I remember a spirited fight among some writers on the left that debated whether the Treasury Department supported or did not support structural, fundamental changes in the FinReg bill (soon to be FinReg law). Mike Konczal and others said “absolutely not,” while Tim Fernholz and others said “sure they did!” Typically, the Fernholz faction would use the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a major structural change, as an example of Treasury’s support. The Treasury Department and the Obama Administration supported the CFPB throughout – though it’s worth mentioning that they vociferously opposed carving out auto dealers from the consumer protections, and that made it into the bill anyway.
But if the Treasury Department was so insistent on the CFPB, you’d think they’d want the most qualified person for the job running it – indeed, the person who came up with the idea. But that’s where you’d be wrong.
Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has expressed opposition to the possible nomination of Elizabeth Warren to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, according to a source with knowledge of Geithner’s views [...]
Warren, a professor at Harvard Law School whose 2007 journal article advocating the creation of such an agency inspired policymakers to enact it into law, has rocketed to prominence since the onset of the financial crisis as one of the leading reform advocates fighting on behalf of American taxpayers.
Yet while her work on behalf of a federal unit designed solely to protect borrowers from abusive lenders has been embraced by the administration, Warren’s role as a bailout watchdog led to strained relations with the agency her panel has taken to task with brutal reports every month since Obama took office: Geithner’s Treasury Department.
It’s no secret the watchdog and the Treasury Secretary have had a tenuous relationship. Geithner’s critics have enjoyed watching Warren question him during his four appearances before her panel. Her tough, probing questions on the Wall Street bailout and his role in it — often delivered with a smile — are featured on YouTube. One video is headlined “Elizabeth Warren Makes Timmy Geithner Squirm.”
Boy, and bloggers are called the immature ones. Geithner gets his fee-fees hurt because Warren dares to tell the truth about the Wall Street cartel and the woefully inadequate job Treasury has done, particularly on the foreclosure crisis, and so that makes her unacceptable for a position she literally dreamed up. I think it’s time to end the fiction that the Treasury Department is in any way interested in fundamentally changing the balance of power between Wall Street and consumers. If this report is correct, Geithner is using his power to block someone who would actually make Wall Street nervous from having a position of authority.
At least one progressive group is already fighting back. The Progressive Change Campaign Committee has blasted an email to their supporters demanding that Warren be named the head of the CFPB.
As a Harvard professor, her credentials are impeccable. And she was the one who came up with the idea for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau — perhaps the best piece of this bill — in the first place.
In short, Warren is perfect for the position and most financial insiders have just assumed she would get it. That’s why it’s so outrageous that Geithner — a longtime Wall Street insider — would attempt to sabotage her appointment.
I will be in a position to gather more information about this in the near future, not only from Treasury, but from Elizabeth Warren. It turns out I’m on a panel with her next week at Netroots Nation. We’ll talk about the Forgotten Foreclosure Crisis along with Sen. Jeff Merkley and the Huffington Post’s Ryan Grim. So if you’re in Vegas, please come out as I speak with the next head of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau – unless Timmeh has something to say about it.




61 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Thank you. Once again the Obama administration is showing its true colors. Geithner wouldn’t fart without Obama’s approval.
Warren is an honest person and an effective public servant. She is everything that Obama and Geithner hate.
Obama may have promised to oppose Warren to get Ben Nelson’s vote. Would be typical of Obama to compromise when he didn’t really need to.
Thanks so much for highlighting this, David. Go Elizabeth!
The CFPB has been largely gutted, a feature, not a bug. So of course, this Adminstration is not going to let it have an effective director.
Geithner is a soldier in the army of corporate kleptocracy and belongs in prison.
PETITION: Let Elizabeth Warren Police Wall Street
http://act.boldprogressives.org/cms/sign/petition_warren/?source=dkos1
Sorry, since I work long hours and can’t follow the blogs, do I write/call my senator? My congressional rep?… wish everyone voted for my primary candidate and realized what a media creation this president is?… Is there something that can be done? Sorry, petitions do not do it for me. But I’m willing to make the personal phone calls and letters.
