Today’s the day of Democrats calling for firings, I guess. On top of Tom Perriello wanting Tim Geithner to step down, Elaine Marshall, the Senate candidate who is close to even in polls against Republican incumbent Richard Burr in North Carolina, announced in a speech today that Alan Simpson should resign as co-chair of the deficit commission.
“Alan Simpson’s remarks were disrespectful to women and to social security recipients. He should resign or the President should fire him,” Marshall said, speaking at the Levine Museum of the New South in Charlotte.
“The fact that he thinks this way shows that he can’t do his job with an open mind. We should be doing everything in our power to strengthen and protect Social Security, not attacking the recipients who depend on it.”
Simpson sent a series of derisive emails to critics, not only filled with name-calling and attacks but reflecting a staggeringly ignorant view of Social Security. He apologized for the name-calling, but most of the groups calling for his resignation didn’t let up. As Marshall says, the emails show that Simpson “can’t do his job with an open mind.” This has been true for a long time now, as Simpson has an unbroken 30-year record of advocating benefit cuts. He shouldn’t come within 1,000 feet of any decision over retirement security, given his predisposition.
That Marshall would make this statement in the midst of trying to win a Senate race in a Southern state shows how Simpson really crossed the line here, damaging not just his reputation but the credibility of the cat food commission entirely.
For the record, FDL has a petition out escalating the dispute and calling for the President to disband the commission altogether.
UPDATE: Rep. Jerrold Nadler (D-NY) called on Simpson to be fired as well. His full release is available here.




12 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Simpson’s history! But it won’t change the dynamics. Deficit reduction is a world-wide mania.
The leak of the cat food deliberations was a smart political move by the Republican members of the Commission. It’s the one issue that could have moved a large block of seniors to vote against anyone talking cuts to SS for any reason. But, now, it appears to be a bi-partisan motivation. So, the calculus is: vote for the best sound bite.
Rove 2010 style.
Pigs may fly before the Democrats smarten up. Makes you long for the ’60′s, doesn’t it?
K A B U K I
rotating villains and heroes
Will Obama listen to the wishes of the people?
nope.
And yet, the 55+ voter block is the only one they still fear generally. the can the catfood petiton is smart. any attacks on simpson and the cat food commision are smart. its smart to take away Obamas and the senates cover on this issue. if they want to gut Social Security to extend the bush tax cuts let it be on THIER heads.
We need numbers how much will consumer spending go down if we cut Social Security during a Depression.
Porn Tobacco and Booze sales are all down they were suppose to be recession proof so was gambling but a look at the Las Vegas housing market proves otherwise.
Its time we start calling this a Depression.
Interesting Geithner is becoming a political issue for smart Dems who want to get elected. I wonder who Obama will choose to replace him?
The Obama administration will never fire Simpson because they AGREE with him and need him to do their bidding. Progressives, WAKE UP! Obama “is just not into us”. He’s a conservative. Or at least, he wants to be re-elected by conservatives. And the only way he can do that is by throwing progressives and the middle class out of the life boat.
Has anyone seen the “comments” by Rep. Bobby Bright (Democrat) from Alabama where he jokes about hoping Pelosi is dead by next year?
The Democrats don’t represent the Progressives. They stopped doing that back in the Clinton era. It’s time we get out of the party!
Here’s what the Caucus blog on the NY Times said about Rep. Bright:
Most of the people on Obama’s commission aren’t even qualified for the job.
Lift the cap.
Problem solved.
Next issue.
Why must we have a president who continually stands in the way of progress?
Obama picked Simpson to co-chair this committee.
Obama is standing in the way of progress. What ham handed selection of right wing enemies of Social Security floated in Obama’s brain when he sponsored this committee and the incompetents and enemies of social security?
Obama is clearly incompetent and his disconnect with Americans is visible.
I want my vote back.
Obama is a total phony. This committee and Alan Simpson has Obama’s approval and we now see American Idol as a narcissitic hack whose disconnect with us is palpable.
Doublespeak, inexperience, deception,backroom deals with Insurers and BigPharma, along with being an enemy of Social Security all make Obama a dangerous choice for true liberal democrats who were snookered.
There is no clarity, vision and certainly no daylight. The existing leadership vacuum presents many dangers for americans who believed Obama’s promises.
The democrats will pay dearly at the polls and this administration is a tone deaf disaster.
Doesn’t matter what she wants.
she is a progressive or somethin
!