Jim Bunning’s one-man filibuster of a temporary extension of unemployment benefits (which actually may not have been a one-man filibuster at all) has drawn fire from Congressional Democrats today, even while leaders today introduced a broader measure, including a one-year extension of UI and the COBRA subsidy, along with dozens of other tax extenders and additional measures.
Democrats are certainly trying to make a political point over Bunning’s rejection of unanimous consent to move a short-term extension on several items which expired on Sunday. Bunning continued his refusal this morning.
Not only have hundreds of thousands of unemployed Americans lost their unemployment benefits (14,000 in Bunning’s home state of Kentucky) and 65% subsidy to pay for COBRA health benefits. In addition, doctors just received a 21% pay cut for Medicare patients, as per the so-called “sustainable growth rate” (SGR). Congress typically patches the SGR to avoid the cut, known colloquially as the “doc fix,” but the patch elapsed, leading to the immediate reimbursement cut. As a result, doctors may refuse to accept millions of Medicare patients. Likewise, an expiration on highway funding means that thousands of construction workers just got furloughed for construction and infrastructure projects.
Also, in perhaps the greatest suffering you can extend to any American, millions of satellite TV subscribers in rural areas could lose access to local TV channels, as a result of an expiring mandate on satellite providers.
McClatchy actually had a good breakdown of all the expired deadlines triggered by Bunning’s action.
Progressives have begun to organize against the Bunning filibuster, and locals in Louisville have a protest scheduled for tomorrow at his office.
This, in addition to the torrent of criticism from national Democrats, is starting to get to Bunning. He ran away from reporters today.
Said Bunning: “I’m not talking to anybody.”
When producers asked him to stay and talk on camera, Bunning “walked toward the elevator and shot the middle finger over his head.”
A video clip shows Bunning kicking correspondent Jon Karl off the elevator, yelling “Excuse me! This is a Senator’s only elevator!”
(That’s not actually true.)
Even Jon Kyl, a member of the Republican leadership, said this weekend that the Senate would pass a temporary UI extension over Bunning’s objections, though he clearly hasn’t lifted a finger to get Bunning to relent.
Even while Democrats pressure Bunning to lift his objection to a temporary extension, however, Harry Reid and Max Baucus have readied a bill that would extend unemployment benefits and the COBRA subsidy to the end of the year, and offer retroactive payments to anyone who lost their benefits. The American Workers, State, and Business Relief Act has a number of provisions beyond that, however, including SBA loan programs for small businesses, disaster relief and flood insurance provisions, an important extension of federal assistance for state Medicaid programs that states with struggling budgets sorely need, retroactive extensions of highway funding, the doc fix and the satellite TV mandate, and a series of “tax extenders” that provide tax cuts which expired late last year.
You can access the bill at the Senate Finance Committee website. The tax extenders are a very mixed bag, with some important credits for renewable energy companies, teacher expenses (so they don’t have to shell out for their own classroom supplies) and others, but also corporate giveaways like the R&D credit and many others. Basically these are many of the measures Reid stripped from an earlier jobs bill, which passed last week.
But this bill would cost much more than that $85 billion dollar measure – $150 billion, to be exact. There are only about $37 billion in offsets in the bill.
So while Bunning feels the heat from Democrats, the bill that would cover unemployment and COBRA till the end of the year, along with a multitude of other measures, could get a vote as early as this week, overriding Bunning’s UC objections.
UPDATE: Looks like we could see an estate tax change attached to this bill as an amendment. Keep in mind that the changes sought to the estate tax could deprive the government of at least $233 BILLION in revenue over ten years, all of it going to super-rich heirs to family fortunes.





70 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
So it was mainly about giving the super-wealthy a massive estate tax break all along and not about making sure that Congress paid for the extenders provisions as suggested by Bunning?
http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2010/02/26/should-the-jobs-bill-be-held-up-for-an-estate-tax/
OT: More breaking news about Patterson…another piece of scum, apparently. So sad.
Ha. Knew there was some ‘protect the rich’ associated with this shenanigan. & Ds will go along, of course.
Link?
Paterson is someone I had no priors about. Patter was positive, but waited to see whatever. What a failure.
I enquired on an earlier thread whether the poor political leadership was a sign of end of empire. Worth repeating every time an example pops up. Don’t know any who are much good.
Must see Jim Bunning Video!!
What an ass!
So, Harry stripped out the tax extenders and the estate tax fix (yea!) so he could put it back in two weeks later? (boo!)
Is there some contest for looking ridiculous?
