This chart showing US home vacancies tells you everything you need to know about the near-term future of the economy. The United States has twice as many vacant homes as the entire housing stock of Canada. The US has ten times more people than Canada, too, but that doesn’t exactly help us think about the problem.
With that much excess supply, prices simply have to fall. And the worst part of this story is that the foreclosure tide, which has been held back temporarily by a few Administration programs, is about to burst. Basically, the failure of the HAMP program to actually modify loan terms is about to lead to a big spike:
What you’re seeing here isn’t subprime dreck: it’s sensibly-underwritten conforming loans which were bought by Fannie and Freddie. Through 2009 and the first half of 2010, the rate at which those loans entered foreclosure proceedings was pretty steady. But as we enter the second half of 2010, there’s a huge spike, especially in the loans which have been delinquent for more than six months.
That spike is loans which entered the HAMP modification process, but then got kicked out, for reasons good or bad. Without a successful permanent HAMP modification, foreclosure comes soon enough.
As homes move out of HAMP and into foreclosure, the amount of distressed real-estate sales will rise, and home prices will of course fall in the effected areas, pushing ever more homeowners into the negative-equity status which is very highly correlated with default risk. And so the vicious cycle continues.
There are a number of ways to arrest this cycle – level the playing field for the borrower by allowing bankruptcy judges to modify loan terms, allow borrowers to rent their properties at market rates for a period of time, force the lenders to write the properties down to present value, or whatever. But clearly, HAMP can’t do it alone, and none of those other options are on the horizon. I’d put my money on the smart organizers in New York trying to force write-downs over Treasury, at this stage. But you can see in their model the options available:
Now NYCC has turned up the heat on the banks. It has joined with state and local legislators to make foreclosure a more expensive and onerous proposition for Wall Street.
In a press conference last week, members of NYCC, the State Senate, State Assembly and New York City Council announced legislation that would force banks to pony up to maintain foreclosed homes rather than letting them deteriorate at the expense of impacted communities.
State legislation that took effect in April required banks to maintain foreclosed properties so they don’t fall into disrepair, increase blight and crime and further drive down property values while devastating entire neighborhoods.
The point is that the props for the housing market are gradually being kicked away. Either the economy will suffer from the huge costs associated with foreclosures, or the banks will participate in offsetting the funding. Right now, it looks like the former.




24 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
they really screwed this up
a lot of the new developments that are sitting almost entirely empty should be condemed and razed. there is a 150 acre tract of mc mansions near where i live thats now 95 % empty. most of them were never even sold. the forrest they destroyed to build them was contiguous with state forrest lands and required very hard to get permits to use. a complete waste from every perspective.
They, i.e. our political elites have screwed it all up. There is already a large shadow inventory of houses that would normally have gone into foreclosure but which the banks have not moved on because not doing so spares them expense and allows them to carry these properties at full value on their balance sheets. What we need are cramdowns to pre-bubble levels and, of course, jobs so people can afford any house at all.
At some point too, the MERS fiasco is going to have to be addressed. Yet another screw up by our elites.
I walk a lot, and I see too many empty houses in my neighborhood with no “for sale” sign out front. A lot of people see this, too, but choose to ignore what it means. It’s been obvious to me for a long time that we’re heading for another round of foreclosures and that prices are most likely going to drop again.
Feel badly for those who get caught by lower home values, but quite honestly, I could never see how the insanely high prices could ever be sustained. There definitely seems to be a group-think (?) mezmerizing that went on during the housing bubble, which was remarkably like the tech bubble.
Citizens of all classes, income, race, education, intelligence, whatever really drank a ton of Kool Aid and believed that their tech stocks/houses would continue to increase in value ad infinitum.
There was only a small minority that realized what a chimera it all was, but in both cases, some folks did make a ton of money. Everyone wants a get rich quick scheme, but as they say: there’s no such thing as a free lunch.
I figure we’re heading for a new round of foreclosures, and I figure it’s needed to bring housing prices back to some kind of realistic level. There’s tons of people out there out of work and/or underemployed. The center can no longer hold. Time for more belt tightening, I’m afraid.
You don’t understand. The only important thing left on Obama’s agenda is gutting Social Security. All he has to do is hold on until the lame duck session in December and get defeated Dems to vote with the GOP to enact the Catfood Commission recommendations. Once that happens it’s Mission Accomplished for President Pinocchio, the real-life Manchurian Candidate of the elites. Whatever economic catastrophes ensue are of no concern to him. He and his family will be well provided for by their friends in the ruling class.
“With that much excess supply, prices simply have to fall.”
We need to get back to an economy where people can predict the future with confidence, where home prices don’t spike and collapse and health care costs don’t double and triple in a matter of years and where social security/pensions are not on the chopping block. Normalcy will only be achieved again when retirement is not a frightening economic prospect, when homes become affordable and when business is regulated in a rational manner, not given free reign to do whatever the heck it wants.
We have a long, long way to go.
Bank “closing costs” via maintenance and fines for non-maintenance, via review of foreclosure sales for required maintenance, would indeed slow down the process – and might change a few minds.
But mind change on business processes in the executive class is a bit like changing religious beliefs – folks don’t do it often. The management will need to be changed – and with self-nominating, evaluating senior management I do not see that happening. We have a federal group of politicians that will not do anything not approved by the executives – despite forced principal amount modification being required for the good of society and for the good of the banks.
