The President wants to create a blue-ribbon commission to study the growing Gulf oil spill. But investigations are ongoing right now. The House Energy and Commerce Committee last week found multiple problems with the various companies involved in Deepwater Horizon, as well as the regulatory failures surrounding them. The Senate is involved in hearings today with Interior Secretary Salazar, where he tipped his hand about future offshore drilling, telling anti-drilling Sen. Ben Cardin (D-MD) to “stay tuned.” (Salazar made some onshore drilling changes today.) And yesterday yielded this fascinating bit from a hearing with Janet Napolitano:
Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano acknowledged Monday that the federal government doesn’t have the resources or expertise to deal with an oil spill 5,000 feet below the sea, and must largely depend on oil companies to deal with an incident of such magnitude.
Napolitano, the first Cabinet-level official to testify to Congress about the April 20 explosion in the Gulf of Mexico, also said there may have been too much reliance by the industry on blowout preventers as a fail-safe in the event of a catastrophe. There was perhaps not enough regulation or testing of the devices by the federal agency that oversees offshore drilling, the Minerals Management Service.
“I think that’s one of the reasons why the president has been so very clear that further deepwater drilling permits are going to be stopped until this can be investigated and assurances can be gained that things have been changed so that we don’t have a duplication of the deepwater Horizon incident,” Napolitano said. “And so I think we’re all working together to say, ‘All right, what happened here? What power should MMS have had that it didn’t have? What powers did it have that it didn’t exercise?”
This is just a recognition of total regulatory and oversight failure. You cannot create the conditions for an oil spill that can affect millions of citizens and then throw up your hands that you simply don’t have the expertise to deal with the fallout. BP should obviously be in the lead financially, but consequences that are out of the control of those with the responsibility to protect the citizenry should be avoided. It’s the very definition of “too big to fail,” if you think about it.
I don’t know if this nuclear sub-captain is right, but the point is that the federal government probably doesn’t know either. And that’s a tragedy.
So is all the oil washing ashore (yes, it’s there, Brit Hume)



23 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
…Why in the blue hell are we doing something if we cannot even begin to react to a “worst case scenario” crisis?
This may not even be “worst case” but for the sake of this argument, it might as well be.
Seriously I’d like one person in the government to explain to me with a straight face how we should keep drilling if the answer to the question of “WHAT DO WE DO OH GOD IT WON’T STOP GUSHING INTO THE GULF” is…
*Shrug of shoulders*
Rubbish. The problem is the people running the federal government are too ignorant/incompetent to know where to begin. We should never have gotten into the habit of letting political appointees run our various agencies, because this is the result, clueless people who don’t know what and where their resources are and how to put them to good use. This is too depressing for words.
So who the hell decided that the oil companies, while raping Mother Earth’s blood, have the knowledge and resources?
It’s been 21 days at 5000 barrels a day ==105,000 barrels X 42 gallons a barrel == 4,410,000 gallons since day one MINIMUM and obama is doing the BP shuffle, he’s really good at show time but there’s no pop in the soda so to speak.
Destroy the well before the well destroys us.
Just maneuver a bomb over the hole and detonate it! They still think they can control the uncontrollable and get the oil.
Time to stop that Mutha…right now. Not wait for “congress to investigate”.
Jeepers creepers!
Salazar just basically said this is OUR problem!
No caps!
Thanks for the post. And here is my comment: No sh**, Sherlock (said to the gov’t, not to Mr. Dayen), tell me something I didn’t already know.
Geez. I keep thinking: when will they ever learn, but that’s equally pointless bc in this INSANE mad rush to suck as much money outta everything, these crazed rapists really don’t give a fack.
I’ve said it before: what in heck they think this planet will be like for their own kids and grandkids is waaaay beyond my imagination, unless they are somehow planning to send themselves up on a rocket to the moon or mars or something. And: good luck with that!
And yes: the fed govt is filled – nearly from top to bottom – with a bunch of dumb cretinous scum sucking bottom dwellers. I’m not sure if it’s a fairy tale, but it seems like at one time, there were responsible, educated folks doing the Agency work. Since Reagan’s time, it’s all been downhill with dumbed down cronies instructed to turn their heads and look the other way whilst the corporations loot and pillage.
