I don’t suppose it’s a surprise that super-rich financiers and business tycoons periodically meet to determine how to best shape the world to their ends. Actually, we had that for about a minute on the liberal side, with the Democracy Alliance; it didn’t really hold up. This Kochtopus gathering seems much more robust; and the cast of characters involved certainly makes one take notice.
A secretive network of Republican donors is heading to the Palm Springs area for a long weekend in January, but it will not be to relax after a hard-fought election — it will be to plan for the next one.
Koch Industries, the longtime underwriter of libertarian causes from the Cato Institute in Washington to the ballot initiative that would suspend California’s landmark law capping greenhouse gases, is planning a confidential meeting at the Rancho Las Palmas Resort and Spa to, as an invitation says, “develop strategies to counter the most severe threats facing our free society and outline a vision of how we can foster a renewal of American free enterprise and prosperity.”
The Koch network meets twice a year to plan and expand its efforts — as the letter says, “to review strategies for combating the multitude of public policies that threaten to destroy America as we know it.”
Those efforts, the letter makes clear, include countering “climate change alarmism and the move to socialized health care,” as well as “the regulatory assault on energy,” and making donations to higher education and philanthropic organizations to advance the Koch agenda.
As it happens, they held the last one of these meetings in Aspen, where participants, including top hedge fund executives and major CEOs like Phil Anschutz, Steve Bechtel, Amway’s Rich DeVos, and Home Depot’s Kenneth Langone… watched Glenn Beck give a presentation called “Is America on the Road to Serfdom?” Beck has apparently addressed this Teddy Bear’s Picnic more than once.
Think Progress has more.
ThinkProgress has obtained a memo outlining the details of the last Koch gathering held in June of this year. The memo, along with an attendee list of about 210 people, shows the titans of industry — from health insurance companies, oil executives, Wall Street investors, and real estate tycoons — working together with conservative journalists and Republican operatives to plan the 2010 election, as well as ongoing conservative efforts through 2012 [...]
• Corporate “investors” at the Koch meeting included businesses with a strong profit motive in rolling back President Obama’s enacted reforms. Several companies impacted by health reform, including Allan Hubbard of A & E Industries, a manufacturer of medical devices and Judson Green, a board member of health insurance conglomerate Aon, were present at the meeting. Other businessmen at the meeting, like Omaha Burger King franchiser Mike Simmonds, are owners of fast food stores which have fought efforts to provide health insurance to their employees. Many corporate attendees of the meeting represent the financial industry impacted by Wall Street reform. For instance, attendee Bill Cooper is the CEO of TCF Financial, a corporation involved in the mortgage banking industry. Cooper recently filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Wall Street reform. Other financial industry players in the meeting hail from firms ranging from Bank of America, JLM Investment, Allied Capital Corp, AMG National Trust, the Blackstone Group and Citadel Investment. Annie Dickerson, a representative of Paul Singer, a powerful hedge fund manager who also gives tens of millions to Republican causes, was present. In addition, Koch Industries itself has a hedge fund and other financial derivative products in its portfolio of interests, which include oil pipelines, coal shipping, asphalt, refineries, consumer goods, timber, ranching, and chemicals.
• Fred Malek, Karl Rove’s top fundraiser for his $56 million attack ad campaign against Democrats, attended the meeting, along with leaders of other secret attack groups. Heather Higgins, who leads the Independent Women’s Forum, a shadowy group that has spent millions of dollars in attack ads on health reform, attended the meeting. So did Gretchen Hamel, a former Bush flak who now runs an attack ad group called “Public Notice,” which denounces spending programs.
The full memo is here, and there’s a full list of attendees at the link. These events are not just about campaign spending, although hundreds of millions have been thrown at that in what some have called as big a scandal as Watergate. But the Koch brothers’ aims aren’t so low. They have been and will continue to try and shape the dominant political culture – to make it more corporate-friendly, more conservative, and more solicitous of their ideas. From the media to Congress, their goal is to ensure a full airing of their messages and a locking out of anyone else’s. They don’t play a game of election to election; they play a longer game. And even when their politicians fail and the Democrats get into power, they feel they can still win even when losing. The trajectory of what passes for “progressive” and “conservative” in the last 30 years should prove their success.





