What we saw happen in Egypt over the past few weeks and the final joyous hours was a citizen-led movement. It was a worker-led movement as well, with female beneficiaries of micro-finance and youth entrepreneurs and the working class taking to the streets to air their grievances about their personal conditions. It was not a Western-led coup, or something the West even had a whole lot of leverage to effect. In his final days, the Mubarak regime tried to claim a grand conspiracy of foreign operatives and satellite news channels angling to push them out, a play to nationalist fervor. But that’s not what happened. The people in the street toppled them.
President Obama spoke to that today in his remarks:
By stepping down, President Mubarak responded to the Egyptian people’s hunger for change. But this is not the end of Egypt’s transition. It’s a beginning. I’m sure there will be difficult days ahead, and many questions remain unanswered. But I am confident that the people of Egypt can find the answers, and do so peacefully, constructively, and in the spirit of unity that has defined these last few weeks. For Egyptians have made it clear that nothing less than genuine democracy will carry the day [...]
One Egyptian put it simply: Most people have discovered in the last few days…that they are worth something, and this cannot be taken away from them anymore, ever.
This is the power of human dignity, and it can never be denied. Egyptians have inspired us, and they’ve done so by putting the lie to the idea that justice is best gained through violence. For in Egypt, it was the moral force of nonviolence — not terrorism, not mindless killing — but nonviolence, moral force that bent the arc of history toward justice once more.
And while the sights and sounds that we heard were entirely Egyptian, we can’t help but hear the echoes of history — echoes from Germans tearing down a wall, Indonesian students taking to the streets, Gandhi leading his people down the path of justice.
As Martin Luther King said in celebrating the birth of a new nation in Ghana while trying to perfect his own, “There is something in the soul that cries out for freedom.” Those were the cries that came from Tahrir Square, and the entire world has taken note.
Today belongs to the people of Egypt, and the American people are moved by these scenes in Cairo and across Egypt because of who we are as a people and the kind of world that we want our children to grow up in.
The Administration spent most of the past few weeks catching up to events. But this statement puts them where they need to be. Much needs to be done to help Egypt prepare themselves for the next stage of democracy, and there’s no guarantee they will get there. The White House needs to reverse decades of US policy in the region and support the will of the people of an Arab country, not the will of whoever is best for business and security. Earlier in the speech, Obama did mention some specific steps – lifting the emergency law, revising the Constitution – that Egypt must take. But more than that, he needs to allow them the space to achieve a meaningful democracy without interference. Obama’s other statement about Egyptian ingenuity and how that can transition to economic opportunity for the country, is hopeful in this regard.
The best part of this statement is the restraint. Not only the celebration of non-violence and moral force, but the restraint of an American leader reluctant to put an American face on Egyptian events. We don’t control the world and we shouldn’t. We couldn’t wave a magic wand to make Hosni Mubarak go away; a mass of people strained and struggled to do so. I prefer this foreign policy to the one which announces the bombs set to drop unless one dictator – but not another – gives in to demands.
I don’t want to glorify this speech too much, or the Administration’s handling of the matter – they included some serious missteps, and should be ready for criticism if they try to boost Omar Suleiman again. But for the moment, this sounds right.




67 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Now if Obama changes course, acknowledgng the dignity of Americans and responding to our calls for real democracy, we and the world will be in great shape.
Don’t think this administration isn’t working behind the scenes to ensure a Pakistani-style “democracy” in which the people are allowed to vent against a civilian figurehead while the military has all the real power.
P.S. I’ve said before I can’t stand it when Obama wraps himself in progressive iconography, since he is most certainly not a progressive himself. Many people already believe Obama originated the quote, “There’s something in the soul that cries out for freedom.” Ugh.
unless your poor, in the USA, and live somewhere cold, or somewhere hot.
how dignified does someone look wearing a winter coat. inside their home, in the winter?
nice words anyway. sorry dave, I am sick of this man.
Congratulations to the Eypgtian people!
Here’s to you.
I’m way, way past being impressed by this hypocrite’s words and I bet the Egyptians are too.
Z
Obama’s statement was excellent.
Egyptians need Big Oil, GWOT, War on Drugs, Coca Cola, Marlboros, Domestic Surveillance, Giant Agribiz (Frankenfoods by Monsanto), Hexavalent Chromium water, and AT&T administered by Suleiman and the American AIPAC Military Industrial Complex.
This is Democracy. This is Change that can be believed.
And Jack Daniel’s Sour Mash Whisky (Republican Party Donor and major contributor to Mitch McConnell).
