A very smart activism campaign by MoveOn and several gay rights groups against Target has culminated in their shareholders pressuring them for their campaign spending.
After weeks of public protest over its financial support of an organization that backed a GOP gubernatorial candidate opposed to gay rights, Target Corp. now faces a new form of pressure: demands from institutional shareholders that it revamp its donation process to avoid the chance of additional backfires [...]
“Imprudent donations can potentially have a major negative impact on company reputations and business if they don’t carefully and fully assess a candidate’s positions,” said Tim Smith, a senior vice president at Walden Asset Management, one of three asset management firms that this week filed a resolution asking the retail giant to overhaul its campaign donation policies. He cautioned that funding ballot initiatives, as many corporations have done, “can similarly backfire.”
The three management firms sponsoring the resolution — Calvert Asset Management, Trillium Asset Management and Walden — together hold $57.5 million of Target stock. Other institutional investors, including the giant New York state pension fund and union investment managers, are considering co-signing the resolution, which calls on Target’s independent directors to review the criteria and risks in making donations to organizations active in political campaigns.
We like to talk a lot about the power of money in politics, and how decisions like Citizens United will end up crushing what’s left of representative democracy. But that sells short the power that citizens have through collective action. Indeed, the shareholder movement is one of the more exciting developments I’ve seen in some time. Public pension and union funds play a role, but so can institutional investors and even individuals. What’s more, by putting on the public pressure, grassroots groups can spook investors so they tell their corporate parents to keep their heads down and stay out of the business of spending on elections. This can work as a deterrent.
This is a solution to the Citizens United problem that doesn’t have to come from the government. Having full disclosure on all spending would make these kinds of campaigns more effective, however, and that’s where government actions like the DISCLOSE Act come in.




70 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
The target CEO said a few weeks ago he would set up a “review process” for future donations. It seems like the demands of the letter have already been agreed to.
I’m sure this will have a devastating effect on Exxon/Mobil’s donations. Not to mention WellPoint’s.
I can only speak for myself but I’ve stopped going to Target at all. It was my big box store of choice but now I’ll skip them altogether. Too little, too late.
P.S. And what the CEO said wasn’t an apology.
Won’t corp power prevent full disclosure? After all, what’s the point of corp power if they can’t at least do that?
Seems to me this Target brohaha has caught Target flat footed and that other corps will learn from that and not make the same mistake.
Besides, how long before MoveOn, already in the D veal pen, learns that they get more donations by catering to the corps than to the peeps.
This is killer news. Target has made lots of money off of being the stylish and ethical big-box alternative to Wal-Mart, and these three shareholder groups represent its (ahem) target market.
It’s not just Target — it’s Best Buy, too. And corporations can run but they can’t hide. Shareholders, if nobody else, can find out who’s giving to whom.
TARGET sux…used to adore massimo stuff,but im done
snack time,…………later
Therein lies the problem in my opinion. All this will force them to do is be more careful about what they disclose. It isn’t going to make them change in any meaningful way or at least there is no way to be sure that they will. If they’ve supported homo bigots once, there’s nothing to prevent them doing so in the future and their track record is already crap.
So why isn’t Wal-Mart a bete noire, esp if it’s worse than Target?
Years and years and years ago, JCP announced a program of targeting clothes purchasers, as a niche. At a NYC Soc of Securities Analysts, I asked why everyone wouldn’t copy JCP ASAP as their tactics proved successful, if they did. My colleagues at the meeting were embarrassed on my account for asking such a stoopid Q.
I didn’t go there because they were “hip” or “stylish” but because they weren’t Wal-Mart. I normally try to avoid big box stores so I didn’t spend a lot of time in there anyway but I did go there from time to time. They just threw their “better than Wal-Mart” status away as far as my patronage is concerned though.
It is hard to shop locally since the B boxes have put so many out of business. I want to start a site that lists merchants by neighborhood, etc.
And yeah….Best Buy has a lot more to lose from my lack of business than Target does. Too bad Best Buy. I was a loyal customer….
I’m not shopping at Target now but I really do like the store. They have everything and I don’t have to make 15 stops. It’s very convenient but I won’t go right now. And I never go to Wal-Mart.
Yep. There are whole towns with no alternative to the big box stores. I’ll never understand why people think that buying cheap crap from China is a GOOD idea. It doesn’t matter how much you “save” if it’s crap. As a former airframe and diesel mechanic, I’d like to point out that buying cheap tools for example is more trouble than what you “save”, because they invariably break and have to be replaced and by nature, they break while you’re in the middle of doing something. Better to spend more and get a quality product. the same can be said for clothing, shoes, appliances, etc.
I need to replace my ipod. Where do i go if not best buy?
And their stuff is of better quality than Wal-Mart at least. The last item I bought from Target was a new tea kettle and I love it. Too bad… :(
Amazon. Everything at the big box electronics stores is out of date and overpriced.
Heck if I know. I don’t own an ipod. I would suggest doing a web search for the product and local dealers.