74 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I wrote about this a long time ago and we should have been focusing in on these maggots from the very beginning;
the koch brohers are the real force behind the right wing, they are responsible for rush, krystol, right wing think tanks and the libertarian movement
the real force behind the right wing
back then I linked and wrote;
they have FINALLY gotten some of the attention their insidious behavior should have gotten long ago but the koch brothers are the death of America as we knew it, as we know it
it doesn’t get better from here, they have achieved their goals beyond their wildest imagination and they won’t stop there either
the worst is yet to be seen
I’m surprised that the Lake’s wealth of posters have yet to express themselves. However, I will!
For these past ten years, I have managed to survive and prosper the Era of Incompetence ushered in by both Bush and Cheney. And to this extent, I think that should the ‘base’ begin advocating for the demise of the AUMF Resolution. If so, the Democratic Ship of State can be ‘moved’ into the calm waters that is our collective Future.
In the meantime, I will continue to remain exasperated and frustrated with my fellow Demorats, or until My Folks, the Native Americans and Chicanos, gain the ownership of both the Republican and Democratic Parties. To wit, the Egalitarian Party of the Right and the Egalitarian Party of the Left, will put all the arch-conservatives into the arena for America’s “new” Documented Immgrant” status, pending their departure for Canada and their new Canadian Citizship Sytemic that we, the taxpayers will gladly pay for. And of course, the Koch Brothers, et al, will fight this Systemic with both hammer and tong.
So, “bring it!”
Jaango
“• Corporate “investors” at the Koch meeting included businesses with a strong profit motive in rolling back President Obama’s enacted reforms. Several companies impacted by health reform, including Allan Hubbard of A & E Industries, a manufacturer of medical devices and Judson Green, a board member of health insurance conglomerate Aon, were present at the meeting. Other businessmen at the meeting, like Omaha Burger King franchiser Mike Simmonds, are owners of fast food stores which have fought efforts to provide health insurance to their employees. Many corporate attendees of the meeting represent the financial industry impacted by Wall Street reform. For instance, attendee Bill Cooper is the CEO of TCF Financial, a corporation involved in the mortgage banking industry. Cooper recently filed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of Wall Street reform. Other financial industry players in the meeting hail from firms ranging from Bank of America, JLM Investment, Allied Capital Corp, AMG National Trust, the Blackstone Group and Citadel Investment. Annie Dickerson, a representative of Paul Singer, a powerful hedge fund manager who also gives tens of millions to Republican causes, was present. In addition, Koch Industries itself has a hedge fund and other financial derivative products in its portfolio of interests, which include oil pipelines, coal shipping, asphalt, refineries, consumer goods, timber, ranching, and chemicals.”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Liberty_League
“The American Liberty League was an American political organization formed in 1934 by conservative Democrats to oppose the New Deal of Franklin Roosevelt and other liberal Democrats. Jouett Shouse, a prominent Democrat, was the League’s president. Other leaders included prominent Democrats and businessmen, such as Al Smith (the 1928 Democratic presidential nominee), John W. Davis (the 1924 Democratic presidential nominee), and John Jacob Raskob (former Democratic National Chairman and the foremost opponent of prohibition), Dean Acheson (future Secretary of State under Harry Truman) and Bainbridge Colby, a former secretary of state. It attracted many industrialists.[1]”
Attacked
“The League came under heavy attack from the Left. In 1934 General Smedley Butler, a well-known speaker at left-wing events who often denounced bankers, claimed the League was plotting to overthrow the government and wanted Butler to lead the coup; he never was in contact with anyone from the League and offered no evidence to support his claims.[4] Roosevelt’s campaign manager accused the Liberty League of being an “ally of the Republican National Committee” which would “squeeze the worker dry in his old age and cast him like an orange rind into the refuse pail.”[5]”
Deja Vu!!
I read about this meeting and I have only two questions:
a) Weren’t we told that we’re all conspiracy kooks when we raised warnings about things like the Bilderberg Group, the Tri-Lateral Commission, and the Council on Foreign Relations?
b) This is a four-day event. How will Obama possibly clear four days of his calendar to meet with his bosses?
We can’t sit back any longer and allow the likes of Koch Industries to decide what is best for us. We can plan our own direction!