Very interesting that he hit more batters than anyone else. Wonder if that is accurate.
According to this website, he’s #8.
Wow. So the Dems are going to replicate Bunning’s FUBAR antics?
He just handed them his ass, along with the GOP, on a silver platter.
And their reaction is to park their own asses on that silver platter, right along with his…?!
Unbelievable.
Every elevator Bunning rides is a Senators-only elevator in his own mind.
How are they going to do pay/go on the estate tax giveaway?
This may be the link RevBev is referring to:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/02/nyregion/02paterson.html
Protecting a wife beater– not good politics. Not good period.
Actually, some ABC reporter got terrific footage of Bunning’s senatorial arrogance. It’s actually a nice piece of reporting, in the sense that you have to see it to believe it.
(Dylan Ratigan ran the clip on his MSNBC show today. It’s not your average conversation with a Senator 8-0
you trust him to be accurate?? without looking I am dubious of his website’s claim…
To paraphrase the old saying…
Inconsistency is the Republican hobgoblin to reality based minds.
Republicans are completely inconsistent, and don’t even mind it one bit.
Duho!
Oh, saw that earlier. Agree, Paterson’s involvement is reminiscent of Spitzer sending out the state police to harrass people investigating him (or something to that effect; I don’t keep track of details). Thought it might be yet another something I hadn’t heard of yet.
Who is the ‘him’ in you q? I have no idea what is accurate, which is why I asked and why I went to look for what I could find. If you have some actual information, please present it.
Link?
Charlie Hough was a knuckleballer for the Dodgers. He’s hit more batters than Bunning.
Caught a snippet of Tweetie tonight, just at the moment when he was avering that someone thought Bunning was a bit off. Can’t remember his exact words but implication was that Bunning really had a screw loose. Wouldn’t be a bit surprised. Loved Bunning’s screed against Bernanke in the confirmation hearings, knowing all the while I shouldn’t feel warm & fuzzies toward him just because he was right for once.
Bunning is an asshole, and the entire Senate is an asshole for pretending that Bunning has any standing to obstruct unemployment insurance benefits extensions at this time of historic unemployment. Bunning’s antics in front of the entire country should serve as the final needed proof that, whatever purpose it is that the Senate is serving at this point, that purpose has nothing in common with the needs or interests of the vast majority of the population. Anytime some cracked politician can personally obstruct desperately needed economic aid to unemployed people during an emergency using some sort of quaint parliamentary tactic you know that it isn’t just the politician himself who is being a malignant creep and atrocious burden on normal people but the institution that abides by his “standing” as well.
I just can’t believe the Senate is allowing some geriatric baseball celebrity who bought himself a seat to get in the way of pressing emergency economic aid to the American public. The Senate (both parties) is ok with foreign war funding, with giving trillions of dollars to bankers, etc., but allow some out-of-work guy a pittance of a check for another few months while employers dither about hiring? Hell no, they won’t do that!
Where is my pitchfork when I need it? I have my torch lit already but I can’t find my pitchfork! Where DID it get to?
dude – major league hitters would get in line to be “hit” with a knuckleball.
And then laugh all the way to first base.
It’s been rumored for a year or more now he’s suffering from Alzheimer’s.
yup it is all there the Internets don’t lie too often… but sometimes..
BREAKING!!!!!
The editors of the NYT decide that they haven’t pimped enough for Harold Ford, Jr.,
and give Ford one more chance to vent before he crawls back to the warm embrace of Merrill Lynch.
According to the link, Hough is #5 at 174, with Bunning at 160. #1 is Walter Johnson at 203-206.
I think a lot of people are suffering more from his Alzheimer’s than he is.
Thats AllyzHeimzers to you buddy!!
I wouldn’t be a bit surprised. The kind of anger he displays, both in Bernanke hearing and in recent episode, could be symptoms. But IANAD, so consider my opinion less than useful.
Two of the GREATEST pitchers of all time in Big Train Johnson and Cy Young, then there’s Randy Johnson who made it to 300 wins, he was WILD in his younger days, like Koufax was. Add Hough (a knuckler will DO that to ya) and it’s four of eight, and I know VERY little about Plank, McGinnity and Fraser.,
Outside of Sal Maglie, though, nicnamed The Barber, who THREW at people ALL the time, Bunning IS one of the worst of all time in terms of pure malice.
And Don Drysdale and Bob Gibson were BOTH known to be headhunters if you crowed THEIR plate.
But Bunning, he was mean then, and now.
