I just got off the phone with Anthony Weiner, who stirred things up during the debate on repealing the insurance industry’s anti-trust exemption with a pretty glorious call-out speech calling Republicans a wholly owned subsidiary of the insurance industry. During the conversation, he acknowledged that the strategy for actually passing a comprehensive health care bill remained fuzzy, saying “I’m not sure what we’re doing, and I’m pretty tied in.”
Asked by FDL News about the outburst and why he felt it was important to make that known, Weiner explained that there is a “contest of ideas” going on within the Democratic Party. “Some think that, like the unicorn, we’ll discover bipartisanship on health care reform. Some of us believe this is not going to be solved with Republican help. So we need to call them out for what they are.” Republicans were actually trying to get away with the idea that repealing the exemption wasn’t doing enough to introduce competition in the insurance market, and Weiner simply said that his B.S. meter on their concern about that “goes into Spinal Tap neighborhood”.
Weiner didn’t get an invite to tomorrow’s health care summit, but he’ll be watching and even live-blogging the proceedings, he told me. He found its utility limited. “If we want to spend hours tomorrow highlighting bankruptcy of GOP ideas, fine. But we mustn’t delude ourselves. When we gave up public option, we didn’t get a single Republican. When we gave up national exchanges for a state exchange, we didn’t get a single Republican. We keep negotiating with ourselves.” If the summit is meant to contrast the two parties on the issue, Weiner was fine with it, but if it was seen as an opportunity to convert Republicans to the cause of fixing health care, he advised, “Good luck with that.”
I wanted to know from someone who has been in the room for these discussions whether he thought the votes were actually there to pass the bill, regardless of what fixes could be made in reconciliation. Eric Cantor’s memo today certainly suggested otherwise, as have multiple news reports. I asked flat-out, does this thing have the votes?
Weiner replied, “Well, we passed the bill once.” Obviously, he said, the abortion language was a concern, and he admitted, “I don’t know how it gets resolved.” He reiterated the constant dynamic of dropping things like the public option, which he thinks has majority support in the House and Senate and among 72% of the American people, and getting nothing in exchange. In the final analysis, he said, “I’m not sure what we’re doing, and I’m pretty tied in.”
Finally, I asked Weiner about Kent Conrad’s comments, that the House would have to pass the Senate bill first before any changes could be made through reconciliation. He said, “The House has been passing bills on spec for quite some time. I think the record speaks for itself. I don’t know that senate can be trusted to do just about anything, let alone get reconciliation right.” He likes that Obama’s plan was released to work as a 51-vote plan instead of a 60-vote one, and said that if Conrad didn’t like it, he could vote no on it and explain that to his constituents.
The problem with that, I said, is that Conrad is the chair of the Budget Committee, and would be intimately involved in the reconciliation process.
“There is that,” he said. Weiner circled back to today’s vote on repealing the anti-trust exemption. “We’re not going to wait for 60. Waiting for Senate to act has been like waiting for godot. The House is not going to do it anymore.”



32 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Good for Weiner! Can we clone him, please!
This does not sound like they have a good strategy for moving forward.
Obama, Robert Gibbs, and David Axelrod, now know the control of the Dem party slipping away from them.
Weiner statement and his willing to critize the current white house and senate dems show that the only thing cold in DC is not the snow.
Obama made a huge mistake, I mean huge mistake, trying to govern from the Corporate Point of View, (the middle if you watch and listen to the MSM)
News out of the White House today is Obama, Robert Gibbs, David Axelrod, gearing up for 2012. The BIG QUESTION is can OBAMA run as a Moderate Republican in 2012? The answer is NO.
Smart House Dems will run from this white house quickly.
Super Smart House Dems will run against the Obama white house, ie Howard Dean is already running to the left of this Republican White House.
Good Luck with Tea Party Obama, they may support you as their candidate once you convince them you are American.
Ummm … check it:
“The Unemployed Now Have Their Own Union, and It’s Catching on Quickly”
http://www.alternet.org/economy/145797/the_unemployed_now_have_their_own_union%2C_and_it%27s_catching_on_quickly
“Exposing the Great American Bubble Barons: Join Us in the Investigation”‘
http://www.alternet.org/investigations/145735/exposing_the_great_american_bubble_barons%3A_join_us_in_the_investigation
Here’s video of Jim Himes telling a great Anthony Weiner story.
