The military airdrops of seawater onto the Fukushima Daiichi plant continued throughout the day today, and Tokyo Electric Power Co. was nearing completion on a new power line that would restore the cooling systems in the reactors. The outlook remains bleak after a week of crisis, but Japanese officials appear to have settled on a plan to best avert a nuclear disaster.
However, the focus on events at Fukushima Daiichi belie the apparently woeful response to the crisis created by the companion natural disasters that have killed at least 10,000 and left up to a half a million homeless. Japanese bureaucracy is typically efficient and competent, but the magnitude of this disaster has left them flailing. There are mass shortages of basic supplies, including food, water and gasoline, in the northeast where the earthquake and tsunami struck. Several towns have been without power for five days. And the problem does not appear to be a lack of funds but a lack of planning and organization.
But the state, overwhelmed by problems, has abdicated some of its most basic duties, some say. “The government is not doing anything. They are not present here,” said Akase Hiroyuki, the principal of Ishinomaki’s Nakazato Primary School. Along with 20 of his teaching staff, he runs a shelter for 1,200 people left homeless and hungry by the tsunami. Classrooms serve as dormitories, and the school’s gymnasium has become a food-distribution center.
When Emperor Akihito made a rare television address on Wednesday, his soothing words were not heard in Ishinomaki: No one has watched TV since power failed Friday.
Foreign governments and charities have pledged money and sent a few rescue teams to Japan, but fear of exposure to radiation and uncertainty over what they can accomplish has limited their role. A German medical aid group pulled out after barely 24 hours in Japan.
Some have laid the blame on the doorstep of the feckless Japanese leadership. The country has had five Prime Ministers since Jonichiro Koizumi ended his reign in September 2006. The Japan Democratic Party just got into power last year after a nearly unbroken string of 50 years of rule by the Liberal Democratic Party. According to the New York Times, the career bureaucrats haven’t worked well with this new regime, and that is crippling the country in a time of crisis.
Experts consider this a leadership vacuum. I would also add that this smacks of elite failure. The bureaucrats may not have the benefit of strong leadership, but if they are failing to issue orders because of internecine rivalries and turf wars, it seems just petty. Furthermore, Japan is notorious for tightly controlling the flow of information to the citizenry; it’s why I’ve been skeptical from the beginning of their claims about the nuclear accident, and it could explain why other countries have been so slow to come to their aid. They’ve also basically outsourced control over power lines and rolling blackouts to industry, creating disruptions without warning or explanation. The people, already battered by the horror of the cascading events, are now just plain angry. It’s as if they’ve awoken to find their government less a protector or model of competence than a collection of bumbling fools.
I know how they feel.




81 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Sound like the Japanese Govt. is as useless as the USA Govt. when it comes to disaster response.
this is exactly how the USG responded or didn’t respond to the BP disaster.(which by the way is still a disaster, for the Gulf Coast, the corporate MSM left, but the problems still remain)
the Japanese are having their good job brownie moment now.
govt. by corporations for corporations has a serious flaw, it is not people friendly.
Of course! The Nihonjin have emulated the American system in every way and therefore their response is no better than the US response to Katrina. If there isn’t money to be made, a profit to be turned, then they just aren’t interested in recovery efforts.
Heckuva job Browniesan
” A collection of bumbling fools”, you say. Gee that sounds vaguely familiar. I think we got some of that?
Radzilla is taking giant thundering steps towards Tokyo but the soothing message from the energy industry captured government officials never changes.
This is one more dramatic example of what happens when you turn (what we once called government responsibility) responsibility for the peoples’ essential needs to those who seek profit and are accountable only to the money lenders. Nope. The invisible hand doesn’t push to good things for all. It pushes to insane risk for gold.
That quote needs to go on t-shirts and sold as FDL gear. It would be a best seller.
I’d imagine Xe is standing by to go in and shoot looters (for a hefty fee). The free market is prepared!
Definitely no firm hand on the rudder of this ship of state.
We’re watching a new civil war in America which hasn’t been declared. Bush wanted to run “merika as a corporation and now it IS a corporation.
I just saw Lamar Alexander on MSNBC pontificating about noocluar power and that we wouldn’t change our path to destruction because ” we have better technology now” ( even as Tokyo Electric is going to build two in Texas)
Does anyone think we “have better technology now?”
