Gen. Stanley McChrystal and a coterie of aides in Afghanistan stepped out in a magazine profile in Rolling Stone, speaking of betrayal and mocking members of the Administration like Vice President Joe Biden. McChrystal also expresses “disappointment” over his first meeting with President Obama, and especially over the appointment of Karl Eikenberry as the top diplomat in Afghanistan.
An article out this week in “Rolling Stone” magazine depicts Gen. Stanley McChrystal as a lone wolf on the outs with many important figures in the Obama administration and unable to convince even some of his own soldiers that his strategy can win the war [...]
If Eikenberry had the same doubts, McChrystal said he never expressed them until a leaked internal document threw a wild card into the debate over whether to add more troops last November. In the document, Eikenberry said Afghan President Hamid Karzai was not a reliable partner for the counterinsurgency strategy McChrystal was hired to execute.
McChrystal said he felt “betrayed” and accused the ambassador of giving himself cover.
“Here’s one that covers his flank for the history books,” McChrystal told the magazine. “Now, if we fail, they can say ‘I told you so.’”
Because Rolling Stone apparently doesn’t want to sell Web ads, they haven’t yet put the article on their site, even though information wants to be free and Politico has posted the whole piece as a PDF.
McChrystal and aides reserve their greatest rancor for top members of the Administration. They call the “inflection point” deadline of July 2011 to transition to local Afghan forces “arbitrary,” one aide calls National Security Adviser Jim Jones a “clown… stuck in 1985,” and another aide McChrystal himself offers a rejected “Wayne’s World” joke about the Vice President: “Biden? Did you say: Bite me?”
McChrystal had to apologize for the entire profile.
“I extend my sincerest apology for this profile. It was a mistake reflecting poor judgment and should never have happened,” McChrystal said in a statement.
“Throughout my career, I have lived by the principles of personal honor and professional integrity. What is reflected in this article falls far short of that standard,” he said.
“I have enormous respect and admiration for President Obama and his national security team, and for the civilian leaders and troops fighting this war and I remain committed to ensuring its successful outcome.”
The damage is done, of course. And if Team McChrystal wasn’t busy lining up soundbites to start the round of blame for their inevitable failures in Afghanistan, maybe they’d pay more attention to the problems happening inside the country. Like the nation of drug addicts being created. Or the sudden resignation of the leading British diplomat:
Britain’s special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, who has criticized elements of the U.S. war strategy, has resigned and the new government of Prime Minister David Cameron is reviewing whether to fill the job, British officials said Monday.
Sherard Cowper-Coles, the British counterpart of Obama administration special representative Richard C. Holbrooke, had held the position since early 2009, after serving nearly two years as ambassador to Afghanistan.
He had pushed for a political solution in Afghanistan and for higher priority to be given to talks with the Taliban and other insurgent groups, while expressing skepticism that increased military force could prevail.
The resignations of honorable men always come first. I guess this guy betrayed McChrystal too. In the end, everybody does.
UPDATE: The article confirms that old axiom, that military commanders never ask for less troops at any point in a war:
But facts on the ground, as history has proven, offer little deterrent to a military determined to stay the course. Even those closest to McChrystal know that the rising anti-war sentiment at home doesn’t begin to reflect how deeply fucked up things are in Afghanistan. “If Americans pulled back and started paying attention to this war, it would become even less popular,” a senior adviser to McChrystal says. Such realism, however, doesn’t prevent advocates of counterinsurgency from dreaming big: Instead of beginning to withdraw troops next year, as Obama promised, the military hopes to ramp up its counterinsurgency campaign even further. “There’s a possibility we could ask for another surge of U.S. forces next summer if we see success here,” a senior military official in Kabul tells me.
UPDATE II: Gen. McChrystal’s press aide has reportedly resigned for setting up the interview. And McChrystal has now been called to Washington to discuss the matter.
UPDATE III: So here’s something fun. It’s the section in the Uniform Code of Military Justice about insubordination:
Any commissioned officer who uses contemptuous words against the President, the Vice President, Congress, the Secretary of Defense, the Secretary of a military department, the Secretary of Transportation, or the Governor or legislature of any State, Territory, Commonwealth, or possession in which he is on duty or present shall be punished as a court-martial may direct.
Pretty clear-cut. (Sec’y of Transportation at one time commanded the Coast Guard)
UPDATE IV: Eugene Fidell, a Yale professor and president of the National Institute of Military Justice, calls McChrystal’s words “disrespectful” but not contemptuous, but nevertheless says that the General should be fired. Michael Cohen offers a fusillade of reasons why McChrystal has to go. At the root, this is about the military commanders understanding their role.
UPDATE V: John Kerry won’t call for McChrystal’s ouster, considers it “poor judgment” on the part of the General and his aides.