1 Walter Johnson 203
2 Eddie Plank 196
3 Joe McGinnity 182
4 Chick Fraser 177
5 Charlie Hough 174
6 Randy Johnson 168
7 Cy Young 163
8 Jim Bunning 160
Unbelievable? lmao
Feels like the thirty seventh viewing of an instant replay.
Well, that’s a point I don’t wish to make, as my parents died from alzheimers.
But I wish Bunning were no longer serving in Congress, for a FEW years now.
If Bunning is such an outlier, why aren’t the Republicans joining with the Democrats to stop his filibuster?
That was my link. Nahant doubted it at 14. Do you have reason to believe it or to doubt it?
It is a terrible thing but the Rs should not cover for him. Imagine a sick old man having this much power.
Scary.
I’m a baseball fan, and he was once upon a time a great competitor in the game, so I tended to keep an eye out for his name in politics over the decades. Sadly, the past two years have had rumors swirling, and his behavior and actions CERTAINLY doing little to dispell the rumors.
Insidious disease, no matter who gets it. He should be out of Congress, one way or another, for his actions the past two years . . .
That was sorta my point. The only other pitcher up there from the modern era is Randy Johnson.
The good news is Ford is out. I’m not a Gillibrand fan, though her recent pre-election lip service to some progressive causes is better than nothing, but Ford is truly disgusting.
It’s a valid and commonly accessed statistics site for sports, what’s not to believe? Why would anyone question it?
I think Nahant might have looked at quickly and saw what I first saw in the blue linky . . it READS ‘this site’, but I saw at first ‘his site’, meaning it was Bunning’s site. Once I clicked in, I realized it was ‘this site’, and my eyes were playing twicks on me as I was speed scanning comments . . .
Lengthy reply about very little, huh . . . lol ;-)
I caught onto him only as recently as the Bernanke hearing. What other misbehavior?
I had a number of interactions with David Paterson when he was an assemblyman from Harlem and I was working for the city in Harlem. He was always working hard for the people in his district and I was always very impressed with him.
When Spitzer had to step down I felt OK with Paterson especially after the initial efforts to dirty him up so that Bruno could take over as governor before the 2008 elections fell short.
What has soured me on him, though, is his refusal to tax millionaires to help with budget shortfalls while having no problem with cutting school budgets, canceling STAR rebates for homeowners, attaching a 5 cent deposit to bottled water, all these things that affect families and allow the finance sector and its star earners who live in NY to gather as many shekels as possible while giving nothing back.
Good riddance David, it’s a shame you had to go out this way.
sheesh eCahn “I” didn’t say “he” was the worst but.. he sure was a head hunter… I wonder… just for you statisticians how many hits per pitch, who hit the most batters and the medical results of such egregious physical damage done to the batters????
The R’s are NOT covering for him, they got him to DO it!! The R’s are indeed using a man who is likely in some advancing stage of a terminal illness. It’s how they roll. Same as the ‘rotating villian’ the dem’s use.
Ask nahant. I just look, find, and ask. My only prior on baseball is that it’s not about the sport but rather all about the stats. So I give the benefit of the doubt to a site that has baseball stats. But since I know nothing about the sport or the stats, I stand ready to be schooled.
Heh, saw Tim Wakefield a bit further down the list, another knuckler.
Charlie Hough is pretty modern. (I remember him. Also Drysdale and Koufax – he’s still around.)
Wow, didn’t hear Ford was out! Great news! Yeah, Kirsten G, another semi prog with ties to big money. Sigh.
Thanks for the flavor & anecdotes. I hadn’t thought of a millionaires’ tax (shame on me with all the Wall St. comp issues in the news), but you are absolutely right. Tax the rich bastards first, cut spending second.
I meant other than Charlie. I’ve spent many an afternoon at Dodger stadium watching Charlie throw that thing.
It’s hard to get out of the way of that thing, slow as it is. You lean back it follows ya.
Why do Senators get their own elevator? Are the some kind of untouchable royalty? I rather think not and that needs to get changed ASAP. Really Really. I might be tilting at a windmill, but that shit sucks. They are not little lordlings running their little fiefdoms in DC, no matter how much they desire to be.
His Wiki.
There’s enough info there to set the patterns up, I don’t have specific examples of his actions at hand.
Start with his House info and read down from there . . . even Big Dawg called him ‘mean spirited’ and couldn’t work with him . . . ;-)
Your link said he was the worst. Just following up ’cause you can’t trust everything you read/hear on the internet. He’s certainly bad, and your link could have characterized him as ‘one of the worst.’ Or since the worst, Johnson, was pre-WWII, maybe Bunning was the worst in recent history. I have no idea. But characterizations like in your link beg for google, and when they fail the google test, create credibility problems.