So I agree with you – foreclosures will spike up in the next 6 months as prices fall in certain areas. We have prices rising in some areas and indeed bidding “wars(as in 2 bids)” have broken out in some markets, albeit only after large drops from the 2006-07 level, so it will be an uneven result across the nation. A change to GOP control will not solve the foreclosure problem – or anything else – as the GOP’s masters just want more tax cuts for the rich.
Just to pile on with the bad news, it looks like commercial real estate is about to take a major beating as well. Many strip centers and office buildings are sitting mostly empty and have been for a couple years. The owners are starting to refuse to pay their mortgages, and are forcing the whole issue so that they can claim the losses for tax purposes.
Hold onto your hats, its gonna be a VERY bumpy ride!
BTW, does anyone know what the current inventory level is for salable homes? The last time I checked was about 4-6 weeks ago and they were saying over 12 month supply (3-4 months is considered normal, IIRC).
BTW, does anyone know what the current time-inventory for salable homes is?
The last time I checked was a while back, and they were claiming a 12 month supply when 3-4 months was normal. I suspect it has gotten even worse (this tends to make foreclosures lag somewhat, since the market has a glut that will push prices lower…)
It went back up to 12 months in the July reports.
So with sales plunging, home foreclosure rates poised to spike and inventory at 15-year highs, it isn’t looking to good…
Calculated Risk had it at 12.5 months a week ago.
Housing prices have been grossly inflated in the US for the past decade and change. They need to come back to Earth (i.e. pre-1997 levels) in order for the economy to properly recover. That sucks royally for people with money in the housing market, no two ways about it. However, the inflated cost of housing is ultimately a drag on the economy because of the drag it puts on discretionary spending and the pressure it puts on local governments and small businesses.
Should have said pre-1997 levels, adjusted for inflation.
Belt tightening is okay for some. But this has been a Potemkin Economy for decades. When you have stagnant incomes it made sense that housing which rose at 20 percent a year looked like the only way to prosperity. God knows unless one is a rock star or Goldman Sachs douchebag or designer of iPhone apps, just about every road to prosperity now is blocked. Anyone who makes their career as an employee – anyone in any field now – is heading for a dead end (with the exception of Wall Street douches). Absolutely nothing is safe, not even in the medical field. It just doesn’t pay to be a wage slave anymore.
In other words we need to permanently kill the ideology of “I got mine,” and look at it like we’re all in this together. Which we are. It may require a lot of pain to make enough people see the light and kill the undead philosophy that Reagan and his ilk foisted on us.
Right. The economy can’t recover by pumping more hot air into the housing bubble. At some point this country is going to have to create something other than debt. Those in power don’t see it that way apparently.
“The American dream is not that every man must be level with every other man. The American dream is that every man must be FREE to become whatever God intends he should become.” –Ronald Reagan
Good Grief, we are NOT all in this together..I do not want to live in your vision of the all encompasing American Hippie Commune, where all is equal and individuality is frouned upon. Yours is just a freaky concept…
So with 10 million homes emptied, if the average number of persons per home was 5 then 50 million USAers are now homeless. Could there be a homelessness problem of that magnitude going on? Or are these houses that were never occupied? If these homes went onto the rental market, maybe rents would finally come down.
A significant portion were never sold. A sizable but unknown portion were sold to speculators or as second homes, and never occupied on a full-time basis. Many of the people who have moved out of them have moved in with friends or relatives. Hard to know how much of each without a deep dive into the data and/or substantial fieldwork. I’m pretty sure a sixth of the US population is not currently homeless, however.
“The American man must be free to be whatever
godthe American ruling elite intends he should become.” There, fixed it for the gipper.In wingnut land it’s either a hippie commune or “freedom”. Nothing in between. Unless you can be absolutely sure you’re in the ruling elite, the boot is probably on your neck too. You just don’t know it yet.
Get out of your denial. Capitalism is melting down. The times of laissez-faire selfisheness are over and the sooner you realize the better person you will become. Reagan was an actor, that’s all, he was not smart, he was not a leader, he was an actor reading a script.
As far as housing goes, maybe we should begin taking over the foreclsures and leading homeless families to them and then setting up protection zones around them before the thugs and cops move in. This is already happening in some locations. On the plus side, someone like me, with a middle-class job and some savings, may actually be able to buy a home…even though rayguns deregulatory disaster has prevented me from doing so until now (or six mths from now.)
Worthless comment, but it’s a pet peeve: “data” is plural.
I agree about MERS, but I think that the states have an easy solution to this problem. The state of California could form a state bank and refinance all homes at 4% interest (fixed 30 years). If your mortgage was over 4%, you could refinance at 4% for a 1% fee (mortgage brokers would get half of the fee to encourage the refinancing). The refinanced homes would be for up to 125% of the current value of the property. Home owner would have no out of pocket expenses.
This would help upside down mortgages and force all new mortgages to around 4%. The restrictions would be that the home owners would have to show 12 months of payments on time and have a verifiable income source. Home owners could not take money out of their house. The result would be that the state collects the mortgage income instead of banks. A trillion dollars worth of home in California would mean a budget surplus of 40 billion (minus operational fees) PER YEAR.
Refinancing would be optional. The 125% LTV would enable those upside down to stay in their homes. The profits would not go into bankster’s profits, but into state revenue.
Bill Gross of PIMCO (most successful bond trader to date) suggested this. Also, North Dakota already has a state bank.
The virtues are people keep their house, the state gets additional revenue AND the BANKS GET FUCKED!!! The only problem is that mortgage bond holders (insurance companies etc) Hate the idea of exchanging their 7% mortgages for 4% bonds and have halted any discussion on this.