In a sometimes contentious call, Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission representatives Phil Angelides and Brooksley Born acknowledged that we might still be in a financial crisis, and that their report should not be seen as the last word on an event that still has the capacity to significantly damage the global economy.
Brooksley Born, who as head of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission under Bill Clinton urged more regulation of the derivatives markets, responded to a question from FDL News on whether we’ve seen the end of the financial crisis. “I do think we are still in somewhat of an economic crisis,” she said. “We may well be in a financial crisis, we don’t know that yet. We don’t know how solvent a number of institutions are.”
Both Born and Phil Angelides, the chair of the commission, described the report as part of an ongoing process of discovery. They had 18 months and around $10 million dollars to come up with a report, one which is sure to be buffered by future litigation, regulatory agency reports and Congressional investigations. They hoped their report would guide future actions, particularly on the hundreds of rules being promulgated by the regulatory apparatus under Dodd-Frank. But Angelides said, “I hope our report is not the last word on this crisis,” particularly because he acknowledged that little, if anything, has changed in the years since the real bubbling up of the crisis at the end of 2008.
Angelides also understood the serious complications that could still arise from MERS and the true ownership of mortgages, and the impact that could have on the system. The FCIC report, on pages 407-408, does go over various aspects of foreclosure fraud and additional lawsuits, including Countrywide v. Kemp, which easily could pose a systemic risk to the financial system. Needless to say, the foreclosure crisis, and its potential for 13 million families to lose their homes before it’s all over, remains a giant sore thumb as well. “Who would have known a system so efficient at creating mortgages would be so hard to unwind,” Angelides said.
Angelides added that, as of September of last year, the regulator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac demanded $35 billion in repurchases of 167,000 defective mortgages, where the underwriting standards were lax or not as represented. So far, the banks have paid up on $20.9 billion. And Fannie and Freddie have only sampled a small percentage of loans so far, finding almost 1 in 3 to be ineligible. Obviously, this is why Bank of America decided to settle with Fannie and Freddie, but the other big banks have resisted that to this point. Fannie and Freddie own or guarantee $1.5 trillion in loans. This isn’t going away.
Here is the commission conclusion on this aspect of the going-forward crisis:
The Commission concludes the unchecked increase in the complexity of mortgages and securitization has made it more difficult to solve problems in the mortgage market. This complexity has created powerful competing interests, including those of the holders of first and second mortgages and of mortgage servicers; has reduced transparency for policy makers, regulators, financial institutions, and homeowners; and has impeded mortgage modifications. The resulting disputes and inaction have caused pain largely borne by individual homeowners and created further uncertainty about the health of the housing market and financial institutions.
What that conclusion doesn’t come out and state is the evidence shows clear criminal fraud on the part of major banks and loan servicers. They have little problem agreeing to the incidences of mortgage fraud – which became such a large industry that losses on fraudulent mortgages reached $112 billion between 2005 and 2007. But that’s a well-known problem which does not take in the accounting fraud of major banks which many, like Bill Black, say drove the crisis. When asked on the call if they agreed that criminal fraud was responsible for the crisis, they fell back on mortgage fraud, a common technique. Angelides countered that you’ll see numerous places in the report where fraud and crime are referred to. And that’s generally correct. But their official statements fall much more along the lines of “imprudent” or “misjugded,” the kind of words not normally used in court.
Born added that the commissioners, acting under a statutory mandate, did issue criminal referrals. She said “We were not a judicial body making decisions about the intent of the actors. We reported on a lot of behavior which may or may not have been criminal or civil violations. We’re leaving that to prosecutors and civil authorities to decide.”
The Justice Department has not yet responded to my inquiry about the FCIC referrals, where they will go, who will handle them, and when we can expect information about them.
As Robert Borosage of the Campaign for America’s Future said in a statement, “This report shines the spotlight on the policies and financial malpractices that drove our economy off a cliff.” But that shouldn’t be in the past tense. And malpractices isn’t nearly as strong as “crimes.”





70 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
There is all kinds of testimony and depositions that reveal clearly fraudulent/criminal/illegal behavior on the parts of many many people and yet we all wait breathlessly for the perp walks like this is all going to be resolved like an episode of Law and Order. The difference being that Law and Order had purely fictional characters who actually cared about the law and enforcing the law. We don’t appear to have anyone like that on our (the peoples)side.
