Jim Bunning got away with blocking an extension of unemployment benefits and COBRA on Thursday night because “coordinated support materialized” among Republicans to help Bunning in his cause, Sen. Jeff Merkley explained in a conference call this morning.
Merkley (D-OR), Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) and Jack Reed (D-RI) participated in the call, about the urgent need to pass an extension of unemployment benefits and the 65% COBRA subsidy, which will run out for hundreds of thousands of Americans on Sunday. Bunning (R-KY) waged what amounted to a one-man filibuster at the end of the week, refusing unanimous consent to move to a short-term extension of benefits before the deadline. Bunning wanted the package of extensions to be paid for, but when Harry Reid offered Bunning an amendment to that effect, he said he wouldn’t accept that because the amendment wouldn’t pass. (Really.)
All three Senators, whose states are experiencing high unemployment rates, expressed outrage at Bunning’s action, discussing the real-world consequences for their constituents. Stabenow said that 62,000 Michiganders would lose their unemployment benefits on Sunday, and by the end of March, across the country 1.2 million would lose them if no action was taken. Furthermore, almost half of those now receiving unemployment benefits are getting them through some form of extension, so the result of inaction could be catastrophic.
Reed added that historically, whenever the unemployment rate exceeded 7.4%, Congress has always extended benefits, and that such extensions generally create $2 in the economy for every $1 spent (you could say that they pay for themselves, which was Bunning’s entire objection). Merkley noted the expense to state unemployment agencies to send out notices to shut down benefits, only to start them up again if they are extended. “The Republican filibuster is irresponsible,” he said. “Republicans didn’t filibuster to pay for tax cuts for the wealthy, but when families are struggling, they take this outrageous action.”
I asked the Senators why they didn’t continue asking for unanimous consent agreements on Thursday night, forcing Bunning to stay on the floor and continue his crusade. He was already getting belligerent, and could have just faded through the exhaustion of an all-night filibuster, but the Senate adjourned around midnight. Many Senate observers have described this as letting Bunning win.
Sen. Merkley, the only one of the three who was on the floor that night, responded. “When it was Bunning by himself, the prospect of breaking him was very real,” he said. “But when coordinated support materialized, it became clear we weren’t going to be able to overcome this on the floor.” In other words, other Republican Senators stopped by on the floor in reserve, and if Bunning could no longer continue, they stood ready to step in and object to any unanimous consent agreement. Obviously, UC agreements require… unanimous consent, so any Senator can block them. Merkley identified Bob Corker (R-TN) as one of the Senators who reached the floor late at night, and Stabenow added that Jeff Sessions (R-AL) showed up earlier in the evening.
“The most important thing is the people impacted,” Stabenow said, “But on the process, Bunning was concerned about paying for the extension, he was offered an amendment and he didn’t accept it. In the Senate we’ve seen a hijacking of the legislative process. In a legislature you debate a policy and then you vote. Voting is the American way. Instead, Bunning chose to use the filibuster in blocking and hijacking the system.”
You can argue that the Senate used bad time management in not giving enough space to file cloture and getting a vote to override Bunning with a short-term extension of what would expire, not just unemployment benefits and the COBRA subsidy but also the Medicare doctors fix and some other matters. But if Republicans were prepared to switch off in objecting to UC requests, then they could have held out at least until the Sunday deadline, it seems.
Therefore it’s wrong to call this Jim Bunning’s filibuster. It was a Republican filibuster, as they offered “passive support,” as Stabenow put it. “We’re going to see benefits run out on Sunday” as a result, she concluded. “Where is the Republican leadership? Where will it be next week?”



64 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
This is just more BS. The idea originally out there was there would be blowback if they wore the Alzheimerish Bunning. This is hoohaw. The question is why do other Senators who know Bunning is Alzheimerish allow him to still sit in the Senate? Why did Democrats fold yet again on the mere threat of a more general filibuster when it was precisely in their interests to expose it as such?
It must have been verrry verrry scary for them… That a ‘small’ organized group of Democratic Senators left holding the fort (nb: on a issue that affects real people and ‘not’ multi-billion $$$ industries) against all those nasty nasty republicans who were evil enough to bring in troop re-enforcements.
