Not to overlook the Wall Street reform bill in Congress, but we have an important new development in the priority ordering for the next major bill:
Democratic leaders are pushing ahead with plans to move comprehensive immigration reform legislation this year — even if it means punting on energy legislation until next Congress.
According to Senate Democratic aides, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) agreed during a Tuesday afternoon meeting that a “moral imperative” exists to move immigration reform in 2010. The decision to press ahead on such a controversial issue now — in an election year — comes even though Democrats have had little success attracting GOP support for their initiatives in the 111th Congress. Hispanic Members have been ramping up the pressure on President Barack Obama to force the issue with Congress.
During the meeting, Reid “reiterated his intention to move forward” this year on immigration reform, one aide said, adding that Pelosi agreed it is a top priority, even beyond energy legislation.
I’m a bit surprised by this. Unlike climate change, the House hasn’t passed their own immigration bill, and given the makeup of the Democratic caucus they’ll be hard-pressed to do so. And with some of the key Republicans who supported a comprehensive package the last time Congress took it up in 2006 now arguing for border security or against reform altogether, the math doesn’t look too hot either.
But there are definitely political reasons for moving immigration up. Harry Reid has made lots of promises about immigration reform in his home state of Nevada, which has a rising Hispanic population. The President has his reputation on the line over this as well. And in general, Democrats may feel that wedging Republicans and permanently splitting them off from Hispanic voters, the fastest-growing segment of the population, is good politics.
That said, at this stage of the legislative calendar, these bills are a zero-sum game. If immigration moves up, something else must move down, and that would be the climate bill. John Kerry, Lindsey Graham and Joe Lieberman plan to drop their version of a bill next week, but they’ve already lost two key Republicans, who have split off to try and push their own scaled-back bill:
Republicans George V. Voinovich of Ohio and Richard G. Lugar of Indiana are developing an energy-only bill that would mandate new renewable and nuclear power production without imposing cuts on carbon emissions. [...]
“I’d like to get something done,” [Voinovich] said. “But I’m not sure it would meet the standards of the environmental groups or what Sen. Kerry would like to get done. I’d like to do the doable — move it down the field while I can.”
Given the giveaways to industry that KGL have been handing out, given the weakness of their overall approach, I could see the value in a pure renewables and energy efficiency bill (without the nuclear industry subsidization). As Dave Roberts at Grist says, there are a variety of ways we can tackle climate change beyond pricing carbon, and it becomes harder for Congress to mess up energy efficiency or improving the electrical grid, or even local control issues like utility reform or controlling sprawl. I don’t see any kind of numbers for a real carbon pricing scheme in the Senate, so we might have to put in a renewable standard and hope we can put sulfur in the air or giant mirrors to block the sun’s rays if it comes to that.
As for the Republican reaction to this, given the target-rich environment for them of “illegal aliens” or “uppity climate scientists who want to control us,” it’s probably six in one, a half-dozen in the other.




20 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Thanks for monitoring all that’s doing in D.C. I’m getting increasing depressed with each passing day, and I might have to mostly absent myself from the ugliness that will be immigration debate, just to maintain my own emotional stability.
Maybe they made a deal with Grijalva during the health insurance company bailout reform bill thing.
This’ll go over well with LGBT folks.
The moral imperative is to pick up the votes lost on the disaffected progressives. At least that was my guess at least six months ago before it was as obvious that the HIR stuff would be unpopular among idealists.
It’s not like climate change is an important issue or anything. There is plenty of time to deal with the planet. It’s only been a little over a year since Democrats have been in charge of everything in Washington, DC. They will get to climate change. Let’s just be a little patient. The ice on the Arctic got a little thicker this year so we got it all under control.
Worst case scenario they will use it as an issue to get us to the polls in November again. We will get that planet fixed. Trust us, just vote again. Oh, and can you make some more donations. Oh, and the phone banks too. Thanks. Will pick it up first thing in 2011. Really.
ha !
I can just hear Solmonese to Carl Pope at the weekly veal pen teleconfab – looks, like it’s your turn bitch !
The President has a reputation?
Pardon my cynicism, but from where I sit it looks as if we’re about to engage in another year-long rat-fuck for the purpose of providing cover for democratic fecklessness.
HCR has been such a rousing success, the WH just can’t wait to start the bipartisan dialogue again.
I don’t know what to do either, but lately it seems every step is in the direction of being wrong-footed by those interested in diverting attention from the looting of our country by war profiteers and financial sector pirates.
I-N-D-E-P-E-N-D-E-N-T-S
..who consistently poll hard in favor of “some reform”
and the Masters of the Electoral Universe have their craven little hearts set on it
Wait. Immigration is so important. St McCain said that
Are only the Republics prepared to stand and protect us from this foreign invasion?
