As I mentioned this morning, the House tried today for a three-month extension of expiring unemployment benefits, which would have continued them until Feb. 28, 2011. This was called under suspension of the rules, presumably for the purpose of avoiding the dreaded motion to recommit, which Republicans could bring up to engage in any manner of mischief. Democrats simply don’t have discipline on motion to recommit votes, and depending on the motion the Republicans could have easily mucked up the bill. Therefore, a bill which got a vote of 258-154 today failed, because under suspension of the rules it needed a 2/3 vote for passage.
Therefore, the Republicans at the end of the 111th Congress have virtually turned it into a super-majority body, at least on some issues.
That said, this vote seemed more like a test vote to me. It was brought up quickly, without much warning, and put on the calendar in a day. They did get around 21 Republicans to vote for the unpaid-for three-month extension, while 11 Democrats voted no (those may not be precise figures; I’ll post a roll call when I have it). It generally shows that the votes are there, with relative ease, for a three-month extension. Then again, nobody believes the recession will be over in three months, and so the entire thing would repeat itself in the next Congress – with a Republican House – if this passed.
The Senate is really where the UI extension will have the most difficulty. Jack Reed and Bob Casey had no idea when a vote would be scheduled on a benefit extension.
If the benefits, which stretch the normal 26 weeks of unemployment insurance out to 99 weeks, are not extended, close to 2 million jobless Americans will lose what is almost assuredly their primary source of income by the end of the year.
UPDATE: Roll call. I was right, it was 21 Republicans voting yes and 11 Democrats voting no. Here are those Democrats:
Berry, Boyd, Bright, Cooper, Lincoln Davis, Hill, Minnick, Nye, Peterson, Shuler, Taylor
Only three of them will be in Congress next year, including Minority Leader candidate Heath Shuler. Who voted against a three-month extension of unemployment benefits. After he voted yesterday for the robo-signers bailout.




42 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
“Eleven ‘democrats’ voted No.”
Nope, those are not democrats. Sorry, they need to find themselves another party or another name.
I presume they are some of the defeated Blue Dogs, doing their last bit to damage the Dem brand and the country before they leave?
Urg – no edi t! Looking forward (/s) to the roll call when you get it.
I watched this on C-span and felt sure it would pass and thanks to the 2/3 votes rule it did not.
Now there will be millions of people who can not find work who will go without food, shelter, medicine etc. How many children will suffer?
The right wants to extend the Bush tax cuts for the 2% wealthiest people in America but they turn there backs on middle class workers who are begging for help???
11 Democrats voted with the right… Who are these blue dogs? We have a grassroots movement to hold our elected officials responsible with a national website and Organizers and volunteers in every state. join us in this fight. http://www.progressivecitizensforamerica.com/index.html
it is a credit to this site that I correctly guessed all 11
A whole lot of people who voted Repub will be hung out to dry.
Average Unemployment weekly benefits across the country are $293. Yep, that will surely break the budget all to hell.
Shuler just needs to go ahead and become a Republican in name as well as in action.
Fear not! I’m sure our Democratic caucus has been taking careful notes and will turn each and every Republican parliamentary trick against them in the next Congress, assuring the complete failure of the Republican agenda and paving the way for a Democratic Wave in 2012.
… uh … right ?
I really detest Shuler. What a liar he is. He came to FDL and we collected money for him ! aaahhhhgggggggg.
No reason to sit around the house waiting on that relief check.
He got his pep rally with Bill Clinton this year, perhaps he’ll get one with Palin in 2012. Stupidest Dem in Congress, no contest.
“This bill is like déjà vu all over again, and not in a good way,” said Representative Charles Boustany, a Louisiana Republican. “We all want to help those in need but the American people also know someone has to pay when government spends money, and it shouldn’t be our children and grandchildren.”
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-11-18/jobless-benefits-extension-blocked-in-houseL-as-republicans-balk-over-cost.html
Let them eat cake??? Let me count the ways that I abhor these people.
“Party of Heartless Bastards”
Yeah, and that includes those 11 Democrats.
Yeah, they should only have to pay for wars and occupations and shit.
This is a travesty of the greatest proportions. Say what you want about Newt Gingrich, Denny Hastert, or George W. Bush. Bottom line; if they wanted something to pass, it passed, period……………
But this is indicative of how Democrats govern. They really have no interest in the middle and working class and the poor. Check out Dylan Ratigan’s show yesterday on MSNBC with his panel with Alicia Mendez of the so-called New Democrat Network (Old Republican Ideas Thinktank). Clearly she is the poster child for the latte drinking, limousine riding liberal. Dylan ate her lunch, and made her look ever bit as the out of touch elitist that she truly is………….Good stuff.
And so they should. Sometimes you need to suffer before you gain understanding.
Exactly. Low information “voters” who don’t follow the news will go to collect and get zero….then, of course, and rightfully so, they will blame the moron Dems. Unfingbelievable.
Maybe not. After all, they voted the Rs in to office in November so many of them probably think the Rs are already officially in charge.
The dems think that by having votes that defeated the bill, they will try to hang this on the Repubs. The whole stupid thing is going to backfire.
