Yesterday, five homeowners in the state of Maine filed a class action suit against GMAC Mortgage, accusing them of filing knowingly false certifications for foreclosure, and false affadavits which back up the documents. Maine is one of the 23 states where judicial sign-off is required to move ahead with a foreclosure, and where GMAC (now Ally Financial) has suspended evictions.
In depositions of GMAC/Ally officials as well as those at top mortgage lenders across the country, employees have admitted that they do not spend any time verifying the accuracy of the foreclosure documents, and often use a “robo-signer” who looks at the materials for less than 30 seconds and signs up to 10,000 affadavits a month.
The lawsuit alleges that thousands of Maine homeowners have lost their homes unfairly due to judgments based on false documents, and that most of them had no attorney operating in their defense. GMAC has been sanctioned in a Maine court for their “high-volume and careless approach to affidavit signing.” Local attorneys, along with the offices of Maine Attorneys Saving Homes, the National Consumer Law Center and the Center for Responsible Lending are working on the case.
Bank of America, the largest holder of mortgages in the country, yesterday admitted to this practice and suspended foreclosure processes while they review the documents. They plan to “amend all affidavits in foreclosure cases that have not yet gone to judgment,” a process that could take months or even years. Citi and Wells Fargo, the only major lenders which have not slowed their foreclosures yet, have defended their documentation actions, with Wells Fargo standing by the accuracy of their affadavits. If all lenders eventually submit to review, it could put on hold the future of 4.37 million households either in foreclosure or severe delinquency.
The lenders often just service the loans, without owning the title. Private investment pools or even the government, in the form of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, often own the homes. Sometimes the owner cannot be determined because of securitization and sloppy processes during the housing bubble, leading to foreclosures by servicers who cannot establish ownership.
Connecticut, a judicial foreclosure state, has suspended all foreclosures for 60 days while the Attorney General investigates. California, a non-judicial state, has asked GMAC/Ally and JPMorgan Chase, another lender reviewing their documents, to halt their foreclosure operations. Asm. Ted Lieu, the state legislator who wrote the law that requires lenders in California to try to contact borrowers and document the outcome before any foreclosure, said yesterday that the state should call for a foreclosure moratorium.




38 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I can see it’s going to be a real mess with no one winning (except the attorneys). I’ll going around back and clean my guns and count my gold.
I’m glad I don’t have a mortgage.
Beyond shocking.
Great thanks to FDL’s Cynthia Kouril and David Dayen for early and persistent writing on this scandal.
Wow. I know I said that the class action tobacco litigations were going to end up being the model for how this will get sorted out, but I am shocked (in a good way) that it’s happening SOOOOOOO fast.
Doing the happy dance
The plaintiffs absolutely MUST add the collection attorneys as additional defendants, for suborning perjury and malicious prosecution on a grand scale. Those scumbags will settle fast – to keep their bar licenses intact – which will provide funding to go hard after the deep-pocket banks. I guarantee they were filing suit without ever seeing the original mortgage or promissory notes.
What ever happened to “Due Diligence” in big business. It was always part and parcel to all business transactions when I was in the Corporate world!!! Seems St Ronnie’s philosophy of greed has completely taken hold of Corporate America at all levels. Greed is their God! The little people be damned, big money walks, the little guys get trampled! Hopefully a few of thee shysters go to jail for falsifying court documents at the very least!!!!
The Media is implying that banks have halted foreclosures because of their own benevolence and on account of political pressure.
The banks are suspending foreclousures because they are getting effectively countersued.
.
Wells states: “We will stand by our affidavits and, if we find an error, we will take the appropriate corrective action.”
In other words, “let’s assume this posture for public consumption, and maybe the whole thing will blow over before we have to open our own books.”
I’m going to go ahead and take a wild-ass guess that foreclosures done by Wells and Citi are every bit as suspect as GMAC, BofA and other bank behemoths. Sooner or later, they’re going to have to drag their crap out, too. So let the class actions begin.
Speaking of banks, here’s the latest and greatest from the FDIC.
