Just as US Tomahawk missiles rain down on another Muslim nation, we’re about to give the entire Muslim world another reason to distrust and even hate Americans. A cache of photographs published by Der Spiegel show an Army Stryker “kill team” in Afghanistan posing with dead bodies they recently killed. Many of the members of this team are already under trial for, among other things, the murder of the Afghans in the photos.
Some of the activities of the self-styled “kill team” are already public, with 12 men currently on trial in Seattle for their role in the killing of three civilians.
Five of the soldiers are on trial for pre-meditated murder, after they staged killings to make it look like they were defending themselves from Taliban attacks.
Other charges include the mutilation of corpses, the possession of images of human casualties and drug abuse [...]
An investigation by Der Spiegel has unearthed approximately 4,000 photos and videos taken by the men.
The magazine, which is planning to publish only three images, said that in addition to the crimes the men were on trial for there are “also entire collections of pictures of other victims that some of the defendants were keeping”.
These are not the pictures that President Obama tried to block in 2009, because the incidents from this Army Stryker unit Der Spiegel describes in their story are from 2010. So the change in commanders-in-chief has not occasioned a halt to atrocities and war crimes in Afghanistan. While Der Spiegel may publish only three photographs for now, I wouldn’t be surprised if more became available. But there’s plenty of detail in the article, according to the Guardian account, to cause outrage in Afghanistan and throughout the world as well, in addition to the photos. In one incident, a staff sergeant threw a grenade at an Afghan civilian, killing him, then cut off a finger and took a tooth as trophies.
I cannot find the article as of press time at the Der Spiegel website. But the pictures are available here, here and here. The AP names the soldiers in the photos holding the corpse by the hair, as well as the corpse:
One shows a key defendant, Specialist Jeremy N. Morlock of Wasilla, Alaska, grinning as he lifts a corpse’s head by the hair. Der Spiegel identified the body as that of Gul Mudin, whom Specialist Morlock claims to have killed with Pfc. Andrew H. Holmes in Kandahar Province. Another shows Private Holmes, of Boise, Idaho, lifting the same corpse by the hair.
“Today Der Spiegel published photographs depicting actions repugnant to us as human beings and contrary to the standards and values of the United States Army,” the Army said in a statement released by Col. Thomas Collins. “We apologize for the distress these photos cause.”
As I said, the men in this Stryker unit have been charged with murder and conspiracy, and not after the publication of these photos, but well before. In fact, the photos were part of evidence being used in those court-martial cases, and were kept by the judge under a protective order until the Der Spiegel publication. That makes this a slightly different situation than Abu Ghraib.
But that difference is fairly subtle given the depictions involved. This brutality adds to the long list of actions that can be used to inflame passions in the Muslim world. It makes any talk by the United States of a humanitarian mission to protect civilians ring extremely hollow. And it is a natural consequence of a long and confusing war, with untold pressures put on soldiers that often manifest in despicable ways.
These activities can no longer be seen as coincidental or the result of a “few bad apples” in the military. They have happened so often, with such regularity, as to be a by-product of a war machine that continues to invade and occupy foreign countries.
UPDATE: It’s strange. I’ve now found a story ABOUT the article in Der Spiegel on the Der Spiegel website, but not the article itself.




85 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
David,
Here is an article you may want to take a look at…after reading the snippets from AP, it triggered recollection of this article.
I have to question the intelligence of people who continue to take these types of pictures, given how frequently these types of pictures wind up becoming public.
Yeppers, dude. You’d also have to question the intelligence of someone that joins the military.
America’s military, where those not smart enough for college or trade school go for a dental plan, a chance to see the world, experience beautiful ancient cultures, and then destroy them for fun and profit.
I take some comfort in knowing that that “kill team” was charged with their crimes BEFORE this became public. Even though I know that there are similar teams still out there, operating under orders so their actions will never see the light of day.
Boxturtle (The difference between a murderer and a hero is nothing more than operating orders)
Let’s walk that back a bit if you please. As a veteran myself, there are all sorts of reasons to join the military. While the last decade has not been positive or pleasant for those serving, realize that many folks over in irak and Afghanistan are members of the National Guard and Reserves who got pulled into things against their will.