Elizabeth Warren is the only choice at this point in time as an advocate for the middle class. I just hope she won’t get the Brooksley Born treatment.
Sadly, you have that backwards. Obama serves the Masters of the Universe, so Geithner tells Obama what to do. When Elizabeth Warren is dropped (or left hanging out to dry like Dawn Johnsen), we’ll know who’s interests Obama really serves.
As much as Warren seems a good choice for the position (which means she won’t get it), the key is that this position is under the Fed, and thus fundamentally serves to vitiate consumer protection, not to consolidate and strengthen it. What it is painted as and what it is are two different things, as we see so often these days.
And it’s also time to stop calling the new “Bureau” a transformational change. (Not that you did.)
Yes, but she needs to be heading a well-funded Think Tank, not working under weasel. That would be like a bad porn film.
Tim Fernholz?
You mean there are still people who listen to and take what Tim writes seriously?
Are these the same clowns who pay attention to Kos, Yglesias, Bowers, Drum -the Thoughtful, Pragmatic Dem faction?
Funny.
No wonder “Progressives” never get their way. Because anyone who has been paying attention since – oh the 1990′s – knows Geithner is, and always has been, an International Financial Criminal.
How do you think he ended up in the Bush/Obama Cabinet?….Duh!
Count on it. The bus she’ll be thrown under is already rolling.
All well funded think tanks are on the right. So Warren has just as much a chance at one of them as head of consumer protection.
Would Rick Santelli meet pissant Geithner’s corporatist requirements? He’s certainly tops in the douche bag department.
Elizabeth will be lucky if these thugs don’t ruin her career or put her in jail. This is how Corporatist treat whistle blowers and honest people like Warren.
Remember – there is a sign on the front door of Treasure reading “No uppity wimmen in the Club House” – If I were Elizabeth Warren, I would not take that job on a bet – she’d be reporting to Geithner, who she embarrassed publicly and professionally. She’d be reporting for a public flogging on a regular basis.
We need to change that. I think she could raise money very easily.
Love it.
My reading of this. It was the price of the 60th vote. Geithner is just the bagman.
Thanks, I see this is an issue people are really getting behind! ;^}
fewer than 5000 siggies! Damn!
Not that I particularly care for Timmy but why Elizabeth?
From whom could she raise money? From corps or rich people, that can outspend the rest of us by orders of magnitude? You must be kidding.
Tim Geithner is a white male.
She’s the only Harvard lawyer around who we can count on to tell the truth.
She couldn’t out raise the opposition.
But $5 million to pay herself and a couple of staff? No problem.
Weasel is one word and you misspelled it.
That size think tank would have very little influence. Not to mention that it would be a matter of months before it was coopted by donations from the likes of Scaife & Coors.
It would be a start. And it is needed.
I’m off. Be well.
David thanks for this. Do you know if there are any petitions going around to support Elizabeth Warrens nomination?
Please contact the White House. Let President Obama and the rest know that you support the most qualified and more importantly the most trusted person for that job.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/
Contact
http://www.whitehouse.gov/contact/
Call
You can also call or write to the President:
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500
Please include your e-mail address
Phone Numbers
Comments: 202-456-1111
Switchboard: 202-456-1414
FAX: 202-456-2461
TTY/TDD
Comments: 202-456-6213
Visitors Office: 202-456-2121
Exactly so.
Geithner, contrary to some popular wisdom is only an employee representing his rightful place within Team Obama. Obama and he have been noted as soul mates in many MSM articles. Anyone that wants to say that Obama, via Geithner, has been obliged to go against Warren needs to show where in the entire Obama administrative structure he has ever supported someone like Warren at any level. Geithner’s animosity is the public face of Team Obama. The idea that Warren, as an ethical regulator, could generate more funds than the Republican and Republican-lite TO is unsupportable.
Actually, I thik part of what Geithner fears is that Warren is too savvy to take shit from him.
She clearly knows how to work public opinion, yeah Elizabeth!, and I don’t think she would be so easy for him to intimidate.
In fact, I think part of Ole Tim’s objectio rests in very much SHE intimidates him.
