Treasury REALLY wants to promote this idea of TARP as a success, don’t they? They released yet another report yesterday on the cost of the bailout, with the number whittled down to $29 billion.
The Treasury Department expects to lose $29 billion on the federal bailouts stemming from the financial crisis, with most of the losses in its housing finance program and the auto rescue.
In a report released on Tuesday, the administration said it expected a $17 billion loss from its investments in General Motors, Chrysler and the auto finance companies, as well as a $46 billion loss from housing programs like the mortgage modification program known as the Home Affordable Modification Program.
OK, it’s time to go to the internals of this report, because the last time anyone looked at the spending on HAMP, it was the Inspector General for TARP, and he put that spending at about $500 million. And actually, the report acknowledges this. So they expect to spend $45.5 billion more in the next few years on HAMP, when the pickup for new modifications is dropping? I know that Treasury expects to pay out incentive payments to lenders over time if modifications become permanent, but that level of spending would require something close to the 4 million mods they estimated at the beginning, when the program for now looks stalled out at 400,000 permanent mods, and advocates have such poor feelings about it that they have begun to encourage their clients not to use it.
And people are quoting from this?
(Note too how they shaved off $4 billion from HAMP without anybody noticing; the expected commitment was $50 billion.)
But here’s the nut of the issue: none of this TARP outlook includes the losses that will incur on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac:
Recently, the Congressional Budget Office put the cost at $66 billion. And, after the bailout, the government will still be left with its investments in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the government-backed housing finance companies. The report said Fannie and Freddie were expected to cause “substantial losses,” but it noted that they were financed using other funds, not the troubled asset funds.
I’m trying to decipher this, or rather why it matters. Fannie and Freddie losses come as a direct result of asset purchases on toxic loans – in other words, TARP as it was originally envisioned. The banks off-loaded their crap onto the government, and we paid the price. Basically, creative accounting is making TARP look better. Incidentally, the bailouts of Fannie and Freddie are unlimited.
But don’t worry, a “substantial part” of those “substantial losses” will be offset! How substantial? This is where the report goes vague.
The Treasury Department today said it expects “to incur substantial losses” from the two government-sponsored mortgage companies, which have operated under federal control since 2008. But the administration believes a “substantial part” of these losses will be offset by income from two other areas, according to an evaluation of the Troubled Asset Relief Program it released today. (Somewhat confusingly, the government assistance to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac had nothing to do with TARP).
First, Treasury said a 2008 law that permitted it to buy $200 billion in mortgage-backed securities is bringing in “notable returns.” It wasn’t more specific.
Also, “as a result of its emergency financial programs,” money from Federal Reserve operations that is shifted to the federal budget has “increased sharply in 2009 and 2010, and they are projected to remain elevated for some time.”
This reveals the true bankruptcy of this report. The TARP cost $29 billion, and the hundreds of billions of losses in Fannie and Freddie don’t count, because the money was separate, even though it was for the exact same purpose. But don’t worry about Fannie and Freddie, because we have these unnamed “other programs” that will offset the cost in unnamed ways.
Either this entire set of emergency lending to the banks is part of a whole program, or it isn’t. You can’t slice and dice the numbers when convenient to come out with a preferable outcome.
The main take-away from these numbers is that the banks got their money very quickly, while a year and a half later, the spending to help homeowners has reached a whopping 1% of what was alloted.



15 Comments



Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Socialize the losses, privatize the profits.
It is ever thus
Creative gangster accounting/statistics 101; sign up today for online course
Thanks to David for trying to stay on top of this fast-paced shell game. Big money is disappearing through the deceptive accounting, and apparently there is no way to know that it disappeared, let alone where it went.
Meanwhile, the people this program was supposed to help are being forced out of their houses because of foreclosure fraud.
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2010/10/paging-elizbeth-warren-california-congressmen-call-for-foreclosure-probe-bank-sub-rosa-pushback-underway.html David, have you seen this? In one day they passed HR 3808 , It’s now on the President’s desk waiting for him to sign. Another sell out to banks. A redo for their fraud. I guess when the law hurts them (their pocketbooks) they just change it.
Why are we losing money we own these companies for all intents and purposes I assume we are selling our stock in these companies?
Are we selling at a loss? Why not wait a few years to sell our stock? Is the Obama budget desperate for the revenue? Can’t we at least wait until the GM Volt comes out before we sell StockMarkets like Hype.