Barbarians!
This is not the Marine Corp that I grew to admire. This is a totally sick and mismanaged gang of perverted minds.
They are acting as part of a military culture that is oblivious of any context that produces your comment. They are unconscious and unaware. I would like to know what they cay about Geneva Conventions and what happened to what they were taught about them. Perhaps the nature, intent, and result of the training on Geneva Conventions has changed subtly (or not so …) such that they are able to somehow dismiss the conventions or rationalize this despicable behavior.
Those of us who are concerned about truth and human rights knew there was a wider problem. That leads directly to the mistreatment of one of our own. It’s been more than a few bad apples for a long time. More people will know now.
And how long before “state secrets” kicks in to toss a blanket on this?
Is der Spegel already being pressured?
This is all really bad news. Where else is this happening? Absolutely NO reason NOT to think it’s not happening everywhere. And it could happen to Manning as well: why not?
Semper Fidalis?
OooRah! Not much.
The dearth of these kinds of photos available to the public to graphically force us to admit how screwed up these campaigns are, is a testiment to the efficiency of the military’s ability to cover them up and the complicity of our short-leashed, willfully impotent media. Like Dick said during the first gulf war, the media is something to be managed. Information must be controlled. That’s why Wikileaks and Bradley Manning are high-level targets.
“Mom, I’ve signed up. It’s a matter of duty, honor, country and my perverted desire to shoot people like game and prop up their gruesome corpses and make trophies out of pieces and parts of them. I’ve always had a fascination with mangled bodies and this will provide an opportunity to see the world and piss all over it at the same time. Remember I love you, I’ll be sure to write and send some really swell photos. I promise to make you proud.”
Isn’t this how you fight the “War on Terror?”
Dude’s from Palin’s hometown? Huh.
Let’s chill on the demonizing of these guys. People get twisted by war, particularly sometimes the people who do the shooting.
Those damn Japanese. They get what they deserve for not helping with the “War on Terror.”
It’s deja vu all over again
I suspect there are a great deal of people in Germany who will be happy to use these photos to pull out of Afghanistan.
Yep! Calling on Mama Cass, Joplin, and others.
Not that it really matters, but Morlock played hockey against Track Palin (his lawyers are attributing his actions partly to 4 concussions he got playing high school hockey and more he got while serving) and his younger sister is buddies with Bristol Palin.
Often seems the people in Germany are the sanest lot around these days.
Let’s look forward.
You forgot to add, “But we support the troupes”.
Interesting, thanks, ew. I saw that on first read and it jumped out at me: “Wasilla!”
Something in the water?
Perhaps.
Apparently the role model for many in today’s military is Colonel Kurtz.
This is what you get with 10+ years of war. There is a generation of young men that has grown up with war as “normal”. There is no horror of war, just another “tour”. I watched the VietNam war destroy a generation of young men.
We see the horror of it from afar and with the benefit of age.
I agree with Dakine@5, the military – used to – provide an education and an honorable career.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/dearth
Christian soldiers no doubt. I hope I live to see the total destruction of the American Empire.
Did you even read my comment?
The fact that we have to hear about 3 little photos out of 4000 from a foreign news magazine makes my point.
How many more of these kinds of photos have been destroyed?
This is why pushing for War Crimes trials after Obama took office was a necessary thing to do, and why under the law, he can be considered an Accomplice After the Fact in shielding them by pardon, and the exceedingly flimsy excuse of “They were just following orders”.
Because of those enabling actions, (among others) Obama might as well have killed those folks, taken body parts for trophies, and posed for photos with the corpses himself as far as the law is concerned.
He made this possible, so he’s just as culpable under the law as far as I can tell. Not that it would ever be enforced of course. It’s not like Obama campaigned on the rule of law or anything…
It’s in the holy water. More and more, our military is being unduly influenced by the Christian Right. They are far more frightening than anything Al Qaeda has to offer.