Meanwhile a very Zen guy was telling Americans that we “have nothing to worry about from fallout from Japan” while I found this bone:
World food supply threatened by Japan nuclear radiation
And, as far as I know, Obama is playing golf….in a tie, no less
Yup. That’s about right. I wonder if the Japanese bumbling elite fools are simply incompetent like the 65 year old American teabagger that can’t understand the world anymore. Or maybe they’re mendacious, cavalier, greedy AND incompetent like our elites are.
Inquiring minds want to know. If souls existed, would we characterize these clowns as having them? Or are they like the sociopaths at the top of our pyramid – cruel, disdainful of anything that isn’t lining the pockets of the rich and unconcerned with human outcomes?
Planning for such enormous disasters is not easy and very expensive and there is a calculus made as to what is reasonable and acceptable preparedness.
Clearly the authorities were overwhelmed by the events and rather than immediately call for all the international help they could get and move into a more humanistic mode for handling the crisis… they chose to tough it out and not act “vulnerable” and ask for the help that could have saved some lives.
Why they were peddling this nuclear disaster as manageable under THOSE circumstances is a sign of gross negligence. It’s easy to be an armchair quarterback… but this WAS an emergency of mammoth proportions and it should not have been handled by a private interest when so many millions of lives are in the balance.
Privatization for profit will lead to this sort of failure of societies and governments to fulfill its most basic function: to protect and foster the well being of the people.
That’s right. There was a time when it seemed this country could keep business and profits in perspective. Now we are fucking nuts about it. Almost anything business wants and “needs” , it gets.
interesting, I was just thinking this morning how fortunate we are this is not happening here with the lack of leaders and the incompetence we have. I dito the bumbling fools. Can anyone stand to listen to what comes out of Washington anymore? I heard last night on the news, this will very likely become global and there is no way we can trust our leaders. They are so petty.
“all energy sources have their downside …. we saw that with the Gulf spill.”
Who said this?
Bush? No
Palin? No
Obama? Yes
Obama is clearly on a mission to become the worse USA president ever.
Link Below:
http://journals.democraticunderground.com/Better%20Believe%20It/823
“Recall that it was Obama himself who in October 2009 celebrated Japan as the model for nuclear power expansion: “There is no reason why, technologically, we can’t employ nuclear energy in a safe and effective way. Japan does it and France does it, and it doesn’t have greenhouse gas emissions. …”
Obama is also trying to move beyond Bush STUPID, he wants to conquer PALIN Stupid. :) In Obama mind being as dumb as Bush is not good anymore, he wants to be as dumb as Palin, he thinks this will set him a part from the pack.
Coming soon, Obama will try to see if he can be as dumb as Glenn Beck :)
The Grand Unified Field Solution for this problem: As Sun Tzu says, avoid being in this predicament in the first place.
How? http://www.solarroadways.com
Turn our pavement into solar panels, and we have three times as much power as we’ve ever used.
And before you say it can’t be done, guess what? The Dutch are already doing it with bike paths:
http://iblockthebikelane.com/2011/02/03/amazing-dutch-bike-path-embedded-with-solar-panels/
“Privatization for profit….. ”
Yep.
It never ceases to astound me the amount of energy people, from all walks and spectra, put into naysaying. “Never” is far too long a word for me.
Already is, imo.
What needs to be done in the immediate term is NOT playing golf.
It is shutting down all 23 U.S. nuclear plants that are the same design as the ones in crisis in Japan. It is passing laws that make it a crime to build a nuclear power plant. It is shutting down all discussions of giving taxpayer funded loan guarantees to future nuclear power plants. Without the guarantees, no plants can be built as no insurance companies are stupid enough to ensure them. Remove limits on the liabilities of the corporations that own nuclear power plants.
The Germans have intelligent leadership
Germany will ‘exit’ nuclear power industry, Merkel vows
http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/03/17/germany-will-exit-nuclear-power-industry-merkel-vows/
BERLIN (AFP) – Chancellor Angela Merkel vowed Thursday that Germany would speed up the transition to renewable energy as Europe’s top economy mulled a “measured exit” from nuclear power after the events in Japan.
Chancellor Angela Merkel has more common sense in her pinky finger than OBAMA has in his entire body.
Chancellor Merkel views what is happening in Japan and says, Nuclear Power bad idea
Obama views the Nuclear Meltdown taking place in Japan and says all energy sources have a downside, and continues to move the USA toward Nuclear Power.
So much for Harvard being a place of higher learning.
and just how do you say ‘heckuva job, Brownie’ in Japanese.
I see Margaret tried first.
In Texas, we are being threatened with a number of new nuclear power plants: two more in the South Texas Nuclear Project (part owner would be TEPCO of Japanese infamy), two others in Victoria County (proposed by Excelon, longtime campaign contributer (aka briber) of Obama).
