Yes, it’s from the Washington Examiner, but it happens to be pretty factual (via Digby):
During the presidential primary, in the spring of 2008, Obama ran a campaign ad aimed directly at Tauzin, chief executive officer of the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America. In the ad, titled “Billy,” Obama tells a small gathering of seniors:
“The pharmaceutical industry wrote into the prescription drug plan that Medicare could not negotiate with drug companies. And you know what, the chairman of the committee who pushed the law through went to work for the pharmaceutical industry making $2 million a year. Imagine that. That’s an example of the same old game-playing in Washington. I don’t want to learn how to play the game better. I want to put an end to the game-playing.”
But Obama has played the game, and Tauzin was one of the first players he picked for his team. White House visitor logs show that between Feb. 4 and July 22, Tauzin visited his office an average of once every 15 days — about as frequently as Tauzin probably collects that generous paycheck candidate Obama derided. We don’t know how often Tauzin visited after July, because of the ad hoc nature of White House visitor log releases.
You can see the ad to your right.
There’s a lot of talk from defenders of the President about how every campaign breaks a promise or two when they get in office, and nobody voted for Barack Obama because he was going to televise health care negotiations on C-SPAN. But if there’s anything Obama ran as, it was as a reformer. He ran explicitly to “change the game” and not “play it better.” Yet everything in this health care deal represents a playing of the game better than past efforts, basically by buying off stakeholders and creating compromises favorable to their bottom lines. Every single thing.
If you want to understand why progressives who have been following the ins and outs of this debate are depressed about the health care bill and about the Obama Presidency in general, watch that ad again. That was the campaign. “I may not know enough about the ways of Washington, but I know that the ways of Washington must change.” He sold himself as an open government, reform-oriented candidate untainted by lobbyist money or influence. He continues to sell himself that way, actually. And the disconnect, as many have called it, is simply staggering.
Here’s what Digby had to say:
Aside from the policy implications, which we already had to swallow, the political problem the Democrats have bought for themselves with this are huge. It would be different if Obama hadn’t explicitly run on a clean government platform and if the Republicans weren’t blatantly hypocritical opportunists. But he did and they are and this is powerful mojo that plays into the hands of the tea partiers and Republicans.
I can’t get over the administration’s sheer political malpractice in handling this populist mood in the country. I don’t know if they all convinced themselves that they were political magicians and therefore the rules don’t apply to them or what, but Democrats should have known that after having turned the phrase “culture of corruption” into their mantra, they would be particularly vulnerable to appearances of impropriety (not to mention actual impropriety.) Bad, bad move.
Those who are trying to write this off as something “every politician does” simply fails to acknowledge this disconnect and how it’s playing in not only the activist community, but the larger population. If you’re going to cut the same deals with the same people, don’t run a campaign on hope, and expect those same people who responded to that message to be gleeful about the consequences. That would be the lesson.




45 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
When campaign promises are only used to to win office and the incumbent upon assuming office shows a clear disdain for the voting constituency who elected him it is long past time to not only withdraw support for the candidate but time to work in opposition to him and the congress that supports his agenda .
The lesser of two evils approach is now shown for what it is , a flimsy scam .It is the definition of crazy to repeat the same behavior endlessly and expect different results . The Democrats in the House negotiating the final touches on their “reform” should be told unequivocally that voting for this bill will lose them their seats come November !
Thanks. This is the best, most succinct summary I have seen about why we on the left feel betrayed. Liberals aren’t starry-eyed purists. We know a certain amount of horse-trading is necessary, & compromise is inevitable, but when a politician completely abandons his campaign rhetoric, almost as if he never said it, we’d be idiots if we didn’t squawk.
The PhRMA deal was the most underhanded bit of chicanery in the healthcare debacle, but it is scarcely the only one. The Administration’s Bush-on-Steroids position on suspected “enemy combatant”‘s rights is appalling & its pro-bank economic policy is the best encouragement the teabaggers have — today’s Bloomberg article (which that creep Darrell Issa, of all people, made public) revealed that it was Geithner & the New York Fed that kept secret AIG’s 100% payments to Goldman Sachs, et al.
