When I wrote a preview of the lame duck session back in September, I called it “the fattest lame duck in captivity.” Because the Senate punted on so many items throughout 2010, it left a lot on the table to be completed, or at least attempted, in the November-December session. Looking back at that list, Congress did accomplish several of these goals:
Bush tax cuts – EXTENDED
Government funding – PASSED UNTIL MARCH
Defense authorization bill – PASSED
Don’t Ask Don’t Tell repeal – PASSED
DREAM Act – filibustered
unemployment insurance – EXTENDED
Doc fix – EXTENDED
Catfood Commission – didn’t get required votes
tax extenders – A FEW PASSED in the tax cut bill
EPA regulation blocking – rejected
Renewable energy standard – not brought up
START – PASSED
Child nutrition – PASSED
Food safety – PASSED
Chinese currency bill – not brought up
Reauthorization of No Child Left Behind – not brought up
Cybersecurity – not brought up
FAA, NASA, Intelligence authorization – not sure
Mine safety – filibustered
South Korea free trade agreement – inked, but not brought to Congress
Judicial confirmations – ABOUT HALF CONFIRMED
In addition, you have a telework bill, the CALM Act (lowering the volume of TV advertising relative to the programming), the COMPETES Act (science and math education policy), a reduced 9-11 health and compensation bill, and more.
Now, it’s fun to hear idiots like Rep. Tom McClintock invoke Oliver Cromwell’s message to the Rump Parliament, “Now depart and go, I say, in the name of God, Go.” Clearly, Republicans didn’t have the best time in this lame duck session, as quite a bit of the people’s work got done. I don’t think it’s an unfair comparison to make between the 111th Congress and the activist Congresses of the mid-1960s, though I think it says more about the intervening Congressional sessions than it does this Congress.
There are a variety of reasons for the success of the lame duck. Democrats still had big numbers and knew this was the last chance to use them. Alienated so-called “RINOs” like Bob Bennett and Lisa Murkowski had reason to go against the tea party grain. The legislation passed had broad, 80-20 majorities in the public. Democrats occasionally communicated effectively, as on the 9-11 health care bill. And the threat of major filibuster reform concentrated the mind on the Republican side a bit.
But what did the Republican letter at the beginning of the lame duck say? Until the tax issue and the funding of the government gets worked out, they would not move forward on anything. That was the threat. And in fact, they won on both of those counts in a big way. They got the Bush tax cuts extended for two years, and they can hold out at that time for another extension. And they stopped an omnibus spending bill and secured a short-term continuing resolution, which blocked funding of health care and financial reform and gave the next Congress an early opportunity to set spending priorities.
That was really all they cared about, as Robert Reich argues.
When it comes to protecting the fortunes of America’s rich (mostly top corporate executives and Wall Street) and maintaining their strangle-hold on the political process, Senate Republicans, along with some Senate Democrats, don’t budge.
Bipartisanship is possible on foreign policy. It’s even possible on certain social issues, such as gays in the military. But it’s not possible when it comes to the core economic and political reality of the United States today — the almost unprecedented concentration of income and wealth at the top, and the way it’s being used to corrupt our democratic system.
In this respect, Democrats are better than Republicans, but not much better. Both parties have rejected efforts to close tax loopholes that would treat much of earnings of hedge-fund and private-equity managers as ordinary income rather than capital gains (taxed at 15 percent). Both parties have refused to cap the size of Wall Street’s major banks or force the banks to aid of distressed homeowners whose mortgages they hold.
Neither party has had the intestinal fortitude to suggest that taxes should be permanently raised on multi-millionaires. Neither will take the initiative on significant campaign finance reform.
It really gets worse than that. Inside the continuing resolution is the two-year pay freeze for public employees. The defense authorization bill funds the war in Afghanistan with basically no strings attached. Inserted in that defense bill were strict limits on the transfer of detainees out of Guantanamo, making federal trials almost impossible. Stripped out of that defense bill was a provision from Roland Burris to allow VA hospitals to perform abortions paid for with private money.
The bipartisan consensus on the corporate-backed economy, the war machine foreign policy, and even some areas of social policy held in the lame duck session, and set up many consequential fights ahead. You cannot divorce the tax cut deal from the looming spending fight. You cannot divorce the START treaty from the fading possibilities of follow-on nuclear disarmament treaties. These things are more lasting than ephemeral victories at the end of Congress. We can savor the victories, but the fight on many key issues, especially the economy, hasn’t even been taken up.