Funny, I don’t feel Egyptian. Heh.
Agreed.
Why wasn’t President Obama talking the talk two months ago, when Mubarak was still considered a stable US ally in the so-called war against terror?
Too late.
Fraud!
Egyptians need government subsidized NASCAR racetracks and sports arenas to benefit Egypt’s equivalent billionaires like The Bill France Family, Bruton Smith and Rich DeVoss.
NASCAR, Reagan, America’s billionaires, The NFL and American Military = Democracy.
Rather interesting analysis from Slate’s Fred Kaplan:
http://www.slate.com/id/2284832/
Dont you just love the absolute arroagance and hypocrisy of the american government. Whenever these things happen elsewhere they are quick to laud democracy and people fighting for it. But when it comes to their own country screw the people, corporations and theocracy rule!
Oh im watching the CPAC a bit which if you look at it as a stand up comedy show its not as hard as it might be. Its astonishing how much hypocrosy flows from these people. The Tan man in one sentence would lambaste spending by the democrats and then in the next sentence would talk about how they themselves were going to spend. Huh? The hypocrisy that drives me nuts with these people though is how they talk about small government but then are socially conservative which is all about big government. And of course to them apparently the dubya administration never happened. Apparently for those 8 years the Dims were in fact in charge. Since they seem to need to blame all of the problems that this country has such as the deficit on the Dems.
Haven’t your learned yet to pay attention to what Obama does, not what he says! And if you don’t think the Egyptian army has been back channeling to the US for the last few weeks you are living in a dream world.
Amazing, isn’t it? When Obama was inaugurated, many thought we were getting Lincoln, FDR and JFK rolled into one. Instead, we got W again.
exactly it’s all bs fraud , a true ship of fools.
it was a very rare pleasant surprise seeing egypt turn out ok, i really thought evil washington was talking out of both sides of its corrupt mouth
Hate to interrupt the Crap-On-Obamafest here, but a gent who is somewhat closer to the situation than we are points out a key fact about today’s events in Egypt:
Was du geschlagen–zu Gott wird es dich tragen!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rECVyN5D60I
It certainly is not over yet. Things could still go sideways quit easily.
Don’t you just love the way the U.S. corporate media celebrates the Egyptian revolution without bothering to mention that successive U.S. governments were instrumental in keeping a dictator in power for 30 years?
Actually O aspires to be Reagan.
Indeed. I am drawn to the conclusion that the GOP is less a political party and more a state of mind.
Actually any President could and would have said what Obama said.
By the way, check out this piece from Global Integrity. Let’s hope that the protesters aren’t still marked men (and women, and children) and the Army will let them go home in peace:
I think we should stress the point that when and the Neocons talked about bringing democracy to the Middle East they were not thinking about bringing it to Egypt they were supporting Egypt.
They were talking about Syria, Iran and Iraq. I expect the MSM talking heads to be claiming Bush’s plan worked all this weekend.
I would like at least one token liberal to have something to say as pushback.
Or Undone:)
Wish O would ‘step down’ in the interest of U.S. democracy.
About the “people’s hunger for change,” unlike you, Mr. President, who only pretended to in order to get elected.
Would have been nice if Obama had shown true leadership and come out strongly behind the Egyptian poeple from the start, instead of waffling. Just emphasizes his establishment roots.
…and the peace and security of the world.
Seconded!
I want to hear what the new government will do to create jobs.
I’m not sure what your point is.
Z
Actually, Bush would have diverted troops from Iraq to defend Mubarak — or OKed an Israeli intervention. (Israel would have preferred that we do the dirty work, just as they want us to nuke Iran so we and they get the international pariah status. But not even Bush and the PNAC crowd was that dumb, not after getting burned on Iraq.)
Go here for elaboration.
The words worse President for African Americans very well might be true in 2 more years. If we can find a African American Woman to run against him someone very pro union since government employees are getting fired in all 50 states we might have a shot at taking away 3 of the Dems cornerstones of support.
These issues have been discussed. I know that for a fact, because I have raised such issues myself. (For example, I already posted that events in Egypt contained elements of a coup, revolution and civil war–but I won’t split hairs or repeat myself to bore folks.) It is NOT a ‘Crap-On-Obamafest,‘ however much that’s deserved.
Obama very well might have wanted to send troops to defend Egypt but like Bush if he were still incharge we can’t fight a third war. The World just got confirmation on that fact. I expect American foreign policy is about to get much harder.
More like a state of mental illness. One of the things im finding odd is how many of these people meaning men that they have talking are so obviously gay. Which is probably why they are such extreme social conservatives.
