In an opening bid that’s more of a mood setter than an actual policy expected to be signed into law by the President, the new Republican leadership is likely to pass a repeal of the Affordable Care Act as one of their first bills in Congress. Rep. Fred Upton (R-MI), the incoming chair of the Energy and Commerce Committee, said yesterday that the House would bring up the repeal bill before the State of the Union address.
Hilariously, House Republicans are basing their policy agenda on a country and western song:
Health care is only one item on an aggressive agenda of Republicans eager to distinguish themselves quickly from the House that was run by Speaker Nancy Pelosi. Many seem to have latched on to “Undo It” the hit by the country singer Carrie Underwood, as the refrain for their planned attack against legislation that grew out of the 111th Congress, when the Democrats were at the helm in both chambers.
This may be a nice feather in the cap to show to the Tea Party base, and it will be interesting to see how many House Democrats cross over to vote for it. But that bill won’t go anywhere in the Senate, and even if by some miracle it did, there’s the Obama veto backstop. There’s not even a pretense of “repeal and replace,” which was the mantra immediately after the ACA got signed. Just a full repeal, and let the free market elves sort it out in the fantastic way they have that has led us to 50 million uninsured. And they put in a special exemption from budgetary rules to allow for repeal, which the CBO would show would increase the budget deficit by over $140 billion dollars in the first ten years and over a trillion in the next ten. It’s not a serious effort.
The real policy agenda comes when they can use the budget and the debt limit as leverage. Passing a health care repeal bill is more of a shadow play. And there will be piecemeal efforts to repeal after the full repeal fails. For instance, there’s the 1099 reporting, which both sides agree should be altered but which they haven’t come up with a change to because House Republicans want to take credit for fixing it or place the blame on Democrats for passing in the first place. And then there will be some Stupak-type bill, codifying the executive order from the President that has already been signed. Finally, they’ll try to just defund the law.
So the pomp and circumstance of a repeal bill is almost meaningless. It’s the chipping away that will determine the ACA’s success. Everything else is bad references to war battles:
“That’s what we promised the American people who are still in the 60 percent range in strong opposition to it. They gave us a net of 63 Republicans in the House of Representatives — and believe me, the people out there, they’re going to hold our feet to the fire,” [Rep. Phil Gingrey] said.
“And, they may say, you know, look, don’t just say you’re not going to do it because it’s too heavy a lift,” Gingrey said. “For goodness’ sakes, back in 2006, when we were about to lose the battle in Iraq, thank goodness our patriots fought in the Anbar province and Fallujah and turned that thing around.”
Um, the way that they “turned Fallujah around” was by paying off the Sunnis. The extended metaphor doesn’t really work.





42 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
This is not a bad play by the GOP!!! at all :)
Make the phony Dems defend the Bob Dole Health Care bill every month!!! :)
the GOP has no ideas or plans to fixed the USA economy so the GOP does the next best thing attack the DEMS and make them defend stuff their BASE HATES
the GOP is not going to destroy the BOB DOLE HEALTH CARE BILL OBAMA just got the phony DEMS to pass, it just kabuki for them
the 2012 election is in full bloom right now!
this is an awesome strategy for the GOP!!
real DEMS hate the BOB DOLE health care bill
the base of the GOP hates the Bob Dole Health care bill = WIN WIN for the GOP
23 phony democratic senators are up for re-election in 2012, the GOP needs video of these 23 democratic senators defending the BOB DOLE health care bill that real progressives hate, and the GOP hates.
smart politics if you ask me
Progressives need to find people to challenge these 23 democratic senators, they will be easy targets in 2012.
Democrats defending Bush Taxs Cuts and the Bob Dole Health Care Bill will get little to no love from real liberals and progressives
Who cares about OBAMA he is 1 termer
2012 outlook
$4.00 to $5.00 gas
High un-employment
Bush tax cuts
Bob Dole Health Care Bill
99ers living in deep poverty
no chance Obama wins in 2012
thou should never put a dumb trojan horse in the WH democrats
Obama is going to end the careers of a lot of phony DEMOCRATS in 2012
Ha! I’m sure he feels that Insurance, Medical, and Pharma did not give him enough in campaign monies.
Why are the GOP planning to steal my health care benefits?
Dunno. Probably for the same reason they want to steal your Social Security.
That’s the best he could do? Talk about pandering to your base. Although I’m sure 90% of the base, in this instance, don’t know where Anbar province is and were faaar too busy watching Survivor 83 and the Bill Engvall Show to pay attention to that battle.
If the citizens (“we the people”) owned the ‘means of production’ (raw materials, machines, tools, etc.) we could cut out the middleman (capitalist) and recover 100% of any of the gains (profit) made from the production and sale of our goods. That’s crazy talk some may be thinking. But don’t we (“the people”) already own General Motors? Isn’t GM a means of production? Doesn’t GM now make a profit? So why sell it back to the capitalist middlemen? Why not capture all of those profits for ourselves? Let’s use our tax dollars to buy up everything and end the reign of the corrupt, warmongering, capitalist middlemen. Peace
Can we find an independent journalist on the hill who would be willing to ask the GOP congresspeople only when question whenever the opportunity arises?