I’ve had enough of the corporate elite running everything in this country.
heh, heh. Yep and he won’t need to be there. They will come back with their decisions and give him a wad of money and say, “Do it”.
This thread and many other posts like this are so fucking wrong and self defeating, it boggles.
CLASS WARFARE! – that’s all you need to know. Continuously splitting it into some left/ right paradigm, is making FDL seem like it’s been bought by the MOTU.
The American people are being herded into servitude by extraction of wealth through interest on the one side and rent on the other. Let’s stop being suckers, please!!!
OT: Just heard the 9th Circuit issued a stay on the suspension of DADT. Anyone have any further details?
North Carolina’s contributing members to this shindig were:
Robin Hayes, the guy Larry Kissell beat in 2008. A scion of the Cannon towel family, he moved all of the jobs in his plants offshore by selling them to other companies. Last owner, which shut them down, were PillowTex. Kissell lost his job as a result of Hayes’s action, which was one of his motives in running for Congress.
Bob Luddy, owner of Captive Aire, a manufacturer of commercial kitchen ventilation equipment with plants in Muscogee OK, West Union IA, and Youngsville NC (a small town north of Raleigh). He is a member of the Advisory Board of the Foundation for Ethics in Public Service. This year he has contributed to Mike Pence, John Thune, Portman, Nevada Republican Central Committee, National Restaurant Association PAC, Patrick McHenry, Virginia Foxx, Jim DeMint, and Richard Burr.
Art Pope, owner of Variety Wholesalers and director of Americans for Prosperity, the Tea Party astroturf organization. He is founder of the big-tobacco funded John Locke Foundation. He is a director of the Atlas Economic Research Foundation, which funded the following:
* Fraser Institute
* Manhattan Institute for Policy Research
* Pacific Research Institute
* National Center for Policy Analysis
* Center for the Dissemination of Economic Information in Venezuela
* Centre for Independent Studies
* Adam Smith Institute
* Hispanic American Center for Economic Research
* Acton Institute
* African Research Institute for Public Policy and Market Process in Kenya
* Free Market Center, Belgrade, Serbia
* Civic Institute in Prague
* Centre for Civil Society
* Circle of Tradition and Progress, London
* Liberty Institute, New Delhi
* Liberty Institute, Romania
* Unirule, Beijing
* State Policy Network
* International Policy Network
* Institute for Economic Affairs
The Atlas Economic Research Foundation’s funding comes from corporate and institutional sources. During 2002, $193,500 of the organisation’s funding came from the Earhart Foundation, $100,000 from the Sarah Scaife Foundation, and $50,000 from the Carthage Foundation. The Earhart Foundation has given more than $1m since 1995. The Earhart Foundation is one that gave Dinesh D’Souza his start.
Because of all of his front groups, Art Pope is referred to in NC progressive media as the “puppetmaster”.
Staff are not invited.
Do you have a plan? Financing for your plan?
This help?
Here’s another post.
how involved are scalia and thomas with this?
Thomas isn’t involved cause Ginny won’t let him out of the house.
So, will FDL be organizing massive protests outside this event?
Let’s see, the bad, bad Republicans fund all these bad, bad groups which manage to pervert all this goody good legislation the Dem’s come up with. Thereupon the Dem’s sign whatever perverted legislation into law.
hmmm…..
LOL. Good one.
You know that you are just enabling, don’t you? Not saying you shouldn’t. But. That prolly took you 3 minutes, for both links. What has this site turned into?
How about you organize one? Not snark at all.
Between Blogger, WordPress, Googledocs and Google Earth, all free by the way, as well as complete pimpage available via The Seminal you could do such a thing your self.
And why demand something of someone else that you won’t do yourself?
Huh?
Anybody know how to ***edited in Moderation*** on this resort?
***Mod Note: Please, no violent references***
Obama has not enacted any policies that would negatively impact Koch Industries.
Obama killed EFCA; Obama loves big oil and mountaintop removal. He also loves “clean coal” and Nuclear power. Obama hates wind and solar and he hates electric cars. Obama hates solar panels on the rooftops of American homes and businesses. Obama supports tax cuts for the rich and austerity measures for the rest of us.