I dunno… will the US population wake up out of its stupor now? Or will they continue to demand that the obscenely wealthy never be taxed under any circumstances, while having an ever “smaller” govt because regulatory agencies are the root of all evil? Stay tuned…
Brit Hume’s family should do him the favor the Cheney women owe Dick: keep him away from microphones and cameras so he stops making an utter fool of himself. Shredded and tarnished though the Hume ‘journalistic’ legacy is, it won’t be helped by any further media appearances.
What was the factory that Mr. Bipartisan went to for his photo op today? The largest manufacturer of pipe for oil drilling.
Astonishing factoid just revealed on CBS network evening news: Coast Guard threatened to “arrest” CBS camera crew & reporter who attempted to boat into barrier islands off Louisiana to film oil making landfall on beaches & marshes. CBS showed aerial footage made earlier by “parish” (equivalent to “county”) officials in LA showing miles-long tar-black oil smears along white beaches and in tall-grass marshes along barrier islands of LA. LA Gov. Bobby Jindal was quoted on camera as eyewitness: he said it’s not a “sheen” it’s deep black oil.
Yet Coast Guard was caught on camera threatening news crew, saying it was enforcing “BP’s rules, not ours.”
Quick questions: did USA just surrender sovereign control over our coastal waters to a British corporation? Has LA (site of British invasion during War of 1812) again become foreign-occupied territory? Since when do we allow the British to command our US Coast Guard?
Considering the simple fact that the Gulf is well on it’s way to being a complete dead zone anyway due to the toxins and pollutants we’re washing down the Mississippi and, considering that we’ve pretty much destroyed most all the fisheries beyond repair by overfishing what’s the big deal about 50 to 100 million barrels of oil gushing into the Gulf? Think of all the profit to be made by mining the Gulf waters directly for oil with no need for expensive drilling rigs. Heck, we can even claim it’s environmentally sound by using the oil from all those dead fish to increase the supply — kind of like using ethanol from corn to increase our gas supply.
nice. kinda like “biodiesel” only with fins?
It is well past time for The Queen of England as the major stockholder of British Petroleum to own up and stop this charade…
Shouldn’t it be a black-ribbon commission, in honor of the new color of the Gulf of Mexico?
WTF we are spending untold billions researching how to invent robotic killer bees and tiny surveillance drones and we can’t figure out how to deal with a predictable envmntl disaster? This country is a sham and Obama is a self-serving stooge. This is his real Waterloo.
This is just a recognition of total regulatory and oversight failure. You cannot create the conditions for an oil spill that can affect millions of citizens and then throw up your hands that you simply don’t have the expertise to deal with the fallout.
Thank you, David. For saying what needs to be said.
It is so much more than that. The Obama Administration could have been out in front measuring and assessing the spill. Here it is coming up on a month since the rig blew up and the Obama Administration can’t even answer basic questions like how much oil has spilled and is spilling into the Gulf. Why did it take one small research vessel to finally break the story about the oil plumes? It is apparent that more than 5,000 barrels is pouring into the Gulf. That oil had to be going somewhere. Now why is the government trying to shut down what little information we have? Why does it keep deferring to BP? What a bunch of criminal malevolent clowns our elites have become.
I guess this finally is showing us the real difference between Republicans and Democrats. Republicans couldn’t organize a two car parade, and Democrats are incapable of leading one.
just watch the Republican use this spill for PR. don’t ask me how, knowing the Republicans, i’m sure they will find a way to put all the blame on Obama. i hope they sink Obama good for letting BP control the PR in our parishes here in La affected by the spill. this is Louisiana, not BP territory. and it is heavily Republican, the locals are good ole boys, don’t like Democrats at all, that ‘us vs. them’ strategy really does work.
just reading that BP can tell people who live here not to take pictures, or go in their boats will have great repercussions, not that LA would ever go Democrat, lol. just amazing to think Obama is that easily owned. i guess that is the real shock that Obama is so much “owned” by the Villagers who run this country.
Absolutely astounding. to think it is Nelson of Florida who pushed the video. it will be up to Florida to stop this oil leak. that’s where the money/power seems to reside, not in LA where the oil and gas comes from.
