MADISON, WI (FDL) – While the nation, and this reporter, is transfixed on Wisconsin, another Midwestern state just to the south has a similar battle going on. In Ohio, Republican Gov. John Kasich is trying to restrict and in some cases eliminate public employee collective bargaining in a bill known as SB 5. Unlike Scott Walker’s bill, which has exemptions for public safety employees, Kasich’s bill in Ohio would not exempt police and fire, instead taking away their binding arbitration and the right to strike. This has law enforcement and firefighters up in arms in Ohio, along with public employees across the state. Over 10,000 showed up in Columbus at the state house earlier this week.
I talked to Sen. Joe Schiavoni (D-Youngstown), the ranking member of the Insurance, Commerce and Labor Committee, which has jurisdiction over SB 5. The bill has had hearings in committee but has not yet passed through it, with Republicans vowing changes. Schiavoni told me that there are different provisions in the bill for different types of public employees. Some, including corrections officers, would have all their rights stripped. Teachers would only be allowed to bargain on salary and grievance issues. And police and fire would have their right to strike and binding arbitration taken away. “If you take away the right to strike, Schiavoni said, “you have no bargaining leverage. You have no threat.”
Schiavoni said that Republicans are feeling the heat on this bill. “They don’t have 17 yet or they would’ve passed it already,” referring to the 17 out of 33 votes needed to pass the bill in the State Senate. Republicans control 23 of 33 seats in the upper chamber, but anywhere between 6 and 9 Republicans are either opposed to the bill in its current form, or on the fence. Republicans are working on a substitute bill now, which may include a restoration of bargaining for wages, and they claim they have the votes. But this seems like bluster, as action has been stalled amid the protests.
“I’ve been holding events in my district, we had 1,500 at Youngstown State the other day,” Schiavoni said. “I’m in Miles today, Lorain last night. All the Democrats are holding district events. And we’re telling people, you have our support, let the Republicans know that if they vote for this, they will not have support for their re-election.” He said that many of the Senate Republicans have large numbers of public employees in their districts.
Public employees in Ohio made $250 million in concessions to help balance the budget in 2009, including cuts to their wages. “Our middle class is afraid that they’re being kicked while they’re down,” Schiavoni said. “They gave up $250 million two years ago, and now they want to take away their rights? It’s completely unfair. Public employees didn’t cause these budget problems. We have an $8 billion deficit on a budget due July 1, and we’re wasting our time with this bill to take away worker’s rights.”
The overhaul of collective bargaining in Ohio, much like Wisconsin, could put federal transportation money in jeopardy, costing the state much of its $171 million annual haul. So this hardly has anything to do with the budget. Instead, it’s part of a pattern of new right-wing governors taking advantage of their opportunities to force through ideological policy they have long sought.
What’s happening in Wisconsin is, instead, a power grab — an attempt to exploit the fiscal crisis to destroy the last major counterweight to the political power of corporations and the wealthy. And the power grab goes beyond union-busting. The bill in question is 144 pages long, and there are some extraordinary things hidden deep inside [...]
don’t expect either Mr. Walker or the rest of his party to change those goals. Union-busting and privatization remain G.O.P. priorities, and the party will continue its efforts to smuggle those priorities through in the name of balanced budgets.
The Wonk Room printed a list of the 10 worst policies inside the Wisconsin budget repair bill, and similarly, under the guise of the budget in Ohio, John Kasich is aiming to implement a severely ideological anti-union policy.
Sen. Schiavoni believes that this extreme behavior has lit a fire in the public and particularly among public employees nationwide. We’re seeing the stirrings of a labor revival, in Ohio, Wisconsin and across the country. “What a coincidence that it’s happening in these states with Republican takeovers, right,” said Schiavoni.




19 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
GOP: All ALEC, all the time.
Thanks DDay.
OT, even Gov. Dropout’s acolyte, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel admits he never campaigned on breaking the unions: In the turbulent wake of his controversial plan to sharply curtail collective bargaining rights, Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker has faced criticism that he gave no warning of such a dramatic plan during the long 2010 governor’s race.
David, this is slightly offtopic but maybe not in connection with the false Koch phone conversation – over at counterpunch.org I have just read an article by David Lindorff to the effect that the Pakistani prisoner Davis had connections with terrorist organizations so could well have been engaged in disrupting legitimate protest there, or at the very least attempting to infiltrate those organizations. Now he is in a peck of trouble with the authorities there, and hopefully this kind of under the radar manipulation will be seen in future as without merit. We thought it came to an end with the end of the Bush era. How wrong we were.
The tangles of complicity which lie behind acts of violence, hopefully not any longer to be attempted in this country, make these very dangerous times in which our only hope is to restore a democracy answerable to the people, and not to those who supposedly can wave a magic wand over the economy while getting mighty rich in the process. It ain’t gonna work; people have had enough.
Rescued from 2 threads down…
Folks should realize that several national one day strikes and work slowdowns will be necessary to put a stop to this nonsense. We’re long past the time when mere rallies will have any effect. The moment Walker signs the Union busting bill into law, no interstate trucker should exceed 40 mph on any highway in the US.
The only thing that workers can do to retain their dignity against the bosses, is to withhold their labor and their commerce.
Sadly this should have happened when Reagan shut down PATCO. It’s probably too late now.
We should all pause and reflect for a moment that most of these GOP takeovers of state houses and legislatures are in large part a result of Obama destroying the Democratic party brand and suppressing progressive turnout in 2010.
Gov. Scott “Dropout” Wanker Walker, unwitting savior of unions, liberals and progressives.