Now that Scott Brown is onboard with immigration reform, I guess it moves up on the agenda. s/
Oh well, Earth Abides.
Happy Earth Day everybody!
It is all about the elections. The Dems are desperate to find another constituency now that they have told independents/progressives to take a running jump.
It is only because the congressman said that he would encourage hispanic voters to stay at home in the next election. This seems to be the only thing that the Dems and Administration understand. They only respond to the people complaining the loudest after the fact. Look at who they coddled in the insurance industry bill that was just passed. There isn’t any leadership..
They asked for a filibuster proof majority and they got it, but it was only after they lost it that they moved the bill forward – and they could have done that at any time.
It is all a shell game and kabuki. I mean are we really supposed to wait with bated breath to see whether the Democrats are going to pass bad non-reformist legislation on climate change or immigration. It’s like getting excited over a fixed horse race, one you know to be fixed.
Yes the people we all elected are again talking Immigration reform.
People should really think on this. If it just was to make immigation easier or treat people more fairly they could just amend the old laws and fix the problems.
The object of what they are talking about, past all the retoric is to make all the illegals legal. This is not just the people who have broke our laws and walked across the borders, but those who came and stayed past visa’s. It also wants to make it real easy for our Corporations to bring in even more people to work for them.
This is not about helping poor people to come here, or people to bring family members here.
What it does is make citizenship whether born here or immigrated here worthless, useless, and degraded. So we are really being again being asked to give up the rights and privleges given to us by birth or legal immigration to accommmodate those who enjoy either.
All Americans should be up in arms at what they are talking about. Both parties are only looking for more voters and to accommodate the big Cororations. There is no concideration for true citizens, but only what what others want.
Don’t be fooled that this is to solve immigration problems, or to make us safer, or to be more fair to everyone. This is a disgrace to this Nation about to be prepetrated on us by the very people we elected to work for us.
Call Your Congress Person and make them know You are against this unless You want worse problems. If they make illegals leagal, everyone will come here because it becomes the best way in.
Amnesty for illegals: another Reagan/Bush tricklenomics idea now adopted by Obama. Amazing what those Wall Street cheap labor lobby campaign contributions can buy.
Pelosi’s statement is being blown up a little bit in the blogosphere. The House has already done its part.
There is no talk in the Senate of a pure renewable-only bill. The horrible ACELA “energy-only” bill that passed the E&NR committee last year with Republican support did so because it had lots of giveaways to nuclear and fossil fuel industries.
The KGL bill is anticipated to price carbon at about $30-33/ton.
What lessons should have been learned from the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986? That amnesty is not the solution to the problem. Unless we start enforcing immigration laws against EMPLOYERS who employ people who are here illegally, the problem will continue (people here illegally also get a mindset that they only have to wait for “amnesty” at a later date). Doing “sweeps” to pick up illegals doesn’t take care of the problem because companies just hire new “illegals”. As long as there are jobs for them, people will continue to come here illegally. I truly feel for the plight of people but the reality of the situation is that there are almost 7 BILLION people in the world now and the United States can’t support everyone who wants to move here. Frankly, at this point, we are having major difficulties supporting current citizens.
Climate Change? Gotta be kidding…
Ironic…I guess, that the oil companies managed to blow up an
oil platform in the Gulf for Earth Day. Just a couple of weeks ago we
were hearing (again) the “Drill Baby Drill” refrain and repeatedly
being told “Nothing can go wrong with offshore drilling.” Ask the
eleven missing platform workers if that’s true. If you can find them.
We heard oil would be contained in the platform design. The Miami
Herald reported an oil slick moving away from the platform this morning.
Pretty much the entire economy of Florida is one way or another
dependent on tourism. Good luck if oil sludge washes up on the beaches.
The numbers I’ve heard are $60-$70B per year in touristry. Ask the folks
in Alaska if anything can go wrong. And Exxon STILL hasn’t paid their
bill. They’ve stiffed Alaska. Ask the folks in Santa Barbara if anything can go wrong. And we don’t even ask for a Security Deposit up front? I’d
suggest $120B Oil Industry deposit (2 years) in case something DOES go
wrong and the oil companies walk out without paying their tab…AGAIN.
But there’s an easy way to tell if oil companies are lying to us. Are their lips moving?
I was going to mention that illegal immigration went down a lot during the recession because of a lack of jobs, and if there were actual employer sanctions, they would leave, but my guess is you couldn’t care less about facts.
I found this video at Democracy Now interesting regarding the climate bill:
New Senate Climate Bill Is “Slap in the Face to Everything that Earth Day Stands For”