This all ties in nicely with Edward Teller’s recent Diary.
http://my.firedoglake.com/edwardteller/2011/03/20/queen-esther-visits-jerusalem-on-purim-her-devotees-rejoice/
This is why war is almost always bullshit. Email this to all of the Cruise Missile Liberals, (as Kelly calls them)
I have a friend who was an undercover police officer. She said this is what serial killers do, so they can relive the experience.
The army spokesman says, “We apologize for the distress these photos cause.”
Ye gods! There’s the sickness, right there. The photos cause distress? How about the murders? The prissy amorality of the US military and government generally is what authorizes this barbarity.
Right? What about the “distress” the victims endured? I guess that’s okay…
We have to destroy the village in order to save it.
We have to turn Bradley Manning into a mental case in order to protect him.
We have to slaughter people and take pictures of us smiling with a cigarrette in our lips in order to win their hearts and minds.
It all makes perfect sense, in bullshit world.
Excuse me. I thought you didn’t know what dearth means. I found your 1st sentence unclear.
I tend to ramble. Thanks for the feedback.
I read the article on the Der Spiegel website yesterday or the day before, but I can no longer find it. I wonder if Der Spiegel pulled it or the US blocked it.
In bullshit world, slaughter is collateral damage and bombing the shit out of somebody’s house because you were aiming at the despot down the street is perfectly okay. Exploding a nursery school trying to take out a dictator is better than the dictator being mean to them.
I’m not walking that back. My comment isn’t directed at people who served before 9/11 or Bush.
There may be many reasons to join the military. That being said, when one joins the military they are saying through their actions that they are ok with being culpable in terrorism, death, destruction, profiteering, rape, warrior culture and murder.
The reasons one joins the military don’t matter. What the military does is what matters. Anyone that joined in the last decade has the blood of millions of innocents on their hands. It’s not a morally defensible choice anymore, even if it was back in your day.
And I say all this with a brother I love very dearly in the National Guard right now. He may be a part time terrorist but I still love him.
And diplomats are murderous mercenaries. “HEY, I’m immune man, give me back my gun!”
Yep. I hate that this douchebaggery is being carried out in my name.
RE: Abu Ghraib:
Just to back you up on your point…emphasis on
Emphasis on 2000.
The edit would not let me edit. My comment would not show up and my cursor was blipping out.
Lot of them just need a job.
We can’t handle the truth. It’s too complicated and we’re so subject to emotion, you know. $2 billion a week though, we can handle that while our infrastructure is crumbling and our teachers are getting laid off. I can’t help feeling that Dick Cheney is still pulling the levers.
Too bad all those poor stupid soldiers and Marines can’t be as privileged as you.
I can’t see you all the way up in your ivory tower.
Well, it would be nice if we could offer them an education or some other means of financial well-being without having to subject them to giving up their rights as citizens (see Pvt Manning).
Very true but it’s also wrong to blame the enlistee for the policy. Many of these people come from worlds of crushing poverty where the two ways out are crime or service. I don’t fault them for doing what they have to do to raise themselves out of it.
Just watched Winter’s Bone last night. Too true.
I’m not that privileged. I’d just rather starve than kill and maim for a living. Or be an accessory to it.
Notice I didn’t say anything about class or “privilege”. I said stupid. Huge difference.
And from what I am able to see, guess what folks get when they go to prison? Christian Right indoctrination (a glimpse of it here).
Because no Christians have ever been outlaws, heavens no! Aren’t people too simple sometimes?
Have you starved then? If not, maybe you’re wrong about what you’d do in someone else’s shoes.
Good to remember, before you start judging.
Kill teams.
Which brings up the swept under the rug assassination of one, Pat Tillman who had the audacity to believe as a citizen of a free country he had the right to object to an unconstitutional, illegal war. Command got wind of it’s through censorship of communications.
A triple tap , which was meant for his mouth, as an example,wound up in his forehead. Shut him up though didn’t it?
Kill Teams indeed !
Let’s compare the soldiers with some people who are definately not starving, shall we?
http://www.hcn.org/issues/42.4/the-war-next-door/article_view?b_start:int=1&-C=
http://dunwalke.com/8_Dillon_Investment_in_Cornell.htm
http://www.ratical.org/co-globalize/narcoDollars.html
I watched the VietNam war destroy a
generation of young men.country and it’s morality and it’s since of proportion in military activity.People from back then who opposed the war and didn’t do the killing are still treated as trash.
