For those who have always wanted to “make ‘em filibuster,” you actually saw a variant of it last night, if you were paying attention. Jim Bunning, the slightly kooky retiring Senator from Kentucky, refused unanimous consent to move to a bill extending unemployment benefits and the COBRA subsidy for 30 days, basically ensuring that millions of people will see their benefits run out on Sunday, barring some miracle today. Democrats went until midnight on the floor of the Senate trying to get past Bunning, but he stuck it out for a few hours, refusing to consent. And he had the gall to complain that he missed the Kentucky-South Carolina basketball game, while denying help to the jobless and the suffering.
And while he said the Senate spent almost three hours “telling everybody in America that Senator Bunning doesn’t give a damn about people who are on unemployment,” he assured those still watching that he was indeed interested in renewing the programs as long as it can be done to his satisfaction.
Senator Richard Jr. Durbin of Illinois, the No. 2 Democrat, said he intended to try to break the impasse again Friday morning but Mr. Bunning indicated he would again be on hand.
Senator Jim Bunning, the conservative Kentucky Republican, insisted that the jobless pay due to run out Sunday night should be paid for rather than added to the deficit as an emergency. During the debate, Mr. Bunning stood rigidly at his desk in the back row of the Senate and objected to repeated Democrat attempts for agreement to extend unemployment coverage through April 5.
“I believe we should pay for it,” declared Mr. Bunning, who said he was determined to remain to thwart the Democrats. “I’ll be here as long as you are here.”
Democrats went one by one giving speeches intended to shame Bunning, but the Senate operates under rules of unanimous consent. And overriding his objections, if he does not leave the floor or otherwise miss a call for unanimous consent (which the Democrats attempted every half-hour) would require a cloture vote, which cannot be accomplished before the deadline. You can accuse the Democrats of poor clock management, but basically they have to bow and scrape just to get something done that will pass 97-1 when it comes to a final vote.
And while this was relatively painless (outside of the basketball game) for Bunning, millions of real people will suffer, the kind of people Rep. Dean Heller (R-NV) calls hobos.
There’s an easy way to handle Bunning’s call for an offset – debate it and put it to a vote. If it wins, great. If it loses, great. Then we move on to a final vote. That’s called legislating, in a functional lawmaking body.
I try to always say that we need a change in Senate rules, not the filibuster, because the rules offer lots more veto points than just those associated with cloture. And because we have an inattentive public and media, making the Republicans bear the cost of obstruction is a nearly impossible task.
UPDATE: Bunning reportedly responded to Jeff Merkley begging him to allow a vote on benefits extensions by saying, “Tough shit.”
UPDATE II: You do have to wonder why Democrats let Bunning off the hook last night and are indeed negotiating with him this morning, instead of trying to break him.



81 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Why does Bunning hate people?
I didnt see this on the NYTIMES and WAPO front page.
They dont think it is news when UI benefits for millions are torpedoed by a cranky old gooper coot?
Thanks David.
Why do Republicans hate America?
Why do Republicans hate Americans?
poor dems in congress, there’s nothing they can do. it’s all the fault of ordinary people (for not watching cspan last night).
maybe if the dems made the case a little more forcefully and honestly and gave it a couple of days instead of a few hours and made bunning actually do the filibustering (what were the dems doing not making him stay on the floor if it was only bunning?)…… or not. but that’s an experiment i’d like to see.
I too would very much like to see Dems make th R’s filibuster. Please just for a week or so.
via twitter just now:
KagroX: Want to find out if this Bunning thing is a 1-man filibuster? Make him stay on the floor. If not, fine. Make Rs take turns blocking COBRA.
must see tv! *g*
Bunning: A mentally challenged kook that belongs to a party of dysfunctional losers. This has got to be one of the most bizarre political stunts of the year.
“Tough shit” you say to those who object, Jim? Hope you say that when your seat goes Democratic because of your insensivity and ineptitude. I am so glad you are getting out of public service. Good riddance to bad rubbish.