Rep. Jim Himes On Rep. Anthony Weiner Talking to President Obama about Single Payer
“We keep negotiating with ourselves.”
Not Weiner in particular, but rather it is the likes of Obama and others who cut deals with corporate lobbyists behind closed doors and then use the Republicans as cover. Weiner is going to have to wake up and see that Republicans aren’t the only ones owned and once he does things become much more clear and make sense. For those in charge this isn’t about passing good HCR, but rather delivering corporatist legislation to show the corporate lobbyists who the politicians are really working for.
Thanks David! That was very informative.
It sounds like the Dems are leaderless as well as stupid.
It is hard to imagine that some Dems are still thinking they can get Republicans to play ball. And to have no game plan at this point after a year of work is pretty pathetic. No wonder things are so screwed up.
Anthony Weiner, one of the last sane people in a Congress full of lunatics.
Good Post,
Green Glennwald basically told us the truth about the White House and the Senate Dems, they are on the same team as the Republicans
Weiner Obama is not on your Team.
After Much Reflection
I have to believe The Obama’s “Bipartisanship” is an excuse for not getting things done that would displease his corporate masters, and to give him an opportunity to point at Rs or Ds and say “bbbbbut, but, but…. they wouldn’t do it”
There’s more to this than simply being on the same team as Republicans. Axelrod and Plouffe were going to personally benefit financially from the Pharma deal via the advertising contract:
http://techpresident.com/node/16255/
- Tom
well that sure is stinky
You’re exactly right, the “bipartisanship” BS is just cover for implementing the DLC corporatist agenda. What a disappointment he has been. But the worst part of it is that Obama and his team in the WH seem to believe the public, and especially Democratic voters, are too stupid to see this. These guys are waaay off base – I keep thinking they will wake up and smell the disaster facing them but it never happens. Are they using tarot cards instead of pollsters at the WH now?
On HCR, Democrats have been fighting with themselves and losing more and more each step of the way.
Congressman Weiner, you’re obviously as frustrated by all this bs as are most Americans. Please stop trying to figure out what the party leadership is doing. Please step forward and lead the debate.
Saying that efforts at bipartisanship is bs isn’t the answer.
Rather than sit around tomorrow live-blogging the bs event, find some cameras to get in front of and announce that you will vote against any bill that does not include a public option, that you will vote against any bill that has state exchanges instead of a national exchange, etc.
Take a stand. Call on others to join you. Get Kucinich and others to join you in front of the cameras if you can.
The fact is that private insurers want to continue profiting from our sickness and death. They know that the current situation is unsustainable as much as we do. They need something to change more than the American people do. So why are we all acting like they hold all the cards? Why are we all acting like we need them more than they need us?
If you stand firmly in favor of real reform, they’ll have to accept it if they want to continue making money off us.
Congressman Weiner, I agree wholeheartedly with this post. The time to take a stand is NOW. PLEASE consider doing just that. It is very clear to a certain portion of the population that White House, the POTUS (and his team), plus many so-called “Democratic” Senators are simply bought off by the corporations.
President Obama ran a disingenuous campaign, and it’s beyond clear that BHO had no intention of even attempting to live up to almost any of his campaign rhetoric or promises. Many of us were skeptical going to the polls but willing to give it a shot (what were our options?). But the time to question the validity of anything even remotely “bipartisan” with the current Republicans is beyond stupidity… IMO it’s a complete dereliction of your duty to your constituents.
I applaud you for your honesty and what appears to be some morals and values. I hope that you can stay grounded and continue on your current path, but I strongly and fervently urge to take a very public stand on this. Gather around you those like Kucinich and Grayson who might be willing also to stand up for what 70% of the US population wants.
We are beyond sick and tired of watching corporate-bought and owned politicans in Wash DC selling our nation down the river.
Thank you for your support and good luck.
It continues to amaze me how often votes are (sort of) counted, but without there ever really being a real vote.
Reminds me of the torture/detainee trials. We must know the outcome in advance, before we can know how to proceed.