Wiser, more experienced folks than I have suggested on numerous occasions that a secular ethic based upon principles of basic, common human goodness would be a better way to go. There would be no admonition of blind faith or blind belief as that’s a point where things easily go awry (e.g. abdication of considering cause and effect, personal responsibility, critical analysis of would-be authority figures, yaty, yaty).
But how will you get people to participate if there’s no fear involved? That’s only half-snark.
Regarding prisons, it is not limited to the Christian Right. There is a growing trend to convert prisoners to Islam.
http://www2.newsadvance.com/news/2010/jan/04/group_muslim_chaplains_needed_in_va_prisons-ar-216807/
http://www.zimbio.com/United+States+Prison+Reform/articles/23/prisons+Growing+Islam+provides+protection
Farrakhan began a program in the 1970s to convert prisoners across the country to Islam.
http://tdn.com/news/article_7fa97a03-5073-521a-b7f5-80a67c20d0be.html
If everyone in the military has blood on their hands, then so do all of us in the U.S., including you. The fighting and murder is continuing every night – where are the protests in the U.S.? Have you planned or taken part of a protest? You seem to find it easy to blame the military for everything, what about Congress that enables the wars by funding them.
Okay, I guess you could scare them by saying “This could happen to you, if you decide reason, evidence and a cool head aren’t your cup of tea.”
Impunity breeds crime, period. An unenforced law is no law at all, and one would think that a Harvard trained lawyer would know that.
It’s possible to demonstrate that the learned skills of emotional self-management actually allow a person far greater opportunities for self actualization than otherwise (a glimpse here). Who doesn’t want the better tool once they discover it?
Of course. Did I say otherwise? However, there is a monstrous difference between complicit (me and you, I assume) and culpable (the military).
Ah, the what are YOU doing? argument, a total red herring. The question of whether or not I personally protest has nothing to do with my comments. I’m not going to legitimize a BS argument designed to distract from the main point: that those who have joined since 9/11 have made a morally indefensible choice.
My only brother, a little brother, just joined the Guard. We’re 14 months apart and have always been good friends in addition to being brothers. We’re not talking anymore because of what he has done. /s Is that morally pure enough for you? /s
Show me where I “blame the military for everything”. Don’t bother – I wouldn’t do that because it’s not accurate. I blame them for murder, war crimes, the destruction of entire societies and every other sociopathic aspect of their mission. A good question would be “do I blame individuals for choosing to take part in the things the military does (regardless of why the military does these things)?”
Absolutely I blame the individuals. Without their willingness to commit their crimes the war machine wouldn’t exist. It is partially their fault, absolutely, but not entirely, obviously.
Hmmm … thank you for the links. I will review that material. It would be very interesting to see an analysis of this by Gorilla Guides.
fantastik!
Cool. I’ve got to go back there: lots of good links. I can’t argue with your last sentence, other than to ask, why have we not evolved to have adopted such a system?
If you haven’t read “My Stroke of Insight” I recommend it. The author talks about her experience and how the two halves of the brain have different influences and how she was forced to more consciously use the less logical side to process her environment for several years. She also talks about the “barrier” (sorry, can’t remember the technical term) between left and right hemispheres and how thc kind of lowers the barrier. It’s a really interesting read.
I didn’t make any argument about somebody else. I said I would rather starve. So you’re saying that poverty is an acceptable argument for being culpable in atrocities? Got it.
It is exactly this kind of moral relativism when it comes other people’s choices that makes this kind of atrocity possible.
You’re arguing that nobody should judge someone that kills civilians because you don’t know what led them to do it. BS. Killing other human beings is wrong. Wrong. Sometimes justifiable, but always negative and, most importantly, wrong. Sometimes violence is the best of a set of bad choices, but still wrong.
No wonder the left can’t win a moral argument to save it’s life, quite literally.
You’re assuming he cares.
