When the Senate failed to move forward on a bill repealing Don’t Ask Don’t Tell, one option for a President allegedly committed to getting rid of the law would be to stop the discharges. Helpfully, there was a court ruling finding the law discriminatory and unconstitutional, where the judge planned to file an injunction against further discharges of gay service members. The Justice Department didn’t have to appeal that ruling, and this entire business would take care of itself.
Attorneys for the Obama administration objected Thursday to a proposed worldwide injunction being considered by a California federal judge that would halt the military’s ban on openly gay troops.
Calling the possible move “untenable,” Department of Justice attorneys filed their objections in U.S. District Court in Riverside.
They said Judge Virginia Phillips, who declared the policy unconstitutional earlier this month, would be overstepping her bounds if she tried to stop it in its tracks.
Instead, she should limit any injunction to the 19,000 members of the Log Cabin Republicans, the gay rights organization that filed the lawsuit to stop enforcement of the ban, the lawyers said.
The case has put the White House in the uncomfortable position of defending a policy President Obama has said he wants repealed.
Actions speak louder than words.
It sounds like a crazy idea, that two separate classes of gay service members should be created, one with protections to enter the military under the Constitution and one without, but if there ever was an argument for every gay and lesbian American to join the Log Cabin Republicans, the Obama Administration just made it. Maybe he’s just trying to aid their membership drive.
Robert Gibbs tried to pre-empt any suggestion that this backpedaled from the President’s commitment to repeal the policy by saying this makes it more crucial that Congress act. That sounds like “Congress, we demand that you stop this thing we’re doing before we do it again!”
Really, this is another example of the President trying to protect the powers of the executive branch, specifically:
“A court should not compel the executive to implement an immediate cessation of the 17-year-old policy without regard for any effect such an abrupt change might have on the military’s operations, particularly at a time when the military is engaged in combat operations and other demanding military activities around the globe,” federal attorneys said in their objection.
Yeah, so the court should care less about the military’s operations when it rules on the military’s violation of individual civil rights. And as a co-equal branch of government, the court can do a whole lot of compelling on the executive. This brief is almost sad in how nakedly power-aggrandizing it is.
The ruling on the injunction could come as early as today.



51 Comments



Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
It was said the GWB had destroyed the Republican Party. What an irony that Barak Obama is destroying the Democratic Party.
Our “fierce advocate” in action. Don’t ever believe that it’s the dirty f*cking hippies or the Republicans that are taking down the Democrats.
This is really scurrilous behavior. The only explanation that comes to mind is there are 2 Obama agenda. One to placate the common folk with illusions and lies. The other to conduct the nation’s business as close to the Reagan Bush principles as possible. The ultimate conservative behind the curtain.
They have no choice or the generals will turn against him, more. They have to circle the wagons and grasp any last shred of institutional support in advance of the coming impeachment move.
I believe Obama has some personal homophobia issues. I get the impression he is not above telling “gay jokes” with his buddies.
On the looming impeachment I think the White House will support it in the name of bipartisanship.
I never will!
It must be another brilliant 11-dimensional chess move that those of us who perceive a merely 4-dimensional spacetime cannot possibly hope to understand.
That’s a bullsh*t excuse. Is Obama the Commander in CHIEF? Emphatically and undeniably he is. He could COMMAND. The generals would have nothing to do with any possible impeachment case, bogus or real. Clinton was impeached and he was still commander in chief.
Corporatism: absolute power corrupts absolutely. The American Dream has become the American Nightmare.
Obama’s excuse has been that he has to defend an existing law, well that law was ruled unconstitutional by Judge Phillips, what is Obama’s excuse now?
Just another reason why.
More eleventyseven dimensional chess.
New post up top…
He’s doing it with the help of fellow Blue Dogs/DLC’ers.
I hope the federal judge enjoins the military from enforcing DADT while the government’s appeal is pending. Then we can watch Obama eat his bullshit sandwich (AKA: The Awesome Fierce Advocate) as he twists slowly in the wind defending the indefensible and becomes an embarrassing sideshow in the battle for equal rights under law.
And so his inexorable march continues to become the most despised and reviled person on the planet.
Yet another reason to DUMP OBAMA!
We need an appease-o-meter. Then we could all vote on the degrees of mealy mouthed, backsliding, cowardice actions of the day. I personally can’t keep up with it. And not for lack of trying.
This type of behavior reinforces a friend’s favorite line: “if voting made a difference they’d make it illegal”.
The only hope is to hose the place out and hope that a few more years in the wilderness will shake something loose. Thirty years of dung indeed and the freshest stuff is at the top:
He’s admitted that he is opposed to gay marriage. He’s not so great on women’s reproductive issues, either. Apparently, he’s not that open-minded about sexuality.
Behold the FRAUD in Chief.
I never thought I could loath a POTUS as much or more as I detested, despised and disdained GW Bush. I think BHO just gained an edge in the neck and neck race he has going w/W for being the most disgusting and worst POTUS ever.
I won’t actually print out what I was originally going to rant, but this is the acronym JHFCOPS!!!…anyhoo, nothing, absolutely nothing about Obamco failing to keep, breaking, pissing on a campaign promise surprises me anymore.
Mr President, a few words please: If you’re such a “Fierce Advocate” for the rights of the LGBT community, the poor, the disadvantaged, and the middle class as you claim to be, GET OFF YOUR ASS AND DO SOMETHING! Sign a stop loss order or two, tell your DOJ to put this issue on the backburner, fight for a health plan that isn’t a bailout to a corrupt industry, start some fraud investigations on your Wall Street buddies ,(it’s not like they’re throwing money at you anyway). Make a fucking speech- it’s the only thing you’re supposedly good at anyway.