What could they do…? it was past their bedtime and the media wasn’t there — so they caved.
Oh, here’s a good one!
The Great American Bank Robbery
How did the big banks nearly take down the entire economy and still continue to profit? Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz explains.
LINK.
Why is Stiglitz outside and Summers inside? The consequences of this juxtaposition are obvious.
So the Repubs think that it is important to pay for the extension of benefits UNLESS the tax benefits are for the Uber rich and big Corporations.
Now they are looking at destroying Social Security and Medicare to protest Uber and Corporate entitlements UNLESS we expose the true cost of their entitlements and refuse to extend the Bush tax cuts. Which will it be?
Their goal is simply to bankrupt the country.
Finally, during the Bush years where were the Dem’s and why did they allow Bush’s legislative agenda to occur with out using the same tactics and the Rebups are now using. Spineless you say?
The Dems, as I remember it always gave the excuse that if they acted in this manner the country would view themas obstructionist. BS! The Gopers don’t seem to mind the title do they? The Dems. deserve have another title more appropriate JELLYFISH!
Bunning can sign a couple of baseballs and generate cash for himself. Every other Senator, D or r can hit their checking account/ATM to grab a few Benjamins at need, whenever, wherever and it’s “no harm no foul”.
The rest of us getting unemployment, looking for work get to suffer Bunning’s incredible attack of pay-as-you-go conscience with our checks. I don’t seem to remember that the Gentlefuck from Kaintuck was all about paying for the Iraq War before the first troops rolled into Baghdad. Or am I wrong?
would you please give me the cite (congressional record page, or time of day for cspan) for when bunning objected to the unanimous consent agreement? i can’t find it.
Oh no! There were wingnut senators on “stand-by” and they could have kept the “filibuster” going all weekend? WHY THE FUCK DON’T YOU LET THEM?
BTW, I have yet to receive even one email from the DSCC/DCCC/Reid Re-Election Committee/Ad Nauseum fundraising vacuums expressing “outrage” over Bunning’s move. Nice media coordination, morons.
oops reinforcements
Exposing more GOP intransigence on UI and COBRA extension for unemployed Americans would have been better, not worse. The Democrats should have let Corker and Sessions join the party. Then it wouldn’t have looked like the majority was beating up on a senile old man, as they were supposedly worried about.
How is it possible these people are successful in politics? They seem to only succeed at cronyism and insider clique-ishness. They completely missed the boat on this issue: make the whole GOP caucus support Bunning if needed, right up through the expiration of the benefits on Sunday, when they could bring a big bell onto the Capitol ground and ring it as benefits expired and still the GOP held up the bill.
Really badly played, Senate Dems. Again.
It would be great optics for R’s to obstruct it throughout the night. Even the bland MSM cannot blame dems in that scenario. But they can in this one. Go Team!
100% right.
The dems need to exploit this and call it what it is–a gooper filibuster. And it would be allot easier if they had sucked in corker and sessions. a big mistake.
Regardless, the goopers had his back and so it is misreporting to say it is a one-man filibuster. Dems need to insist and start calling it a GOOPER filibuster and they need to do it more loudly than with just a Saturday (lost to the world) phone presser.
If they are smart it will be part of the Sunday gasbag talk fest.
More to the point, the dems did blow it by not allowing MORE time before the deadline so the bill still could have come up for a vote if they used cloture.
They didnt think the goopers would act against the unemployed AND the docs? they dont know by now that the goopers are crazy as dogshit?
watch out for the next ex-Phillies nutjob pitcher coming down the political trail in PA – Curt Schilling.
http://www.videoweed.com/file/4b5e6caada543
The Senate makes me want to bang my head on the table. It is the most pretentious group of people I’ve ever seen and they accomplish nothing. The Dems could have scored a lot of points by making them filibuster and once again folded. aaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrgggggggghhhhhhh!
