The US media and political establishment – increasingly a redundancy – told me that Omar Suleiman was managing the transition in Egypt very well, and talking to the opposition groups, and that progress was being made and life was returning to normal and we can all put this out of our heads presently. Somebody forgot to send the message to the people of Egypt:
Thousands of pro-democracy demonstrators have poured into Cairo’s Tahrir (Liberation) Square as protests against Hosni Mubarak, the Egyptian president, entered their 15th day despite a slew of concessions announced by the government.
Tens of thousands of protesters have also come out on the streets in Alexandria, Egypt’s second largest city.
There were also reports of a protest outside the parliament building in the capital. A witness said at least a thousand people had gathered at the spot and more were coming in.
According to Hoda Abdel-Hamid, Al Jazeera’s correspondent in the Egyptian capital, the crowd at Tahrir Square grew rapidly on Tuesday afternoon, with many first-timers joining protesters seeking Mubarak’s immediate ouster.
The newcomers said they had been inspired in part by the release of Wael Ghonim, the Google executive, after what he said was two weeks of detention by state security authorities.
“I came here for the first time today because this cabinet is a failure, Mubarak is still meeting the same ugly faces … he can’t believe it is over. He is a very stubborn man,” Afaf Naged, a former member of the board of directors of the state-owned National Bank of Egypt, said.
Yes, you read that right, the former board member of the national bank is out in the square.
I was on Virtually Speaking with Professor Juan Cole last night, despairing that the US has thrown in its lot with the torture chief Suleiman and undertaken this concerted effort to avert the eyes of the world away from Tahrir Square. This could pave the way for government repression, the rounding up of the activists, and an end to any hope of a better future. But Cole was oddly confident, saying that the Iranian Green movement didn’t have as clear a goal as the protesters in Egypt, who clearly want nothing less than the removal of Hosni Mubarak from office. And they have the desire to bear witness to the brutality that the regime has already employed. A video of a protester being shot by secret police in Alexandria bounced around the country yesterday. Wael Ghonim’s detention has become another symbol.
The Mubarak regime continues to scramble, forming a committee to review constitutional reforms, promising more talks with protesters and an investigation into the violence. Suleiman and Mubarak promised that protesters would not be prosecuted for their actions. At the same time they are playing on the fears of the great masses of the public, intimating that the protests are hurting them economically. But the protesters have no trust in the regime to make good on their promises.
I feel more hopeful for the protesters today because of their resolve than I did when it appeared that the US was successfully stage-managing.




49 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Cynic that I am, I have still been stunned by the way that the US media have been reading from the same set of talking points about Egypt for the last 24 hours. David referred during the day yesterday to interviews being conducted at cafes in “middle class” (meaning upper class) neighborhoods of Cairo, and sure enough on the PBS Newshour yesterday evening, there was Margaret Warner conducting an interview at a cafe in a “middle class” cafe.
Time to get fitted for that tinfoil hat.
thanks David –
followed the Wael Ghonim Is Released story all day yesterday via twitter – simply incredible – almost like a Costa Garvas film with a happy ending (well, except I know we aren’t anywhere near the end yet)
but fascinating (and admittedly uplifting) nonetheless – the backstory with the Dream TV reporter/interviewer (she had interviewed him the night before he was disappeared and involved herself personally in the search), his release at the direct involvement of the Interior Minister (who personally drove him home) – Ghonim told the Minister he must resign and join the people in Tahrir – wow, just incredible
are US media bobbleheads trying to say middle class isn’t involved in the struggle ??? there’s only a bazillion images from Tahrir, Alexandria, Suez, etc to disprove that crap -
I was in Tehran and Tabriz 1 month before the Shah’s departure when there was little apparent middle class involvement and then 3 days before he left the country when it appeared there was no one but the middle class in the streets – the current images out of Cairo remind me so much of the latter
fyi – Suez Workers go on strike
I watched the interview twice last night, just to be sure I got the full scope of what he was saying. I was genuinely touched and impressed by his concern for the protesters, and the importance he placed not on himself, but their actions. He wants to keep the focus solely on them, it seems.