You are so right, Hugh. If my math was close enough over on that other thread,
Which would mean that whatever BP admits sucking through the “straw” would represent only 3.6% of what the volcano is belching out. Give BP a break, assume it’s 5%. That means the volcano is belching out TWENTY (20) times what BP is recovering. So, “straw” collects a thousand barrels a day, riser is putting out 20,000 barrels a day. If 20,000 barrels a day have been escaping into the ocean in the 26 days since April 22 (when rig sank, breaking the riser), that’s 520,000 barrels. Twenty-one million eight hundred forty thousand (21,840,000) gallons. Two Exxon Valdezes.
There are genius engineers & fluid dynamics physicists working on this exact problem, so don’t listen to me listen to them. But a fifth grader can figure this out. (Is BP smarter than a …..?)
Those are very interesting questions given the scenario you describe.
Got a link for that CBS crew’s story?
I’m with you, beleck. I caught only that one sound bite on CBS tonight, I hope we find links to other sources confirming that Coast Guard is allowing BP to control the navigable waterways around the LA barrier islands ruined by deep frosting of black oil.
Two weeks (12 days) ago, the Coast Guard was doing this:
Bloggers on Audobon Magazine’s site said two days ago that they had to buy “permits” at Walmart in order to get access to a wildlife preserve on one of the barrier islands.
Not sure what the Coast Guard is doing or who it is taking orders from.
Yes. Took a while, had to take a break to watch Sestak’s victory speech!
Here is the link to CBS’s story.
CBS gave a little update to what it aired:
Same link reports that tar balls washed up in Key West but Coast Guard station there said it was not qualified to say where the oil came from.
This entire disaster is being covered up at the direction of the WH. Obama is sacrificng the economy, the environment, wildlife, and the well being of millions of Americans for corporate gains. He hides behind BP instead of telling them to crush the damn pipe and kiss it goodbye. Obama is a sneaky coward. He’s using the US Coast Guard to protect BP’s crimes by threatening to arrest news crews getting video of the black goo coating the coastline, and he’s censoring independent scientific reporting.
There’s no way in hell BP and Obama don’t know how much oil is blasting out of that pipe ionto the Gulf. BP has experienced engineers and equipment that can figure this shit out in a heartbeat. Believing they don’t know is absurd. If that’s the case, then how can they claim they’re capturing 20% of it? More bullshit? Everyone involved has been lying from the get go. One month into it, nothing’s changed. It’s all bullshit and our Fascist in Chief is happy to oblige. It’s Obama’s really big FU to America. His Chernobyl like cover up so his real constituents, BP and Wall St are covered.
Obama doesn’t give a crap about wildlife, clean water, or the American people. He’s a power mad, money grubbing, sociopath. I can’t think of another president in American history that would simply shrug his shoulders and walk away from something like this. Even W wasn’t this brazen about environmental disasters, was he? But Obama is a true narcissist. He’s fine with leaving us in the hands of the criminal eco terrorists. Just like putting the financial terrorists in charge of our economic policy. Then he forms another one of his fucking blue ribbon commissions to show he’s getting serious. But it ends up to be another pile of stinking manure that’s sure to spin the outcome so taxpayers pick up the tab for most of the damage and offshore drilling will go on as scheduled.
Wake up sheep. This leak could have been pumped from day one. The reason that it has not been pumped is because that pumping costs money and the perpetrators of this crime know there are no consequences coming from a corporate/facist US government that is complicit and future leaning.
That BP and BO are totally disingenuous on the spill is clear from the use of toxic chemicals to conceal the oil with no effort to contain and collect. Let’s face it, if you can get away with 9/11, illegal wars, torture, and all the rest then why worry about a crime against humanity. The beat down idiots can’t stop us anyway so who cares what they think.
Does it not seem entirely stupid that there was no preparation whatsoever for this sort of event? Not by Drill Baby Drill Barack or BP(bad people) and that after 4 weeks of oil gushing into the gulf of Mexico they won’t even say what is actually happening. If this was brown people treating us this way we would have to bomb and torture them. Shouldn’t we be on orange alert or something. Maybe take our shoes off and give up some civil liberties. What a crock.
Give me a budget and I will capture that oil in three days. These guys suck.
Conrad C. Elledge
If these situations are existing, I’d venture to say that qualifies as High Crimes and Misdemeanors
This shit is starting to create quite a bunch of anger inside of me.