I hope the press constantly throws his own campaign statements in Obama’s face. At some point, he’s got to cop to the fact that he lies like, well, a Republican.
The Constant Weader at http://www.RealityChex.com
Thanks David.
The truth sucks. I dont like that “candidate obama” puts “president obama” to shame, but thats the truth and there it is. I dont acccept the Usual cynical apopolgia the everyone does it (run left rules right) crap either because so many people voted for obama to be different and better.whether he will admit it or not and here is one more piece of proof.
Progressives have been dissed and abused. We all read it, say it and breathe it every day. The question is what do we do? The Obama team is banking that we will support them in the end because they are “not the other guys.” They are the other guys. I propose that the progressive wing of the Democratic party STAY home in 2010. Let Obama see how far he gets with his blue dog and Republican soul mates.
O/T but related to what a fucking sack of Cheney that Obama is turning out to be:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/01/07/geithners-new-york-fed-to_n_414449.html
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2010/01/geithners-dubious-aig-cover-up.html
Geither must not only be fired, but he must be indicted for securities fraud as well.
Otherwise Obama can take ‘Rule of Law’ and shove it up his Change-hole.
Hiring the sleazy lobbyist you ran campaign ads against is a pretty clear sign that Obama certainly never was serious about reforming the health care system. It’s also a sign that Obama is not particularly honest in general. He knows who Billy Tauzin is if I know who Billy Tauzin is and I do. And if Tauzin is making twice-monthly trips to the White House it isn’t it to meet with Bo, the White House dog.
Tauzin’s name and picture belong on the Post Office wall, not the White House visitors logs.
I couldn’t be more dissapointed.
Ok, I have to ask, has anyone checked to see if Jim Guckert’s/Jeff Gannon’s name is on the visitor’s list?
Orahma is a liar, I’m shocked… not.
Pelosi on “campaign promises“(politico):
George W. Bush was the “Decider.” Barak Obama is the “Charlatan.”
If you want to change the world; stay at home, write emails, and sign petitions, – yup. /s
Obama & Right-wing Democrats are about to stagger into a blazing crossfire of left and right anger. And, unfortunately, Rahm will probably ride into the sunset, back to Chicago, instead of being publicly tarred and feathered.
“The disconnect”? Do you mean “the continuing cynical exploitation of the rubes”?
It is a grave miscalculation on their part. I am done. No more support in a way shape form or fashion. Perhaps when people turn away in mass he will get it. At this point I don’t hold out any hope. This bushesque manuever by Orahma is the last straw.
I’ve posted about this ad several times on FDL… there are lots of youtubes out there showing clear campaign promises that Obama has violated…
this is one of the more egregious given that the WH negotiated directly with Tauzin during the spring sellout of the middle class to PhRMA…
It’s fucking amazing.
And why is there not more coverage of the financial reform bill that just passed Congress that is a complete sellout to the “fat cats”?? That one seems to just be slipping under the radar while all eye are on “healthcare reform.”
And apparently Obama and his admin orchestrated many of the last minute giveaways in the “reform” bill.
A Dem rep, Hinchey, is putting a separate bill before the house to re-instate Glass Steagall… which should have been one of the first things Obama did.
It is mind-boggling.
I have actually been writing about financial reform quite a lot. The Senate hasn’t produced a bill, and as we all know, nothing exists in Washington unless the Senate acts on it.
BEAM ME UP! Former Rep. JIM TRAFICANT for president in 2012. Why? because the American people are feed up and pissed off just like Jim is!! You read it here first.
And “an end to the game plan” will happen when?
Mr. Techno-Savvy Obama left all this evidence around. Tsk tsk.
Poetic justice?
I agree. I’ve always believed that voting was important but now I see sometimes we have no other alternative but to basically say none of the above and just stay away. I’ve been a loyal Dem. party member for 40+ yrs. have worked , gave and voted straight party line. Not anymore. Obama has really pissed me and my family off with his disingenuous BS. Its over the dems. want my $$ , time and vote then friggin deliver or forget about me and mine.