“Are you smarter than a 5th grader?”
Do you mean to say that the “Government own and control” the business, or we the people do as a Co-operative?
Suggested that this dude’s kid might one day become a wealthy doctor.
The dude said – Not (wealthy) with Obamacare!
(Most people are totally clueless.)
I said, Doctors will always be richer than the rest of us. Even doctors in Canada are wealthy.
Since most people are clueless – and the media insures that they remain clueless – the GOP can still attack Obamacare as Socialized big gubmint takeover of healthcare.
And those of us who recognize that Obamacare was and is simply a giveaway to AHIP, will be angry at any Democrats who attempt to defend it.
It is a Rove Strategy that will work well for the Rethugs. It is especially helpful that they own the MS Media.
Exactly! You can’t even get behind one Dem in Congress because they all played the game.
Austerity I say! Austerity for thee but not for water parks in Baghdad. WTF?
I’m right there with ya’.
I want to watch Obama and his Band of Centrist Dems defend mandated insurance. Heck, I want to see all the so-called Progressive Dems defend it, too. I hope the freaking thing IS repealed or at least, the citizens hate it more and more. Enabling and entrenching the Health Care Industry into our healthcare system is not now and never will be a good thing, and Obama and his lockstepping Dems should be made to pay. I’m sick of them all and I wouldn’t vote for any Dem if Atilla the Hun was running against them.
I think progressives WISH the Demo congress of the last two years took more votes on solid progressive issues whether they had the chance to go all the way or not.
I saw a lot of complaining that they weren’t doing so here on these pages.
so, it would seem praise for some people who at least have the guts to vote their issues rather than tip toe around.
This is, again, one of those principle things. In favor of a type of action if it favors your mindset, but against the same action when it doesn’t. Example; all for the filibuster when it stops GOP initiatives but turn it into the most evil thing ever when used to stop your initiatives.
Those are politician “principles.”
As usual, the wingnuts will go all batshit crazy and overplay their hand.
This works perfectly for Obama in 2012. He’ll make it the cornerstone of his presidency–running on the we suck less than the repubs schtick, and appearing grandly progressive in comparison.
Maybe because you aren’t paying for them.
Are not “we the people” suppose to be the government? Is there really any need for a “government” over time? If “we the people” understand our real role and faithfully execute are true responsibilities? Peace
They all wilfully accepted Obama’s horrible health insurance giveway – Obama’s Waterloo. Many Dems paid the price for doing so with their defeat in the Midterms. The ones that remain face the same fate.
They would be wise to flip flop now. Pandering shitheads have no qualms about flip flops.
Wise Dems(?) should be on offense – attacking Austerity Measures and the Social Security Raid.
Once you suck them (the health care industry) in, then you can blow them away. Once and for ever. Peace
Peace, Bro!
Wanna help stop the wars and violence?
So…now all the people without insurance can go and get free “preventative” testing..mamograms, etc., however, if they are diagnosed with cancer or whatever they have…how will they get treated?? This is the kind of “negotiating” President Pompous accomplished…a crumb with no solution for the people just to appease us, while he back-doored guaranteed mandated future profits for the greedy, corrupt bastids. Exactly the same as the tax “negotiations”…throw us a crumb and caviar to the rich. Grrrrr.
Paying both sides – multiple sides – in the ME Terror wars and big fat contracts for the MIC is ok with you I guess.
the GOP is being very smart here!
how many dems want to defend Mitt Romney/Bob Dole/Obama health care bill that forces everyone to buy health insurance?
Progressives Base of the DEM party hate OBAMACARE
GOP BASE hates OBAMACARE
this is a clear WIN WIN for the GOP
you can not escape that FACT
ask your Democratic congress person, if they want to be in commercials looking like NASCAR drivers showing all the Health Insurance COmpanies they are making very rich.
This has been the plan all along…and then in will ride Jeb.
yes it has!
Obama the TROJAN HORSE is doing his JOB very well.
Remember in 2008, most americans thought the GOP was DEAD!
In comes Obama the trojan horse Democrat, and within two years the GOP re-takes the HOUSE of Representative.
Obama has done more for republicans than BUSH SR and BUSH JR combine! :)
Next Obama the Trojan Horse Democrat cuts Social Security.
It makes them look like the slimey lizards they really are.
You have forgotten that Obama HAD to negotiate this because of the GOP. They forced his hand. You simply don’t remember all the posturing and just say no that came from the GOP when the bill was being worked on.
Progressives never bought that healthcare switcheroo. We saw through it then and the playbook that is now being put in place.
Obama is part of the team GOP.
Don’t underestimate Fred Upton. First of all, this flurry of announcements has more to do with party unity after his appointment screwed two Tea Party heroes than it does repealing the healthcare bill. So his telegraphed strategy is to salami-slice the law starting with the least popular provision, the 1099 reporting provision. On this he is likely to get bi-partisan support. He thinks that as he moves from one unpopular item to the next, momentum will gather to take down the individual mandate. And Obama has already telegraphed capitulation if the individual mandate is destroyed.
The best hope for real healthcare reform is through innovation by the states. Vermont, Massachusetts, and California are teed up to adopt single payer systems and get waivers from DHHS.