Why not just proceed with an actual voting process?
Then we’ll finally know who to praise and who to blame.
long overdue that we adopt an overall, embracing mantra-rallying cry to hold obama and senate dems accountable: Demand they STAND AND DELIVER rather than wax prolific about the nebulous urgency of now.
Yes, this is correct. But I do not believe for a minute that it is his mistake: This is Obama, CEO of the United States.
With the supreme court transfer of ownership of the government to corporations, expect the situation to get much, much worse for the majority of Americans.
It’s been over a year of talk, talk, talk with heath reform. Tens of thousands have died, tens of thousands have gone bankrupt.
But a corporate state has no compassion for people, only profit. It’s been a very nice and profitable delay for the insurance industry, hasn’t it? And Wall Street profits, too, because insurance corporations invest in stocks…to get more profit.
America’s “In God We Trust” motto should be replaced with “In Idolatry of Money We Trust.” It’s chilling to think what this country has descended into.
Obama has been absolutely clear about what he wants for HCR as stated in his proposal so let’s stop scratching our heads in wonderment. So Weiner is wrong to be at a loss about what the plan is at least as it refers to Obama.
Obama wants to allow the monopolized private insurers to continue making profits and in fact wants to force the public to transfer more of its money to these private insurer’s profits. That is what he has said in his proposal.
We on the left reject this and so does the majority of the country. So at least on this point let’s not continue to show confusion. The man is telling us what he wants by his deeds.
Since we are diametrically opposed to this let’s make clear the grounds of our objection to him and make a commitment to not give him our future support in the polls.
I am with Weiner on this,the health care summit is pure BS for TV,
Not one single GOP will vote for HCR.
It’s another giant watse of time by the Prez.
but he likes to talk,so maybe he sees some good
in it for him.
Thanks for the kind words. I’ll keep fighting for the public option, but I need your help.
The Republicans are wholly-owned by the insurance companies, but as for me and my campaign, we’re wholly-owned by grassroots Democrats.
To prove it, I’m organizing 2,000 donors to show that the people willing to stand up for the people and against the special interests will always be rewarded. Join this “moneybomb” today.
Click here to make a contribution and fight with me for the public option. Even as little as $5 from you will help make our voices heard.
I’ve been saying all along – We have to stop making concession after concession to win Republican votes. We haven’t won over a single person from the other side.
That’s why I’m so pessimistic about tomorrow’s health care summit. We know the Republicans won’t bring any real ideas for reform.
But just in case the Republicans thought they could tap dance their way through the summit without getting called on their baloney, I’m going to be live-blogging all day at countdowntohealthcare.com.
What a read David, and thanks again.
Sigh, if WEINER is just figuring this out, and is confused as to how, where and WHY it’s going, we truly ARE doomed.
@19, GONALB, nice comment. Our rhetoric however must be a become a bit more inflamed and public, in the streets en masse, in an ongoing basis. Non violent, of course. But the bodies alone will pressure, and force SOME adjustments to we the people . . .
The polls that Ruth Calvo broke down, and Mz. Hamsher posted below, along with some other polls and analyses I’ve seen today make it pretty obvious . . . 65% of the nation want a public option that delivers nationally for anyone who wants in.
If we the people lose this one, the corps (after the Supremre Ruling) marriage to our government and elected officials will be unbeatable.
Agreed that Obama has betrayed us with his corporatist bipartisanship meme. But the guy has some smarts, doesn’t he? I can’t believe the WH is not going to make a hard left turn after tomorrow. Perhaps wishful thinking on my part. My only evidence/argument is that if they don’t end the bipartisanship crap and tack hard left immediately, the D’s are going to get absolutely annihilated in November, notwithstanding how bad and bifurcated the R’s are. Passing a corporatist HCR bill with a mandate and no PO or MFA will guarantee, not preclude the slaughter.
What have I been saying for the last two months?
Stop worrying about what happens at the Federal level, your not going to like it, you can’t make lemonade out of it, just forget it.
Start locally in your own State get a movement for Single Payer.
For the 3rd time California will bring a law to the Governor’s desk that will give all Californians health care insurance, you know Universal Coverage?