Well well. It seems the banks are in a pickle. They can’t collect and they can’t foreclose. Ha Ha Ha!! SCUMBAGS!
Imagine what would happen if I drew up fraudulent but official looking documents that deprived someone of their property. I would go to prison of course. These people on the other hand get invited to box seats at sporting events and golf outings with congress critters.
As for GMAC, for decades they have been notorious for agreeing to a payment schedule for automobiles when the owner falls on hard times, only to repossess the car anyway. I knew they were going to be no different when they got involved in mortgages. Anybody who does business with them is a fool.
Oh, how I would love to see this balloon into the great and scandalous downfall of the “too big to fail” banks and their sleazy cousins in the financial/credit industries! I know that is unlikely when they’ve got Washington DC totally in their pockets but one can dream and wish.
Ian Welsh, in his latest post, “A Republic of Men, Not Laws”, has this to say about the fraudulent foreclosures:
Yup, Ian. It was all predictable.
I’ve had a fixed rate GMAC Mortgage for ten years, but I didn’t pick them. GMAC bought my mortgage from another company. Haven’t had any issues with them, thus far, but I’ve been lucky enough, thus far, to have been able to make my payments on time.
They’re all pirates.
Apparently we don’t have a functioning DOJ. There should have been several perp walks on wall street by now.
Since they decided there was no ‘crime’ at AIG, no crimes in the lead up to war, and no one busted for bringing the economy of the world to implosion, I’m sure they will keep busy busting people for getting their internets free or file sharing.
As dispicable as BofA is, they were compelled to absorb Country Wide who was at the root of the sub prime mortgage fraud, but I agree these guys are feeling heat, sadly it isn’t from law enforcement.
I totally agree with PricillaQOB
What the majority of the public probably fails to grasp yet is to what extent this will prevent the huge backlog of already-foreclosed properties (the “shadow inventory”) from being liquidated, resulting in ever-more downward pressure on house prices…
link to Ian Welsh post.
Cynthia, is there some “get out of jail free” card Congress can pass to derail the litigation and bail out of the banks once again on our dime?
Hi David, good post; you’ve been doing a lot of good work here. I’ve also seen that some neighborhoods in Minnesota are pushing back against the mmortgage lenders on foreclosures.
OT – is anyone wathcihg the One Nation rally in DC today? I’ve been watching it live stream on ourfuture.org. Harry Belafonte just gave a tremenous speech. Such a great advocate for human rights, he is.
the elephant in the room, notice my bold
10,000 frigging forclosures a month from one bank, you might have thought that amount of loans would be enough for a generations worth of business
In 1999, as congress was about to pass the Gramm-Leach-Bliley (Rubin-Summers) Financial Services Modernization Act ” Michigan Democratic Rep. John Dingell, in a speech on the floor of the House, warned that his colleagues were passing a bill “written in the dark of night, without any real awareness on the part of most of what it contains.” Dingell said the law was creating a group of institutions which will not just be “big banks” but “big everything.”
“And under this legislation, the whole of the regulatory structure is so obfuscated and so confused that liability in one area is going to fall over into liability in the next,” he continued. “You are going to find that they [financial institutions] are too big to fail, so the Fed is going to be in and other federal agencies are going to be in to bail them out. Just expect that.”
http://www.publicintegrity.org/investigations/economic_meltdown/articles/entry/1306/
I wouldn’t start dancing just yet.
What? You don’t think criminals should be made to pay for their crimes? And yes, fraud committed by banks is as much a crime as any other fraud, no matter how much you may wish it to be otherwise
I confess when this mess broke big time last week I was only moderately interested. With no mortgage and no connection to any of this I was just a bystander. But then this morning a light went on in my head. I do believe there is money to be made in all of this. Now I am very interested in all of this.
One thing for sure. This will be the final straw that will basically destroy the US economy. But then I’ve been betting against our economy since 2007.
Bon Appetit.
I just don’t think the politicians will let the banks suffer too terribly much. Do you?