I’m personally sick and tired of the fucking endless excuses that are issued from the Dems. on why they allow the Gopers to kick their asses on a regular basis. We need a party that represents us the way the Gopers represent the rich. The Dems. seem to loath their own base, at a min. they disrespect us and it’s really starting to piss me off. Let them find another base more to their liking. Oh, I forgot the rich were already taken.
House of friggin Lords is all its become. Just add the titles. I despise these people.
how long would it take to get a vote on this issue?
Monday morning?
Often appears they’re playing on the same team. Eh?
Expecting Senate Democrats to do anything to help the people of this nation is as ridiculous as betting on the Washington Generals to beat the Harlem Globe-Trotters.
“You can argue that the Senate used bad time management in not giving enough space to file cloture and getting a vote to override Bunning with a short-term extension of what would expire, not just unemployment benefits and the COBRA subsidy but also the Medicare doctors fix and some other matters. But if Republicans were prepared to switch off in objecting to UC requests, then they could have held out at least until the Sunday deadline, it seems…”
The Democrats, which ran congress most of last year, could have seen this deadline long ago. In fact, I am sure they could have thought about it while they had 2 months off for Christmas.
Both political parties are responsible for the massive unemployment. And both are now responsible for using the unemployed to score minor points.
Noone in congress, if they are human, should be able to sleep at night; knowing the hurt and damage they have done to this country.
Lame, lame, lame, lame. I fired off two steamed-up letters of outrage to my Senators demanding apologies to their constituents for their parts in letting this kind of crap continue. I mentioned that the takeaway the general public is going to have is, “Hell, the Democrats couldn’t get our benefits extension passed; their weekend was more important to them, so why should I support them in the future?” And, they’d be right.
There’s no excuse for this, none. Merkley’s plaintive “Gee whiz, I’m just one li’l guy, what was I supposed to do?” may be an accurate (and damning) measure of the lack of heart and leadership and foresight and CARE about ordinary Americans that exists among Senate Democrats, but it’s utterly and completely unacceptable. I suppose it falls to us all, over and over again, to instruct these self-absorbed, gutless nincompoops about where their principal responsibilities lie (and no, it’s not to Senate “custom”, not when people need benefits to put food on the table).
This is easy to fix. Extend the benefits and pay for it with a 50% tax on bonuses in excess of base pay. Let the GOP fight against that in public.
Yes!!
There should be wall-to-wall ads up on tv and in the print media trumpeting this “Republican screwing of the American people.”
I agree with others–this excuse from the Dems stinks. A couple of Republicans show up in the night and the Dems fold? Give me a break!
Maybe it’s the strong coffee that has me on edge, but the sheer volume of nasty characterizations here seem to indicate a lot of passive agressive minds, and its subsequent self-loathing. It’s just never as simple as it seems, despite the poor performing US Senate. I know of Jeff Merkley pretty well, was very happy to be able to vote for him as a progressive candidate, and will take his word at face value.
If properly publicized (I know, I know) this stab at the unemployed and those needing help with the COBRA extension will add to the marks against Republicans in general, and will also add to the self-inflicted demonization of the South (note where the support of Bunning came from).
Sigh…guess impatience know no party.
There should be wall-to-wall ads up on tv and in the print media trumpeting this “Republican screwing of the American people.”
Heavens! How very uncivil that would be!
Glad to hear you “know Jeff Merkley pretty well.” How about letting him know his “explanation” on why the Dems let a couple of wingnuts hold an extension of UI benefits hostage is seen as a load of fucking bullshit?
As to the “proper publicizing” of this for some sort of Dem benefit – that should have ALREADY HAPPENED. How long are we going to wait for the sort of “rapid response” the Rethugs would already be blanketing the airwaves and internet with if the tables were turned?
Dems are the weakest and wussiest of all known creatures. I threw away my Dem party ID a couple of months ago and am now a progressive independent. Can’t stand the stench of the prospect of voting for any of them on anything in the future. How pathetic they are. Give them power and they find new ways to lose. They sicken me.
“While unemployed Americans worried about how they’d buy food for their children, Jim Bunning was worried about missing a basketball game.”
How hard is that, DSCC? OFA? DNC?