One of my most major questions is:
Why would anyone anywhere purchase an American financial instrument again? Are they regulated? Are the regulations enforced? Are miscreants/criminals investigated/prosecuted/punished? The answer so far appears to be no.
So basically it’s a crapshot or a casino. The ratings meant nothing. The securitizations themselves were not legally fulfilled. So far the only ones paying the piper have been the American taxpayers and homeowners. The upper levels of the cabal are actually rewarded with elevated seats at the governing table so that they can continue to mislead, prevaricate, deceive, and keep on keeping on with their 3 card monte. They got theirs. Too bad for everyone else.
But back to my question about the future. Why are American bonds any more highly regarded now than Russian or Nigerian or Tralfalmadorian bonds? That’s the crux of the matter. And that’s why prosecution and punishment are important. Maybe the MOTU have finally crapped in their own nest enough to raise a stench strong enough to keep investors/gamblers away. What happens then? Some other country will be the haven for the world’s money. Our economic slide continues.
On a side note – How can one sleep being in the stock market once aware of naked shorting? The greatest, most well-run company in the world can be stripped like a goat carcass covered with army ants on the whim of a financial Dr. Evil.
It’s incredible to witness in my single lifetime the erosion of respect and trust for the financial sector and then the resulting same erosion of regard for the government in terms of its competence and will to regulate and govern meaningfully and justly.
I heard Angelides on NPR on my way home and, now as I read about Brooksley Born, I’m reminded of Pontius Pilate, who also took the easy way out. (I am sure that Born, Angelides and their colleagues did a lot of good work. But in the end it may have been too little, too late. No one has stood up on hind legs and said, of the entire train wreck: This is a crime scene. We will investigate, capture and punish the perpetrators,
And this is 2011, folks.
MSM: The Dow’s banging around 12000 again, so everything’s hunkey-dorey.
I find it hard to get worked up over a financial crisis that may be when they apparently couldn’t care less about the jobs crisis that is.
This certainly falls into the category of nodding acquaintance with the obvious.
Yes, BB served in the Clinton admin. and tried to warn about the dangers building in the financial system.
Obviously, she was totally unfit for office.
That would be my second comment. MOTUs are doing jest fine. What me worry.
What use is their work and report if they cannot pinpoint to a crime or state obvious derelection of fiduciary duty? Another commission wasting time and money on the backs of taxpayers to show somebody is looking into it seems to be their purpose.
What an understatement.
in December of 2008, the IMF warned governments of the prospect of “violent unrest on the streets.” The head of the IMF warned that, “violent protests could break out in countries worldwide if the financial system was not restructured to benefit everyone rather than a small elite.”
Dennis Blair, told the Senate Intelligence Committee that the greatest threat to the National Security of the U.S. was not terrorism, but the global economic crisis:
“I’d like to begin with the global economic crisis, because it already looms as the most serious one in decades, if not in centuries … Economic crises increase the risk of regime-threatening instability if they are prolonged for a one- or two-year period… And instability can loosen the fragile hold that many developing countries have on law and order, which can spill out in dangerous ways into the international community.
We haven’t come out of the Recession, and are being steered into a Depression. Washington is sooo out of touch!
Are Angelides & BB rubbing shoulders with the select at Davos? If not, let’s chip in & buy them plane tickets.
Those two are trying to differeniate between Financial and Economic crisis. Where is the line drawn?
Oh drat.
They are fiddling as Rome burns and we’re screaming with our hair on fire…
But we’re all going to hell in a handbasket or not.
Incredible work being done and comments on FDL… You guys are great!
they just print whayever $ they need,soon we will be paying debts in edible beans
OMG! Does that mean that the peasant hordes will run screaming the streets because they are tired of eating cake? Oh My!
Hey, I was just thinking that maybe we should change from the dollar to acorns or painted rocks. Beans would make sense, if you had a pocketful you would not be hungry.
We must band together to prevent that at all costs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_las_Barricadas
escape!
http://www.groundswell.fi/galleries/index.ph?Qwd=./Specific%20Places/Bordeaux%202008&Qiv=thumbs&Qis=M
Salt was one of the earliest forms of money.
true dat,ya aint worth your salt O
precisely!
Yep. Prevention is the key. At least I’ve always thought so. But, what do I know. I’m just an average person that hasn’t had the priviledge of elitism.