And you have the gall to question the people who knocked on doors and made phone calls for you, who gave money they didn’t have to you, who prayed and “hoped” that you would bring the change you promised. And you have blocked that change, not by your words, but by every action you’ve taken since elected to the office you are no longer fit to hold.
I’ve got two words left for you, and they ain’t “Fierce Advocate”.
I’m right there with ya, OIG. But if Shrub is forever known as “Worst. President. Ever”, what do we call Obama?… “Worst. President. Ever. II?”
Just more proof that every president from Reagan on is the exact same guy, who does what the corporate fascists who actually run this country tell him to do.
“The case has put the White House in the uncomfortable position of defending a policy President Obama has said he wants repealed.”
Yeah, he SAYS he wants it repealed.
Even. More. Worser. President???
Like many, I had doubts about BHO all along (not my first, second or even 3rd choice, quite honestly), so I never felt he’d do everything he said during the campaign. But by Spring of 2009 I stopped “believing” absolutely anything Obama SAID. It seems to me that, something like 99%, of what Obama “says” never happens; you can almost count on the opposite of what Obama says happening.
So the eleventy dimensional chess is also being played in a mirror…
this was a gimme, well, a gimme for an administration not truly opposed to repeal –
absolutely nowhere for them to hide here
effin tragic
not bad…that definitely has a certain panache to it.
They said Judge Virginia Phillips, who declared the policy unconstitutional earlier this month, would be overstepping her bounds if she tried to stop it in its tracks.
Instead, she should limit any injunction to the 19,000 members of the Log Cabin Republicans, the gay rights organization that filed the lawsuit to stop enforcement of the ban, the lawyers said.
OK Brown, your kids can go to a desegregated school. Anyone else who wants that can file their own damn suit against the Board of Education.
The DOJ response to the injunction is SOP for any suit brought against US legislation. Its there job. So lets not get our pee hot. What they do when the judge makes her next ruling is when the rubber hits the road.
Naturally most who make comments on this site, Ms TeeVee Hamsher, and the contributors just get woodies when they can bash the Obama White House. Nothing new here.
The more and more and more we get exposed to the Obama chimpy-bush-wannabees the less and less we see of ANYONE taking up a mantle of bold decisions, bold actions or bold new programs… This is kick the can down the road at it’s best..
These people have turned out to be absolutely spineless..
Brilliant, beowulf…brilliant.
Thank you for being a shinning light in a rather dark place. Many of these comments are not thought out very well or not at all. I find that your comments are mostly on the mark.
Nothing new
herefrom Obama either.He can easily make an exec order to stop loss all the troops discharged on DADT… Shrub Jr. never hesitated to scribble his name on an exec order to stop loss anyone – unless they were gay.
Obama’s words…plenty of hot air.
Obama’s actions…crickets.
Lame.
“GET OFF YOUR ASS AND DO SOMETHING!”
EVEN IF IT IS WRONG!!
I’m betting that “most who make comments on this site” know the difference between “there” and “their”.
The Best Con Artist Ever?
Well said, unfortunately.
Never thought I’d see a Democratic administration do anything to boost membership in a GOP club. What a bunch of stooges these people are.
Just issue the fucking stop-loss order, and be done with the whole thing until the study is complete. Stop ruining lives every single day, Obama. You have the power: for once, please use it.
The real Barack Obama made himself quite clear to the booing crowd of AIDS and DADT protesters at the Dems NYC fundraiser when he tried to get them to focus on the upcoming election instead of the “Broken Promises” their signs tried to draw his attention to.
As all his other spokesmen/cronies have been doing, including Ed Rendell, instead of trying to sooth their worries he chose to take the Rahm Emanuel Method. He dared/threatened the protesters with Rahm Emanuels’ favorite tool – fearmongering. Bringing back from the dead what Howard Dean once killed, the whole gang of insiders now use threats of what Republicans will do to them if they don’t do as they are told and show up on election day. Re-elect those same cowardly Democratic Dogs responsible for blowing all those promises, or else..
We have a President who may be worse than Rahm Emanuel ever was.
Wow.
“We have met the enemy and he is us”…Walt Kelly
Obama has lost my vote. He has continued at AG to defend all of Bush’s policies, with the exception of torture, and failed to intervene when he could have made positive changes in the lives of people who are being denied US Constitutional rights on a regular basis.
I will never vote for a Republican, but I would vote for my first choice in 2008 and that was Hillary Clinton. If Obama runs again I will not vote for him sad to say. Being the least repugnant is no reason to vote in my book! And they are actually using that as a campaign slogan. How sick is that?
Does anyone know who to believe anymore? I don’t!
I don’t really disagree with your actual point.
So how do you reconcile the “Hope & Change” (& transparency) rhetoric with fact that everything the O admin does is the SOP that the executive has followed since Reagan?
(No offense to Margaret, whose comment was absolutely spot on.) What the hell are you talking about?
Deep.
I don`t understand why it is so hard for people to get this. He has never shown that he truly believes gays to be equal. He has only shown that he believes them to be inferior, even equating them to pedophiles. Just the statement that he opposes same-sex marriage is an outright denial of their status as human beings.
Maybe they get it, but can`t accept it.
Thanks, half pint. You just saved us a lot of investigative work.
One can only imagine what it must be like to have sex with this dude, and the picture ain’t purty.
Can anyone spell R.E.P.R.E.S.S.E.D?
WBTYM!
Ain’t I awful?
Heh.
Oh I don’t know, there is a huge BSMD crowd in DC, always struck me that might be just his thing.
That would be BDSM.
I don’t know how I know that. Must be from a previous life.