Weird how so many jocks are reich wingers.
Disgusting.
Fine Mr Bunning, get your Republican friends to help slap a Tobin tax on Wallstreet. Then it’ll be paid for.
Seems fitting that Wallstreet should pay for peoples unemployment anyway. After all, who caused this mess.
i was a little frustrated with kagro x’s lack of response re filibuster vs faux filibuster, but today is more than making up for that.
the senate (cspan2) play by play of a quorum call is awesome!
more via twitter:
KagroX: Who thinks it’s cool to let a single filibustering Senator take a 40 minute nap rather than stay on his feet and fight? Today, Dems do.
So why don’t the Dems take some money out of the Defense budget and pay for it?
and more:
KagroX: Dems had Bunning frustrated to the point of his shouting obscenities on the floor last night in his filibuster, but decided to let him go.
This motherfucker’s phone number is 202-224-4343.
Right up there with curling! *g* (I swear I’m an addict)
Actually, I would watch. And be fascinated.
I think the Republicans would prefer a tax on homelessness to pay for it.
Who cares what the Reps would prefer? The Dems are in charge, take charge!
Haven’t read all the comments…but did he say what would = his narcissistic satisfaction…Wouldn’t we want to know?
The Dems have taken charge, and this is what they’re giving us.
me too! (can’t say the same re curling though *g*)
and if we could have kagro x do the play by play as he is today, that would be fabulous (would work to pull in Rs as well as Ds and Is).
this is the best. quorum. call. ever.
but i have to go to the library before i get snowed in again…. later friends.
i called …
the staffer hung up on me.
have a nice day, you old coot.
I recall a favorite movie of mine, where the cantankerous newspaper editor says of the obstructionists and other rats preventing progress:
“You should take them out in the street and shoot them down like dogs.”
It is nice as a metaphor, albeit not a proper thing to do.
Interesting point….Part of that macho/prowess thing, I guess…not so much value in the “least of these”. (Not to generalize too much)
An interesting word, “hobo.”
For insight read Frank Higbie’s “Indispensable Outcasts: Hobo Workers and Community in the American Midwest, 1880-1930″ about into contingent and marginal workers of the last gilded age. “Seasonal laborers of the early twentieth century were a lightning rod for tensions over class, citizenship, and manhood because their existence disrupted widely accepted narratives about the character of American society. Most Americans wanted to believe that a man could rise from hired hand to independent farmer or could earn enough to support himself and a family. [or become a Major League baseball player, right?]
Yet … hard work and determination were almost useless because bad conditions and the chaos of the labor market ensured that laborers inevitably moved downward on the social scale.”
The Democrats are as phony as the Republicans are mentally unstable.
Some choice facing American voters – vote for the Corporatist Democrat because he/she is not as crazy as the Republican candidate.
Let me think …
I’d love to see Bunning lose the next election so HE can start collecting unemployment checks, and then have to see some A-hole senator make it his life’s crusade to cut them off.
By June over 500,000 Michigan workers unemployment benefits will be exhausted. Let them march to Bunnings doorstep and let him say to their faces “tough shit.”
You have no idea how painful its is for an old-time Phillies fan to see someone you thought was a hero be such a creep. Maybe it’s just Alzheimer’s. That would be the kindest interpretation.
He’s retiring. Will not run again.
Before a Philly he was a Detroit Tiger and was one of the best. Too see him now as a tool and idiot is pathetic.
oopps… bluetoe2 beat me to it.
but i do share your frustration.