According to google translator: 仕事のブラウニーのヘック
(hopefully the characters will display)
You can’t translate that into Nihongo because it wouldn’t convey the true meaning or irony of that phrase.
Given how far and wide radioactivity can spread, nuclear power should not be tolerated worldwide.
So wtf is Obama doing? Is it just campaign contributions? Is it a desire to hide nuclear weapons manufacturing?
It’s clearly a blatant disregard for humanity.
Based on the comments from the nuclear industry and advocates during this crisis, I wouldn’t let them design a dog house.
hey skepticdog, i can see where you’d take dog house design personally.
Obama is a lawyer, not a scientist. He must rely on his advisers for information. A tightly controlled group of greedy industry insiders.
This statement seems to have a vaguely familiar tone. I remember something very similar to this, but I just can’t quite put my finger on it. Let me think…
It’s so Republicans will really, REALLY like him! Obama turned out just as I suspected at first he would: NOT ready for prime time. I forgot the first lesson of test taking: Your first response is usually your best one. Don’t second guess yourself.
I don’t do konji. ;)
Obama is a disaster of epic proportions. It’s rather sad on so many levels and especially for the African American community who supported him and who could have produced a leader on the level of MLK and produced one on the level of GWB. Many in the black community are pissed at this deception and lost opportunity… not to mention the pale skinned folks out there.
This doesn’t bode well for the future. The few who show a spark of sensibility have a ice cube’s chance in hell to have any impact. This ship is going down.
ALL of whom HE picked!
“i know how they feel”
me, too.
“elite failure” – that sounds like an interesting concept. i haven’t run across it before.
Oh please, he was SUPPOSED to be listening to a team of rivals so he would get the FULL spectrum of thoughts on a topic.
That too was marketing hype.
Why do you hate America?
The same is true for the MOTU business “leaders” in the US. They can only see out as far as the end of the next quarter. Deliver bottom line…and the devil take the foremost…
Obama, it is my understanding, gave Tokyo Electric a deal to build 2 nuclear power plants in Texas and is now NOT backing away from the deal!!
I only do google.
Precisely. “Sustainability”? Dunno. Too many syllables for me…..
Nah, we just need to have Goldman turn it into a profit and presto, it’s american.
“collection of bumbling fools” – Perfect! I have no idea why at least half of our elected officials are not intelligent but it appears the dumbing down of America has affected all social levels. I would say 95% of our elected officials are very low-IQ types completely lacking in logical thought processes (and absolutely no integrity or principles).
Were they not so tragic, the pics of choppers dumping water – and reports that they are mostly missing the reactors – would be comical.
What is comical is our foolhardy acceptance of the “need” for this “technology” in the first place. In less than a year’s time two “proven” power sources have caused us to shit where we eat – on a grand scale.
And now, idiots like Bill Richardson and Jim Woolsey are calling for still more environmental diarrhea, but this time where we won’t be able to see it happening: underground.
Ah yes, “natural” gas – that’s the ticket.
Until, of course, flames shoot from faucets.
David,
Based on reporting at AC 360 on CNN last night, I think focus on failures of Japanese officials and bureaucracy might be a little off. A big part of the problem seems to be that the government is being blinded (lied to) by the company that runs the Fukushima facilities.
From what I’ve been able to gather, the blame falls far more on TEPCO (Tokyo Electric Power Company, Incorporated), which is acting a lot like BP did during the Deepwater Horizon oil spill last year.
Unfortunately, they do what they’ve been hired to do by the people who pay to put them in power. As Michael Moore said, it’s time to get up off the sofa.
Too many of them big, fancy, liberal-elite college words in there for ‘em…
I don’t even try, especially since from my long ago childhood, I realize that there is on such thing as ‘Japan’ in English, as to them it’s Nipponese.
Tepco took 6 days to get power back to one of its own main facilities from their own grid. And as you would guess it would have been the highest priority despite what may appear as incompetence at the company (which is probably to a great extent true) it is probably a function of difficulty of the job.
The scale of current problems is just too big for things to go quickly. Half million people suddenly homeless and dispersed with the grid, roads, rail, and telephone in tatters.
It will take a while to get things fixed. However, contrary to your belief leadership got nothing to do with it. As long as no great mistaken decisions are made or forced, things will work out fine. This is very different from the way things are expected to work in a command structure such as found in the USA.
The rolling blackout does almost resemble an act of Enron, though.
democracy now, as usual, outstanding coverage of this.