What in the hell are people going to do??? Food, rent, gas, mortgages, elec….Talk about a bunch of asshoooles ruining this country…we’re gonna end up with revolution in the end…
Those who continue to vote “no” on providing some semblance of a safety net are truly diseased and evil people…
Self-moderated.
First, the corporations fuck them over in order to increase executive compensation.
Now their own – our own – representatives fuck them over in order to benefit the corporate masters.
It is time yet? If not now, when?
They might as well be, for all the good the idiot Demos are doing.
The ludicrous talking point the rightwingers gave was that there is the money in stimulus to pay this UI – ignoring that would mean failing to pay commitments under the stimulus plan. They don’t even pretend to be rational.
Sucks but totally and utterly unsurprising. Go eff yourselves, citizens. The HAVES got more; you get sh*t. STFU and go away (but pay your taxes as you slam the door on your sorry worthless butts).
Please FDL, name names. Democrat, Republican. It makes no difference. Name all the names. Include all contact info, too.
11 ConservaDems voted ‘NO.’ It’s to know who’s side the conservadems are really on…and it’s not the working and middle class.
11 ConservaDems voted ‘NO.’ It’s nice to know who’s side the conservadems are really on…and it’s not the working and middle class.
I’m done with these fucking people. I’m glad I wrote in “public option” on every race outside of the judiciary earlier this month.
Don’t they realize that they can serve their MOTUs by extending UI? Giving the jobless insufficient amounts of money forces them to spend it all in their local micro-economy, just to sustain life. This directly injects capital into local businesses. How about that, conservative fuckwads? I thought you were all for small business? Self-serving slave-mongers. As if we aren’t close enough to indentured servitude. I wonder when they’ll start opening plantations and working chain gangs on the mountain-top removal operations?
Fuck, let’s just go back to paying people with company coin, and forcing them to rent company housing and buy groceries at the company store! And pay them less than cost of living so you can take their retirement when they’re too old to work!
And please, stop fucking around and just change the line item on my paystub from “Social Security Tax” to “You’re inevitably going to get fucked here, so just start accepting it now. You’ll never see a penny of this money again”.
/end rant
Is it true that this is the first time that UE benefits have not been extended during a “recession?” I heard that statement the other day, but do not know if it’s actually true. Anyone?
Democrats aren’t even democrats anymore, they’re simply moderate republicans now.
They’ve been voting against their own self-interest for so long, they don’t even understand what their vote means. I guess when there’s no money coming into those who are counting on UI benefits over the “holiday” season they can be comforted to know that their votes ensured the zillionaires got their tax cuts.
I’m sure that will keep them warm and feeling happy with their kids feeling like their bellies are full… perhaps food will “trickle down” to them.
No Harry Hopkins for us! And the WH? Mute as ever.
Don’t be so sure that’s not coming.
We can complain or not occupy the political process and it will get worse. It is not the democrats that defeated this bill, yes there we some but all but 15 republicans voted NO. After that a republican gave a speech about Thanksgiving and how lucky we are an God, blah, blah, blah. I am sickened by the site of those that can live with this…
I think that Social Security issue crosses over the stupidity line of the public at large. Even the fools will take a second look at this one and scrap for it.
Exactly what alternative to ‘eating and having roof overhead’ do the Republicans and 11 Democrats propose?
‘Tree Bark, it’s what’s for dinner’
‘Die, the faster the better’
‘It’s for our childrens future’
‘We need to destroy the village to save the village’
Bah… what happened to ‘United We Stand’?
Oh, I’m sure they are looking at ‘both sides of the issue’. /s
As for old Harry, we should dig him up. Even his corpse could do a better job than the folks in Washington.
Interesting that Melissa Bean, who just lost her re-election bid, voted to extend benefits. On the last go-round, she voted not to extend benefits. Either she received a loud message from her constituents after her last vote or, because she knows she isn’t headed back to D.C. in January, she just doesn’t care anymore. She was always a corporate shill, so this vote of hers surprised me–Melissa regularly voted against bills that would have helped consumers.
Just despicable.
That’s really all, but if anyone needs a little more, here’s Mike Konczal:
Car Breaks Down, Shows The Importance of Extending Unemployment Benefits
Its a shame this did not pass. However, one slight encouraging sign is that almost 260 folks voted for it, with over 20 Republicans joining with the majority of Dems, which has not happened much (if at all) over the past two years. So that tells me there are 20-30 Republicans that will be joining the Dems on “helping people” bills over the next two years and rejecting their t-bag leadership. And Republican support in the house, is now critical for sure.
Why are they being allowed to Thanksgiving break ?
Why are these folks allowed to have a Thanksgiving break ?shouldn’t they be in DC trying to resolve this issue.
This is a scam….notice it always comes just before a “recess”.
This congress should not be on any recess,they sent all our jobs overseas,there are no jobs left & sure as night congress is going on recess.
This is piss-poor leadership from the Dems…
oh, please. we’ve seen this one before. remember the paa? this is what the dems do when the house leadership wants a popular bill to fail.
please please please stop feeding readers the dem party line. we should be smart enough by now to see through it.
The Republicans still win by saying “no”. That’s the whole problem.
Most people still have jobs.