you can always call in KY:
District 4 – Ft. Wright (Main State Office)
1717 Dixie Highway
Suite 220
Ft. Wright, KY 41011
Main: 859-341-2602
Fax: 859.331.7445
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
District 1 – Hopkinsville
1100 S. Main Street
Suite 12
Hopkinsville, KY 42240
Main: 270.885.1212
Fax: 270.881.3975
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
District 2 – Owensboro
423 Frederica Street
Room 305
Owensboro, KY 42301
Main: 270.689.9085
Fax: 270.689.9158
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
District 3 – Louisville
600 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Place
Room 1072 B
Louisville, KY 40202
Main: 502.582.5341
Fax: 502.582.5344
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
District 5 – Hazard
Gorman Education Center
601 Main St., Suite 2
Hazard, KY 41701
Main: 606.435.2390
Fax: 606.435.1761
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
District 6 – Lexington
771 Corporate Dr.
Suite 105
Lexington, KY 40503
Main: 859.219.2239
Fax: 859.219.3269
Toll free: 1-800-283-8983
Map this | Directions To
His replacement might be Rand Paul, so it could be trading one pain in the ass for another, younger pain in the ass.
Boycott Sports. Tim Tebow, and other religious extremists with bible verses on their cheeks, might as well be ads for Jim Demint or that other Neanderthal from Oklahoma. Republicanism and all its warmongering and hate is the default position of most atheletes.
OT but last night on the News Hour they once again said the American people do not want health care reform. Listening to the NPR coverage of yesterday’s dog and pony show one couldn’t help but notice how the frames and memes were leaning distinctly to the right. A majority of the sound bites were by Republicans and the only interview was with Republican Dave DeCamp. National Propaganda Radio and their broadcast sister PBS doing all in their power to maintain a corrupt status quo.
Gregg Levine has a new post up: New York Governor Paterson Drops Election Bid; Will Not Resign
Can’t the dems change some of the rules of the senate? They have some kind of power here don’t they?
here is the top item at Senator COOT Bunning’s webpage:
Latest News
Feb
22
Bunning Announces Federal Funds For Southgate Volunteer Fire Department
U.S. Senator Jim Bunning today announced that the Emergency Preparedness and Response Directorate of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has awarded the Southgate Volunteer Fire Department $30,928 in federal funding as part of the 2009 Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program.
Oh never mind. Dems and power just don’t go together. How many Americans have to die, go hungry, become homeless, etc.?????????????????????
they’re not using the rules they already have.
So, we should be calling the dems then and not Bunning. Bunning is obviously unstable and probably won’t budge. Is this a Harry Reid problem??
JOCKS HAVE ISSUES. THIS IS NOT NEWS. WE’VE KNOWN IT FOR YEARS.
[Edited by Moderator: If "all caps" is considered shouting, you can imagine how impolite "all caps" plus bolding is! Please do not use "all caps" again.]
That comment is uncivilized and immature. How is it that we know better than to use the N word but think it is just fine to make nasty comments about “hillbillies” and “retards”?
Why wasn’t this the top story on CNN to cover every 15 minutes? Instead they have chosen to pursue the killing of a poor abused whale.
Your comments are disgusting and reflect no more sense of human worth and civility than Bunning.
This was just bunning; I want the entire shittaree to have to move their cots and hotplates into the Senate foyer.
At this point, forcing them to in-your-face obstructionist bullshit, instead of just sending word to Obama and Reid that they don’t like something they’re doing, and having them cave, is the only thing that will save what cred the dems have left, and that aint much.
Time to write Keith and Rachel. CNN is hopeless.
I understand that he wants to know how the extended benefits will be paid – but why not propose something useful – like cutting all salaries on Congress and their staffs by 10% this year – and if the jobs pictures for Americans does not improve, cutting it again next year and the next until we see improvement?
Also removing all health care benefits for Congress so that they can go out in the ‘open market’ and purchase the Health insurance for themselves.
[Edited by moderator: Please can we avoid the graphic references to violence.]
It amazes me that Bunning would take this position after he has announced his retirement because the wing nuts want him out. He must have a big pile of corrupt money to collect if he keeps his balls in the Republican freezer. I suggest the Senate majority institute a tax on media commercials to pay for extending unemployment. Let the Republicans defend viagra commercials and email spam over unemployed citizens.