As for the law, that’s never gotten in the way before.
The banks probably won’t have to suffer too much until the pols realize that they’d better jump on the train as it is leaving the station.
Just like they did with the tobacco companies. The pols will fight it until they realize it can mean money back to the government finally and that it is both popular and expedient then they will all try to grandstand how they led the fight to fight the crooks.
Foreclosures VIA DECEPTIVE and FRAUDULENT proceedings enables repetitive, and illegal property flipping; it enables lenders to falsify IRS form 1099-A’’s; it enables unscrupulous foreclosure mill lawyers (especially because of judges who purposefully abet deceit) to deceptively hold auctions and make insider bids to acquire those properties; and blighted neighborhoods. Fraudulent foreclosures ensure the success of FABRICATED BANKRUPTCY COURT ‘Lift Stay motions’ and false ‘Proof of Claims’.
Foreclosure via fraud is the reason for illegitimate homelessness and underhanded evictions, unjustified IRS tax bills due to false 1099-A’s, and unfair “Deficiency Judgments.” Ironically, some people who express their anger at “deadbeats” appear to be more acceptable about the manifest fraud and criminal activity being carried out by people with credentials to practice law. Equally ironic is the reality that some people pretending to be annoyed about “deadbeats”are the actual people who are participating in real estate racketeering –fully sanctioned by the majority of courts, especially Bankruptcy Courts!
http://www.lawgrace.org/2010/09/30/important-facts-about-foreclosure-and-mortgage-fraud/
It’s going to be a mess.
It’s hard to imagine they will force buyers out who have bought foreclosures. People will have no certainty in their lives for years I suspect.
Sorry for those folks who bought property taken through fraudulent foreclosures but that’s pretty much what they get.
It’s why some Title insurance companies are refusing to write any title insurance for foreclosures from some of the banks
Do you really care? I mean the heartless one thinks it will be a mess OMFG! There just may be hope for ya tinman, man who is empty…shit maybe there is some feeble smidgen of a heart in there after all…
Book Salon up with David Callahan’s Fortunes of Change: The Rise of the Liberal Rich and the Remaking of America hosted by Stanley Greenberg
I understand that tarring and feathering is a descriptive Laurel and Hardy expression meaning laugh out loud public embarrassment. I’m having chicken for dinner. GMAC, you’re welcome to come to the feast.
Here in Florida things are getting quite heated and nasty:
Why Sloppy Foreclosure Process Could Ruin Florida
“Even the credibility of the state’s court system could be questioned. Pressured by legislators (who control the court system’s budget) to clear Florida’s huge foreclosure backlog, many judges employ what derisively are known as “rocket” dockets. They speed foreclosures by minimizing legal arguments. But in the name of expediency, they bend the rules governing individual property rights.”
and
“”I don’t want to say that every one of these cases is wrong and a fraud on the court, but it is a big concern for us,” J. Thomas McGrady, chief judge of the Sixth Judicial Circuit in Florida, which handles cases in Pinellas and Pasco counties, told the New York Times after GMAC’s announcement. Pinellas County alone is dealing with 33,000 cases in the foreclosure pipeline. Statewide, there are more than half a million cases.”
Gotta love the Republican-ruled Sunshine State. Modern Conservatism is coming to full fruition here.
Since Ally is 56% owned by the US gov, I guess those folks are suing themselves.
Just pay the friggin’ mortgage!
GMAC filed a foreclosure action against me on a house that I had already sold. I didn’t even know the action was going on until it was processed through the court system. I have been fighting for 3 years to get it off my credit report because it has affected me in more ways than you can imagine. They said I wasn’t paying my mortgage. I didn’t realize I had to do that after it was sold at more than $100,000 than I owed on it. Is it my fault GMAC can’t keep up with their paperwork, especially when the title company had already given the money that paid off the mortgage several months before. It was going to cost me dearly to hire a lawyer to go after them. Needless to say, I now bank with only local banks and the credit union. GMAC is horrible to deal with.
Not only that, but they are probably worried about their shareholders suing them, too.