Interview in Japan on CBC television yesterday, showed survivors at some sort of shelter, they told the CBC journalist that they have been
abandoned to die, by their government.
Natural gas doesn’t produce soot, so people call it “clean” but it still produces energy by combustion, which is defined as the process of combining a substance with oxygen to produce heat, and therefore it still produces copious amounts of C02. “Soot” is a much safer form of carbon it turns out as it’s sequestered carbon. In this case “clean” is true only by the most superficial of standards but what do we expect from a nation obsessed with Charlie Sheen’s latest binge or Lindsey Lohan’s latest felony?
Wrong. It’s Nihon (The country), Nihonjin (the people) and Nihongo (the language, culture, etc) “Nippon” is just another example of European colonials arrogantly renaming them to suit their language.
Wow, TEPCO’s spokesman… right here at FDL…
How did we get to “Japan” when the “Japanese” call it Nihon?
Nihon is the less elite word. Sorry. Now off to get garden soil so the veggies here will be locally grown.
Right.
And the crap they are pumping into the ground to force the shale to break – literally anything caustic on which they can lay their hands – is
almostcompletely beyond belief.Project much, dday?
To me, it appears that our media and dday are projecting their anger at the Bush/Obama failures to address US past crises at Japanese government officials. It looks to me like the Japanese are assisting their citizenry a thousand times better than we helped NOLA during Katrina/Rita and Gulf coast residents during the BP oil slick. Does this mean everyone in Japan is immediately safe and sound after such a massive ongoing catastrophe? Hardly.
Talk about abdicating responsibility to industry? WTF? Who are you accusing again?
I know that the suffix “ese” doesn’t even exist in the language.
I can’t answer that question. Maybe that’s something Dutch? I just don’t know.
Wtf? It’s like Dubya’s come to say, “Brownie, you’re doing a heck of a job.”
Meanwhile, just as we saw last year during the Deepwater Horizon oil spill, this is what happens when the experts are working to increase the profits of corporations and greedy a$$holes rather than for the common good.
When there’s a disaster, government officials don’t have much ability to deal with it.
Nihon in kanji: 日本
Dai ichi Winter – a not-quite-haiku
Burned with
spent decay
futile
spray by pen
du
lous
thugs
we
die
like sheep.
Who? The morons who think it’s a good idea to privatize every-eff’ing-thing so that experts are working to increase the profits of corporations and greedy a$$holes rather than for the common good and so that, when there’s a disaster, government officials don’t have much ability to deal with it.
Btw, who kept saying that putting nuclear reactors in Fukushima was safe and bullshitted their way through safety inspections again and again?
Yes. Business for profit has so consumed the normal functions of government that in Japan the government is irrelevant as to how to deal with the greatest danger to the state and its people. Just as our government and its pronouncements had little relevant function in the BP/Gulf oil disaster.
Smaller government, out of the way of the players. Just the way the sociopaths in the money business want it.
You nailed it!
very sorry for Japanese citizens, along with the rest of the planet.
I thought all those Galt-Randians said that if the market was “free & unfettered” in the perfect utopia of capitalism, then the magicaly mythical “market” would “take care of,” uh, “everything.”
Yoo HOOOO!! Earth to “Market”!!! Japan neeeeds your help now!!! Knock knock! “Market” – are you listening, Market??? WHERE ARE YOU MARKET????
Where’s Godzilla when we need him? Perhaps Godzilla could be trained to, I don’t know, do his business on the reactors to make it stop, or something?? Might be about as useful a solution as the fumblings and bumblings of the elites, per usual.
Tepco is a utility company, and not a very good one at that. Government is something else. If you watch any of the pressers, Tepco is typical Japanese company the higher the position in the organization the less relevant you are to substance of the operation. That’s why the press conferences appear chaotic. Government press conferences differ in that they appear as though there is a focus of responsibility and power. This is also far from the real picture. The big difference is that no one has the executive power enjoyed by the elites in America, especially in mature (non-family) organizations. The question of heck of a job Brownie do not manifest when it is assumed that a good portion of those in responsibility are there for prestige and not for substance. In any case they do not get rewarded so well either, so its ok.
Do you all think the more ordinary voters could be beginning to notice this massive paradigm failure of the Randnuts and the Invisible hand? Please! Good writers our there, put the message together and spread it. I can’t think of a better time.
This is the result of the wealthy, who want government to be run by idiots so they can abuse the system, and the fault of the people, who debate which idiot is less bad each election cycle and allow themselves to be distracted by nonsense rather than eject all the idiots and all the stupidity from their government.