Yes, David… your work has been fantastic… what I meant is that it’s not hitting the newspapers or new shows with any big push… but perhaps it’s because it’s gone only through the House… but based on HCR, it will only get worse in the Senate.
Thanks for what you do…
I came across this video when I was thinking of making a video montage of all of Obama’s campaign promises and was blown away by it.
At that point, I got too depressed to make the montage.
Rahm made his deals and his nest is feathered forever no matter what he does. He’s a slimy weasel that one, but Obama hired him so what does that say about him? Not very much.
Obama is owned by and a mere tool of Wall Street and Corporate oligarchs.
It’s shameful.
We need a real progressive to run in 2012.
High time for a third party. Personally, I like the Greens, but there are probably other possibilities. Maybe a narrow platform like the Pirate Party. The fed-up on the right are hung up on abortion, socialism, climate change denial, etc, so it’ll be tricky to find a common ground, but it has to happen. A lot of stuff is going critical.
The shame of it is that he could have accomplished so much. He had an election victory that carried a tremendous amount of momentum and good will. He had the worst president in American history to follow on from and with that he had a strong desire from a pretty strong majority to cleanse the White House and bring the sins to light. And yet he has managed to squander it all by making sordid deals with discredited businesses such as the Pharmaceuticals, Insurance, Banks and, among others, Hallibuton through subsidiaries. Firms that have robbed the American people blind for years and will continue to do so as long as we coddle them.
That he is an utter failure as a president in the eyes of many of us that had thought he would at least keep one promise, maybe health care reform, or even closing Guantanimo, should not be a surprise as long as we keep the present system of elections in place. Unlimited sums of money allows for the total prostitution of candidates for political office at even the state and local level. The touted American system of democracy is a sham and a bust. We are told for whom to vote and when too many people disobey the balloting is rigged.
Obama is a product of our system and like any other product he can be bought and sold. …and has been.
Maybe we should all vote for Palin since she’s a real outsider that will ruffle feathers!
Obama is an “honest politician.” As Senator Cameron once stated, over 150 years ago,”An honest politician is one who, when he is bought, will stay bought.” His financial future is assured.
i’m starting to wonder if the Obama presidency is going to make me feel worse then the previous one.
at least bush never got my hopes up.
If he’s lucky Obama will go down as the Democratic version of Calvin Coolidge. More than likely he’ll be the Dems Herbert Hoover. At his point if, heaven forbid, there is some sort of national calamity I don’t see the nation rallying around this guy. If anything there will be an outcry for his resignation. He is either conflict adverse (don’t believe there are any core convictions to fight for), in the pockets of entrenched moneyed interests or is in way over his head, any of which is ominous for a “leader.”
So, next election the Dems will vote Republican as a protest and the “lesser of 2 evils” and the Republicans will continue to vote Republican. A Republican will get elected and behave exactly as any Democrat would because he works for the same people, the big corporations. Bottom line: it doesnt pay to vote for a Dem or a Repug. Vote for a third party and watch the corporate media squirm a little.
If he wanted to make corporate deals, why not push for medicare-for-all and then increase medicare rates? Increase NIH funding for pharmaceuticals? Basically destroy insurers and bribe everybody else with their profits.
There are ways to be corrupt and still accomplish good things – we now have the worst of both worlds.
Rahm may be a foul mouthed ass, but the buck stops with Obama. It is up to him to direct the debate and make clear what he will sign and what he won’t and what he has done so far and signaled is complete betrayal. Obama is the one that has sold out his voters. The GOP hates him because they hate everyone that is not far right GOP. The left no longer supports him because he is every bit as much a traitor as Lieberman. The Blue Dogs tolerate him, but many of them are racists underneath and would stab him in the back whenever it suits them. For a smart guy, it’s really hard to think just where he thinks his support is going to come from. The Obama voter is going the way of the polar bear.
Why anybody thought this guy was progressive in any way is a shocker to me. People just poured their hopes and dreams into this corporate whore without examining where his money was coming from or how he was being marketed.
