This sounds like something better done from Washington.
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) urged Republicans Friday to stop blocking an extension of unemployment benefits.
In a statement responding to Friday’s jobs report, Reid said the high unemployment rate demonstrates the need for another extension.
“With so many families in Nevada and across the country still struggling to find work and make ends meet, it is imperative that Senate Republicans stop blocking the extension of critical unemployment insurance and health benefits — their obstruction endangers the economic certainty of millions of families,” Reid said.
All true enough. But with the expiration date for hundreds of thousands of jobless on Monday, and Congress having spent a week in their districts, taking the time now to demand movement on the extension misses the point a bit. The fact is that cloture could have been invoked much earlier, while the Senate was still in session, and a vote forced that would have made Republicans stand with either struggling families or Jim Bunning and Tom Coburn. If Bunning and Coburn won out, so be it; this statement would make more sense. As it is, Democrats tried to get unanimous consent on an extension, couldn’t, and went home, vowing to take it up later and make the benefits retroactive. That’s a costly activity that adds uncertainty to both families and state governments. And it didn’t really need to happen.




20 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Missing the point is the great benefit of having Harry Reid be Majority Leader, for those who put him there. His great ineptness makes them all look good, and his ability to duck responsibility takes them all off the hook for actually governing.
It’s a feature, not a bug.
Oh, and retroactive benefits don’t pay rent due yesterday.
Once again, the Democrats cower in the corner and beg “Please. Don’t. Hurt. Me.”
Disgraceful. The GOP rat bastards need to be told “We got the votes to shut you down. Go along or don’t, we don’t need you.”
Instead they cower like the cowards they are. Disgraceful.
The Senate Democrats think the only way they American unemployed will feel the pain of interrupted benefits is to actually interrupt their benefits, instead of filing cloture timely so that there could be a vote before recess. Using the pain of unemployed Americans to make your electoral point seven months before Election Day is a pretty stupid lesson to take away from Clinton’s win over Gingrich on shutting down the whole federal government.
Nice one, Harry — call us when you really show you care.
Fuck you, Harry.
Do you think that those of us that owe taxes could just turn in our forms on April 15th and tell them we’ll pay them later retroactively?
Certainly the US Senate does not care about people who are out of work and need government monetary assistance. The vast majority of the people in and around the US Senate have never, I am quite certain, regarded anyone who has no choice but to work for a living as anything but an inferior status of human being to be regarded as part of a broad “masses”.
Filing of cloture before recess is about priorities. If the entire weight of the US national government was needed to assist a multi-billionaire in tying his own shoes, then the Senate would go into overtime with locked-door day-and-night struggle to get the most generous version of the required assistance passed with all haste. However, a mass of poor people can simply swim off into the sea for all the politicians care, the growth rate of the population will replenish their work force in short order.
Incompetence. Hopefully Reid will be justly rewarded come November.
Reid is an asshole. How did we end up with such limp eel in charge of the Senate? I hope Nevadans will stop gambling on this loser.
it is actually refreshing to see comments which reflect reality, instead of diaries and diaries filled with whining about how meanie not nicey lying, cheating, stealing fascists are being mean, not nice, and, btw, lying, stealing and cheating.
Oh yeah, and the diaries gotta contain whining how our sell out “leaders” and how our Diaper-P00Per political zer0es are getting their noble, selfless asses kicked, yawn, again.
Lions and Tigers and Bears, Oh My!
Funny how max & LIEberscum can derail health CARE into AHIP welfare, but my worthless senators, murray and cantwell – can’t do shit.
rmm.
could someone, preferably from Nevada, email this page (or a link to this page) to dickless Harry the prick ?
As usual you people miss the point. You can not pay people not to work for ever. The longer you do so the longer these same people will not find work.
Let me illustrate with a little story I put together a few months ago (but is just as relevant now as it ever was).
Ed Norton works in the sewers. Or at least he did up until a week ago. Ed got laid off and the prospects of being called back to work are dismal. Ed used to make $1,000 a week for working down in the sewers. He’ll miss that income, but he knows thanks to the government he’ll be entitled to unemployment benefits for a full year.
Ed starts to do the math. He knows he’ll only get $500 a week in unemployment but then realizes there is no social security tax on these benefits. When he had his job about 8% of his gross pay went for social security/medicare taxes.
He also now realizes some of his unemployment is not subject to any income taxes thanks to recent legislation passed Congress. Back when Ed had his job roughly 25% of his pay went to combined state and federal income taxes. When he was making $1,000 a week, he was only bringing home about $670 after the above taxes (income and social security).
Lastly, Ed realizes he will eliminate the costs of getting to and from work and buying lunch out (since it’s not practical to take your lunch if you work in the sewers). He figures these costs amount to about another 7% of his previous gross pay.
The bottom line is Ed’s take home pay after all taxes and expenses was only about $600 when he had his job. When he compares that to his unemployment benefits of $500 that are basically tax free, he realizes he is only actually pocketing about 15% less than when he was working full time. He also knows he will now qualify for food stamps which will greatly help offset that 15%. In the end he will be getting just as much financial benefits being unemployed as he did when he was stomping around down in the sewers.
Ed knows he has an extra 45 hours of free time each and every week for an entire year. He also knows the government may well extend unemployment benefits even longer than a year by the time he nears exhausting his benefits.
Ed is absolutely ecstatic about his situation now that he sees he is control of all his time and all he gives up is a small fraction of his previous $1,000 per week. He rushes downstairs to tell his good friend Ralph and to suggest to Ralph he should find a way to get laid off too so they can shoot pool all day and go bowling in the evenings.
America truly is the land of opportunity…to do nothing and get paid for it.
The UI extension vote is once again a typical cluster fuck the dems in the Senate have become notorious for. To prove their hate for the working classes in America, the rethugs jam it up the dems asses and just say “NO!”.
And what do the dems do? They go hat in hand begging these cracker-state plantation owners for help by bleating and braying about bipartisanship.
Will somebody among the Senate dems get some balls already?!? As for Reid, it’s time to put this wheezy old geezer out to pasture. Times have changed and he can’t seem to play the hard-assed politics needed and required to tamp down the obstructionist rethugs and run this government.
On behalf of all of us, Thanks for everything Harry – Now go home…
Your fucked up attitude towards working class Americans and your subsequent twisted logic to justify it under the guise of social responsibility just boggles the mind of rational people every where tinman1967.
Tinman1967 meet Roeder, Roeder meet tinman1967. You two have a lot in common – your both sociopaths with the delusions of moral superiority over all others. The only thing missing from your screed tinman1967 is that you failed to mention that “god spoke to you” and told you what to write…
There are no rational people around here.
save for you, of course.
Of course….
If they let people’s unemployment run out, people will stop applying and the numbers will look better.
It always puzzles me, the type of individual that writes such condescending dribble.