17 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Isn’t it amazing that with all that’s done the things yet to be done is a very long list (or at least some items are ‘short’, but have very big impact).
I agree with your assessment that the Republicans are a bit split and the prospect of new filibuster rules may have inspired them to walk away from McConnell, especially on issues with big public approval. Also, these might have been handled earlier if it weren’t for filibuster, so it’s not as though these were brought up for the first time two weeks ago.
One must wonder, in light of the coming change in filibuster rules and the continuing schism between Bushies, TEA partiers and other Republicans, whether McConnell will remain as Senate Minority Leader. My guess is he will, but it seems inevitable there will be some discussion of alternatives.
NCLB expiring is a win. Now if we can stop the misnamed Race to the Top as well.
unemployment insurance – EXTENDED
I just wondering if I missed the email, did the 99ers get an extension?
Nah, it’s a half a loaf extension.
The 99ers (or virtual 99ers as the case may be for those states that the extensions stop at 60 weeks) got nothing but it did extend the ability for folks to get to the 99 week point if needed.
That’s what I thought, thanks.
Oliver? As in can I have more?
What the Dickens! No. Cromwell, as in:
“You have tarried here to long for the good you have done. In the name of God, go!”
As in not done much.
Not:
““Now depart and go, I say, in the name of God, Go.”
Which is just a dismissal. Cromwell dismissed the rump parliament for cause, not getting done what it was supposed to get done.
Not to mention Cromwell had a few rather unpleasant soldiers backing him up. Somewhat more than Tom McClintcock.
Just goes to show what a woeful grasp of history most elected officials have. In fact, this is the most ignorant bunch I’ve ever seen. It gets worse every election cycle.
BTW, that includes President/Prince Cave-alot.
Thanks for providing this synopsis; it’s important when looking back and trying to draw morals from this story.
King Origami of Cave-a-lot, his magic sword Filibuster, and the Knights of the Triangular Table.
I still wonder why they saved all this until AFTER the elections. September or October would have been an ideal time for most of this crap.
And given the donkles an issue or two to run on.
Its nearly like they didnt want to win any elections.
it’s getting so just anyone can call themselves a knight around here…
That line from Cromwell was so good it had to be re-used. The Time-Life Books History of the Second World War (1989, page 70) cites the following excerpt from the 1940 debate on the vote of no confidence:
With all the agonizing, hysteria, heavy breathing and cries of final victory it seems to me that in the end we have gotten forward nowhere. We are (with two minor exceptions for food safety and 9/11 responders) exactly where we were before. Taxes the same, unemployment insurance the same, people who were in the army can stay in the army, and nuclear reduction agreements renewed.
It was all an unnecessary waste of time, energy and money, while the wars continue, unemployment continues, financial criminals continue at large, the black prisons stay open and the drones fly and kill. I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just.
Luv it!
Josh Marshall remarked that most of the filibustered bills were held up for purely political reasons, just to hurt Democrats in the 2010 election. After the election, the GOP no longer cared if these measures went forward — but they got the bonus tax cuts for the rich plus the estate tax in exchange for doing what they would have had to do anyway!
“(CNN) — Despite President Barack Obama’s signing of a law repealing the military’s “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy, Defense Secretary Robert Gates sent a memo to troops warning them that it remains in effect until 60 days after the government certifies that the military is ready for implementation.”
And who certifies that the military is ready? The president, the secretary of defense and the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
So, when will this happen?
I thought the Pentagon study was meant to determine if this change in policy was ready for implementation. Weird. So, the right-wingers actually got their way in this, too, kicking the end of DADT down the road, to 60 days after certification occurs, whenever that will be. I imagine most people believed that DADT ended the moment that President Obama signed its repeal into law. Unfortunately, this wasn’t so. Delayed repeal describes what happened more accurately, a continuation of the “delayed repeal” dating back years, due to conservative obstructionism, and fears. We know the Marine commandant isn’t too happy with this change, but he isn’t among the three that will certify, luckily, but he no doubt will be lobbying hard to delay the certification, claiming that the Marine Corp isn’t ready. Will it work? For how long? Sometime next year? The next? Incredible.