Didn’t you notice every time you turned on your computer and went to your home page, Obama’s face was in the right hand margin of your screen sending a subliminal message to vote for him? It didn’t matter if it was AOL or MSNBC or Yahoo or google, etc. his face was always there right up through election day.
Do you really think college students making small Internet donations paid for that shit?????
Didn’t you notice that all the major corporate networks were in the tank for him, the very same networks who sold us George Bush and the Iraq war? Even Bill O’Rielly warmed up to him. Didn’t you notice that CNN and others gave Obama unfettered air-time every weekend all day long, while bashing Clinton and McCain and Palin? Clinton was denied any air time to defend herself while pundits on both CNN and MSNBC bashed her relentlessly, primarily using misogynistic stereotypes to do so. McCain also was only given limited air-time and most of that was via FOX.
Didn’t you notice that Obama’s campaign used guilt-tripping tactics about racism to gain white progressive votes? Didn’t you notice his contempt for the working class? Didn’t you hear Donna Brazil tell the working class that the “new democratic party” didn’t need or want them and that the “new creative class” of the wealthy, well educated and well connected was all Obama needed?
Didn’t it bother you that the 4th and 8th largest states in the country were arbitrarily disenfranchised during the primaries by the democratic party w/out any credible reason? Regardless of what you thought of Clinton, what about voting rights? Didn’t it bother you even a little that a so-called 50 state strategy employed by the DNC, so brazenly was willing to disenfranchise its own democratic voters from those states? Why wasn’t it clear then that big money had high-jacked the democratic party?
I’ve been a liberal who votes democratic all my life. I am well educated and I am middle class. I come from a poor and working class mixed race family who were part of the FDR democratic coalition. What bothers me the most about Obama and his “new democratic party” is their contempt for the little people and his brazen lies about it. I didn’t vote for him, and no I did not vote for McCain. After the primaries, I voted green. I had already come to the conclusion that the banksters, corporations, and the military industrial complex owned Obama. Apparently, they decided that he was a better puppet than Clinton or McCain would have been. But never the less, I blame my fellow progressives for failing to do their research, and for allowing themselves to be swept up by the obvious marketing scheme that has resulted in this disaster named Barack Obama.
And by the way, have you heard a peep from this guy about rolling back the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy to help pay for health care? NO!!! And you won’t, even though he campaigned on it. Instead, he’ll tax the middle class and force us all to buy private unregulated health insurance. Just more Bush like looting of the American workers for his WEALTHY CREATIVE, BANKSTER. INSURANCE CLASS!!!!!!! What we have my friends is BUSH’S 3rd term in Barack Obama!!!!!
How do you know when Barry is lying? His lips are moving. Just another of his many lies that progressive elites will tell us to ignore bcz he really is working for us. We are simply childish in believing that Obama wld be able to keep his campaign prblms or even fight for them. Besides he is much better than Bush, so ignore his lies and continue to support the man and his party anyway. Bcz after all he cld be a republican. I cant wait to hear his concession speech in 2012.
…exposed again.
ho ho, you don’t have to be a magician to retain the loyalty of the (D) captured Netroots – you just have run under the flag of the blue Donkey!
after all – Repubs are bad and scary! neener neener! that’s not gonna change – and you cannot vote for 3rd Party or (I) candidates, Election 2000, QED, that’s not gonna change – and you can always convince your own self that microscopic, infinitesimal policy variances combined with stylistic and marketing differences make them The Party of the Least Worst! – that’s not gonna change!
the likes of Digby and Jane Hamsher will never work to defeat their preferred Legacy Party, so their protestations, especially in odd-numbered years, can be brusquely ignored.
Obama and Rahma share one fatal trait: hubris, arrogance so extreme as to be delusional. President Pinnochio has made a calculated assessment that the GOp can’t put up a candidate that will beat him, and that the Dems will, albeit reluctantly, again vote for the lesser of two evils. Boy, are he and Rahm in for a surprise! Can you say, “primary opponent”? Dean? Dorgen? ABO (Anybody but Obama)?