I can understand the impulse to run ads to point out “Republicans screwing America”, but that would just make things worse. That would simply reinforce the message that “Democrats are too weak to stop Republicans from screwing America.”
The American people may dislike some of the things Republicans do, but they absolutely despise weakness.
agreed.
slow out of the box.
poor planning.
poor follow through.
no go-for-the-jugular or killer instinct.
it is almost as if they watched Bunning and took pity on him instead of wanting to swallow him whole, and suck in Carper and Sessions.
How can the Dems be so dim? Do they not see the PR value of letting the gop kill a bill that helps the unemployed? They couldn’t devise a better ad campaign than one with bunning saying tough sh*t to the jobless.
You stop the republicans by showing them up for what they are. Lying down and taking their s**t is what conveys weakness. Give them a taste of their own medicine, but with the truth backing you up.
You stop the republicans by showing them up for what they are.
You stop the Republicans by stopping the Republicans, not by letting them get away with s**t and them whining about how mean they are.
It’s the top of the ninth…Bunning is still in there pitching…the relief pitchers are warming up in the BULLpen…nobody’s out.
Then the Washington Senators called the contest because of darkness.
Now, thousands of Americans are OUT.
We overheard someone asking why the contest was called when we have
lighting. The reply….TOUGH S#*T! Wonder how the KY/SC game is going?
Here’s a question. When is the last time any of these high-profile, 1-Senator blocks, holds and/or filibusters were ever done for a GOOD, SOCIALLY-CONSCIOUS reason. I’m thinking Mike Gravel and the Pentagon Papers.
it is almost as if they watched Bunning and took pity on him
They’ve taken the “bleeding heart liberals” epithet too seriously and too far?
Agree. Someone kinda keeps calling off Democrats-won’t really fight for us and doesn’t REALLY want the Republican asses to look bad. Someone must have a plan for us to fall apart. I fear its the administration.
Stabenow- what the hell is the problem? Why didn’t you do something? Take to the floor yourself. That is what we in Michigan are paying you for.
YOU JUST DON’T LET THIS SHIT HAPPEN.
I’d said a Tobin tax on speculation but yeah… same target: Wallstreet.
Wallstreet is sending a clear message to the public: Die
Wallstreet pays both partys extremely well. And in this case they not only paid Bunning but they also paid the Democrats to take a dive.
When is the last time a Democratic Senator said (In the words of Jim Bunning) “Tough s**t”? Where is LBJ (as Senate Majority Leader) when you need him?
Congress looks a lot like that old Star Trek episode where Kirk is split in two. Evil vs. ineffectual.
It began somewhere in the early evening hours Thursday night. That’s when I accidentally tuned in to hear Durbin’s outage
With all due respect, I think Congress Matters and the Senators don’t portray what happened as accurately as they could have. As Durbin clarified on the floor, all of the Senators supported the extension and most had left town knowing Durbin would file the unanimous consent to get it passed.
The objection was just another last minute trick by a pack of sore losers.
Durbin and the handful of others still in the building did their damnedest, but Bunning and Corker had their orders. Obviously neither expected the Dems to put up the fight they did.Corker was at home and had to come back and Bunting missed a big homestate game.
I hit the Senate hard most of the time, but they truly were blindsided and couldn’t do much until they all came back to town.
On Monday though, they damn well better start kicking some Right-wing ASS!
Well, the rethugs suck. We all (trolls excepted) agree on that. But the fact that they were ready to play rough (i.e. back bunning up) was no excuse. If the Dems had said “Fine, you all just keep objecting to this extension all weekend while the news outlets switch off between shots of your holding up the bill and lines at unemployment offices.”, the thing would have ended before the Sunday talking heads shows. But no, we just can’t do anything because they are soooo mean…
Give me a fucking break!
I couldn’t agree with you more!!!
They are worthless, lying, useless pieces of shit for the most part. What a corrupt, and unworkable system of government we have.
