I don’t think there’s any doubt that the explosion on the Deepwater Horizon rig had a man-made cause. We have an eyewitness survivor of the blast now willing to say that the blowout preventer was leaking for weeks before the explosion, and BP and Transocean failed to repair the valve in response, merely shutting it off instead. If they actually repaired it, that would shut down production. The last line of defense, the “blind shear ram,” designed to slice the pipe and seal the well in the event of a disaster, malfunctioned, and BP never had to show proof that the technique would actually work. In fact, the Deepwater Horizon, unlike every new BP well, had only one blind shear ram; two are now standard.
A legitimate Minerals Management Service could have known about the leaking blowout preventer before the blast. It could have acted on the inherent problems with the blind shear ram and the oil industry’s failsafe measures in general (blowout preventers have a 45% failure rate, according to a confidential Transocean report). But we didn’t have a legitimate MMS to deal with this disaster. We have 62 regulators dealing with over 4,000 offshore rigs in the Gulf of Mexico.
The Minerals Management Service, which regulates offshore drilling, has had an inadequate inspection force, Salazar said.
There are “4,000 wells in the Gulf of Mexico,” he said. “How can 62 people do that job?”
The number of inspectors could quadruple in the wake of the Deepwater Horizon disaster, Salazar said. Still, he expressed doubts that better inspections would have prevented the blowout.
“There were a whole host of problems that occurred on this well and on this rig. Many of those problems were detected hours before, in fact, days beforehand,” he said. “No level of regulation would have prevented what happened.”
I don’t agree with Salazar on that last bit. Some of these problems were identified not days, but months and years before the blowout. Right from the start, MMS provided waivers to the Deepwater Horizon rig, and inspections were often filled out by the company themselves. Maybe this reflexive defense of an indefensible agency is why Salazar has been given a much lower profile as the weeks have gone on.
Even now, two months and counting into the disaster, MMS is giving out permits without environmental reviews. The Interior Department claims that these are not new drilling projects but ones already approved, but given the scope of the problems with MMS, I cannot see how their original permits shouldn’t be scrutinized. Environmental groups are right to sue MMS for continuing to grant waivers. They’re like a junkie who can’t stop taking hits. It’s bad enough having 62 regulators for 4,000 wells; it’s worse taking them off the beat.




41 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Salazar must go.
Even a regulation where you can’t drill deeper than where you can respond in a timely fashion to stop a oil well blow out? 60 days is not acceptable.
If an inspector had no more than ten wells to watch and had to reside on the rigs while inspecting them, that would cut down on short cuts and they would be able to monitor mandated information flow to the mainland in real time where it would be stored and accessible to the public when something went wrong.
The oil company profits soar when oversight , paid by them, is keep to a minimum. The actual cost of a tough as nails oversight compared to the loss, now in hindsight, is laughable.
If no level of regulation would have prevented what happened then we shouldn’t be allowing this kind of drilling.
This has been the story of the entire Obama administration. “You owed us the vote, now shut up, get the f*ck out of our way, we have rich people to please”.
Essentially, what is being averred here is there has been — NO CHANGE. No change we can believe in. It’s a case of widespread nonfeasence throughout Barry’s regime. He’s repudiated all he stood for as candidate for the presidency. He should add his resignation to Rahm’s. What a disgrace. A carbon copy of the previous junta.
If the rumors are true about MMS it was operating like Animal House and twice as many inspectors would not have mattered. No doubt young, inexperienced Bush appointees who didn’t know anything about the business.
From the NYTimes piece today:
Obama said he had arrived at his decision after more than a year of study by his administration, including a careful weighing of environmental risks. Yet the administration’s examination did not question the oil industry’s confident assertions about its drilling technology. The well-known weaknesses of blowout preventers and blind shear rams simply did not make it onto the administration’s radar, interviews and documents show.
Mr. Hayes, the deputy interior secretary, said senior officials were reassured, perhaps wrongly, by “the NASA kind of fervor” over the oil industry’s seemingly “terrific technology.” They took comfort in what appeared to be a comprehensive regime of regulations. Most of all, he said, they were impressed by the rarity of significant oil spills even as more of the nation’s domestic oil supply was being drawn from ultradeep wells.
