn’t pass, no matter how worthless it is, the Dems will lose control of Congress and, more importantly, the White House. But to me, since the health care bill, as it now stands, is so flimsy that it isn’t worth the paper it’s written on, it isn’t worth passing. It won’t do anything to rein in costs or improve health care. It has turned out to be nothing more than one big giveaway to PhRMA and Big Insurers. If anything, it should be called an anti-reform bill!
Keep in mind, though, many Democrats, unlike ones like myself, will continue to vote for Democrats, even if the Democratic Party moves so far to the Right that the Left is left party-less. I suppose one can argue that a progressive such as myself should remain a Democrat in order to make sure that abortion stays legal, prayer stays out of schools, and God stays out of science and government. But to me, such issues are a drop in the bucket compared to all of the enormous issues surrounding the economy and war. So I’m either going to go party-less or join a party that is both anti-Wall Street and anti-war.
It’s now clear the White House is committed to a slow political suicide, but if they keep this up, it’ll be a fast suicide. Dean is the biggest obstacle to Obama’s re-election – all he has to do is enter the primary and the Democratic party will be split beyond repair.
Dean is a politicans worst nightmare because he walks his talk. He has a strong yankee sense of fairness and is not interested in politics that undermine the lives of regular people. Dean got the party into real focus and created the force that gave democrats their last election wins. If they go after him for demanding an honest health care bill then they are really fools. I guess in the next election democrats can only blame themselves as they are trying to kill the messenger. By the way when did obama’s press secretary get all this wisdom that entitles him to trash Dean.
Leave Howard Dean alone. I want him to be president. He is a BRAVE man to go against the mafia and stand tall to tell us that we are getting screwed. The Obama maladministration and the traitorous senators need to scapegoat for lying Lieberman and their own sell out- $$$$$$-you can’t hide- you are bad for us.
Thank you Howard Dean. Hero. Guts. You are a credit to our people and the medical establishment. I wish Paul Wellstone were here. I wish Robert Kennedy Junior would speak. Who will lead us out of this hell?
I am ready to see that happen–split and all.
Obama is weak. Kill the bill