You wrote:
No it’s far worse than that. You are basically throwing any money down a rat hole with the present system. Here’s the money quote from French President Sarkozy at DAVOS (excerpt from “Sarkozy Goes Postal On Jamie Dimon, Says Bankers Made World Into Madhouse,” Jan. 27, 2011):
Nice.
I’ve tried to figure out how to do an allee on my property. It’s not really appropriate. But I have planted a single row of 30 Bradford pears trees alongside one of the paths, and have survived for several years, so hopefully should mature. They are also fast growing so I may even live long enough to see them become shade trees.
I read his quote earlier and watched a clip of Dimon speaking. Strange that Sarkozy had no problem speaking the truth while Dimon was up there making shit up as he went.
who knew,he was sensible?
And Sarkozy is an asshole.
When assholes make sense, the world is surely coming to an end.
fantastique,you must make this
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_Bt2cNCKbETA/SWLR9KpLbFI/AAAAAAAAASY/ly05AL8duS4/s400/Pear+Tart.jpg
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
Yes and maybe all the protesters in France got his attention. I don’t know but it seems that more people are beginning to notice the facts.
That is a piece of art! The merainge/sp is beautiful!
Perhaps we Americans can leverage Sarkozy’s … um … blunt assessment to our benefit. Something tells me he has a bunch of folks talking (screaming ? ) in his ear about this. Non?
Oui! Ce vais. Bein!
makes me hungry
http://www.foodbuzz.com/photos/716563-photo-from-post-twd-french-pear-tart
it was a pear tart
Bradford pear trees are strictly decorative & bear no fruit that humans can eat. I think the beez love the flowers, and they are relatively early blossoming (mid-April in Manhattan, a week or so later in mid-Hudson).
His wife, Carla Bruni, is quoted as saying Nici wants to quit after one term to make money, like Clinton. So as he nears the end of his term, perhaps he wants to go out making sense.
Won’t take much to tip over into the Monty Python joke zone if we Americans don’t take the big fat hint and the support, Monsieurs / Madames / Mademoiselles.
yah,thats right,some of the farms here have them on large driveways,they are pretty
YA FUCKIN THINK?
Someone speaking of tarts?!
The Bartletts look very pretty. The bees dance for flowering lilacs (makes the humans swoon, too, I noticed).
Echan…get a few of these
http://www.buypearsonline.com/faqs.php
you have Bartletts,…..nice
I want the pheromone dispenser.
hahahahahaha
Being There is on TCM
beeeeeeeeeeeeeeee careful
When I was a gentleperson farm type … along with the rest of Wild Kingdom that horned in like something out of a Gary Larson cartoon.
my 47 was responding to mzchief @45
Got plenty of orchards nearby. Will only eat locals.
I prefer Bartletts to all other pears. The harvest was thin this year owing to funny frosts during blossoms. This coming year will be better.
Pears are one of my fave fruits and liquors.
i love poire guillaume
Yes. I also found out about environmental toxicity and questionable state-required medications as the end result was that the bees colonies repeatedly died. This was before the film, “Silence of the Bees.”
My granny used to make pear preserves. Really wonderful on hot biscuits.
http://themanyfacesofspaces.com/poire-williams_2.jpg
oh boy ,im getting more hungry
okay site is acting hinky
TCM
Being There
Doctor Strangelove
Lolita
niterz
Serious yummi-ness.
Mark the assets to actual real market and you’ll find out in a hurry…
Heh.
Pouting Baby is upstairs!
Late Night: Pouting Baby Doesn’t Understand Why Creepy Clarence is Allowed to Lie
Interesting. Born and five others on the FCIC report hint at the wreck that is yet to come, as the system is largely unchanged and the financial institutions are only larger. Yet, four of the commission dissented, and are issuing a dissenting report. This will weaken the whole, if any effect, of the exercise of the FCIC inquiry. Then to be seized upon by the media as an issue of principles and economic philosophy regarding views of the role of government and business. And of course the bugbear, regulation and the rule of law.
The most serious results may be deferred prosecution agreements (DPA’s), or non prosecution agreements (NPA’s). No “To Big To Fail” institution or it’s officers will suffer for these crimes of the century.
Otherwise the Fed will continue to print (originate) money, loan it to these very financial institutions (“banks”) at near zero interest, accept known trash as collateral, and then broadcast which Treasury Notes they wish to purchase, allowing these “banks” front run by purchasing the Notes and inflating them, then to be sold to the Fed on our dime, crap, I mean’t millions
trillions.The game is on and the players are in charge of writing the rules.
