This happened late last week, and the biggest thing I want to know about it is how Pennsylvania snagged the coveted attorneygeneral.gov URL, but I should give it some attention here. Basically, all of the scumminess associated with foreclosure processes is also present in debt collection, by a factor of ten. This is almost unbelievable:
Attorney General Tom Corbett today announced that a consumer protection lawsuit has been filed against an Erie debt collection company accused of using deceptive tactics to mislead, confuse or coerce consumers – including the use of bogus “hearings” allegedly held in a company office that was decorated to look like a courtroom.
Corbett said the civil lawsuit was filed by the Attorney General’s Bureau of Consumer Protection against Unicredit America Inc., with corporate and business offices located at 1537 West 39th St., Erie, also identified as the “Unicredit Debt Resolution Center.”
“This is an unconscionable attempt to use fake court proceedings to deceive, mislead or frighten consumers into making payments or surrendering valuables to Unicredit without following lawful procedures for debt collection,” Corbett said. “Consumers also allegedly received dubious ‘hearing notices’ and letters – often hand-delivered by individuals who appear to be Sheriff Deputies – which implied they would be taken into custody by the Sheriff if they failed to appear at the phony court for ‘hearings’ or ‘depositions’.”
It’s unconscionable, but sadly a part of the new fabric of America, that debt collectors managed to pull off this scam for so long, inventing fake courtrooms, fake attorneys, fake judges, fake subpoenas and fake sheriff deputies to intimidate and bully debtors into giving up assets. Basically, that amounts to theft.
And it does signal the end of the American dream. I don’t agree with everything in the Der Spiegel piece, but the overarching theme is correct – Americans were taught that they could have it better than their parents, through hard work and initiative. And that’s not necessarily true anymore. We have an economic system tilted to the benefit of a several-block radius in Lower Manhattan known as Wall Street. We have a political system bought and paid for by those corporate interests. We have a legal system where power and influence can buy justice. And we have a culture of accountability that’s in tatters. So out of all of that, you get scam artists making fake courtrooms and stealing from people, basically assuming the robes of justice themselves in the absence of any competition.
It’s inequality, not just income inequality but inequality of opportunity, upward mobility and justice that drives this. In these times, it couldn’t be more important for community groups to band together, work with their neighbors and build a collective voice. It’s almost the only hope left.




25 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
What would you think if you got a certified letter containing this?
And yet it’s real, and if you don’t answer within 20 days a default judgment is entered against you.
This is definitely a job for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, assuming they have jurisdiction.
Wow. Every time I think I’ve heard the worst of these types, something more amazing turns up.
Just a few years ago, the Boston Globe, I think, had a series about the incredible behaviors of debt collectors. Also, the fact of the giant business of buying debt on which the statute of limitations has run.
It was one of the early clues for me that the legal system – of which I was once proud to be a part – had been flipped entirely to the advantage of the coporations, scammers, and flim-flammers and to the harm of individuals. So much of this stuff made me feel helpless to do anything; part of that is that the laws have changed to favor the big bad guys, and that the regulators have consciously abandoned (or had their budget starved) enforcement.
This is far, far worse than theft.
It’s intimidation, it’s usury, and it’s impersonating law enforcement officials and courts.
Yup. DADT fail, Stupak Win are canaries in a non-Chilean Coal mine. Ain’t no rescue comin’ neither. For anyone who ain’t a MOTU.
[practicing my hickspeak the better to blend in when required]
I can’t see Melissa Bean getting upset at this at all, except perhaps if banks aren’t permitted access to this business model.
Worse yet, look at how this sleazy industry uses the real courts to screw people.
Wait till we find out that they can’t be prosecuted because it might cost them their jobs…
Hi M!
You know what other little juicy news came out of CO today?
Hickenlooper has picked former Repugnant Governor Bill Owens to be part of his transition team. You know, transitioning from another Democratic Governor we have right now.
#wordsfail
Fuckety fucking hell. What are these bastards going to take from us next. What the hell is going on?
Why am I not surprised? After all, everything is Republican!
Speaking of words failing, now that there is no possible chance of actually passing a DADT repeal through the Congress, Obama wants to go on record as being against stripping the repeal out of the defense authorization bill. See? he really IS our fierce advocate after all! I’m sorry to say that my predictions are already coming true. Let the
greattransparent kabuki begin!Unbefuckinglieveable!
It’s a ironic that the accountability died with an alleged “constitutional scholar” in the white house. and here I thought that irony died in 2000 with the supreme court deciding an election on partisan lines.
wow, was i wrong. oh, and what teddy said.
I feel for any of the people ripped off by third tier collection companies masquerading as a district court. (if i dress up like a judge and order people to give me money can i get away with it for yesr too?) Thanks for posting this. A state district or circuit court hearing will tak place in an official building. Even the smallest rural jurisdictions have them and their will be Real Judges and real courtrooms with real police officers coming and going through a real metal detector.There will be lists of courtrooms and names of cases. In fact, if theres not, you arent in a court building. Unless you are Jefferey Dahmer or Lee Harvey Oswald, not even a snall rural district court is going to hold a session just especially for you.