Oh they had an “educator” on that bitched and moaned that his college was forcing politics down the students throats. And of course it was a liberal political ideal. Basically they were teaching students how to think for themselves. No it cant be! The serfs cant be allowed to think for themselves. They might rebel. NO they need to be brainwashed braindead zombies. Which sadly is essentially what most americans are.
Second that.
O has, along with W, made a fool of the U.S. through his fliping remarks over the days & his complete inability to recognize the obvious until after it’s over. And it’s not as though the Egyptians are unaware (even though the U.S.ians are) of how much the Mubarak, under U.S. pressure, has humiliated Egypt to Israel.
Not so.
In June of 2009, Obama gave a remarkable speech in Cairo urging young Egyptians to take charge of their lives, saying:
As such, Obama had a unique standing to congratulate these young Egyptians for their remarkable accomplishment.
http://www.csmonitor.com/Commentary/Opinion/2011/0211/Mubarak-steps-down-Obama-s-a-big-reason-why
Since Jan.20,2009 Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have both worked hard to cloak and seed ignorance of what Israel is doing in Gaza,Arab Jerusalem or across the West Bank.
When will POTUS Obama take on the thugs and death dealers in TelAviv or order Hillary Clinton to stop doing TelAviv’s bidding regarding illegal/criminal Israeli conduct in Gaza,Arab Jerusalem or West Bank?
The raw hipocrisy that Barack Obama is giving voice to here again discredits him and only underlines more completely the duplicity he stands for regarding Israel and the mockery he makes of being a champion or agent of good for Egyptians. Barack Obama displays little or no awareness,empathy or sympathy for what Gazans are enduring at the hand of TelAviv. The fraud of this little speech about Egyptians he gives here is exposed by his lack of doing anything about the wickedness TelAviv is inflicting on the Palestinians.
There is nothing excellent about this being so.
Barack Obama is a liar. He has little credibility to back his smoothly spoken words here.
One more pathetic attempt to portray himself and his WH here as being something it is not.
Has no intention of being.
Will not be.
Double High Authoritarians who are in the closet thus 2 reasons to be mad think Roy Cohen, J Edgar Hoover, Probably Senator McCarthy, Rush X amount of wives no kids. The Conservative movement owes so much to these extremists.
I am sorry, David, I am not impressed by your reaction to Obama’s response. Obama towed the imperial USA line. keeping supporting Mubarak and the shamble supporting the regime until Mubarak resigned. I am so happy Egyptian kept at it until they got part of what they wanted, Mubarak leaving…time will tell if they get most of what they want.
Being gay is politically (and morally) neutral. Believe me. I live in San Francisco, and know many GLBT people very well. They can be wonderful, or not. My point is: Sexuality is irrelevant. I have known many gay men who supported gay rights, when they could be mossback political reactionaries otherwise. Go figure. Well, it’s easy actually: socio-economic standing will always trump mere sex.
(Sidebar: Sex can be bought. Love cannot. Human rights are forever.)
An inconvienent fact that is only mentioned in quick passing if at all….
Even though CNN did show Mubarak’s “tour” with photo-ops with Reagan, Bush I, Clinton, Bush, and even Obama embracing him.
Awful pretty words aren’t they old gold?
Damn I love me some of them pretty words that the fraud says.
Man he sure does have some “unique standing with “us” progressives.
Give me a frikken break.
I can’t keep up. But I did manage to post a few thoughts on Egypt and Palestine.
Bob in AZ
Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Hillary Clinton say Mubarak was something of a close family friend? Didn’t VP Biden say on a recent Sunday news talk-show that Mubarak was not a dictator? And former VP Cheney, didn’t he speak up about Mubarak being a stalwart friend and ally of the US, and freedom, and blah-blah-blah (or words to that effect)?
Who ARE these people, and why do they represent us?
Look at Repressed Gays
Thanks.
What I meant to say.
I have been giving you a frikken break by remaining silent as to the damn foolishness you fevently peddled here for months over John Edwards’ sterling character.
You funny.
Whipping a dead horse is the best you can do.
Last I looked at my calendar it is 2011 and Edwards has been toast for a couple of years.
I could do better. But, I am a person who considers discretion to be the better part of valour.
Last spring was almost a year ago.
Who is the “he” in your sentence. Edwards? Who gives a ff about him anymore, esp what he said a year ago.
Some of us admit when our idols turn out to have feet of clay. Others don’t.
On edit: When I typed this, there was an oldgold in-between. Seems to have disappeared.
