The Speaker’s office denied any deal with Bishop Stupak and his monsignors last night, and now this morning, a press conference they were planning for 11am has been put on hold. Lynn Woolsey denied on the record that there was a deal, probably because of what she said later, “all pro-choice female Dems will bolt if Stupak prevails.”
Now the Democrats are calling the last card on Stupak – his mentor, John Dingell.
Veteran Democratic Rep. John Dingell vowed Saturday to work to defeat fellow Michigan Rep. Bart Stupak (D) on abortion in the healthcare bill.
Dingell, the longest-serving member of the House whose career has centered around healthcare reform, said he would work to “beat” Stupak’s efforts to add additional restrictions on federal support for abortion to the healthcare bill before the House.
“I strongly disagree with Bart,” Dingell said during an appearance on MSNBC. “I think he’s wrong.”
Both the anti-choice and pro-choice side have the power to stop the leadership from getting to 216 votes. I’m revamping the whip count chart a bit to reflect that from the anti-choice perspective. From the pro-choice perspective, Diana DeGette still holds a letter with 40 names on it, all of whom would vote no if the Stupak deal came to pass, and they wouldn’t need that many – 10 would probably be sufficient.
The path of least resistance remains going around Stupak by peeling off a couple members of his bloc. But this will probably go all day. The Rules Committee has already started their markup, and remember in November, the deal wasn’t made to get a vote on the Stupak amendment until late on the night of the committee hearing.



4 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
If passing this is so important to democrats, why is one supposedly minor issue derailing it from both sides of the abortion issue? I think it is because they know the bill is bad and are just looking for any excuse to get out of voting for it.
Analyzing the facts I can’t see how anyone, republican or democrat, can support this bill. Insurance companies have the most to gain from it. Personally I have a lot to lose. I am self employed and pay about $3000 a year for a $5000 deductible health care plan for my family of 3. It covers some preventative care, and we make sure we have savings to cover something catastrophic like a car accident or serious illness. Our household income is just over the $88,000 subsidy limit. So now it looks like we will be forced to pay a $12000-$15000 (according to CBO estimates for a minimum plan meeting the bills requirements) a year for something we don’t want. That is in addition to the extra taxes I will be paying to cover the huge cost of the bill.
This “reform” is going to subsidize unhealthy lifestyles and wasteful consumption and push health care spending through the roof.
Dear GOD, which is it? Has Pelosi handed over the keys to my uterus, or has she NOT?
What the fucking FUCK.
The keys to your (and my) uterus are not in issue at the moment, whatever Nancy Pelosi agrees to (or doesn’t). This is all process.
Yeah, I know it’s process. Nevertheless, procedurally, Bart Stupak is demanding it. And Nancy Pelosi and President Obama seem to be capitulating to everyone BUT the liberals in the process.
Sometimes this tyranny of the minority shit drives me insane.