Great reference! I found the web site, My Stroke of Insight. I had read previously about Dr. Jill Bolte Taylor. Yeah, I’m definitely going through all of that material too.
I think you are referring to the corpus callosum. I can tell you that, in many dimensions, what scientists know about the human body was revolutionized by the rapid change in computer technology. Folks were so excited about it that one graduate student’s adviser would periodically cheer lead the grads and post docs with his version of the “data dance.” Everybody was amused as doing work to even be considered by peer reviewed journals actually takes specific kinds of people with certain training, equipment and other material resources, tons of labor and is actually hard work.
I don’t think it is possible to put this only on members of the armed forces, private contractors, or the corrupt bastards in Washington. This is being done in all our names as citizens of the U.S.
We all own this.
http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,752272,00.html
It is ironic that the U.S. soldiers all have cameras attached to their helmets, and then the commanders are shocked when there are photographs of atrocities and war crimes.
Perhaps someone could compare and contrast the pre-trial confinement conditions of these accused murderers?
Here is a link to the English version.
http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/0,1518,752310,00.html
As I understand it, it is common in the Muslim world to get revenge for a family member who is killed. You kill the killer or his relative and take a finger, ear or other body part back to your mother or grandmother to prove the revenge. We don’t hear about it, but I would not be surprised if many of the American dead were mutilated in that something or other was amputated. In those circumstances people go a little crazy. Doesn’t make it right. Were there justice, the men who ordered them there would stand in the dock beside them.
Despicable and in human. This entire episode and supporting cast needs to be fully investigated and charged. This has no place in any US activity and ought to be made clear as such.
Anyone know if the trial (first paragraph) is open? I’m assuming this is a fed trial in Seattle. I’d be down there at least for a day if I had enough vacation.
Somehow I doubt they’re kept in 23 hours per day isolation and under prevention of suicide watch, prevented from exercising in their cells, kept half or fully naked, required to be inspected while naked, etc.
Something in the water? The Morlock family and the Palin family are very close. The kids grew up together. Jeremy with Palin son Track and daughter spent several weeks last fall with Bristol in LA. Why the media hasn’t raised this point, I don’t know. Look at the way he’s holding that man’s head up like a deer he just killed. Put it side by side with Sarah’s caribou kill and the pics are almost identical.
The biggest mistake this country ever made was to eliminate the draft. There was a mechanism for at least some of the rich to get their ass shot off, one for those who were drafted families to become upset because they were shot off, and those in college who darn sure do not want to serve.
If we had a draft I can guarantee the rich and the college students would have put an end to Afghanistan and Iraq a long time ago, just like they did Vietnam.
Now no one really gives a S___! They all volunteer to get killed because of a woeful economy and the college kids and the rich could care less.
Reply to Evelyn @ 74
“Perhaps someone could compare and contrast the pre-trial confinement conditions of these accused murderers?”
It sure would be interesting. I think we know the answer. Maybe someone like Greenwald could open more eyes to PFC Manning’s situation with proof of their pre- and current confinement situations.
It’s not strange: the article itself is in the current issue (page 64), so you have to buy it as a dead tree magazine or for the pay wall access to read it.
lead?
“If we had a draft I can guarantee the rich and the college students would have put an end to Afghanistan and Iraq a long time ago, just like they did Vietnam.”
No fan of the draft at all. However your point is well taken. The warmongering elite in America, did not want a draft. They knew it would draw opposition as it did in Vietnam. My son’s best friend, a terrific American, an Officer, in Afghanistan is actually fucking disgusted with the policy makers. “We have no business being there.” I was indeed expecting the opposite from this educated young man who could have done anything in life, besides joining the military. Joining the military is not a bad thing at all, unless you are killed.
Great to hear from people living the war in Afghanistan, opposed to the policy makers, calling bullshit, bullshit from a position of first hand experience, opposed to the likes of, fuckhead Cheney, Rumsfuck, Chump, Wolffywitz and the plethora of well connect corporate scum who profit from war, while others die! The Corporate interest in America, is dysfunctional, meddlesome and truly a fucked up lot, believing in thier own “fecal matter,” as did the Nazis.