***Mod Note: Let’s not go any further down this path.***
Thanks for another reminder of what we are not compared to other people. A country of 80 million people has just liberated themselves from the yoke of a 30 year dictatorship. But let’s not dance in the streets even for a day. Let’s start throwing buckets of cold water over our heads right away!
I listened to the speech on the way down to the country today. It was right on the mark. The man has talent. I just wish he would use it domestically. The scary thing is probably he can`t. He is a very intelligent man. He may know things we only guess, and wish weren`t true but expect they are: that the country is ruled by a nameless elite. The President is a figurehead. If that`s the case, he is working on a thin margin. We just don`t know.
Eagerly awaiting your rebuttal so I can keep up the optimism for another day.
“The best part of this statement is the restraint…”
It’s meaningless. Tomorrow we’ll be back to the same bullshit we’ve been up to for years, no matter what comes out of Obama’s lying mouth.
The great speechmaker strikes again. Can’t wait till he’s gone.
not convinced that the US administration has any leverage to work behind the scenes to impose anything, not after hrc’s championing of torturer in chief, ex spook, suleiman, who, i don’t get the feeling has the support of the egyptian army’s supreme council which now heads an interim government – it’s perfectly prepared to ditch him and his demeanor, when anouncing mubarak’s eventual departure, said it all
both saudi arabia and hrc should take a dose of the red pill – saudi’s desperate brinkmanship at the 11th hour to replace US aid wasn’t to their credit bc they never had the goodies that the egyptian army required – it was hot air
thwe protest movement hasn’t gone home – it’s articulating a political agenda and has formed a disparate and plural front for negotiations towards drawing up a new constitution, romatically entitled, The Unified Leadership of the Youth of the Rage Revolution, – should get beck and fox really worked up
there is no mb representation in the lineup of that group
President O doesn’t need to step down. He needs to step up more and more. I’m proud of the Egyptian people. I think they understand and we understand there’s a long ways to go still. We are still traveling that road from our revolution in this country in the 1960′s. The Egyptian people showed the world they could achieve change in their government through passive resistance, the walk and talk of Dr. Martin Luther King. And we should be proud of them at this moment. Lives were lost and people were injured. Can you imagine what it would have been like if the government had turned on the fire hoses, unleashed the dogs, bombed churches, killed children, and innocent students on a college campus? we have been asking the Obama administration for help in Atlantic Beach, SC. The election was held in November 2009. The winners have still not been seated. And this is not the first time that has happened in SC in recent years in other cities and Atlantic Beach. Tell me again whose going to help the people of Egypt have fair elections. Surely not our President, Jim Clyburn, Lindsay Graham and Jim DeMint.
Giving Obama credit for the uprising cause he gave a speech over 2 years ago is an insult to all the martyrs. Yea , had nothing to do with Tunisia, half-dozen self-immolations, 28 + 2 years of Obama supported torture and abuse. Yea, it was that one speech 2 and half years ago.O wouldn’t say sh-t two days ago, now makes it sound like it was all his idea.Sickening
ever considered the possibility that it dont get better than this in our lifetimes, sorry
Then surely Obama will help the people get back their billion$.
And yet after his Cairo speech, his administration cut Bush’s funding for democracy in Egypt by half; and this indicates that the people knew it, and really didn’t care for it.
And the remaining grants could only go to NGOs approved by Mubarak. Now if you want approve because Obama and his team ‘were trying to mend fences with Mubarak that were broken by Bush’, that’s fine with me. But if we only define a politician by his words instead of his deeds, I think we will always get what we deserve.
Pay attention America! Hey Wolf Blitzer! Scarbrough! Watch Dylan Ratigan’s show; he’s been telling the truth about all this.
(Sorry; end of rant.) ;o)
Funding cuts:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/01/28/obama-cut-egypt-funding_n_815731.html
The statement was excellent, perfect framing with respect to the power of nonviolence exhibited by the Egyptian people in truly brave and remarkable fashion.
The problem is that it totally goes against the speech which Obama gave in accepting his Nobel Peace prize, when he said that he could not be engaged in the kind of rhetoric and action that Martin Luther King devoted his life to, because he was involved in matters of governance. The implication being, sure, nonviolence is fine if you are not running a country.
So, Obama feels free to say one thing and do another, because he is running a country. Well, we saw what that got for Mubarak and Sulieman.
Until Obama stops sending drones to kill defenceless civilians his perfect words are of no account and the free people of the world need give them no weight. They are like that balloon that everyone watched fearing for the boy trapped inside. There is no boy trapped inside. The drones still fly.