Captive regulators and captive environmental groups. No one does their homework anymore, it seems.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/21/us/21blowout.html?pagewanted=9&hp
Way to hand the bio-rapists their meme, Kenny. Because we know nobody in this administration is going to use that ‘fact’ to support restrictions, let alone bans, on unsafe drilling.
Bingo!
This oil disaster is not only a failure of our government, but a failure of the traditional media. Had they continuously reported and exposed what was truly going on at the MMS, perhaps there would have been more outrage and political pressure to change MMS. And that goes for the continuous corruption in all levels of government today.
My guess is Joe Barton will never really be exposed to the harassment and trashing that an environmentalist (Al Gore) receives at the hands of the media. Instead, we hear about the “shakedown” that BP received by Obama, and the GOP’s efforts to protect corporate profits at all costs are ignored.
Horseshit, Mr. Secretary. Horseshit. Pure, unadulterated horseshit.
Go back to Colorado and study some horseshit so you can recognize it.
This is very dangerous talk. Essentially he is saying that our federal government has no power. Why do we pay taxes then Mr Secretary? If you are so powerless just go home so we do not have to pay you or even look at your idiocy. This is the first step to anarchy. So why vote for Dems or even vote at all much less pay taxes. If this is the new WH mantra they can leave now instead of a slow motion coup by corporations. Why are we even a union if the feds cannot do anything and forbid the states from their own regulations on drilling or try to clean the oil up? So they are helpless which should help a lot in this November election.
Spoken like the true corporate lackey he is. On the one hand, he is trying to save his own job, on the other he is trying to prevent improved regulation.
David, you use the term “legitimate”, I prefer “competent”. The federal response has been negligent and incompetent and Salazar is a poster child for both.
Yes MMS is inadequate. But we have the latest narrative. Corporations good. Regulation bad. Salazar is also inadequate. He is inadequate and incompetent and so is Obama.
The Administration was quite happy with MMS because the Oil Companies were quite happy with MMS. The neo-cons got theirprivatized government agency controlled by the corporations. I think most of the government is the same, privatized by the Corporations.
We do not need to fight the same old battles over and over about off shore drilling. The Oil Companies won, and they always win. They have poisoned the Gulf of Mexico. Offshore drilling has no place in our energy future, other than a very bad place.
Mr. Salazar may tell himself he’s defending the role of his agency with comments such as, “No amount of regulation could have prevented….”, a not very imaginative reworking of Condi Rice’s not very inventive, “No one could have predicted….” Anyone but a Second Amendment absolutist or hater of Social Security would interpret that as an abject defense of BP and its sister oil giants. I hope that brown on Mr. Salazar’s nose is oil.
Salazar is lying, obviously. Had there been adequate regulation, this disaster would have been prevented. British Petroleum would be paying through the nose for the damage it has caused. There is no effective regulation in the United States anymore, and there hasn’t been for years. That’s why we have Exxon-Valdez and BP and food poisoning and drugs with side effects worse than the conditions they’re supposed to relieve and which are marketed as being potentially fatal.
precisely
Salazar doesn’t want to screw his chances to go for a cruise on Tony’s yacht…
You just can’t make this shit up.
agreee …he needs to be fired for this mindset alone…we need a petition
Cringingly, Mr. Salazar is defending the status quo and rejecting any attempt at regulating oil and impliedly other corporate giants at work, historically polluting oil well blowouts and all.
Any sensible department head would have long since tendered his resignation. A sensible president would have immediately accepted it.
Why is it that progressives like Van Jones are kicked to the curb and inept idiots like Salazar are still allowed to make lying, ridiculous, bull-hockey statements like this?
I have no hope left for the country – the evil ones will be taking over soon because the man who gave his word to change business as usual seems frozen by making any decision that may anger wingers and corporations.
No such delicate thought seems to be given to his base – you know, those who brought him there.
Dean Baker has a fresh cross-post ready: America Speaks Back: Derailing the Drive to Cut Social Security and Medicare
Exactly so.
Salazar, has said that he is completely incapable of running MMS and by extension the Interior Department. He does not think that the people he works for, or scientists in general, are capable of balancing risk and avoiding catastrophe. He accepts his inability to act as a regulator and wants everyone else to do the same.