UPDATE VI: Rolling Stone has the full story up now. It occurs to me that the carping from McChrystal and his entourage (generals have an entourage now) mirrors almost perfectly the whining from Wall Street CEOs that their asses haven’t been properly kissed. We live in this culture of elite entitlement, and even the elites who get practically everything they want – from Jamie Dimon to Stanley McChrystal – still find fault with those who fail to fully recognize their brilliance and worth.




47 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Fire this clown.
Breaking on MSNBC: McChrystal going to WH to tender resignation.
Ya think?
MSNBC just said that Karzai has released a statement in support of McChrystal.
Look’s like he’s going to deploy the “stab in the back” theory.
Wikipedia:
McCrystal’s problems are essentially his own, and will not have much overall effect on the course taken by the war machine.
The pentagon has an endless supply of yes-men waiting in reserve.
I’m sorry, I have looked and looked on Politico (ugh) for the PDF and cannot find it. The link only goes to the Politico html. Do I need to clean off my contacts?
considering all that’s gone in to Axelrod and Plouffe’s branding efforts, calling Obama “unprepared” jumps out as the most egregious gaffe so far.
Didn’t I link to it in the piece?
other TradMed outlets claiming pdf link is now gone
I can’t find it. I even found a purported link to it in another URL and I land on the same Politico page: http://www.politico.com/
Could they have taken down the PDF? (BTW I have an IT job, so I’m not exactly a novice, but I simply don’t see a link on the Politico page to a PDF).
Doesn’t surprise me…I’m sure the PDF violates copyright.
And now I gave Politico a bunch of clicks. I need a shower.
We’ll see if they have any back bone and fire him.
cb12 the idea of calling Obama unprepared is McCrystal way of saying Bush was Sun Tzu? I don’t think so.
McCrystal can read, and he understands that he will be blame for the Afghan Disaster, so he jumps ship ASAP. Obama and Rahm were going to hang him out to dry! along with Gates, Pakistan is falling a part rapidly, and once Pakistan goes, GAME OVER! Obama like Bush does not understand the Arab street, the Arab street HATES the USA, and they Hate their Govt..
Obama is no genius, he was a great con artist.
The problem Obama has, and what most politician have is that when politics become real, and you have to develop real solutions to deal with real problems they have failed.
See the elites prop up people like Rush Limbaugh, Sarah Palin, who are clowns to keep the masses away from real issues, you can do this when you are not in a depression.
The USA now finds itself in a depression “Great Recession” and the masses need food, water, shelter, clothes, etc. and the Con games are not working.
Obama speaks well, but words don’t feed people.
“the pentagon has an endless supply of yes-men waiting in reserve.”
True. But Barack Obama does not have an endless supply of yes-men, and yes-women, waiting in reserve…as he is about to find out, 18 weeks from now.
Palace intrigues. Read “I, Claudius”.
He should fire him immediately; like Truman fired McArthur
UPDATE V: John Kerry won’t call for McChrystal’s ouster, considers it “poor judgment” on the part of the General and his aides.
“poor judgment” Like Kerry, Clinton and the rest of the Senators who voted for the invasion of Iraq
We should keep in mind, that Obama sent those 30,000 troops into the shitmire. What did McChrystal want?
This is shaping up as LBJ’s quandary when his massive escalations in Vietnam yielded him a LOT of anger and frustration at the casualties and economic cost of teaching the “gooks” a lesson.
Obama is caught between the warbots who still think they can “educate” the [edited by mod], and the growing number of americans who understand that we are throwing good blood and treasure after wasted.
Pre-surge, Petraeus and Gates assured Obama that with the 30,000 new troops, we could Afghanize the war by June of 2011. How strange that none of Obama’s braintrust, and he, himself, didn’t realize the deadly deja-vu of that, that the promise was given, time and time again, by the military in Vietnam.
[modnote: please don't use derogatory terms]
In a few hours we’ll hear leaked stories about the “tongue-lashing” a “furious” Obama gave McTorture and he’ll be sent back to continue overseeing the catastrophe.
I think one of the great under-reported stories are the ways in which the generals have controlled Obama. It was because of their pressure that Obama pushed back Iraq “withdrawal” and didn’t release the photos depicting torture.
The wild card in this, or one of them, is that we don’t know the price-point of Obama’s fear of the brass, and of the repubs taking advantage of any effort on his part to reign them in. He set the tone for dealing with them as an inferior wimp, and it’s going to be hard to change it.
I suspect he still shits green nickels when he thinks about going into a real adversary relationship with them. Haven’t seen much to indicate otherwise.
Would not be surprised if some of those photos end up leaked soon after this interview.