The Koch heads are meeting to insure that things continue to roll the way they have for the past 40 years – in favor of big business and industry at the expense of the citizenry.
Soon, no Americans will be able to afford to buy Koch Products. In that regard, the Conservatives have fucked themselves.
No wonder they love globalization. They can manufacture overseas and sell products to overseas customers.
i’m looking forward to taibbi’s book; there’s an excerpt of it at rolling stone about how states are selling off their infrastructure to middle eastern sovereign wealth funds to cover budget shortfalls. so that toll bridge/parking meter/highway you’ve been driving on is gonna get a lot more expensive in the years to come. and there’s not a damn thing you can do about it.
“I was in a meeting where a bunch of American investment bankers were trying to sell us the Pennsylvania Turnpike,” he said. “They even had a slide show. They were showing these Arabs what a nice highway we had for sale, what the toll booths looked like . . .”
I dropped my fork. “The Pennsylvania Turnpike is for sale?”
http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/17390/222206
List the Democrats who attended.
There were none from North Carolina.
I was saying that it prolly didn’t take you very long to find some google links to answer that person’s questions. What do you mean “huh”? I thought I spelled it out. Honey?
On edit, you know what enable-ing means, I’m sure. :)
Please; no suggestions of violence.
Read my conclusion. No Dems need to attend, they merely need to enable the Kleptocrat cooked assault to become law. And, that’s precisely what has been happening since Clinton and the Third Way replaced FDR Democrats ideals.
Republicans and Blue Dogs and New Dems must continue to sandbag Public Transportation (especially rail) so their wealthy foreign donors can rip us off on tolls (after they buy the roads).
It is already happening.
I believe the question may be whether FDL, certainly brainy and well intentioned, can brainstorm a way to an approach that might help America from becoming a third world country.
Being gay in a developed intolerant country is bad enough, it’s usually far worse in an underdeveloped one.
I believe that enlightened economic policies would result in enlightened social policies.
Marcy here wrote the Road to Neo Feudalism almost a year ago.
The FDL front pagers are writing/have written a bunch about this stuff, including this very thread.
Why people gripe that they’re not, baffles me.
I hope Fred did some counting for the Kochs at their shindig.
Jew-counting. It’s what Fred’s famous for, all the way back to Dick Nixon.
lol, LOL! No I have no plan to finance it. I have no finances that not tied up in HUGE fees and penalties if I withdraw it. I’m hanging on by a thread here.
Actually, we have a great think tank right here at FDL and we can meet in our neighborhoods on a local level. We just need to get a blank template together for each neighborhood group to fill in. I don’t know. I’m very well trained in several different areas, but not this. I guess we could do a strategy similar to 50 state, just on a more personal level.
eCHAN, sorry to be so slow to respond. I was down below trying to help out another pup.
Jew-coutning? OMG!!!!
Me? Hey, I’ve been active in local (small city) politics and I’d love to, only a few problems:
a) Got no money to get the demonstration permits, the insurance, pay for the lawyers, and all that shit. Hell, if I did organize it, I couldn’t afford to attend. I couldn’t afford a motel room in Palm Springs during the winter “high season”. (Or the off-season, for that matter.)
b) Barely techie enough to compose a reply to a post. Have no idea what Blogger, WordPress, or GooglePress are, or how to use them. (Have used GoogleEarth, but that’s a passive, no-brainer. Type in location, get your answer.) Would probably be hard pressed to get through the procedures, whatever they are, to post something at the Seminal. Hell, until a few months ago I didn’t know how to post a link. Have no clue how to establish or maintain a blog, and couldn’t afford the cost if I did. I still don’t know how to post a photo or artwork, any of that shit. I don’t text or Twitter, my cell phone does one thing: takes and sends calls, and sometimes I’m lucky to get that accomplished!
c) Who would bother to attend? Who would follow somebody they knew nothing about, with no name value, no credits or pedigree? Why would anybody with a name be willing to appear, when they could just as easily do their own protest and get all the media attention, donations, etc?
Maybe if I’d started years ago, taken all the techie courses, and made a name for myself like Jane, Digby, etc., it would be an entirely different story.
