Here’s what the President managed to put out regarding the shameless murder of citizens today in Bahrain, Libya and Yemen:
I am deeply concerned by reports of violence in Bahrain, Libya and Yemen. The United States condemns the use of violence by governments against peaceful protesters in those countries and wherever else it may occur. We express our condolences to the family and friends of those who have been killed during the demonstrations. Wherever they are, people have certain universal rights including the right to peaceful assembly. The United States urges the governments of Bahrain, Libya and Yemen to show restraint in responding to peaceful protests, and to respect the rights of their people.
In case you’re coming to this late, we know of at least three dead in Yemen from anti-government protests, with police firing tear gas, rubber bullets, and according to some protesters, live rounds. Libya’s security forces are shooting protesters indiscriminately. And in the most shocking massacre, Bahraini forces from an overhead helicopter fired into a crowd of thousands. There are varying degrees of media access in these countries, so we probably don’t have the full picture. But we know this much: this is a day of blood.
So in response, we get this boilerplate from the White House. It sounds pretty similar to what they said during the Egyptian revolution, and we have no way of knowing what is going on behind the scenes. But we do know that there are varying relationships between the US and these countries. Yemen has emerged as a key ally in counter-terrorism operations, and Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula operates in the country. Bahrain houses a US naval base. Libya, by contrast, is basically an enemy of the US, though not as much in recent years. So the juggling priorities between so-called security interests and respect for human rights is not clear-cut in all three cases.
What ought to be clear-cut is this: a country that massacres its own people deserves no support from a country claiming to be a signal beacon for freedom. And the national security implications of propping up tyrants is actually pretty clear. Juan Cole writes for the Nation:
Many among the demonstrators, whether union organizers, villagers or college graduates, seem to believe that once the lead log in the logjam is removed, the economy will return to normal and opportunities for advancement will open up to all. Somewhat touchingly, they have put their hopes in free and fair parliamentary elections, so that the Middle East may be swinging back to a new liberal period, formally resembling that of the 1930s and ’40s. If these aspirations for open politics and economic opportunity are blocked again, as they were by the hacienda owners and Western proconsuls of the mid-twentieth century, the Arab masses may turn to more desperate, and dangerous, alternatives.
This is the point that the foreign policy mandarins in this country cannot seem to understand. Our support for dictators around the world costs us in terms of national security more than whatever benefit in basing rights or counter-terrorism efforts we assume to get out of it. One would think that the uprisings in Tunisia and Egypt, and these all-too-routine massacres, would change the usual equation somewhat.
Meanwhile, just to bring another voice into this discussion, read Zach Carter and Ryan Grim on Wall Street’s role in the uprisings.
UPDATE: I shouldn’t leave out Djibouti – I should never leave out Djibouti – which has the only US military personnel in all of Africa.




33 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
“AMY GOODMAN: Marwan Bishara, you just came back from Washington, D.C., where you were meeting with think tanks. What is your sense of the Washington consensus understanding versus what you are experiencing in the Middle East?
MARWAN BISHARA: You know, sometimes I forget exactly what are the concepts that are allowed on television or not, but let me just put it this way: they were caught with their pants down, completely. I mean, people in Washington, until today, have not realized exactly what is going on. They’re still trying to play catch-up with what’s going on in the Arab world.
So, for example, I was in one of those brainstorming sessions that tried to talk about what’s next for Palestine and Israel. And what amazes me is that everything that they speak about has an Israel reference to it, because that’s where the correspondents for their main networks are, that’s where their people are, and that’s how they’ve seen the region—Egypt, Palestine and so on—from Israel’s prisms. So, every point of reference is, what did Netanyahu say, or what does Israel think, what would the Israeli lobby consider. Would now, for example, President Obama do this and that, and will the Israeli lobby allow him? What does that mean for our strategic interests in the Middle East? Not understanding that there is a complete sweep that requires not only a change of mindset and, if you allow me here, a change of decision makers, perhaps, or a change of aides in Washington. There’s a complete class of bureaucrats in Washington that are not only not in touch with what’s going on in America, they certainly are not in touch with what’s going on in the Arab world.”
FRom here:
So, I guess it’s too much to expect a little US “gunboat diplomacy” on behalf of the people of Bahrain, Yemen and Libya–particularly Bahrain with an entire fleet sitting right there. “Urging” these ME dictators to “show restraint” in slaughtering their people–gah!
Never misunderestimate David’s sly sense of humor.
I never thought I would despise a politician more than I despised Cheney.
“The situation is very fluid”
“We are deeply concerned”
“Democratic rights must be upheld”
“WTF”
The US has satellites that can count the hairs on your arm, and CIA/military in every nation in the MidEast. Some “experts” say that Washington was caught flatfooted and didn’t see it coming. I say, I have some prime waterfront property to sell in Arizona for a really low price.
Juan Cole this morning points out that they’re also demonstrating in Iraq, with loss of life, but I guess Iraqis don’t count anymore. U.S. has already killed so many innocents, what diff does a few more make.
Sounds like D.C. when Soviet Union fell apart.
This could be a whole post by itself:)
I wish I could get me some of that $80 billion we pay our “intelligence” services.
I am tired of the prez being “deeply concerned.” I would prefer that he kick some a** and stop all this slaughter.
I think this has nothing to do with spooks, who only tell their bosses what they want to hear. This is all about the bosses losing control of situations that they thought they had mastered. And being unwilling to face it.