That story deserves a post. Thanks for the link.
The USA is all for change as long as, well, nothing really changes. Watching our Sec of State revise the official position on the demonstrations on an almost daily basis has been educational and depressing.Depressing because one expects most Americans buy the officail line unquestioningly.
“Thank goodness all those scary Mooslims stopped rioting and life is getting back to normal there! Just look at the upper class people in the cafes on TV. Its just like Greenwich Village! Why would anyone in Cairo be unhappy with their way of life?”
Heh. That’ll slow commerce through the Canal. I wonder how the US will respond? Lawd knows the worst thing you can do is fuck with our oil.
Unfortunately, the international community sees what we’re doing, and sees it for what it is. Our Government is pathetically entangled in this mess, and the fact that we couldn’t put up a unified front or stand behind one position made it even worse.
I think this event, more than anything in the preceeding 2 years, will dominate the international memory of Obama’s legacy.
The event in Egypt should turn out to be a successful revolution because the educated classes seem to be running it.
In the earlier Egypt post, a few of us were noting the MSM in the US giving an impression that the protests were growing smaller and breaking up. A few of us were noticing that Twitter feeds from TS were explaining the protests were growing and remaining strong.
Thank you for the update. It appears that democracy movement in Egypt needs to be updated on the front page on the hour in order to confront the US/Great Britain MSM “move along” mantra.
Wish we could have Juan Cole as a salon guest.
call me crazy but never mind the US response – think China – “chokepoints” – something I’ve been personally anxious about since the beginning.
Obama, Hillary, Bill, Joe, Albright, better known as the Israel Lobby has fail yet again to deal with reality
the young people of egypt probably have more reasons to die for their cause then to live under another brutal dictators prop up by the USA.
I love the people of Egypt, they know change does not equal the STATUS QUO
in the USA, OBAMA = BUSH,
OBAMA, Hillary, Biden, Bill, Albright, thought Mubarak = Sueliman was going to work. NOT!!!
Me-Thinks the current group of morons in DC, are going to cause the Mid-East to explode with rage.
Thanks for the update, David.
(good morning CBL and KrisAinCA)
That could get seriously ugly. Oooorrrrr, it could go the right way and our Government and China’s Government could back the protesters and demand Mubarak’s resignation, handing the Government over to a panel compossed of Oposition leaders, and this could all end today.
That would be the smart thing to do, and the right thing to do. It seems that power begets more power, though. Governments don’t know how to let go.
It is apparent, the Egyptian people have more courage than all the corporate whores in our media who just do and say what they are told by this administration. They would not want to lose out on the possibility of being at the side of king Obama. No one throughout the rest of the world who has not been subjected to our propaganda media will ever listen to this administration again. They have lost all credibility and the world will have to fall down around them and their media before they know what happened.
mornin’
call when you can
Good morning! I was just perusing the job listings in the greater Austin area…
Perhaps those Egyptians who won’t fit in the Square, we could bring over here, surrogates sort of, to protest our corrupt government, since we seem to prefer to tweet and blog about it rather than actually doing anything.
It’d be nice to import 500,000 people to put in front of the White House…
On the other hand, it’d be nicer if those 500,000 people were Americans.
Ah well. Once a war criminal, human rights abusing *edited by me ;-)*, always a war criminal human rights abusing *edited by me ;-)*, hey Bambi?
But do take a look at your uncle George’s restricted travel options as you go down this road. That’ll be you in a few years time….you fascist *edited by me ;-)*
Wow. That’s major.
Thank you, David! What a privilege to sit next to the legendary Juan Cole. We here in the US think that we remain objective when the truth is the media hammers us with every tool in their box to deflate and defeat our expectations of real change. Right down to the idiotic Superbowl commercials, all orchestrated to dumb us down, point us in the wrong direction – and why should we suppose it to be different when it comes to something really important like the uprising in Egypt.
