Just a quick word on the primaries last night, because most of what needed to be said has been said, and it all happened while I was watching the astonishing crumbling of financial reform (more on that in a minute, and how it ties into all this).
By now you know the basics: Joe Sestak didn’t “get killed” by Arlen Specter, but put him out to pasture. Democrats got the most favorable possible matchup in Kentucky, with solid Democrat Jack Conway edging homophobic ConservaDem Dan Mongiardo, and Rand Paul infuriating the state GOP establishment – enough to stay home? – by beating their golden boy Trey Grayson. Bill Halter not only forced Blanche Lincoln to a runoff, he came within 6,000 votes of beating her outright, and will be IMO favored to win on June 8 (again, more in a minute).
In the biggest bellweather race of the night, Mark Critz thrashed Tim Burns in PA-12, and will replace the late Jack Murtha in PA-12. Critz is a pretty crappy Blue Dog Democrat, and I’m not going to cheer his arrival into Congress. But this result was completely obvious, regardless of what you hear about this being a Kerry/McCain swing district (hate to say it, but the 2008 general election followed the general bad showing for the African-American Obama in Appalachia, and cannot be attributed to other candidates). Critz knew exactly how to win in this district – he latched himself tightly enough to Murtha that there was no doubt who the old man would have supported. The headline “Murtha aide wins Murtha’s Congressional seat” is appropriate here. I think everyone in my family who works in that district works in a building named after Jack Murtha. And this was his district director, his face inside the district. Not only that, this is one of the few districts left in the country where labor GOTV really can matter, and it did. Plus, this is a rapidly aging district, and Critz did nothing but talk about Social Security for the last months.
That, and the NRCC is just completely and totally pathetic, and frankly, the DCCC is pretty darn good at this stuff. They’ve won 7 straight special elections in a time when the tea partiers and the like are supposed to be destroying the Democratic majority. For that reason, you pretty much can rule out a big wave election in November. The founts of conventional wisdom will extrapolate from this race, rightly or wrongly, that if Republicans cannot win this seat, precisely the type they’re supposed to win in November, they cannot win the 40 or so seats they’d need to regain Congress.
As for what it all means, I’ll take Sam Stein’s take as a template. The progressive movement showed they can still be a force in elections, if not in governing (I keep previewing my next piece). Across the country, real Democrats were chosen over corrupt elites or conservative Democrats. This really ends up being a game of inches – but I still believe it matters who gets these politicians into office. Joe Sestak is accountable, in the short term, to a whole different set of actors than Arlen Specter. The same with Bill Halter over Blanche Lincoln. The same with Manan Trivedi, the progressive candidate who squeaked by a right-wing challenger named Doug Pike in the Democratic primary in PA-06. Incumbents haven’t shown the responsibility to govern; ConservaDems don’t offer the change Democrats voted for in 2008. Not even Barack Obama can save these kinds of candidates from their fate.
As for the right, the tea partiers or whoever is pulling the strings behind them have a long-term goal to take over their party and move it even further to the right, and they’re succeeding wildly, institutionally speaking. Winning elections against Democrats is another matter.




21 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
thanks so much David.
I’m embarrassed to have never heard of Trivedi – how’d I miss that one ?
Just curious how Doug Pike is a right wing challenger? I see the J-Street incident, but what on earth would classify him as a righty? Secondly, I would characterize Trivedi as the challenger in the primary considering Pike had been in for many months beforehand. I certainly wasn’t in the sack for Pike, but am interested in the background for you assertion.
Thank you, David.
Whole bunch of conventional-wisdom purveyors eating crow for breakfast today. They’d better like it; there’s another serving on order for June 8th, let’s hope.
D.C. Morrison “out of runoff” wont endorse either candidate:
http://tiny.cc/k4jpx
Bu..bu..but I thought it was all good for Republicans yesterday.
Like anything else that ever happens anywhere.
STTP !
How are you, my friend ?
Yes, it’s only a matter of time before the ReichWing spin all of this to show that Voters cannot elect proper Reps. …
Call the WH and ask them if they got the message. Tell them the people want FDR style government not corporatist government.