This is like the Berlin wall falling down the Warsaw pact nations being free and Russia in the end giving up being commies and setting free all those former Soviet Republics. The American CIA had no clue any of that would happen then either.
Saudi Arabia might be the last to fall this time or maybe Iran I have no clue but this could take years not days everyone thinks next week which country will fall next.
But I’m thinking this will take years and it would be nice if the State Dept created a Marshall plan to create jobs and grow food for these people. Or we can just watch civil wars happen in the nations that supply us oil.
The US gov’t is not interested in getting involved in internal matters of other states. Bwahahahahahahahahaha…couldn’t even keep a straight face typing that one!
We are better than they are at predicting things maybe Jane can ask for some Government cash for all of us. Wisdom of Crowds!
All of this leaves the triangulator-in-chief with a problem from Djibouti to Wisconsin.
How on earth do you provide for the corporate interests upon which you figure your next election depends, without completely alienating the base you felt was already in the bag?
I’d guess we’ll see more schizophrenic behavior in the next few months. For the rest of us, buckle-up for some extreme right-wing governance at the state level, “compromise” in the federal sphere. It will be a longer wait, with significant pain, before an actual progressive voice is permitted to emerge at the national level.
As more Americans slowly realize that the dream no longer applies to them, first anger, then hope, then change will emerge. I suspect it will resemble the 1930s.
It will happen. Just not yet. Not with this administration. Our hope for a smoother transition to sanity has been squelched.
Of course not. We are special.
That would require someone with compassion and some testicular fortitude, not the puta madre we currently have.
They did invest all their cash outside of America recently, the higher food prices that helped spark these rebellions I am sure will hit the low wage countries our Elite outsourced our jobs too.
The Elite have made a huge mistake and are afraid that they won’t be able to sell their foreign assets at a price they can repay their $36 for every $1 of collateral bank loans
Given such a choice denial utter denial might be self protection against suicide during the Great Depression stock brokers jumped off of buildings If India or China start to have food related unrest like they are having in the Middle East then WallStreet will collapse.
We are the shining sumptin or other on the hill. /s
We do not live in a manichaeistic world. As such, those who demand clarity, particularly in the short term, are going to be disappointed.
It is now apparent that the US has, for decades, been supplying a number of foreign states with warplanes, tanks, missiles, rockets and other military equipment that have been used for violent internal repression. Egypt, Bahrain and Israel (in Gaza) being just three of the countries now known to have used US supplied armaments to kill civilian demonstrators and/or pro-democracy activists.
America, the world’s most powerful democracy, has clearly been responsible for this reprehensible conduct throughout a number of different administrations including those of both Bush and Obama. The only viable explanation for such self-defeating and undemocratic action by both Republicans and Democrats is that they have succumbed to powerful pressure from politically-motivated, minority lobby groups representing foreign interests, in the House and Senate.
Until the American electorate wakes up to that which is tragically being done in its name, we in Europe, can only look forward to a nuclear-armed world that will eventually explode in our children’s faces, if not in ours.
I don’t think Obama even spoke today. I bet you if you listen to a sound byte of David’s quote in the piece you’ll hear a robotic voice saying “Bahrain, Libya and Yemen”.
They just took the statements he made about Egypt last week and the week before and crudely pasted some new country names in.
Whats this friend request thing I see to my right as I write I click and I get an link to an Xvid link what ever that is but its not compatible with my computer. I take it this is a non FDL related ad of some kind?
That means the same plan that didn’t work last time is in effect which is good the less the WH does the more likely the Arabs will win their revolts. Bahrain can’t keep killing Shia many Persian Shia American fleet or no without Iran feeling they have to get involved.
More Force only works if no foreign press gets hurt or is in the country and the net is down. But more force can’t force people to work.
I advise you not to hold your breath. While what you say is completely true and gawd-awful, this kind of sh*t has been going on for, well, quite a few decades, to say the least, in this nation.
I gave up a loooooooong long time ago hoping that citizens would “wake up” to what’s being done in their name. Frankly, those sentient enough to actually “get it” mostly don’t give a sh*t or are willing to say: rah rah rah… US citizens care about the rest of the world? Not bloody likely. Pass the remote, I wanna watch the football game or find out who Justin Bieber is dating or whether Jennifer Anniston got around to slapping Angelina Jolie yet….
I gave up a loooooooong long time ago hoping that citizens would “wake up”
Wisconsin gives me hope:)
Not exactly. There were people in government generally, CIA specifically, who did actually see that the Soviet Union was collapsing economically. They were ignored in favor of Poppy Bush’s Team B (think WHIG, OSP, and Dick Cheney all rolled into one; hell there’s nice sampling of actual neocons in Team B).
Hard to keep/ramp up Cold War defense budgets if it’s known that your opponent is collapsing.
did Djibouti call show up? :~)
Hey how many people have to die before we really promote democratic values?
Corporate colonialism must come to an end. The American colonies in the Middle-East are rising up because too many years of piss-poor management. Allowing dictators to be he voice of the people because it is economically convenient should no longer be America’s foreign policy.
IOW, if the world was a stable place where people were treated fairly, we probably wouldn’t need all those frickin’ bases.
Hillary and Barry: do they have a whole soul between them?
Obama can’t do anything because he’s as guilty of killing innocent Arabic-speaking people as any government leader in the world!