I hear that reconciliation has it’s limitations. But most important things that get done in Congress have to do with money in some form or another. Like Unemployment Benefits. The Dems should just start doing everything through Reconciliation. If it’s possible to do…then do it. To worry that it will look bad is stupid. The Dems look like ineffective, old, bloated, corrupt, spineless assholes….how much worse could it look? To say that the GOP will whine, threaten and be uncooperative on other issues…also ridiculous. They don’t help on virtually anything any ways. So fuck the Senate Blue Dogs and fuck the GOP….Reconsile everything possible, and get some shit done. Grrrrrrrr……………. They’ve got the rest of this yr to pass legislation to help Americans and then they are losing Congress. If they don’t take advantage and get things done, then we’ll lose the WH as well. Sad, stupid set of circumstances this country finds itself in.
I’m sorry to hear Merkley is one of the people offering up this bullshit. No matter.
More importantly, the simple fact is Reid & Co simply let the Thugs get away with this and now they’re making some pretty dumb excuses to cover their own asses. Why didn’t they simply keep the sesssion open and make the Thugs physically filibuster? Why not turn that into a battle royale over the fate of millions of unemployed people? The Thugs would have caved and this thing would have passed and the Dems could have scored a real victory for once.
They had an opportunity to strike deeply at the sociopaths on the right, but instead they decided to fuck over millions of unemployed people instead. I guess they had some corporate fundraisers to attend in Boca or something. Jeebus, these people suck.
This one is on the Dems. No doubt about it.
Last I checked the Dems still had the majority. If they choose to abdicate to the GOP, fine, but they’re still abdicating and violating the public trust in the process. No more excuses!
The Senate Dems have precisely ZERO credibility going forward. ZERO.
Maybe the DSCC is learning that their base is no longer outraged over the rethugs but rather over the Dem’s complicity with the rethugs.
Stabenow laments “Where is the Republican leadership?” You’ve got to be kidding. I’ve been asking that same question about the Democrats who I thought were in the majority. I’m from Michigan, and I intend to vote against EVERY single incumbent from this state. That includes Levin and Stabenow. What a joke! The 3 C’s, Comfortable, Cowardly and Corrupt.
the reason i asked the question up thread, “would you please give me the cite (congressional record page, or time of day for cspan) for when bunning objected to the unanimous consent agreement? i can’t find it.” is because of powwow’s comment in a previous thread (i highly recommend reading powwow’s entire comment, this is just a part of it):
it looks like durbin objected to a UC also.
Winning called them on all their endless BS, because now they had to put up or STFU. Instead, these jellyfish just continue to spew their BS. They don’t seem to understand that talk without action is just annoying everyone. The Gopers on the other hand have taken a stand, few words just pure non-action same thing. They understand that they are their to do something anything even if it means saying HELL NO to everything. The Dems. think Congress is a fucking College debating society that doesn’t require them to so shit but give each other hi fives before a long lunch and probably a slow blow job somewhere. They have no clue @ how sick and tired their base, especially those of us that were their activist base, is of them and their BS.
Thanks for the update, David!
I saw the report of this on C&L, and also on KO last night but those reports did not include what appears to be essential info: Corker and Sessions ready to back Bunning.
As for where the Republican so-called ‘leadership’ is…?
Lemme guess: at AEI. Or at some K-Street corner office, calling instructions into the GOP Senate offices…?
Shorter Stabenow and Merkley:
We don’t have the guts to stand for genuine leadership and do what’s right when it’s just easier to be seduced into the ease of political convenience.
Do us a favor then, cowards: Just put numbers by your flaccid excuses to save us some time.
And another thing DNC, DLCC, et al.–I’m not giving you one more goddam cent until you people actually demonstrate you have the courage to represent principled leadership that benefits the people that elect you and traditional Democratic values, not extending the failure we call the status quo by being Republican Lite.
You should see the write up that Faux news gives this issue. They state the Repubs in the red corner led by Bunning and the Dems in the blue corner led by Durbin. They don’t even mention the fact that so many people will be without benefits but they certainly managed to turn the issue around and blame the Democrats specifically Harry Reid because they said that the unemployment benefits was in the original jobs bill.
You hit it right on the head. If the Democrats start sticking it to the Repubs the media and the American public might finally start taking notice
Can they recover these extentions come Monday morning?