Hey eCAHN “I” never said he was tyhe worst but yes the video did ,,..,,… and.. come on are you saying he is not what the evidence says he is??? Just another ass who thinks he is King…& can do what ever “HE” wants and screw the people??
certainly sounds like a SOB. Whether that means SOB augmented by Alzheimer’s anger remains to be seen. He’ll soon be gone, more’s the blessing.
I think you might have posted at the same time as my 54, which explains why I asked what I did, and how your link might have avoided the problem. I know nothing about BB, so when I hear ‘worst’ I take it literally. If it is not accurate, I doubt the source. Is that not reasonable?
evening, firegods
Basking in the Reagan Glow
Looks to me like Bunning takes it as a compliment when anyone calls him the new Ronald Reagan, unaware that they are referring to people in high office who display unmistakeable symptoms of senile dementia.
Score another one for the Gipper, Jim.
watertiger is upstairs!
Late Night: How Do You Say “Bitchslap” in Dutch?
This is not about Bunning and his Alzheimer’s or just dementia, or just SOB-ness. It’s about the Gooper leadership enabling him, or worse, putting out front to shit on the rug in a way they are just too cowardly to do themselves. But they can stop him, or it, and they won’t. THEY are the problem. DUH!
It’s because they only have one goal — to take down this administration and majority controlled congress exactly according to Rove’s 2008 plan.
And they don’t care what it costs the country.
Sounds like Obama is making good on his promise to negotiate with terrorists, domestic ones anyway.
Scrooge 2’0
Are there no prisons 1 ” asked Bunning
“Plenty of prisons,” said the gentleman, laying
down the pen again.
” And the Union workhouses ? ” demanded Bunning
** Are they still in Operation ? ”
“They are. Still,” returned the gentleman, “I
wish I could say they were not.”
” The Treadmill and the Poor Law are in full vigor,
then. ” Said Bunning.
” Both very busy, sir.”
‘^ Oh ! I was afraid, from what you said at first, that
something had occurred to stop them in their useful
course,” said Bunning. ” I am very glad to hear it.”
“Under the impression that they scarcely furnish
Christian cheer of mind or body to the multitude,
returned the gentleman, ” a few of us are endeavoring
to raise a fund to buy the Poor some meat and drink,
and means of warmth. We choose this time, because
it is a time, of all others, when Want is keenly felt, and
Abundance rejoices. What shall I put you down for ? ”
” Nothing ! ” Bunning replied.
” You wish to be anonymous”
” I wish to be left alone,” said Bunning. ” Since you
ask me what I wish, gentlemen, that is my answer. I
don’t make merry myself ever, and I can’t
afford to make idle people merry. I help to support the
establishments I have mentioned — ^they cost enough :
and those who are badly off must go there.”
” Many can’t go there ; and many would rather die.”
I’m a little dickens aren’t I. Thanks Chuck
Bunning and Kyl made it pretty clear how the GOPErs really feel about average Americans out of work. Kyl called us all BUMS. Yea, were BUMS and what are they? WHORES! They gladly piss away trillions to the wealthy and their Big Corps. but don’t see the hypocrisy in denying their laid off employees a nickel? Why? because in their world-view if your out of work your a bad person a criminal that must have done something wrong to have ended up in such a place. Criminals are punished and unemployment is punishment and shouldn’t be rewarded. It’s that simple.
Bunning is pretty much just Republican concentrate. He is the unadulterated residue of the mean spirited, hateful, sociopathic thing at the heart of modern conservatism. Add an occasional reference to “what the American people want” or what “the founders intended”, and you create their most eloquent, thoughtful proponent.
When my wife was laid off two years ago, unemployment benefits didn’t amount to a 10th of what she was being paid. Also, Cobra is no disincentive to work – but without it you might have to choose between the death of a family member or personal bankruptcy.
Sens. Bunning and Kyle, like most senators, either are living off of inherited money, being supported by a wealthy family or are fortunate enough to have retained 6- or 7-figure incomes (along with at least a like amount of corporate campaign bribes) without interruption from an inconvenient recession. But about 15% of U.S. citizens have fared otherwise. Apparently the Republican corporate elite will be satisfied about the time the American middle class goes the way of its Mexican counterpart.
Bunning speaking about jobs bill live on senate floor now
Bunning’s claimed objection was always bogus. It was ALWAYS about the Estate Tax.
We can not afford to pay unemployment benefits forever. This recession has a long way to go. It’s sad but true.
Stop him how?