Interestingly, the supporters of Obama keep defending him even though he cast them away in favor of the insiders once he was elected. Like the Bush supporters, they somehow refuse to acknowledge that they were punked or duped, but eventually, they will. It took Bush supporters 8 years, however.
Yes people did vote for him because he said the negotiations would be on C Span. It meants no more lobbyists writing these types of bills. He lied worse than Bush. He is worse than Bush. I knew he would be worse than Bush. And the people who attacked us who gave reasons why he would be worse than Bush should be investigated by this BLOG. I wrote about 0bama and who he was. And then was attacked like I had called him the N word, and every other epithet know to civilized people. I would like FDL to do an investigation of the commenters who attacked with such vitriol and insanity to people who just argued for Hillary, or against 0bama. I think this site, along with others were taken over by paid 0bama trolls. Only you could check out the IP addresses and see who commented and how many commented before the fall of 2007 and since the election of the corrupt 0bama. I mthink it wopuld be a very interesting exercise in how these trolls astroturfed this site and others to get their corrupt candidate in. Bush stole the 2000 and 2004 election and 0bama stole the primary. It sticks in my craw and this site and this country will never again be able to regain its footing until this is examined and acknowledged.
It’s better understood that Obama is the “Seducer.”
A charlatan is more of a straight-up liar overselling his abilities, whereas seduction – playing on the hopes and manipulating the emotions of the victim to get what one wants – is the hallmark of Obama.
It’s “I promise not to cum in your mouth, baby” applied to the whole nation.
“The O’bamboozler”
Obama Warns SC Voters Of “Hoodwinking,” “Bamboozling,” And “Okey Doke”
digg Huffpost – Obama Warns SC Voters Of “Hoodwinking,” “Bamboozling,” And “Okey Doke”
First Posted: 01-24-08 09:24 AM
Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., warned a Sumter, South Carolina crowd against the “hoodwinking,” “bamboozling” and “okey doke” by people in other campaigns.
“Don’t be confused when you start hearing a whole bunch of this negative stuff. Those are the same old tricks. They’re trying to bamboozle you. It’s the same old okey doke……Don’t let people turn you around because they’re just making stuff up! That’s what they do. They try to bamboozle you…. to hoodwink you!”
Read the whole story: Political Radar
Well, I guess it takes a bamboozler to know a bamboozler….
If one understands the nature of projection (where a person or a group attributes to others attributes they’re unable to accept about themselves), then it’s been very easy to understand what’s coming from both Bush and Obama. They consistently explain just what they themselves are going to do, and then also explain exactly how to stop them – but because they’re projecting they believe they’re speaking about some imaginary “other.”
Bush warned us all about how the world was full of brutal dictators who hate freedom, and needed to be resisted. That was clearly a good description of himself, and also the exact action we should have taken – against him.
Obama talks about “they” want to “bamboozle” and “hoodwink” us. And in this case our path to victory is “don’t be confused when you start hearing a whole bunch of this negative stuff” (remarkably prescient advice for how to react to their response to Jane’s push to kill the “health” bill and investigate Rahm) and “don’t let people turn you around because they’re just making stuff up. That’s what they do.”
And if one wants to take this a step further, one can look at the things about which a person or country get defensive. We again trust Obama to tell us the real truth about himself by looking at what he chooses, of all things, to defend against:
“There’s nothing false about it, it’s no fairy tale.”
It’s just like when a player tells the naive girl at the bar “I wouldn’t lie to you, baby.” It’s because that’s exactly what he’s doing.
No, they are not the ‘other guys’. They are worse than the other guys because the other guys make no pretenses about what they are up to. You know going in what you have with the Republicans. The public was sold a bill-of-goods and now the administration is laboring under the delusion that they’ll get away with it again for a second term. Meanwhile, Democrats up for re-election in the mid-terms, and in general, are going to wind up taking it in the shorts because of the White House shenanigans.
And the sad and tragic thing is this: A rare point in history to fundamentally change things for the better in so many ways was squandered. In the process, the country was systemically and brutally Butt-Effed.