The National Council of La Raza just issued their opposition to the health care bill, saying that the immigration restrictions (which disallow undocumented workers from buying coverage on the exchange with their own money) are too punitive to earn their support.
“[NCLR] believes in supporting efforts that address the concerns; the House bill did this, the Senate bill did not,” said Jennifer Ng’andu, Deputy Director of the Health Policy Project. “We supported the House bill. It contained rigorous safeguards that would extend access to health care to all U.S. residents while preventing unauthorized workers from receiving taxpayer-funded subsidies. The spirit of the bill worked to ensure access to coverage for vulnerable, eligible families and children, and it was a health reform plan worthy of our support. We cannot say the same for the Senate bill, nor can we support reconciliation if the health care reform proposal remains unchanged.”
In airing such concerns about the health care legislation so close to Congress voting on its passage, NCLR adds yet another element of intrigue into whether the bill actually has the necessary votes. Already, members of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus have threatened to vote against the Senate bill for provisions that they argue would bar access to health care for even legal immigrants; prevent illegal immigrants from using their own money to purchase health insurance from the proposed health insurance exchanges; and would erect overly burdensome barriers to enrollment for Latino families and children.
Luis Gutierrez, who has been out front on this issue and continues to insist that he will vote against passage, wrote yesterday that he was no longer able to “confidently say yes” to the bill, which is actually a far cry from a firm No. But the NCLR opposition will have a lot of Hispanic lawmakers thinking. And there’s something else.
With the health care bill pushed back to Sunday, it will now coincide with a large protest on the National Mall from immigration reform supporters. The March for America has been planned for months, designed to spur action in Washington to a comprehensive solution to the immigration problem. The organizers are angry that their call for reform has been ignored and that immigrant raids have increased since President Obama entered office.
And now, members of Congress will be voting on a health care bill that punishes undocumented immigrants, on the same day. Some of them, like Gutierrez (whose op-ed is much more about getting immigration reform going than health care) may take to the lectern moments before voting. This dynamic really does impact whether Hispanic House members can justify their vote.



9 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Not providing free health care for folks illegally in the country is punitive?
That will go over well.
I don’t see how people apply the word “punitive” to this part of the bill’s language. I am hispanic and also sympathetic to how people can feel that way. But are we to allow anyone and everyone absolute rights and priviledges without the requirement of citizenship? Remember not everyone that is here illegally is hispanic. The issue isn’t that cut and dry. It’s a new program so, are we to immediately put finacial strain on it and deplete it’s effectiveness even before it gets off the ground? These issues can be worked on later.
I’m guessing these members have received assurances there will be a fix for this disgraceful provision in the forth comming Immigration reform bill.
Here is the reality, there are Undocumented workers who are here and would be willing to buy their own HCI. If they cant they, and their familys will end up in the Emergency rooms costing all of us a lot more. So the issue is, do we want to be so obsessed over punishing “ILLegals” and spiteing ourselves in the process or do we want to allow PEOPLE to pay for and get the health insurance they need, no matter their immigration status.
Oh, by the way as a Hispanic you should be aware YOU will most likely constantly find yourself being forced to provide proof of Citizenship at every turn even if you show up in the ER. Nice
Dave, please don’t use the propaganda term “undocumented workers” — puh-leaze, they’re undocumented because they are illegal immigrants, not because the government for who-knows-what-reason has failed to give them “documents.”
That term, pushed by one side, is ridiculously misleading and requires a person have a lot of background knowledge to know what it means. The only people using it are latte liberal journalists who are happy to screw the working class if it saves them a buck at Whole Foods.
Millions of foreigners are legally in the country because they have non-immigrant visas, such as temporary worker visas, foreign student visas, and other types of non-immigrant visas. They are often given those visas because that’s the only option available to them (sometimes because their employers don’t want to go through the much more costly, lengthy and uncertain process of soponsoring them for a green card).
These people face plenty of hurdles trying to switch their status to permanent resident (and in a timely manner so they don’t fall out of legal status). You won’t become a permanent resident (aka green card holder) unless you are sponsored by a spouse (but not if you are gay, since the federal government won’t recognize your relationship for immigration purposes) or an employer –but careful not to lose your temporary worker status before getting that green card: if you lose your job, are promoted or transferred, or if you just try to get a different job because you realize your current one isn’t a good match, then you will go back to the end of the line.
So yes, these are law-abiding, hard-working, tax-paying individuals, and the government is not making it easy for them to become permanent residents. Some of them may fall out of legal status while navigating the US immigration system and trying to do everything by the book. I don’t think we should make it illegal for them to participate in the health insurance exchanges.
I second that.
Rusty please don’t use the propaganda term Illegal alien. The are no illegal people according to our Declaration of independence all people are created equal! There may be people who are here illegally that is true but they are not illegal and they are not aliens from outer space either.