The PO will not DO THAT, not even close.
So instead of coming to FDL to complain, you have two choices -
Move to a state with a Single payer movement or beg your reps to pass a bill with a PO, knowing it won’t do what you want it to do.
TomR thanks for the information.
David Axelrod, David Plouffe, it is going to be hard to run against the Bush Adminstration when yours is worse.
again thanks for the info TomR
David Axelrod and David Plouffe are trying to sell out the progressive movement for Pharma Advertising Contract.
“…Moderate Republican in 2012…”
The red wine spurted up my nose and barely missed the keyboard. Nicely done.
Moderate Republicans became extinct in 1994.
“Weiner is going to have to wake up and see that Republicans aren’t the only ones owned”
Weiner woke up to that long ago. I don’t see any evidence that Weiner is unaware that the White House and significant numbers of House and Senate Dems are owned. Weiner is one smart and savvy knife fighter that i would like to see in a ring with Rahm.
Weiner needs to call Rahm out.
The word from the street is that Obama is finished.
It started with his reluctance to go after anyone criminally in the Bush Presidency. It continued with the TARP bailouts, the post tarp financial reforms I mean lack thereof, and now, with his failure to include public option in Health Care reform. The people I talk voted for his presidency and are disappointed to say the least, some are downright disgusted. It seems Tavis Smiley was right when during the Michael Moore interview he said Obama has sold out.
Here’s my take, the Obama team fell for the Trojan Horse that is represented by Bipartisanship. That false choice was first floated by Republicants (sic) after the election who realized their golden goose was dead and buried.
Who gives a %^&*@#$ about bipartisanship? Only the guys who aren’t cooperating, as it’s a way to exert leverage they literally don’t control.
As for “negotiating with yourself” this is a basic problem as old as rugs. A rug merchant never lowers his price unless he gets something in return. Weiner hits the nail on the head – just exactly what have WE gained by giving up Medicare for All, Public Option or Single Payer? Not a ^&*$(% thing has been gained, other than my blood pressure has risen.
Congressman Weiner,
I’ve given nearly $1,000 to various campaigns in the last 18 months and frankly I can’t see how it’s measurably improved the lives of my family, friends and neighbors.
I’m here in Pete Stark’s district in California, and when Pete doesn’t have a clue as to what the White House is up to then I’m reluctant – no let me restate it – I’m insulted that I’m having to shell out more money for nothing. I respect Pete and have been chatting with him for nearly a decade at his town meetings.
He was disciplined by his own party hierarchy a couple years ago for a floor remark – one that hit the nail on the head much as your comments in the well.
I can’t match Anthem dollar for dollar in donations. We have 65-75% of the American people supporting Public Option, but money controls congress.
How many months have these pols been doing what I was taught not to do my first month bargaining labor contracts with asshole employers? When the other side won’t bargain, what you’re doing when you counter yourself is worse than masturbation because at least the latter doesn’t mean you chop off your own fingers one at a time while the other side sits back, folds its arms, and smiles. All of which makes me wonder whether all this Dem crap, dividing the house against itself, isn’t just a form of time-waste posturing, which, because it involves so much hypocrisy, is also worse than self-abuse. The handwriting’s already on the wall: The Democrats, and the Democrats alone, pissed away whatever mandate they had on 11/4/08. They could have done away with the filibuster. They could force reconciliation. They won’t do any of it because they never intended to. Fuck…them…all.
I appreciate Rep. Weiner’s statements and actions and willingness to appear here. We need this consciousness raising in the well and on tv. But it’s getting really late.
Earlier I said we need to see action.
I was wrong.
We need to see results now. Now.
No, we cannot fight the big money dollar for dollar and we are no longer willing to try. Congress members must realize they are in as much jeapoardy from the ongoing corporatization of politics as well as the Citizens United decision as the general electorate.
We need to see results now. Now. Not after November. Not the current Health Insurance Profit Protection bills.
Health. Care. Now. For everyone. No mandates. No limits. No recision. No shit. Or this is no longer “the best country in the world.”
Pay for it by taxing Bush’s millionaire+ “base.”
Do it quick. And do jobs as quickly.