Thanks for a better explanation of what you meant. That dynamic of Democrats supporting the policies of the plutocrats has gone on for a very long time. The Democrats who passed FDR’s legislation (and the Republicans who joined them) are a big exception to the trend. The Democratic Party when Scoop Jackson and Mendel Rivers controlled the Armed Services Committees was no better than today and actually worse.
It’s a thorny problem that only a long-term effort like the progressive, labor, and civil rights movements of the first half of the 20th century accomplished. And the pressure has to be maintained over time; one victory is not the end of the war.
But what we see with Koch’s effort is not trusting Democrats to do their bidding and not trusting establishment Republicans to do their bidding, they are upping the ante by intensifying the propaganda and astroturfing to put pressure on Congress to stay in line. If that doesn’t work, they most likely will be running for office themselves.
Building a popular movement that can cohere in the face of the barrage of propaganda and eventual intimidation is hard work. It is instructive to study how Gandhi, Walesa, and Havel did it. This is the promise of the blogosphere if we can successfully use it. The sort of leadership that the Koch folks present depends immensely on having followers among the public; that’s what Limbaugh and Beck are out to do. Break the enthrallment of the mantra “liberty, liberty, liberty” and the plutocrats lose power. Their idea of liberty is definitely Orwellian.
This firedoglake is too much outrider and alienated from the Birch-right to ask the Friars Koch if our best bloggers could attend and live blog the event, huh.
Lets not forget DeVos’s kid..the ex of Blackwater..Libs had better put on the ‘raincoats’ because these guys are very serious..They have the Supremes behind them and they mean buiness.
Kelly,
It’s not the griping about information, there is plenty here @ FDL, and it’s all good as long as it remains within the parameters of established, albeit left, thought.
I think that some people are getting a bit more distraught about the rolling coup that appears ever more certain to cast the US into socioeconomic turmoil. They want to feel that their intellectual peers are not only evaluating the information, but actually organizing a bulwark against the implementation of a Neofeudal rentier society, with two sets of law.
The question then is, whether any discussion, independent of current events, could take place that would have as its goal movement support (building)?
That answer is YES; CA Prop 19.
Getting a huge state past that hurdle would start the process of removing a big block of power from the State. Free a bunch of future prisoners. Deny police-power interests money and prestige.
Make 10 calls.
Walesa, Ghand, Havel, etc. seem to have had one thing going for them: No internet!
Now, that we have the internet, instead of it becoming an organizing tool, it has engendered a kibitzing, Kaffee Klatch parlor type mentality, where everyone who signs a petitions feels like a self satisfied revolutionary who has done his/her part.
Left leaning organizations, for instance, propose remedies, offer petition drives, but have no vibrant, a la FDL, blog where ideas for action could be generated. Everyone seems to have their little comfortable niche and thus the ‘movement’ is fractured and impotent.
The only energy and militancy is currently on the right, and should another black swan land on our heads, they will be the ones to take the reins, – not the Left.
Maybe but doubtful. CA Prop 19 – notwithstanding all the good that would follow its passage – is mostly Libertarianism. The State should be more powerful than it is, as long as We (the People) are the State.
At the moment where a whole slew of sidelined economists, and financial professionals, are entertaining a scenario that could cast the US into a generational depression, 20% plus chronic unemployment, the end of a viable social safety net, etc. The notion that Prop 19, is a doorway to a anti kleptocratic Plutocracy movement, misses, imo, the enormity of the problem confronting 95% of wage earning Americans. High interests, rent, and a tollbooth economy is the problem. All else, at this point, pales in significance.
Rich deVos is a scummy, wrinkly old little prick who made his money on a fucking pyramid scheme. And the douchebag politicians here in this town wanted to prove that we’re a real city so they built him a zillion dollar arena when he threatened to move his basketball team.
what’s a tollbooth economy? soundds like a great phrase that i’m going to use all the time once i find out what it means.
well, there’s that. and we got no money.
You do know that they are demonstrating in France because they say they do not want to end up like the U.S..