This is beyond outrageous. Where I come from impersonating an officer is considered a big time crime. I would think that impersonating a judge would infuriate real judges that take their posts seriously.
If this crime goes without real punishment, the real legal entities should also be charged with enabling. Impersonating authority is a very favored MO of pedophiles. I would be more than a little surprised if a real pedophile was not among this group as it is such a favorite of these SOBs.
The real legal system will show a complete lack of respect for itself if they don’t throw the book at these bastards and put them in prison for many years.
I hope FDL and others covering this crime will keep us posted to the outcome of this offense as it affects all of us greatly.
I certainly understand why people worry so much about having a debt collector on your ass.. BUT, that’s their job..AND they get paid EXCEPTIONALLY well for what they recover… or should I say steal???
A number of years ago another ‘debt resolution Center’ called Commercial Financial Services was probably the best ‘debt collector’ in the business… They generated MILLIONS in profit every quarter.. They are the ones that under their Irish (native) CFO, first figured out how to ‘package’ debt obligations into ‘Securitized Debt Instruments” and sell them off to the big NYC banks (investment banks back then) and brokerage companies as AAA+ rated instruments that could be resold… over, and over, and over…
One day, a group of gentlemen walked into Bill Bartman’s (CEO at the time) office and slapped the cuffs on him.. AND on the other senior management of the company.. They seized EVERYTHING (buildings, thousands of computers, trucks, cars, 2nd and 3rd home real estate, etc..)..one minute there were 3600 employees in the building – two hours later – not a single sole and the place was locked up with chains and locks and armed guards… As a company -they were done….As an industry they are just like the worms they are.. chop off anything and it grows back somewhere else…
Wow, this is way beyond fraud. Why exactly is this being filed as a CIVIL lawsuit? If impersonating government officials with the intent to steal property isn’t a nasty CRIMINAL FELONY, I don’t know what is.
They are the ones that under their Irish (native) CFO, first figured out how to ‘package’ debt obligations into ‘Securitized Debt Instruments” and sell them off to the big NYC banks…
One day,
a group of gentlemenanother group of Irishmen walked into Bill Bartman’s (CEO at the time) office and slapped the cuffs on him.. AND on the other senior management of the company…Not to stereotype, but the bold sons of Erin do seem to carry handcuffs (and I hasten to add, badges) disproportionate to their census enumeration. :o)
Privatized courts?
Does this seam so far fetched?
Yes, it is not only “far fetched,” it is criminal activity because it is a crime to impersonate a law enforcement officer, extortion to collect a debt, and theft by fraud.
There is a well established statutory alternative dispute resolution process in most, if not all states in which cases are diverted out of the courts to an arbitrator who is usually an attorney in private practice or a retired judge. Typically, the courts maintain a list of lawyers and retired judges who have been screened to make sure they are honest, experienced, competent, and respected in their specialized areas of the law. Five names are randomly chosen from the list, which is submitted to the lawyer representing each party. The lawyers can strike two names each and the remaining name is assigned to be the arbitrator. A similar settlement process also is typically available and is initiated by the parties whenever they agree to seek settlement.
Arbitration hearings are like informal trials. The arbitrator issues a decision that either or both parties may appeal to the circuit or superior court for a new trial. The catch is, if the appellant doesn’t get a better result, the appellant has to pay the opponent’s costs and reasonable attorney’s fees. There aren’t many appeals because arbitrators try to render decisions that splits the baby just right making it too risky to appeal.
Settlement judges also are attorneys in private practice or retired judges and they preside over settlement negotiations. They usually succeed in brokering a settlement because the parties want to settle, or they wouldn’t be voluntarily submitting to the process, and the settlement judge fashions a fair and equitable result that both parties can live with because it provides a quick resolution and avoids the uncertainty and high cost of litigation.
Both processes involve real lawyers representing their clients and an independent adjudicator who is a real lawyer or retired judge. They tend to work pretty well as far as the parties and their lawyers are concerned and the courts are generally pleased because the process reduces their caseloads significantly. The key to the success of these alternative dispute resolution procedures is everyone knows what’s going on and a dissatisfied party can insist on a trial, if the process doesn’t produce a satisfactory result.
The fraudulent creditor courts are a bunch of actors paid by a bill collector to con or scam an alleged debtor into admitting a debt and collecting it. There is no meaningful opportunity to contest or negotiate the debt, no right to counsel, and no right to appeal. Such a process is vile, repellent, intolerable, and everyone who ordered, authorized, facilitated, or participated in it should be prosecuted and sent to prison.
Alleged constitutional scholar is about right. After all, what did Obama do at Harvard but play intellectual pattycake with the conservative law students, just as Elena Kagan did?
Does Minnesota have a procedure for reopening default judgments to allow a person to litigate the issues?
Agree with your post. Just a further point that not all jurisdictions require the appellant to pay the opponent’s costs if the appeal is unsuccessful.
In Pennsylvania, impersonating a public servant (the definition includes judges) is a misdemeanor. If the authorities are able to identify the individual who was sitting as a judge I expect charges to follow.
I would do what I always do, throw it in the garbage.