Uprising is a great term because it reflects the fact that the cream rises to the top. Those people in their millions come from every walk of life and are united in that common hardwon realization that Mubarek must go. They have lived it while we only saw through a glass dimly. And they know that as the uprising continues, more and more of their fellow citizens will also rise to the top.
We are watching (when we get a chance to see them) heroes; and we are listening to (when we get a chance to hear them) heroes. And the more the media disallows this seeing and hearing, the more we know them for what they are.
Bravo, Egyptians! We love you.
IIRC, most of our oil from that part of the world goes via supertankers around the Cape of Good Hope. This would mainly impact European supplies. Brent crude went over $100 a barrel when the demonstrations started but prices here were still in the low 90s.
Juan Cole being confident is heartening.
Journalists turning on the lying Egyptian state media too.
And more actions across the country, from the same source.
Oh shit. It may be starting in Saudi Arabia.
Juan Cole has an emotionally powerful Egyptian television interview of Wael Ghonim that’s a must see. He’s the Google exec who was arrested at Tahrir Square on January 25th and finally released last night. Some are calling him the Egyptian Ghandi, although he would certainly deny that he is. If you want to know why these young heroes cannot be vanquished, watch this video.
Our Response In Motion?
What you said.
Just hours ago the revolt was being called dying and dormant . . . and I concurred.
Appears news of its death is premature . . . interesting.
“Meanwhile, about 20 lawyers have petitioned Abdel Meguid Mahmoud, the country’s prosecutor general, to try Mubarak and his family for allegedly stealing state wealth.
Ibrahim Yosri, a lawyer and a former deputy foreign minister, has drafted the petition.”
There is already a small contingent on the ground in Cairo. At least here was last week. They were dispatched to “protect the Embassy”.
If our military gets involved, we’ll see 80 million people in the streets.
Our Marines are in transit.
Wonder why there was no deployment to the region long before . . . admin is WAY behind the curve on all of this Jasmine . . . still.
As others have said, this is huge.
It drags other nations directly into it all . . . as you suggest, China. N Russia, Germany, Japan . . . oil, food . . . and more.
Huge.
This source, Al-Ahram, by the way, is — or was — a state controlled newspaper and the fact that it has turned is significant.
Americans should be so lucky if this event is the only major foreign dilemna faced by our president. Egyptians, on the other hand, are screwed either way.
And thanks to the Angry Arab for pointing that article out.
I believe our government and many of us have seriously underestimated the power of the Egyptian Revolution. I don’t believe it can be stopped.
Thanks again to Mr. Dayen doing yeoman’s work on dozens of issues in the air, all at once.
I don’t understand how he does it.
:)
Exactly .. the world watches, and Mother Nature is concerned ..
This is what you get with a conservative school board.
Just more of that “define our reality” crap.
It’s only US media coverage of the protests that is waning. Gosh, is our attention span really that short? Personally I find the developments incredibly compelling.
Thanks Dave.
I just read an article at counterpunch.org by Tarecq M. Amar that I think calls the events in Egypt by the best term I have heard so far – a far better name than Revolution, since what the Egyptian masses are insisting upon has a different character from what we normally think of as revolution or revolt. Mr. Amar calls it The Nile Uprising. This upswelling ongoing is so uniquely Egyptian and so lifegiving and inspiring that I think it deserves its own unique title, and this could be it. (The article is well worth reading also).
What marines? Aren’t they almost all in Afghanistan? We don’t have many reserves available. Do they think this will be like Nicaragua in 1930?
Yes, I read the article and I agree that calling it the Nile Uprising is more accurate. Also, Wael Ghonim said in the interview that it isn’t so much a revolution as a non-violent declaration of and insistence upon basic human rights and dignity.
Seconded!!