Debate begins today on a health care repeal bill in the House, which retains the civil title “Repealing the Job-Killing Health Care Law Act.” In a corollary bill, Republicans will direct to the relevant committees instructions for changing the health care bill and coming up with some other solution to what remains a crisis in America. The LA Times reports on that alternative:
When they take up the much-anticipated repeal resolution Tuesday and Wednesday, GOP lawmakers also will begin crafting an alternative with the goal of reducing insurance premiums, expanding coverage, preserving Medicare and holding down taxes [...]
“It’s more than just repeal,” said Rep. Fred Upton (R-Mich.), the new chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. “We recognize that there are reforms that are needed. We’re not going to just sit on our hands and do nothing.”
The GOP will face a challenge as daunting as Obama did: reconciling the difficult — and politically sensitive — trade-offs that come with trying to provide more and better healthcare while also controlling costs. That balancing act is one of the reasons Obama’s healthcare law is so complicated. And it explains in large part why GOP leaders never produced a comprehensive alternative during the debate over the Democratic legislation or the 2010 congressional elections.
Take that a step further: they never produced a comprehensive alternative in the eight years they held the White House under George W. Bush, or the previous 12 under George H. W. Bush or Ronald Reagan. No Republican in the White House has taken health care seriously since Richard Nixon, and no Republican majority in the Congress has taken it seriously perhaps ever.
They’ll probably come up with some “plan” to completely deregulate the health insurance industry, but that has as much chance of being considered as repeal does.
Meanwhile, McClatchy notes that the health care law may be a lot of things, but it’s not actually a “job killer.” In fact, the fastest-growing job sector in America is health care, and that shows no sign of slowing down regardless of the law. As for the effect on employers, small businesses are actually signing up for health benefits for their workers in reaction to the law, not firing workers.
The White House tried to pre-empt the debate today by releasing a report showing that 129 million Americans have what could be considered a “pre-existing condition” by the health insurance industry:
As many as 129 million Americans under age 65 have medical problems that are red flags for health insurers, according to an analysis that marks the government’s first attempt to quantify the number of people at risk of being rejected by insurance companies or paying more for coverage.
The secretary of health and human services released the study on Tuesday, hours before the House plans to begin considering a Republican bill that would repeal the new law to overhaul the health-care system [...]
The new report is part of the Obama administration’s salesmanship to convince the public of the advantages of the law, which contains insurance protections for people with preexisting medical conditions.
Since we have an employer-based health care system that allows coverage for those with pre-existing conditions, as well as Medicaid and TRICARE, these numbers are entirely possible, though it doesn’t mean all of them would be denied coverage.
These first salvos won’t result in any actual legislative change, in all likelihood. But it will set the ground rules for changes to the law that could follow. I don’t see a lot of common ground there, however. So this battle just prefigures a more consequential battle over funding the law, which requires an affirmative action of Congress.




16 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
UPDADTE:
Responding to criticism, Republican sponsors of “Repealing the Job-Killing Health Care Law Act.” have changed the title to “Repealing the Obama Sux Donkey Dicks Health Care Law Act”.
As I read it McClatchy doesn’t say Obamacare’s not a job killer. They say it’s too early to tell. It’s certainly not a job killer in the health industry, but is that a good thing? Are the benefits to society worth the investment?
There are similar doubts about the reports of a significantly increased proportion of small businesses offering health insurance. The KFF survey, which first noted the trend, expressed some doubts about its finding. Data from insurers is likewise equivocal. We won’t have an answer to this until businesses file their tax returns in April.
That’s a mouthful. S)
They’re wasting their time attempting to repeal it. That said, I wish they would repeal this fucking piece of shit. Better to go back to the way things were than to indenture Americans to the greedy buzzards that get rich off of the suffering of people.
Add that easing of their regulations http://thecaucus.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/18/obama-orders-review-of-business-regulations/?hp Take the burden off of Leroy and put it on me! Ouch
Try this then if you are unconvinced:
http://www.cepr.net/index.php/blogs/beat-the-press/that-qjob-killingq-health-care-bill-ap-does-real-reporting
They talk big about repealing it because it plays well to their brainwashed base (who David Koch paid big buck$ to brainwash with dumb crap about government death panels & other similar junk), but let’s face it: Obamacare is big buck$ for BigIns, BigPharma & BigMed. Why would they repeal something that inures to the elites’ benefit??? They won’t.
If they want to trade out the mandate……I would trade in the public option plan, just to “keep the insurance companies honest” as someone really important once said to an audience of millions of Americans./s
Kabuki season 2011 is off to a roaring start! :)
number 1 issue in the USA is JOBS. (Jobs have been the only issue in the USA since the 2008 great crash)
the GOP at least knows they have no plan to get americans back to work, so why not do what Obama ie”Clarence THomas” and the other phony dems done for a year argue about the Obama/Bob Dole Health Care Bill.
any one with an ounce of knowledge knows the GOP is not going to hurt or damage the Obama/Bob Dole Health Care Rip Off.
we are about to witness what happens when KABUKI goes wrong.
everyday the current group of clowns in DC, make FDR look like A SAINT!
The Good News is that in a couple of weeks David Axelrod is going to entertain all of us, with his attempt to get Obama “Clarence Thomas” re-elected. David Axelrod is going to make progressives laugh like they never have before.
first David Axelrod Joke “Obama is a Progressive”
Second David Axelrod Joke “Obama cares about the USA middle class”
get your pop corn ready. the David Axelrod gets Obama Re-elected comedy show is coming :)
just in real news!” Obama and his wall street friends are now foreclosing on american soldiers.”
I repeat, Obama has a snow ball chance in hell of getting re-elected in 2012
Health and Human Services next up on Darrell Issa’s “hit list” for investigation.
Obama’s healthcare law is one big giveaway to the medical-industrial complex — anything from the big-box healthcare insurers and the big-name drug companies to the big-box hospital chains and the big-name doctors’ union, the AMA. All I can figure is that the Republicans are envious of the Democrats for outdoing them at what they are best at doing, which is to craft a very business-friendly law.
Let me guess. The GOP plan to replace the health care legislation will propose the following: (1) allowing insurers to sell policies across state lines, (2) limiting malpractice lawsuits, and (3) expanding Health Savings Accounts. You don’t need a Magic 8-Ball to figure that out.
“Heaven knows we tried to overturn this monstrosity, but those socialist democrats wouldn’t budge.” – republican message to the its base
“We needed a 60 seat majority to even get health care up for a vote”
- democratic message to its base
“Drinks all around. We did real good. How’s your Cigna stock doing?” – obomba administration message to its AHIP handlers
Love you guys. Smartest people in the room, no bullshit, no suckers!
: )
Fix it ..don’t flush it..! 189 million people have pre-existing conditions.Time for the GOP to stop jerking us off.
We know that Boehnor can sell a ‘wheelbarrow full of shi-’ to his masses.He winks at Fix news and gets an interview and its all downhill from there. He is somewhat limited as to the words he can use now.But he has a hired hand for that. Never count out the ‘gop night walkers’. at times they are like a breed from another planet. Money is Boehnors biggest problem now. The gop had a 10 million dollar bill from Nov. that wasn’t paid. National advertising to ‘spread his plague’ will be very little.He needs the Fix boys to come to his aide