What he meant was BP, with more citations than the rest of the oil industry combined, is a good and valued partner and the mere fact that MMS and BP are completely unable to protect our nation from being poisoned should not be held against them. Acts of God, whether in this instance or as yet another example of reaching into the taxpayers pockets and livelhoods in order to protect the mega-corporations, are the final, pathetic defenses of scoundrels.
They should have a new regulation that states:
Don’t blow up your rig.
That would fix things.
Deep water drilling is always a risky endeavor no accident is 100% avoidable. Disasters cannot be prevented….but the risks can be lowered through corporate responsibility and commitment to safety and effective government oversight and regulation.
We must look at all factors that have gone into the permitting of deep water drilling, including enviromental lobbying and administration policies that have prevented safer drilling in shallower waters or on land. MMS and the Dept. of the Interior must be cited for their failures and where warranted, individuals at MMS and DOI fired and or procecuted for their collusion, corruption and negligence. It is simply not enough to lay this all at the feet of BP. Our government agencies under the past and current administration have been tasked with oversight and regulation failed as surely as the BOP.
Time to stop covering for the Obama administration and their odious brand of crony capitalism/gangster government. Each day we allow the administration to cover its ass, act outside the law and collude with the interest groups and industries that ‘brought them to the dance’ we place our liberties in peril.
By their deeds, Obama and Salazar have made it absolutely clear that they sold out to and have been captured by BP and the oil industry. “Drill, baby drill,” continues to be the official administration policy. Environmental impact statements will not be required, drilling permits will be rubber-stamped without review, and there will be no regulatory oversight.
It was an unavoidable accident, don’cha know, and anyone who claims otherwise is an unserious and dangerous left-wing prevaricator who should be ignored.
As Obama famously said in another venue regarding a different matter, “I have two words for you. Predator. Drones.”
What a glorious inspiration our president is to all of us!
Thanks, I was wondering if anyone else saw this as Ken Salazar’s “No one could have predicted…” moment. This is just like the housing bubble and the financial meltdown. No amount of regulation will work if regulations aren’t enforced.
How did we allow this worthless excuse for a president and his corporate minions into power? We were fooled and lied to. Has he gotten out of the wars? Prosecuted the torturers? Closed Gitmo? He’s marginally better than Bush. Hell “Salazar must go”? You think Obama doesn’t know what Salazar is doing? Or Geithner or Summers? Don’t kid yourselves. Obama must go and about 85% of the congress critters who all own stock in BP and Citigroup. What ever happened to recusal when there’s a conflict of interest. They’re not even pretending to care what we think any more.
Petition and boycotts? If Salazar resigns will the culture of crony capitalism in the administration, DOI and MMS change? Salazar was placed in that position to collude with big oil at the ‘pleasure of the President’. Is it truly a coincidence that Obama was the top recipient of BP donations in 2008 and in exchange BP received lax treatment from federal regulators.
Obama has done nothing to ‘change the way we do business in Washington’. That was clearly an illusion conjured up con the electorate into preserving the status quo. We are allowing the executive branch to overreach and collude with big business to create ‘too big too fail’ corporations and act extralegally with disregard for due process. We allow Congress to spend irresponsibly and we refuse to make them live within their means.
It is not enough to say the GOP would be worse. Republican governors are balancing budgets, creating surplusses and taking on powerful public sector unions. Voters are taking note and those who ‘walk the walk’ when it comes to meeting the electorate’s demand for LESS government and LESS spending will be rewarded at the ballot box.
Obama has been nothing more than a thug presiding over a gangster government hiding behind a utopian illusion that cannot be created here on Earth.
I think we need to stop conceding that Obama is “marginally better than Bush,” because he’s actually a lot worse than Bush.
He hasn’t changed anything except to make things worse while institutionalizing the worst practices of the Bush administration.
Salazar put Elizabeth Birnbaum in place seemingly because he wanted someone who knew little about the complexities of MMS’s complex job. Then, she was thrown to the lions early on, while he remained – occasionally surfacing to sputter more cowboy tough talk. Salazar sure does not appear too sharp, even if he wanted to be. It’s all about incompetence – and seemingly having incompetent people/stooges in charge so industry can get whatever it wants.