So, Bunning stops UI benefit renewal, so children will starve.
I suppose this will be all over the newspapers and t.v. news to show Americans what the Republicans are doing.
“No”? That damn Liberal press just won’t act Liberal at all. I wonder why that is. Anybody who calls the press Liberal is just a damn liar.
Exactly how is it that they can hurt tens of thousands of people and the press “doesn’t notice”? Can you imagine them doing the same if a Dem had said “Tough shit!” on the floor of the Senate? I know I can’t.
The press is as guilty of letting this kind of behavior go on as are the Republicans. You can’t let this kind of crap go on without very bad outcomes somewhere down the road. The people need to know what their elected reps are doing. It’s fundamental to our system of gov’t.
I certainly hope that video is safely on some Dem computers.
My two sendems,(Wyden/Merkley)are the epitome of the hopeless, gutless, pussyfied, fuckwitted, dem caucus. These two are forever holding up the sendem banner signalling cave-in, surrender, run/hide, snivel/make excuses, shrug shoulders/say we tried. ad nauseum! The senate, a cess pool of spineless, corrupt, sissyfied corporatist whores.
dday, c’mon on, put the blame where it belongs.
This IS Obama’s, Reid, & Pelosi’s FAULT. These lying, stealing fascist f’ks should be so marginalized that they’re begging US for foodstamps so they can eat -
WHY are lying, stealing fascist fucks NOT marginalized?
Sell out “leaders” in the “opposition” party.
rmm.
HELLO – you’re two pathetics can NOT compete with MY pathetics!! murray and cantwell! don’t forget, we’re from the great pacified northwest state of wishy warshy!
rmm.
Does anyone know, can benefits and COBRA be extended by executive order?
Absolutely not. The Senate, however, will be revisiting the COBRA and other extensions bill this week, as Reid acted on Friday (through Udall) to get the bill on the calendar, ready to be brought to the floor for a vote (instead of attempting to call it up and pass it by unanimous consent):
As Reid explained Friday morning:
Going back to last Thursday, Harry Reid offered the first two unanimous consent requests on H.R. 4691 to which Bunning objected – the first unpaid-for, and the second permitting an amendment to be offered to the unpaid-for bill by Bunning (to pay for the bill), and voted on, before the bill passed. Here’s Bunning’s explanation for his second objection:
Harry Reid then moved on to ask unanimous consent to speed up a cloture motion vote (so the Senate wouldn’t need to wait until Friday to vote) on another bill (on which Reid had “filled the tree” to prevent any Senator from calling up a floor amendment to the bill), which he received, after which he said:
Later Thursday here’s a sampling of how subsequent Unanimous Consent Requests on H.R. 4691 went, as initiated by Assistant Majority Leader Durbin:
Shortly before Durbin started that sequence on the floor Thursday evening, Reid spoke and received unanimous consent to proceed to a different bill on Monday:
My eligibility for continued unemployment insurance payments ends today. I had 13 weeks remaining. I lost a job in a local print shop that I had held for 8 years. That was a year ago this month. If 51 senators had decided not to extend unemployment benefits I would not object or complain. But this is the work of one man and he did it just to be an ass hole. Tough shit he says. If I ever meet Bunning I will show him some tough shit.
Selise,
Thank you for the link from powwow’s comment. He provided a link to the GPO (Government Printing Office) through some searching brought me to this section to view the transcripts of daily business in the congress.
Bunning puts on a good show but is disingenuous at best. If he really wanted to pay for the extension in benefits instead of gutting the stimulus funds that are already being relied upon for job creation, he needs to look no further then military appropriations or funding to corrupt regimes that we keep propping up.
My big concern is it appears there were only 4 people on the floor to vote on this extension. Is that the way we want our money being spent by allowing just 4 people to decide instead of a majority of the Senate present?
It’s times like these that make me feel that Democrats are more interested in putting on a show about how powerless they are than in actually getting the legislation passed.
So the story we’re supposed to buy now is that Bunning refused to give his support to a unanimous consent resolution, and there’s no other way to get this bill passed?
Sounds a bit suspicious to me.