1-202-456-1111
MSM BREAKING: A life-long Republican with astronomical name recognition managed to win a Republican primary in Kentucky. Democrats doomed!
oh praise be….Franklin and Eleanor are watching
why him and Scott Brown are the next prezzzies
Paul,Brown 0012
Thanks for your analysis. I’m skeptical about how much an effect this election will have on anything, frankly (albeit I was briefly doing my happy dance last night just because…). As one commenter said last night, even IF we could somehow create a viable third party that wins elections and forms a coalition in the gov’t, who’s to say that they won’t be as bought off as anyone we currently see in Wash DC???
I’m all for the sending of messages and was very satisfied to phoney Specter booted uncermoniously out the door, plus spanking Walmart Blanche is a very good thing, too.
Will this make much difference, though, in the day to day corporate owned govt that we currently have? I’m somewhat skeptical, but GOTV this way is one of the actions that citizens can take.
I find it interesting, too, that so-called progressives did seem to get out the vote in some significant numbers without all the corporate backing, free media attention, and razzle-dazzle that the Tea Party has.
Interesting.
It does seem as if the Tea Party is having some success in the Republic elections, but not sure, either, whether they will be that successful in kicking out Dems (whether incumbent or not). Plus I, for one, don’t see how “different” AynRand is… he’s an elitist from and elitist family, and no matter that he calls himself a Libertarian (whatever that means these days), he’s in favor of cutting the taxes of the super wealthy and the corporations. Is THAT what the Tea Party commoners REALLY want? If so, then the Tea Party is once again being fooled into voting against their own interests. Too bad. It would be nice if the Tea Party voters actually figured out that they’re being ripped off once again. I’d love to make common cause with them, but frankly, most of the candidates they endorse are almost worse than the GOP (almost).
Politicaal, I’m a Trivedi supporter, and you are correct on both points.
I think this is the path for the progressives, at least for a while. In stead of wasting energy on a ‘third party’ we should focus on electing specific reliable progressive candidates to national and local offices. Think what could be achieved if we have a whole bunch of Sen. Sanders, socialist from Vermont, et al! Sure way to put fear into the corporate Democrats.
feh, Penn elects and nominates another couple of blue dogs. The corruptness of Murtha transferred to his protege that knows the job. No breakdown in the bribery chain and the pentagon wipes the sweat from their collective brow and the scrotums of their handlers. This may quash a hundred investigations into crimes involving $6000 dollar toilet seats. Real sweet.
There is little to celebrate in Mudville. If one grasps enough straws, one can create a strawman.
Blue Texan’s regularly scheduled post is ready: Sarah Palin and Sean Hannity Discuss Looming Republican Victory in PA-12
What happened in Hawaii-01?
I can’t find anything about it here, or TPM, or the Big Orange Sinkhole.
Which ones are the “real” Democrats? Are they the ones that flipped on all their blustery rhetoric and voted for the Insurance Company Bailout (HCR) when it actually mattered?
Or are you just talking about ones not presently stuck with the rotating villain role?
election on Saturday?
Petro my man!
So sorry to miss your response; I had to leave the office right after posting my comment.
Great to see you again as well.
It’s been a wild ride for me medically, but (unfortunately for you all), I’m baaack!
Its much harder to be bought off if the Government is a better employer.
In this environment are you telling me you would rather be employed by the private sector?
All you need is transparency in Government and no hypocrisy.
If you solved many of the “Issues Of The Day” such as Abortion, LGTB Rights and Immigration by removing any doubt from them, this would remove much of the radical right social push from candidates.
They could no longer run on hot button issues that cloud the overall discussion.
If they did they appear -
1) Anti-Woman’s Rights
2) Homophobic
3) Racist or Bigoted
Making Government work for the people isn’t rocket science…
The Hawaii special election is by mail-in ballot, with the deadline for receipt being this Saturday, May 22, at 6pm. The counting takes place afterward. (I don’t know if they’ll be counting on Sunday or not.) Results likely on Monday.
Expect the Republican Charles Djou to win with about 35% of the vote, followed by Blue Dog Ed Case at about 30%, then the Demo machine candidate Colleen Hanabusa at 25%.
I voted for someone else; I refused to waste my vote on any of the above.