Oh, yeah, there’s a lot of those around. Unions that can’t strike and who’s membership is not allowed to run for public office are really striking terror. Some union members, like California, ended up with deals that were overly favorable because the other side rolled over. Republicans on the other hand let corporations win even bigger while attacking relatively weak targets like unions because for them there is no downside to hurting the middle class. The only strength public unions have is their contracts not their membership, which is a small percentage of the population at large. If the courts decide that they can arbitrarily void legal contracts then the rule of law will only apply to those with enough money to buy the right kind of political protection. Either justice is blind or it doesn’t exist.
Well, much as I loathe Salazar and agree that he’s a corporate bitch and rather incompetent, he’s also correct on one level. We can have the regulations we want out the wahzoo, but if they’re not being enforced and then followed up by visits to rigs by competent workers who know what they’re doing (and have the law behind them to enforce the regs), why then, of course “no one” could have predicted… bc “no one” was doing anything.
Yaaagh… Salazar craps this stuff out, and I *guess* someone believes him??? Unclear, other than that it’s Kabuki. I really do wonder, though: is there any citizen out there who actually believes this lying bull hockey???
Just stfu Salazar. What. a. waste. of. my. tax. dollahs. Of course, that is also part of the goal, isn’t it???
I think there’s a distinction between government regulation, which has been weak, and government inspection, which has been non-existent and would have gone a long way towards catching the many many vulnerabilities at Macondo. Trusting company men to do what the people and the government need to be done, in the face of management pressure and quick-completion bonuses, is not particularly rigorous. Enforcement also needs to be seated in someone not on the Big Oil payroll.
it doesn’t matter that there are only 62 regulators.
The oil companies write their own inspections reports. I’m sure that cuts down on the workload quite a bit.
I suggest that it would be helpful if FDL were to quote to Private Eye #1264 Re the MMS. The MMS’s chief of staff in the Gulf of Mexico until 2007 was one Jim Grant. Guess what giant British oil firm he now works for.
Baying for the head of Salazar on a platter does nothing to correct the multiple problems caused by VP Cheney.
You said it shorter, and therefore better.
Pithy! Very, very Pithy! I love it! dick c’s comment needs to be posted on billboards across the whole country.
On Sunday morning Rahm starts to make the case that the Democratic philosophy of government is different from the Republicans’ view, that Democrats are better for the country, a distinction that (if voters believe it) could help Democrats win in the fall. By the way, wasn’t it nice to hear Rahm criticize someone other than progressives?
On Monday Salazar obliterates that message by vomiting up the tired old Republican talking point, “gubmint regulation baaad!” Salazar has positioned himself on the wrong side of Rahm’s “re-elect Democrats” message. He might need to “spend more time with the family,” soon.
Yes. It might signal the launch of the fall election meme, and in this climate of corporate generated catastrophe on so very many fonts, it just might put D butts into chairs on the Hill.
Not that the average D actually believes in the meme.
Mr. Salazar is lying. If we had one regulation, one that outlawed all offshore drilling, then we would not be having problems like the BP oil gusher destroying the wildlife of the Gulf of Mexico.
Salazar is no expert on oil drilling, doesn’t have a clue what was done or could have been done, so why would He even make statements other than to cover His butt for not cleaning up the MMS. This guy should have been fired, and maybe brought up on charges for his failures, not still in his job to make things worse.
Had a knowledgeable inspector been with that rig watching over it’s operation, and questioning what they were doing, and insisting the casing be installed, centralizers used, The BP preventer had been tested, and that drilling mud was used, and the cement jobs were proper this could have not have happened. Instead our Government paid hords of people sitting behind desks at MMS doing basically nothing, but wouldn’t pay for qualified inspectors.
Our Government has been criminal for it’s actions before the incident, and criminal for it’s actions and inactions after the incident. It with the help of Thad Allen has actually made this disaster a hundred times worse than it needed to be, by his decisions and letting BP run the show. Had they insisted BP boom the area around the well and suck up every drop that came to the surface, we would not have the disaster and damage we are seeing today.
President Obama should be impeached for letting Thad make the decisions he has, and letting all the people in charge still be in charge.
Everyone is responsible for the people they hire, and what those people do while in Your employ.