Upton is a corporate Republican; at one point his family owned controlling interest in Whirlpool Corporation. He will ally with corporate Democrats and try to pull the Tea Party crowd along with the promise of repealing Obama’s law. But what Republicans need more than the actual repeal of the law is the appearance that they have repealed the law and undone it while keeping a lot of the popular provisions.
So go out an whip up some Tea Party folks to demand an end to the prohibition against disqualification for pre-existing conditions.
Them and us. Them is the GOP and the Democratic Party and anyone else who is represent’n for the oligarchy in this country. Like the major media outlets. Us is the bottom 80% who fight over the 33% of the wealth that the top 20% permit us to have. Them is eating our lunch. And us is fighting over the crumbs that they drop off their table. Peace
Agreed. Our best method to affect change now is at the State and Local levels. California has a well written idea ready to roll out. I hope to see it on the ballot in 2012. And as folks here have said many times, as goes California, so goes the Nation.
Jon Walker has a fresh cross-post already in progress: In Defending Filibuster, New York Times Shows Strange Fear of Majority Rule
Obama has always been a member of team GOP.
Obama just freezes fed wages out of the blue! with no negogiation with the GOP, this should have shown everybody that OBAMA is a member of TEAM GOP.
the KABUKI that followed dealing with the Bush Tax Cuts was CLASSIC!!! :)
the DEMS screamed about hating the OBAMA/BUSH tax cuts for the rich for a couple of days
eventually they pass the OBAMA/BUSH tax cuts
Coming in 2011
Democrats will scream and hollar about cutting and gutting Social Security for a couple of days
eventually they will cave and cut Social Security
Welcome to the Hope A Dope! by OBAMA
this is why PROGRESSIVES need to plan for their Kabuki in 2012
for example,
Progressives need to volunteer to pass out flyers for Dems in 2012, and once their congress person gives them some flyers, progressives should video tape themselves throwing them in a garbage can.
and Post these actions on You Tube! :)
we can’t let the DEMS in DC have all the fun doing KABUKI :)
“the way that they “turned Fallujah around” was by paying off the Sunnis”
AMAZING HOW MAIN STREAM MEDIA FORGETS
They still sell the GOP “success of the surge”
Hard to get truth into Politics when main stream media is not interested in the truth.
don’t know if I can stomach much more American politics.
The endless stream, the growing celebration of stupidity/ignorance/bigotry/greed is becoming intolerable, sickening, and boring.
The contest to see which legislator can come up with the most uninformed comment, position, or whathaveyou, is exploding.
next, “the situation” will become a member of congress.
falluja was turned into a toxic radiactive hellhole, with an unusually high number of deformed, malformed, babies being born, blown to bits, and the scene of many atrocities.
anyone who things this means “turned around” is in denial of the truth.
A better musical star for House Rethuglicans to guide themselves by: “Hit the Road, Jack” by Ray Charles.
Well, since healthcare costs are still skyrocketing anyway, and record numbers are losing their coverage even with the new law, why not just let the GOP kill it?
Defending the law cost many good Dems their jobs in 2010. Probably better to be back to where we were before the law. At least then we don’t need to worry about the mandated private insurance requirements in 2014.
The monstrosity of PPACA should be repealed.
A while ago there was a Kos diary that I always remembered called something along the lines of “Why have the mammogram if you can’t afford the cancer?”
Suppose you have the mammogram and you’re uninsured and it comes up bad. As far as I understand the completely heartless and wretched healthcare bill that was passed, you would be able to get into a state high risk pool IF you are denied insurance and IF you go without insurance for six months. Even then, many still would not be able to afford the risk pool insurance and feed and shelter themselves as well. What kind of country passes health reform that makes people with potentially fatal illnesses go without treatment for six months? In most cases, insurance=treatment.
What kind of country? A morally bankrupt one, that’s what. We prove it time and again with the people we elect, the decisions they make and the legislation they pass, that we tolerate without so much as a whimper.
And now we’ll watch with mouths agape as they gut Social Security because of the deficits (that they created) and because of (sob!) the children.
Can’t wait for tomorrow. The Republican House will be sworn in and will take over the reins..I hope they stick to the conservative mandate they were handed. It is way past time to STOP the spread of tyrannical socialism, the blatant disregard of our Constitution and the supression of individual freedoms and rights to private property.
Hey Hey Hey, stop thith the moral heirarchy. It is completely IMMORAL for you or anyone else to take from me what is mine, and FORCE me to help you, after it was you who made very bad choices, such as not carrying Health Insurance in the first place. I will help by CHOICE but not forced by some govt. bureaucrat. That my dear is immoral…
Quit driving on the portion of the road I paid for – it’s IMMORAL for you to STEAL that from me!
I seriously doubt that I drive on your roads..I dont drive much..I fly and I work..When will it end..when I pay for everyones health insurance (Obama care), their retirement at 50 (Public Employees Unions bail out, SS Bailout), healthcare for life (ditto Medicare bail out), their house (Fannie and Freddie bail out), their cars (GM bail out), their kids they shouldn’t be having (CHIP)???