The Latest in Junk Economics
The Toll Booth Economy
By MICHAEL HUDSON
http://www.counterpunch.org/hudson05202009.html
Also 9 minutes that puts our plight into perspective:
http://www.youtube.com/user/councilonsper?feature=mhw5#p/a/f/1/3pwAFohWBL4
You don’t believe in your heart that our society will become primitive like in those Road Warrior horrorshows, do you? When the collapse comes, when the fear has real taste and displaces the current (and never-ending) apocalyptic anxiety, it won’t take much more than about 18 months to reach full recovery – if we’re willing to give up taking a shower every day and things like that. We’ve plenty of land and plenty of space and room to grow and make everything we used to grow and make. Policy and politics have failed us, we’ve failed at them, and it’s time to grow up and face that.
A young demonstrator was asked by a BBC journo., why all this ruckus about 2 years slapped onto the retirement age. Her answer was something like; we’ll agree to 2 years today, and they’ll be coming back for more in due time, – that’s how they roll, and we know that.
I’m sure they’ll enjoy this diddy at the Koch Coup Clatch.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bs5bnVoZK4Q
We stopped being citizens and became consumers instead, thanks to TV. Is that debatable? Is it debatable that we stopped being a society and instead became an economy?
OMFG! Creepy!
That’ll be easy in a country with over 200 million firearms.
Good thing Glen Beck or Rush Limbaugh or Hannity can’t sing.
I don’t believe in the Thunder Dome scenario. Neither do I believe in a 18 months full recovery one, because the PTB will resist, with all their might and in unison.
One thing that amazes me is the way the ‘Left’, upon hearing slogans emanating from the Right, like: Judicial Activism, repealing the 17th Amendment, abolishing the Federal Reserve Act, knee jerks into an outright defensive posture. If the wing nuts want it, it must be bad.
This is Divide and Conquer in action.
Ha! You probably won’t believe this, but it’s true: I used to counsel parents of latchkey kids, and the latchkey kids themselves, if the kid answers the phone and a stranger asks “Is your mom home?” to answer ‘Yes, but she’s in the shower cleaning her gun’.
Has anyone been to a large ‘Bagger rally?
I read somewhere that the repugnant signage is no more than 10% and that much of the rest constitutes legitimate grievances, many of which the Left would also support, were they to demonstrate using their own.
Heartwarming.
Not really, but thanks : )
Sorry for the tardy reply, I got called away. I was hoping the court might have said more, but I guess we are stuck in “the wheels of justice turn slowly” purgatory…
Leftists in the U.S. don’t demonstrate. We blog.
Ah, the second one is much better! Thanks again!
Worse, the Left ‘progressives’ support neoliberalism.
fuck yeah, fuckno! Bring it.
AitchD@53: That’s exactly it. Notice how accustomed we’ve become to pols talking about “consumer protection” and “tax-payer rights,” as if we’re nothing but appetites on two legs, the sole purpose of which it to be delivered to the slaughterhouse of the highest campai9gn contributor.
The missing word? Citizen. We don’t need no stinking “consumer’ protection, that just makes us build our own slaughterhouses. We need sovereign protection, to assert our sovereign rights.
The French take to their politics like their soccer. Us? We watch it on pay-per-view. We’ve absolutely got to overcome this inertia.
I’m encouraged by knowing this. However large the ship or small the sailor, if you stand on the dock and lean on that baby, she’ll move. Although it looks like an immovable object that would demand an irresistible force, that’s only if you’re looking on it from the outside, in old-fashioned Newtonian terms of leverage uber alles.
Real revolutionaries do it from within. ; }
Excellent video from Michael Hudson
Word!
Must. repress. urge. to. overformat.
Why is the “OBGY” so intent on killing in the name of empire? – I know it’s about equal rights, but it sucks big time, since, by definition, Empire does not respect such rights.
OBGY? I don’t know that one…
“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable” -JFK.
Those here clamoring for some organizing at FDL, when advocating for demonstrations and protests are often regarded and censored, for appearing to agitate for a revolution. Nothing could be farther from the truth.
One must be very politically correct here.
I believe that was Bushspeak for LGBT.
thanks, man
Thanks for a good link.
As long as we maintain import-export imbalances to continue with only one country maintaining the super surpluses every quarter with every conceivable advantages they can think of and internally diminished form of progressive taxation with top 1% paying little or no taxes, a truth validated by worlds second richest person this trend in the article will simply accelarate in the coming quarters with no sign of unemployment waning.