We have to not only NOT shop at Target, but let them know why we aren’t. If we silently just stay away, it has little effect. If the CEO is deluged with letters all explaining the same reason — not form letters, but individual letters that make the same point in our own voices — they may pay attention.
I don’t have a lot of hope. I would have liked to see that Target CEO give an equal amount to a gay rights — or at least a progressive — organization. Talk is cheap, apologies are cheap talk.
go online to apple and ask them for a local place.
Online at Apple.
Good point and I have. I got a meaningless platitude in the form of email.
And yeah. His “apology” was full of regrets but not for what Target did, just for how people perceived it.
Find an Apple store — they are in larger cities and they’re even opening one in South Bend IN, hardly a metropolis. Buy one on eBay (I’ve bought 3 laptops and a few other computer things on eBay and if the seller has very high feedback ratings, you are pretty safe). And you are protected by eBay if something goes amiss.
Yes, that is discouraging, but it doesn’t mean that some functionary isn’t tallying the number of letters. It is no worse than what I get from my elected officials when I write to them.
I think you can buy iPods at Walmart (ugh) or Costco now, too. They’re pretty ubiquitous and you don’t have to buy from Best Buy.
Some invisible hand steered me through a Target, for the first time in literally years, about a week before news of their donation hit. Never again, or at least not soon, though that really shrinks my options.
In a related matter, I see where BP has ended their advertising on ThinkProgress just one day after TP reported on BP’s greenwashing practices.
So they’re paying some attention.
And because now a certain suspicion might attach to sites that still run BP ads unless those sites have strong bona fides, they have created a market for articles that are critical of them at sites that want to preserve the appearance of independence.
They’re an extraordinary lot.
Don’t go to Walmart!!!!!!!!!!!! bad, evil people.
iPods on eBay:
http://shop.ebay.com/i.html?_nkw=ipod&_armrs=1&_from=&_ipg=
I read that earlier. Personally I’m surprised that they allowed their advertisement to stay up here as long as it did.
EDIT: Oops! My mistake. It’s still up here.
Costco has a gazillion iPods.
Yeah, but sometimes there isn’t an alternative. We don’t have Costco here, and I need to buy at quantity prices for some items. I am very selective about what I get at Sam’s Club (actually I almost never shop at Walmart), and I buy mostly at the local supermarket chain or the farmers market. I buy a lot online, too.
Meg Whitman won’t get my trade.
Amazon, it isn’t just for books. Gad, they even show you vendors who offer it for less than they do, it’s the first place I look for anything.
Lately I’ve been stocking up on used CDs in “like new” condition. Often $5-6 with shipping included.
If you don’t use the Firefox browser with the AdBlock Plus ad blocker, you should. You won’t see any more ads.
Me, too. Love Amazon.
Yeah, I think it takes effect at the end of the month. Sort of a nonrenewal.
Yeah, there is nothing good about Wal-Mart and it’s almost un-American to go there and I’m not known to casually throw that term around. In this case it’s absolutely true. They use foreign manufacturers and distributors and have done nothing, NOTHING but try to weaken labor laws, import tariffs and regulations here at home, all to maximize their profits on the backs of the people. I wouldn’t buy bottled water from them in the Atacama Desert.
If nothing else it’s a good place to get an idea of the available price range.
Unfortunately, there is no Costco here, but I make a list and shop there when I go to visit my kids in Indianapolis. Occasionally in desperation I make a “Costco run” to a store about an hour from here, but I have to have a big list no upcoming trip to Indy, and need something badly enough to drive an hour. At that point I sometimes simply grit my teeth and go to Sam’s Club.
I let them cash my social security check then I leave. heh.
I use firefox but I haven’t downloaded the new browser yet.
Minnesota passed a disclosure law that requires corporate donations to be publicly disclosed, so there can be many more companies like Target in the state who may regret their political activism.
Naturally the corporations are pushing for a stay of the law, claiming it harms “free speech”. Minnesota is truly the battleground for the country created by the Citizens United decision.
Costco has the best meat I have found anywhere. Keep my freezer full all the time.
e-Meg is no longer affiliated with eBay.
If you like lamb, their lamb chops are super! I wish we had a Costco here. I’ve been a Costco shopper since the ’90s.
This is a plugin, and it has been available for a long time, not just the new version.
http://adblockplus.org/en/
Love the lamb chops and the t-bones are wonderful and large.
And those “already cooked chickens”. mmmmm
I have nothing bad to say about Costco. I understand it is a great place to work (for the type of jobs they offer). They pay benefits even to their lowest level employees, I think. Their stores are SO much better than Sam’s Club stores.
I’m afraid that’s true. I heard/read (can’t remember source) a piece about this the other day that said the lesson other companies are learning is not to donate to organizations required to disclose donors. So they will just give to organizations that have a status allowing them to keep donor lists secret.
Apparently what made Target’s gift public was Minnesota’s state disclosure laws.
It’s pretty obvious why the federal Disclosure Act didn’t pass, and won’t.