Let’s face it, she has a steel trap mind and this sweet angelic face and voice that appears to be physically incapable of becoming shrill. She’s triple threat.
Geithner is a smarmy little worm of a tax cheat who promptly damaged Obama’s credibility in my book….I’ll wait to judge Obama when he nominates….and… Ms Warren is clearly the best choice….If he doesn’t select her, I will work very hard to defeat him and his ilk at every opportunity…..
Fuck Geithner. He’s lucky he and his thieving cronies aren’t [edited by moderator]
[Mod note: Please don't suggest, wish, or imply violence on anyone. Thanks]
Yes, like this.
I commented in the early morning thread that Timmeh looks like a micro-dick pee-brain scared of a smart woman next to her.
Geithner hates America.
“Let’s face it, she has a steel trap mind and this sweet angelic face and voice that appears to be physically incapable of becoming shrill. She’s triple threat.”
And people who suffer from the condition called greedlock sure do not want a “steel trap mind” focused on protecting the American public.
The Geithner/Treasury/Summers war with Warren goes way back, Yves Smith has more of the story:
Elizabeth Warren in Treasury Crosshairs Again
And Simon Johnson has more:
http://baselinescenario.com/2010/07/15/tim-geithner%E2%80%99s-ninth-political-life/
If he does not appoint Warren. It is all over for Obama. This would be oh so telling about just who Obama is totally beholden to.
Hope folks contact the White House with their support for Warren. What else can we do? Contact?
anyone up for calling into the Diane Rehms show round up hour (right now) and ask this question about why Geithner is against or trying to block Warren’s nomination? And that folks should call the White House to demonstrate their support for Warren’s nomination. Hundreds of thousands are listening. Great way to get a plug in. Can not do it myself just got a comment about Bradley Manning through recently.
Drshow@wamu.org
1800- 433-8850
news round up
http://thedianerehmshow.org/
Oh Geithner loves American alright, as long as it’s the America of the obscenely wealthy ripping off the lower orders, and he’s in the “club.” That America he loves a lot.
Sent this into the DR show without a name.
“Can your guest please discuss why Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has expressed opposition to the possible nomination of Elizabeth Warren to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau? Why would anyone try to block Elizabeth Warrens steel trap mind and her effort to protect consumers?”
I’ve tried unsuccessfully four times to sign the petition. Each time I’ve been kicked off and have received the following message: Internet Explorer cannot display the webpage. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
It is Tim Geither turn to be the villian!
Obama and Rahm are totally against Elizabeth Warren! Why Elizabeth Warren is a real democrat, and we know republicans like Obama and Rahm hate real democrats.
We all know Tim Geither hates the USA, he does not pay his taxes.
Tim Geither is the mouth piece for Wall Street.(Obama and Rahm also work for Wall Street)
Do you have Firefox? FF worked flawlessly for me just now.
In response to the “editor”: oh, grow the fuck up.
thanks. Did not see that. Will sign and spread around
Just sent this in again to the Diane Rehm show. Anyone else want to send it in I just got one through the show so I doubt if I can get this one through
“there is a petition up in the blogosphere called
Let Elizabeth Warren Police Wall Street
Can your guest please discuss why Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has expressed opposition to the possible nomination of Elizabeth Warren to head the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau? Why would anyone try to block Elizabeth Warrens steel trap mind and her effort to protect consumers?”
drshow@wamu.org or 1800-433-8850
Use Firefox and dump IE. IE is a disaster.
I’m already on their email list.
So. Done.
google chrome
For a primer on what a collosal criminal/idiot Geithner is, the gang at Baselinescenario.com has provided a comprehensive breakdown.
Obama, like God, does not hear the prayers of the little people.
Leen: Here’s the link to the comment with the petition.
I think it speaks highly in favor of Warren that Geithner opposes her.
Elizabeth Warren? No, the last thing we need is another egghead from Harvard. We need someone with real world experience.
tinman? did Bush have real world experience, does Sarah Palin have real world experience? No! absolutely not! it time for the USA to abandon the notion that idiots can save the USA
Elizabeth Warren has more love for the USA and the citizens of the USA, than Obama, Bush, Palin, Tim Geither combine!