If the Democrats in the Senate had any balls they would stay in session 24/7 until they clear the 290 bills the House has passed that they have not addressed. Keep it up so the Republicans can’t get on the phone or out to fund raisers where they promise to destroy the last remnants of democracy in America.
well, i wouldn’t say that bunning isn’t a problem (yikes!). but right now he’s just one guy and if the dems are scared to take him on, then i think our problems are bigger than bunning.
yep. Bunning is a big, fat problem that can be dealt with but will that happen? The unemployed need to get organized. Wonder how we could help with that. A big demonstration at Bunning’s washington would be great. Or can Obama make some kind of the presidential maneuver to extend the benefits?
The goal is not to bring your enemies to their knees but to their senses. — Mahatma Gandhi
short answer: i don’t know…
bit longer answer: for my part, and at the moment (have a lot to learn and may change my mind), it is to spread the word of some anti-neoliberal economists who show that all our conventional thinking about fed deficit spending is wrong.
i was in the other room, but i heard some nonsense from the senate on cspan2 about paygo and how to pay for the cobra extension. if we could undo that myth, i think we’d have a chance on some of the other stuff….
…yikes! really got to go. snow starting.
Well yes, but if you ever saw his district you’d realize that it’s a few centuries short of being progressive.
Anyway, if Rand is anything like his dad, at least it would only be batshit crazy domestic policy to deal with…. as opposed to crazy foreign policy on top of everything else.
Either way, what Bunning is doing is insane, even for a Republican it’s insane.
So does this mean if your collecting a claim as of Sunday it’s cancelled for lack of $$?
It is not on Faux news either. I personally think the media likes to keep the American people ininformed so they cannot make informed decisions thereby making themselves seem relevant. With the exception of Faux news which I think intentionally fails to report anything that could reflect negatively on their Republican constituency. What a bunch of B.S.
And with RightWing NUTS like Bunning the spiral will continue. The only thing Bunning WAS good for was throwing his Balls around in his Youth.. now not so much.. his balls have shriveled into sesame seeds…
Bunning is just doing his jobs and protecting entitlements for the RICH. This is just the beginning, they have to get those entitled tax cuts in before the deficit reduction commission begins to deliberate. After all only the little people need unemployment compensation and COBRA subsidies.
Watch the R’s carefully, they will push for their entitlements while destroying Social Security and Medicare. How else can they claim a budget crises then to keep cutting taxes on the rich and the big corps.
Did you know that recently Boeing only paid an federal effective tax rate of a little over 3%? And they are trying to get more $$ from Congress.
This seems like a stunt to cast light on how this is being paid for moreso than the substance of the bill itself. The article linked says that Bunning supported it in its original form, but “insisted that the jobless pay due to run out Sunday night should be paid for rather than added to the deficit as an emergency.”
He wants to pay cash instead of using the federal charge card. I wonder if the Dems who COULD go around him will do so at the risk of giving his “PAYGO hypocrisy” a platform for review. Odd tactic for an odd guy. Hell of a ballplayer though…
What happens to people who have no money? I guess some move in with friends or relatives but no everyone. How big must the homeless problem get before it explodes?
Maybe whe there are 20 to 100 million homeless then maybe and I DO mean Maybe Washington will wake up and make people like Bunning to STFU and then do something before they find themselves at the end of the Pitchfork and torch!!
Well, I just got off the phone with Senator Schumer’s office (this is approx 12:25pm EST) and told the aide who answered that as far as I was concerned, Bunning ought to be forced to stand there on his own two feet, with no naps or breaks, until he drops, [Edited by Moderator] for all I care, with hundreds of thousands depending on those benefits. The aide more or less endorsed my frustration level, and indicated a similar level of frustration in the Senator’s office. Interesting that the aide was ready with a comment that Sen. Schumer was doing everything possible to pass the extension, so evidently they’ve been getting calls on this. My hope, post phone-call, is that there’s enough Democratic spine on the Hill to make Mr. Crankypants yammer on until he dissolves into a puddle of spittle.
Apparently, the Senate has adjourned for the weekend and benefits will lapse. There’s not a complete pair of b***s on any of the Democrats in the Senate.