Nonetheless, I haven’t been to Target since the story broke. Signed MoveOn’s petition, with personalized note about why not. And as I keep pointing out, it isn’t just Emmer’s anti-gay that made this donation so bad. Target’s CEO’s “apology” explained that his purpose was to support a candidate with “prob-business” policies.
Well, that generic description would be enough for me…since that usually includes “anti-worker/consumer/citizen/society,” but Emmer, in particular, is anti-minimum wage among other “pro-business” stances.
She doesn’t own shares?
They have some of the best rotisserie chickens I’ve had! And usually a bit less than the supermarket offerings. Fatter birds, cheaper price.
But the effects of her Reign Of Greed at eBay linger on.
I have no idea — she may. Probably. But when you buy on eBay, the seller gets the lion’s share of the payment, and the seller pays the fees, not the buyer (so technically your money doesn’t go to e-Meg), and eBay has to make money just to keep the “lights on” so on balance I think it is a small price to pay. There are high volume sellers on eBay, but lots of the sellers are small, one-off items. In a way it is like shopping at the local farmer’s market. You pay the farmer, but the farmer pays rental to the market for his/her stall.
Anybody else having weird issues with FDL? I saw someone asking about a “spinning circle” a couple weeks ago; shortly after I began having that problem, too. When it happens, sometimes I can refresh and stop it, sometimes I can’t refresh at all and have to leave the page.
Now, when trying to post the above, trying to highlight a phrase in order to use bold, every time I clicked inside the comment box, the block of typed text moved up. Weird.
Yes, sigh, I’m using IE 8. Keep up with updates. I know, I know, FF, but I’m just so lazy. Used it a few years ago, with an older ocmputer; forget why I didn’t continue.
Any suggestions?
They’re making it somehow, the following is from the wiki.
Like what? (I am not contradicting you, I’m just curious.) As my comment above indicates, to me it is similar to shopping at a farmer’s market. I have no idea what the market owner does — I just hand my money to the seller (farmer), and we are both happy, and the seller of course pays the market owner a rental fee. I suppose if I found out that my local market’s owner was a scumbag it might influence my shopping, but that hasn’t been the case so far.
Tejan — get Firefox and abandon IE. Talk about yer evil companies! LOL.
Oh, eBay has fingers into lots of pies. They’ve bought PayPal, for one thing. At this point, the distance from e-Meg’s shares from her severance are miles away. And I’d rather give my money to an eBay seller than to a store like Best Buy or Target.
OK, y’all. I’ve had two glasses of wine and I am sleepy. Gonna toddle off to the waterbed. Have a good night, everyone!
night, msmolly.
sweet dreams msmolly
Sherrod Brown loves Costco, that’s a good sign for me. That said, we’ve never been there.
Off topic I know…but if you are looking for an iPod Touch eCahn, the new model should be out soon, hopefully in September. So wait a month or so if you don’t want the old model.
I’m compiling a list of designers who supply Target….they need to stop aiding and abetting. They need to be notified their businesses will suffer as well. I have no tolerance for what either Target or Best Buy did, and those who assist them further will have to pay a price if they continue.
Oh please, MoveOn had nothing to do with it. While I appreciate their support, they have only gotten involved in the last day or so. The lions share of work and effort has come from gay rights groups like Get Equal.
What’s next, you’re going to give HRC credit ?
It is amazing there is so much protectionism for a behavior, homosexuality. If there are compelling scientific, peer reviewed and repeatable studies/experiments demonstrating that homosexuality is anything other than a chosen behavior, I’d like to see them. It is also laughable that American society finds polygamy so offensive when it is a consensual relationship between adults. Just another double standard in the land of hypocrites.
All these people recommending Amazon as an alternative to Target are ridiculous. It was just a couple years ago we were all boycotting Amazon for their TERRIBLY homophobic removal of ALL books related to homosexuals — unless they were against “the gay.” That happened on Good Friday. Like Target, Amazon NEVER copped to why it happened or apologized. Not to mention, NOTHING goes back into our local economies when we buy from Amazon.
Second, are we seriously looking for somewhere else to buy an iPod? Have you read about the place Apple CHOOSES to manufacture their products? It’s called Foxconn and I’d buy EVERYTHING I need from Target before buying a product manufactured at Foxconn. I have no love for Target, but selective boycotts are bullshit. They do nothing and they’re about as nonsensical as the rhetoric spewed at a Tea Party rally.
If you only buy items that at least somewhat suit your ideology, you won’t need to boycott. Why? You’d already be shopping somewhere other than Target or Amazon and already be avoiding products like the iPod.
EDIT: After I edited this post to fix a typo, all my paragraph breaks went away. I have no idea how to fix it. I added break tags, but that did nothing. Sorry about the big wall of text.
So your well-taken point is you can shop outside the store fronts owned by The Casino. Plenty of store fronts actually look mom and pop but they aren’t. Find out. Ask where the business has its accounts. Then you know you are really directing money flows back to Main Street.