People don’t need reporting to realize the following FIVE things that will always happen in the world in general and America in particular:
1. Wars to drain the national treasury to a chosen few defense contractors and the politicians sponsored by them (Blackwater, Haliburton, Boeing, Raytheon, etc.)
2. Bailouts to Banks to keep them on top in society and the jackboot of crushing economic pain and suffering on the necks of everyone else (Goldman Sachs, AIG, BOA, Citi-Group)
3. “AUSTERITY MEASURES” meant to keep the masses poor and powerless and therefore subject to the whims of the powerful (Cat-Food Commission to cut Social Security, cuts in social services, cutting off of unemployment insurance to 99ers, defunding public education, raising fees for passports, state issued IDs, property taxes, etc.,)
4. Grotesque and inhuman military, law enforcement, and police state security measures to quell any sense of rebellion to the status quo set by the power elite (Spying, harassing, and raiding the homes of anti war protestors without probable cause, Patriot Act, Military Commissions Act, Enemy Combatants, Extraordinary Rendention by rogue CIA, Summary executions without charge or trial via Predator Drone Attacks, police brutality at the state and local level, barbaric, Roman Colisseum style gov’t and privately run American prisons, etc.,)
5. Distracting people from all of the above national plagues by stuffing their empty heads with garbage such as reality TV, Jerry Springer, celebrity gossip that has no bearing on American life at large, and feeding them the empty promises of riches and fame beyond their own limited imaginations if only they would continue to support the corrupt, rotten, and disgraceful political, economic and social systems put in place by the rich and powerful elites of this country that are oppressing the masses in the first place.
Need any more be said about “THIRD WORLD AMERICA”????????????
Yes many of them Minority Voters who got screwed the most on Home Loans in the first place.
Masaccio has a fresh cross-post available: Official Report on Flash Crash: Nothing to See Here
C’mon Dave. What’s up with the fact checking of this TARP memo?
(BTW is this the fourth or fifth press release touting the Greatness of TARP from Geithner’s Guys in just the past week — I’m losing track?)
Look, we -the peasants- all owe Geitner, Bush II, Paulson, Bernancke and Bush III a great deal of gratitude for their magnificent leadership on the wonderfulness of TARP and the overall Banks Bailout. Sure, over $9 trillion of wealth was pissed away due to global financial fraud, ignorance and Grande Incompetence but everyone deserves a
secondthird4,301 chance(s)to make things right.So please, layoff Bush III (we have midterms in LESS than a month remember!) and just retype those neatly typed press releases and then proceed to provide your readers with a Pro-Progressive spin on the situation.
Thanks
Even if they could actually show that the banks paid back all the money, which I doubt they could, it would still have been a huge boon for the banking cartels.
Setting aside the fact that this kept some of them from going under as a business which is of immeasurable value, when I take out a loan I have to pay interest. They didnt. If I get aid in the form of unemployment insurance, I still get taxed on that as income. Did they? Oh wait, nevermind, they probably barely paid taxes in the US anyway.
this is the way capitalism works.
but hey progressives keep that love affair with capitalism going.
the capitalists are even able to con the progressives.
and the progressives dont have a clue they have become pawns of the capitalists just like the middle class repubs called tea partyers.
at least roosevelt knew who the enemy was.
obama does not have a clue.
Meanwhile,what is the congress doing ?…..it’s not like they are not aware of what is going on.
It makes no difference who is in power….ordinary Americans are screwed either way….meanwhile on your liberal cable TV(MSNBC)tonight…all the news about the crazy teabaggers,nothing about the foreclosure fraud & the harm it’s heaped upon Americans….
That’s right folks…they think we are stupid.Not cuz someone on TV uses a few key words that progressives can identify with means they care about your welfare folks…They are on TV shillin for the WH & by extension the Corporations.In their world everything is OK & Americans are just whinners.
If not for David Dayen,many of us would not be aware of the scope of this fraud….you sure as hell won’t get it from Rachel Maddow,Olberman or Ed Shultz on MSNBC,that’s how much they care.Wake up Americans.
“A Look at Treasury’s TARP Report: Banks Got Money Quickly; Homeowners Still Not Getting Help”
Yeah, that says it all. Well, except for: what a great fooking country, run by and for the entertainment and profit of organized crime.
And, how about all those billions that the Federal Reserve provided to the banking system? That is never mentioned either, even though it was much bigger than TARP.