This clown and his myrmidons wouldn’t have the chance to mouth off about their Commander in Chief if they were more properly spending time with their defense counsel preparing their defense to war crimes trials. McChrystal never should have been put in charge in Af/Pak — he should have been cashiered when his torture, confinement and rendition operations in Iraq came to light.
Obama, of course, will apologize to him this morning.
WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange breaks cover but will avoid America
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jun/21/wikileaks-founder-julian-assange-breaks-cover
Sure seems like McChrystal is floating a balloon to see if the Commander-in-Chief will act like one or if it is safe for his boss Petraeus to make his move to be the American Caesar that Douglas MacArthur always wanted to be.
McChrystal can retire and then join in here as an Obama basher. He’ll fit right in.
again, I sense there’s a Beer Summit or in our future
I suspect you are right Teddy … all too right.
Each step of the way – which we have documented over and over – McChrystal has thumbed his nose at the law, human rights, and his C-in-C and come out with whatever he wanted.
If they fire him, or he resigns, he will be able to speak even more freely and unflatteringly of the POTUS. Can the administration afford that potential PR disaster?
“myrmidon”
I’ve learned lots of new words reading your comments and posts. I wish I could remember them!
Eh – all that keeps running through my mind is: the chickens come home to roost.
If the Barackstar had any political nous, he would’ve been winding down both wars, eliminating torture stat, freeing the prisoners faster from Gitmo, yadda yadda. Instead, Obummer took the cowards way out and caved in to these fascists and now look at the gooey egg all ovah Obummah’s face.
Well, well how ’bout that. Who coulda predicted? And suitably, John Kerry carries the water for McCrystal. How low the mighty have fallen, but who’s surprised.
All I can do is shake my head and think: what a parade of @**holes and clowns… wasting my money and behaving like a bunch of bullshite cretins. My my and so: on it goes….
Great word – eh? And apt. Thanks Teddy.
They should fire this General. You cannot have disobediance in an army, either at the bottom or the top. This guy must be gone, if only by the univerisal mitilitary code of respecting rank and the whole of the army. There are some armies that abide by these rules and then there are the losers of history. Which army will the US turn out to have?
This is funny. Joe Klein: Mac is an “extraordinary man” is simply too honest for the Washington game.
http://swampland.blogs.time.com/2010/06/22/mcchrystal/?xid=huffpo-direct
The Politico link may be fubar’d but here’s the last paragraph of the article:
My bold. Let’s see if anyone wants to address that point.
HERE IT IS!!!!!!!!!!!!
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/17390/119236
wow. thanks
Only Joe K could play the “too honest for Washington” card.
What a sham spin.
It seems to me that destroying al qaida was our objective. That has been accomplished, so what is the reason for us being there now? Is it cia control of the drug trade? Is it forcing karzai to privatize the minerals?
mctorture is simply symptomatic of our inchoate policy in AfPak. He spoke the way he did because he was sure it would bring the support of the wingnuts and force obamarahma to roll over and extend the war.
If there’s anything FDLers love, its perpetual war.
After he says, “You know Stan, I am and always will be your fiercest advocate.”
McChrystal forever lost credibility with the Tillman coverup and lies to Congress. That this was overlooked in the first place was shocking – the natural consequences of it are playing out.
“McChrystal can retire and then join in here as an Obama basher. He’ll fit right in.”
No, he won’t.
He’s been farting in Obama’s face because Obama has some (thoroughly justified) skepticism about the “we can win it” bullshit, and won’t give him all the troops he wants to make sure that he can suppress the insurgency and control the wogs.
I have yet to see anyone on FDL beating up on Obama because he’s not feeding enough fresh meat into the grinder.
In point of fact, I would say that practically everyone on here is at least disappointed with Obama for not breaking THAT campaign promise and refusing to sustain and ratchet-up bush’s (Now his) loon-crusade.
Let’s keep our anger-base straight, shall we? I think that’s going to be important, in the coming weeks and months. :o)
What’s with wogs? I take that as a slur term.
[modnote: edited]
It’s now up here, though who knows for how long.
Same old story…….Obama crawls into bed with snakes and gets bitten.
So Gen McChrystal has tried to live his whole career honorably? Well, I’m waiting for the telegram resigning. And the requisition of a sword to disembowel himself.
I’m no Obama fan when it comes to the management of the Afghanistan or any war, but this is WAY beyond the pale. Even if he thought this, then the honorable thing to do was resign and then speak his mind. He has no honor left and his deceitfulness in saying one thing to one group and another to a different group has destroyed his ability to lead. See ya, General.
Obama better watch out for this McChrystal dood.
I was reading the RS story & this jumped out at me. This McChrystal has a sick mind.