For goodness sakes, we’ve been without power at times for a week after a snowstorm or hurricane in this country. And both are minor compared to what has happened in Japan. The debris piles are 10 ft. deep in some areas. Electric company trucks can’t just drive down the road – there is no road! The amount of devastation is mind boggling without considering the nuclear melt down threat. No matter how much man power or equipment you have you cannot clear a way to deliver water, food, etc overnight. The horror and misery will go on for a long time there.
Looks like you’re paid by the word. Is it your job to come to sites like this one to calm people by means of spouting a lot of reasonable sounding bs?
YYSydie, you’re doing a heck of a job.
Your calm analysis does nothing to advance understanding of just how badly the system has functioned to create this mess or of just how badly it’s functioning in fixing it to avoid further disaster.
Cool article Phoenix Woman! I guess we would have to teach the plows not to run over the bike lanes here in Minneapolis,..maybe sweepers. They plow the commuter trails every morning, so maybe a different sort of plow could be used on them. Glass could be manufactured with a rough surface, (and ice is slippery anyway and we ride it all winter). Actually I used a photovoltaic laminate on the roof of the Science House at he Science Museum of Minnesota, and it had a rough surface. Nice to see something encouraging in an otherwise dismal news day!
BTW I love the accompanying photo with the car driving in the bike lane.
Maybe TEPCO (Tokyo Electric Power Company, Incorporated) should reimburse the government for all costs of the clean up.
Maybe TEPCO should reimburse all businesspeople whose small businesses they’ve seriously harmed or totally ruined.
Maybe TEPCO should pay survivors for their losses.
Maybe TEPCO should pay for reconstruction.
Cohen wrote this song in his album “The Future” in 1990. The whole album is amazing
I guess it really is true that artists are the shamans of our cultures. No wonder fascism doesn’t like existing artists, especially poets;
give a listen if you like:
Leonard Cohen – Anthem
Wall Street will not invest in nuclear power. Bush/Obama need to supply $50 billion in government loan guarantees.
Bush gave the nuclear power industry free government insurance in the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (which is an extension of the 1957 Price-Anderson Act – which was supposed to fill a ten year gap where nuclear power would demonstrate it’s safety record, private insurance would see all the profit to be made in insuring nuclear power plants and free government insurance would no longer be necessary. By 1967, private insurance wanted nothing to do with nuclear power and the government give-a-way continues.
The free market (investment banks & insurance compaines) has spoken on nuclear power – No Thank’s!
To support nuclear power is to oppose the free market.
I found an interesting past article where back in november it was un covered that obama had taken back 6 billion in solar and wind money and now he wants 36 billion for nuclear. Pretty obviously he pimped himself out. I continue to wonder if these guys have a plan for another planet or they just don’t give a shit about their children.
I think the CEO’s and lobbyist of Tepco should now be in the plants working to resolve this issue along with the anonymous ABC WH source. We need to get a list ready for our country for the top CEO’s and money makers pushing this shit for when we need inside the plant people to work on fixing what they have done.
That’s not how it works. We fund the development. We fund the construction. We pay the electric bills and the caculated profit to the energy corps. We pay for the storage of the waste. We pay for the clean-up from leaks. We pay for health care to band-aid lives damaged by same. We pay for disaster management when something goes wrong. Notice a trend here? Have some cake.
This is the important point–government will force nuclear power onto the USA, and so-called free market conservatives will say nothing.
holding hands singing kumbaya in paraguay? aw, the whole thing is just so disgusting.
The Dutch traders I believe were the ones who got the spelling/sound of the word Japan into parlance.
Maximization for profit means nickle and diming on the margins, which reduces quality and drives up risk. The nickles and dimes are too small to notice, and if somebody makes a stink, they are considered paranoid sticklers with no common sense. This is why public services should never be outsourced to private enterprise. The incentives all go the wrong way, privatize the profit and socialize the risk. It’s a feature, not a glitch in the system.
The reason for all you lurking Galtians out there, is because the scale economies in the provision of public services and their often location-specific quality make them natural monopolies. So your God of Competition has no entry there to ‘keep everybody honest.’
See my post on a previous thread. TEPCO lied about its safety inspections in 2002. The Committee set up to reconsider the safety standards in the late 1990s was overwhelmingly dominated by nuclear company lobbyists. The one honest scientist resigned because they lowered the safety threshold to Richter Scale 6.5.
LOL.
Another biting, caustic line from the author of “Vichycrats”.