The FCIC made referrals to DOJ. Now we wait to see if the DOJ will do anything. I wonder what the statute of limitations is for the sorts of crimes in the referrals.
It was a party-line division, with one Republican even dissenting from both the report and the dissent. Republicans know (and Democrats are afraid that the public will find out) how this mess came to be. And both parties are up to their elbows in actions that led to it.
If no leadership changes the narrative, history might intervene once again. The amount of denial is breathtaking. But this time there will be some other wrinkle that indicates that the financial industry can engineer around regulations as fast a Congress passes the watered-down critters.
History’s invitation to hubris.
Someone could write a book on financial v economic. At the base of it all is a debt-based monetary system. Such a system is doomed to fail over time. It is a Ponzi scheme. The debt cannot ever be repaid. The Fed only issues FRNs to cover the principal, not the interest. The only way the interest is repaid is by issuing new debt.
80-90% of the problems we face could be solved by reforming our monetary system. At one time I believed a gold-backed currency was the answer. Now, I’m moving away from that. As eCAHNnomics pointed out, salt was one of the earliest forms of currency.
Why is the USG borrowing money from the Fed on behalf of American people at interest only to have the American people borrow it back at interest? If that makes sense to anyone, please explain it to me?
Here’s another point. The bailouts. The USG bails out the TBTF banks so they can lend they money back to us with interest. What’s wrong with this picture? EVERYTHING!
Fire up a joint on the steps of the capital, and you will quickly see how much care for the law exists in this administration, our towns, the whole country.
Filling the jails and prisons with petty criminals from the lower classes allows them all to be “tough on crime” while institutionalizing corruption and protecting the MOTU from the just ire of the rest of us.
Only a popular, peaceful uprising can get our country back for us. (Whatever the merits – or lack thereof – of some sort of violent uprising, such would be so quickly and ruthlessly crushed that the survivors would be on trial within a year.) Keyboard pounding won’t do it.
Nothing scares the politicians more than a million or so people in the streets. Because the politicians believe their own propaganda and expect the crowd to turn violent at any second, which a well-organized, peaceful group just will not do – despite the actions of the inevitable undercover cop agents provocateur.
The potential is for a sudden contraction of the economy depending entirely on the dominoes that will begin falling if the whole
foreclosure/fraud/derivatives/bankrupt banks,etc situation is “mishandled” from the perspective of the banks.
I put “mishandled” in quotes, because, if justice and the law are followed, our entire financial system is about to collapse like a house of cards.
1000+ overseas US military bases may be part of the answer.
But w/respect to our financial institutions, I agree. Who wants to deal with institutions which are above the law and who’s sole purpose is to ‘melt faces’.
And the non-existant accounting standards of the big multinationals pretty much means that we cannot tell if they are up 100 Billion or down 100 Billion.
TBH, the system worked ok until they eliminated the New Deal era reforms.
I see many problems with the way our FED is currently operating but keep in mind that FED profits are handed over to the US Treasury each year.
David, here’s how you get to a fairer and saner society…
1. Enact Fair Elections Now Act. $100.00 maximum donation
2. FCC mandate that all TV political advertising is a public service and therefore free
3. Permanently ban anyone who has served in federal office from becoming a lobbyist
4. Enact The Bipartisan Tax Fairness and Simplification Act of 2010 – Eliminate $1 trillion in tax giveaways. Change the top tax bracket to 70% to help pay down debt
5. Break up the big banks and strengthen the Volker Rule
6. End ALL wars and lower the bloated defense budget
7. Reduce health care costs by adding the public option. Allow Medicare to purchase drugs. Allow drug re-importation. The Medicare Independent Payment Advisory Board should be given a broader mandate for cost control.
8. National Infrastructure Bank – Run by engineers, not politicians. Find $1 trillion over 10 years to create jobs now and increase productivity later. Put millions back to work. Fund with millionaire’s tax
9. Federal government make massive investments in R & D to create quality jobs long term in areas like biotechnology, alternative energy, IT, materials, science, alternative-fuel automobiles, and clean technology. Fund with financial transactions tax
10. Raise educational standards through a national core curriculum. Advocate the firing of the bottom 10% of teachers nationwide and replace them with good teachers. Make higher education free to families that can’t afford it to encourage upward mobility in society. Fund with carbon tax