Couldn’t have said it better myself. We have Obama to thank for this mess.
Curious. What did progressives think would happen? Everyone knew states were virtually bankrupt 2-3 years ago. Even the few progressive-known economists said as much. Then, tax cuts, tax cuts, tax cuts. What did you all think was going to happen? You thought states would somehow try to balance their budgets without…increasing taxes…or cutting. Where would they cut? OF course they are going to cut middle class! They sure as heck aren’t going to increase taxes on the rich, after the last 3 years of kabuki of how it was going to turn the economy around. The blogs are all exploding on this union attack, like somehow this is a surprise? Who else are the states going to use to get their budgets resembling order? The rich? Please. They just spent 3 years convincing everyone that they needed these tax cuts. See a circle? This is just the start. Wait until California jumps in. And New York. And everywhere else where the books don’t balance.
Forgive me if this sounds naive or if I’m just totally missing something here, but what the hell ever happened to workers striking?
But didn’t he tell us this during his campaign?
I sent him an e-mail and asked that he put on the shoes and get himself to Madison. I’m sure it will happen. s/
Since *when* did it become accepted that pols campaign on one platform to get elected only to govern from a (radically) different platform?
I don’t care what the excuse is … campaign consultant mumbo-jumbo, deficits, bipartisanship, or budget emergencies brought about by tax cuts (not mentioned in the campaign for election).
On this level Barack Obama and Scott Walker are cut from the same cloth.
They are liars. It’s lying.
Good idea, ghost. I did it, too.
David, thanks so much for staying with this!
There was a guy today with a sign that had shoes attached, it said “Obama, here are your comfortable shoes, come on down.”
They’re running for president, showing their bonafides, angling for the Kock-brother $$. Walker, Kasich, want to be known as the union-slayers to further their political careers.
I’m curious why you think progressives here didn’t think that exactly this would happen. You post here all the time; you know how people here feel and think. Sure we all knew this is pretty much what would happen when Obama set about to destroy what was left of the former “Democratic” party.
Just bc this is pretty much what I expected, though, doesn’t mean I’m not going to still be outraged.
I dunno, though, perhaps it’s going to take this to awaken the majority of the US populace from their long slumber. Then again: who knows. All we can do is keep on keeping on.
Gee, you wouldn’t think that a strong labor state like Ohio would allow this to happen but, as with Wisconsin, I’d be shocked if the reason for the GOP takeover couldn’t be traced directly to the un- and underemployed voting against their own interests and most likely creating scapegoats (teh gays, teh jooze, teh mooslims, teh other-unlike-me-lazy unemployed) to blame for their problems. It almost makes me wish they get what they voted for, but I can’t abide punishing the innocent victims who would be created.
Once again, here are responses to your comments:
1. Do not assume electronic voting machines accurately record the intended votes of the citizens- no matter how honest a Secretary of State is- voting machines are hackable at many stages in the process and they are. (planes fall from the sky)
2. Low turnout means the level of fraud necessary is small and less obvious- the Tea Party screamers were primed to create the allusion that there are more delusional voters than our society actually has.
3. Campaigns filled with repetitive lies, hate-mongering and fueled by massive amounts of money from invisible sources serve as effectively as guns to keep people from the polls.
4. It is our job to find the circles of unity that will bring all thinking, caring Americans together to save the environment and our culture. This drive for unity has begun.
Now every category of people includes some who are lazy, some who are stupid, some who are dishonest, even some who are evil, while most are careful and industrious, intelligent and good, but the GOP seem to choose as leaders those that are not all that good (and after Obama, I am beginning to think the same of the Dems).
The Dems refuse to chose an adversary and rally progressives – they tried with health care, and then ran from real change as they obeyed the corporations that contribute to their campaigns. Given the fact that Dems are cheap whores, small contributions kill progressive values, as those same companies – the Dems natural adversaries – give twice as much to the GOP.
But the GOP does not have that problem – they can chose adversaries and not worry about a few pro-GOP unions (or protect the police that supported the GOP while screwing all other unions as is being done in Wis – so much for union solidarity). Ronald Reagan had his “welfare queens,” Rudy Giuliani had his criminals and “squeegee men,” and now Chris Christie, Walker, and the GOP has the public-sector unions that refuse to get out of politics and support the wrong party.
Now police/fire pensions have gotten silly, as has overtime in final years counting as part of final salary for the pension – and every major city has run a piece every 3 months over the past 15 years on some ridiculous pension being awarded – indeed on some “disabled chief’s award” being approved as it notes he has been hired as the chief in the next town over. But the Teachers and other public sector unions have non of these benefits and thus non of the PR problems.
Do Dems continue to support “all unions” – even police unions that have turned on us and sold out to the GOP so as to keep 6 figure early retire at 60 based on overtime given for the purpose of upping the pension? We need to support unions – but we also need to acknowledge what is making the “public sector unions” such an easy target for the GOP. Sadly, the unions are the last offset to the corporations in the donation wars (3 of the top ten were unions donating to Dems – the other 7 where corporations donating to the GOP).
The GOP have taken the media – and now want to defund the Dems – and it will work unless we get ahead of the GOP regarding reform of police/fire pensions. Indeed taking away all rights except as to limited raise bargaining is the way chose to attack those pensions. I am not sure how we – Dems/left – win this one for our friends in the unions. Someone suggested national strikes – but with only 7% in unions and a media determined to ignore, it is hard to see how that will have any impact without the use of violence – and I do not want violence.
I hope someone has some ideas.