Yes, establishment is being fatally short sighted. I mean, half this country is armed with a lot more than a pitchfork and most of them feel cheated by our bankers and politicians.
My solution to the homeless problem would be to give the homeless temporary housing inside the mansions of Jamie Dimon, Llyod Blankfein and the rest. I think that would rekindle an establishment interest in social saftey nets.
What’s going on right now makes Reagan look smalltime. If you remember, homelessness shot up under Reagan. But now… well… this is insane.
Cramdowns legislation would have been at least a good partial solution but it was defeated in a truely fascist move by Democrat leadership. Of course Rethugs were against it but they didn’t have the votes to stop it.
That’s why I don’t understand why the Dems don’t give him what he wants; pay for the extension of unemployment benefits and COBRA by taxing the richest 3%, who currently only pay taxes of under 20% the last time I checked. I paid more than that when I was paid $36K/yr. I know I paid upward of 30% taxes when all forms of taxation were considered.
Yup, that’s what I said. Tell Bunning that we’ll fund it via a Tobin tax on Wallstreet speculation.
You could write a book about what a piece of shit this guy is. And you could write an encyclopedia about what a piece of shit the U.S. Senate is. The next thing you know people will be flying airplanes into government buildings. Did you read about the guy who knocked his house down with a bulldozer? When you put the pop corn in the microwave, pretty soon you hear a pop. Then another pop. And then they all go off at the same time. Hang on to your hats y’all.
Oh please Mary…
Where do you live – Kentucky?
Hillbillies and retards are interchangeable words meaning the same thing. Don’t think so?
Just look what that Cracker Caucus member Bunning did to the millions who are out of work and thanks to his “tough shit” attitude will not be able to feed themselves or their children. If that ain’t retarded I don’t know what is…
They should still be in session until Bunning breaks or his prostate explodes. I really hate the House of Lords, I mean US Senate.
I know you people are not all that up on money and finances but it comes down to this. If you pay someone not to work for 26 weeks that person will not find a job for 26 weeks. If you pay a person not to work for 52 weeks that person will not find work for 52 weeks.
Get my drift?
We simply do not have the money to keep paying people not to work. Sooner or later those people need to find gainful employment.
End of story.
PS-It’s great to be back!
You know, FDR and Harry Hopkins didn’t like “the dole” either. Which is why they decided to put America back to work with the WPA and CCC. They built hundreds of thousands of modern buildings, tens of thousands of bridges, over 900 modern airports. Sure, FDR spent a lot of money, but he got a lot of bang for his buck.
As for not having the money, we print it and have plenty of trees. Granted, if the money isn’t spent productively then it will lose value(inflation). Bailing out banker speculation is a prime example of money wasted.
Hey tinman1967…
You have a phone call – It’s that cracker from KY Jim Bunning calling to say you’re a “real” American and he wants to shake your hand…
Now that’s what I call looking out for your fellow Americans, – if you’re a jackbooted brown shirt form the ’30s – telling them it’s “tough shit” if they can’t find a work no matter how hard they look for a job.
Maybe you should change your handle to [edited by mod]…
[modnote; no name calling, thank you.]
You should now turn around and go back to where it is you came from with that asanine evaluation.
Please follow tinman back to whatever excrement filled cave he lives in. You make the perfect couple.
Mesa Mick was spot on.
Whether Mick stumbled into something most can agree with the mocking demeaning language in his/her postings is inexcusable. Even after moderation.
Have you ever collected unemployment insurance? Are you quite certain that you know what you are talking about?
Thanks so little for your simplistic drivel, which only a Neocon could appreciate. Your bootstrapper perspective is callous and insensitive bullshit.
If that’s the best you can come up with for a comment then have the good sense to stay away—for good.
update (and correction to my comments on this thread): please see powwow’s comment:
http://fdlaction.firedoglake.com/2010/02/26/durbin-asks-supporters-to-help-end-filibuster-while-giving-up-on-attempt-to-break-one/#comment-91422