You could make an argument that this is a great time for the labor movement, energized by the battle in Wisconsin and ready to re-establish themselves in the American consciousness as part of what builds and protects the middle class. And to an extent that’s true. But the wave of labor protests sweeping the country are the direct result of rear-guard, defensive actions where right-wing politicians are attacking and assaulting the rights of the worker. And they won’t all end in victories for labor.
It didn’t in Wisconsin, where Scott Walker had the votes, eventually, to get his anti-union bill out of the legislature. That’s currently tied up in court. But other states are moving forward as well. There’s a Walker-like bill that just passed a House committee in New Hampshire:
Under the terms of this plan, public sector workers in the state would become “at will” employees if and when their contracts expire.
That eliminates all the leverage state employees have in negotiation with their employers, and could ultimately end up busting the unions entirely.
New Hampshire has a Democratic governor, but John Lynch has been known to be pretty conservative. Lynch appears to oppose the bill but he has also said he would have to see the final language before committing to a veto. Republicans have such majorities in the legislature that they could potentially override the veto. The labor protests in the House committee when they passed the bill were intense.
Like Walker’s anti-union legislation, the New Hampshire bill would end the automatic collection of union dues out of paychecks and forces an annual re-certification of the union. ALEC has basically created a boilerplate for these bills. A bill in Florida split off the paycheck provisions and passed their state House this week.
Union leaders representing government workers may need to start looking for new ways to collect payment from their members after the Florida House voted 73-40 on Friday, largely along party lines, to ban automatic payroll deductions of union dues for all government workers.
House Bill 1021 would also require written authorization by union members for their dues to be used for any political activities [...]
Democrats argued that the legislation is nothing more than a thinly veiled and un-American attempt at “union busting,” because unions generally support Democrats.
“This is a calculated step to diminish the power of the unions, and only takes critical brain power away from the issues of what we should be focused on today, jobs, jobs, jobs, economic recovery, education, budget balancing and health care,” said Rep. Irv Slosberg, D-Boca Raton. “We didn’t get elected to sit here to wage an ideological war. We were elected to work together for the state of Florida.”
There are other bills moving in Florida. One would require re-certification for unions that represent a minority of members in any organization. Another would force unions to send a letter to members explaining their right to de-certify.
Alabama already passed the paycheck bill this year, but a federal judge blocked it on the grounds that the law violates free speech and equal protection rights. Florida labor officials said they may challenge their bill because it singles out unions and not other organizations who have automatic payroll deductions set up. But the Supreme Court ruled in 2009 that Idaho could ban automatic deduction, so there’s certainly a path to surviving the challenge.
It goes without saying that none of these provisions really have anything to do with state budgets. They are mostly about decimating unions and removing their power. Because unions most often support Democrats financially, this is merely a Republican effort to attack the power base of the funders of their opponents.
But the point is, the proverbial goalie can only block so many shots. Florida is already a right-to-work state and has several anti-union measures on the books. Other states, like Idaho and Michigan, have successfully passed bills that will impact unions. And dozens of other states are going down that road. And that says nothing of the federal anti-union push that should really heat up next week.
This is a war on the American worker, and in every war, you can lose some battles.





52 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
You know, I really, really detest Obama and the DINOs (virtually all Dems). But I’ve come to realize that they are the smart ones. They’ve seen how this is going to end and have lined up to be on the winning side.
Sorry to say it, but we’re going to lose. And when push comes to shove, when all the protesting and recalls and other stuff fails, the Army will roll into the streets just like it has in Syria and Libya and Iran. And this time there will be no UN, no NATO, no coalition to come to our rescue.
We are literally FUBAR — Fucked UP Beyond All Repair. It will give some of us a certain satisfaction to keep fighting, but like the Alamo or the 300 Spartans, the end is predetermined and we know we’re on a suicide mission.
Oh, it can get very rough, even deadly, but you’ve got to try and hold on. Here’s something from a previous struggle which just might inspire you.
Wisconsin union law published despite court order LINK.
Grrrrrrrr.
Yep.
Especially because a significant enough minority of citizens actually *agree* with facism, welcome it, clap for it & cheer it on.
We are totally FUBAR and HOW!
Not good. When the dust settles – as it will – hope all those TeaPartiers feel happy with their measly crumbs & bones, if they’re even lucky enough to get that.
Where’s Waldo?
Sometimes I’ll go to the Facebook page for the Rachel Maddow show. The fans consistently say that we have to accept torture, detention without trial, war without declaration, nonunion charter schools, and all the rest, without complaint, because we must support our guy. Obama. It’s not about any issue. It’s not about right and wrong. It’s about who is the bestest and the goodest.
No one seems to be selling this war harder and with less reflection than the “left-wing media”
Rachel is a big disappointment. Can’t watch anymore.
You forgot to mention Obama’s cute ears.
American “workers” shot themselves in the foot back in the ’80s when the ones who had voted for Raygun were downright giddy as he screwed over PATCO. The rest of the workers who set the groundwork for where we are today are all those non-unionized petit bourgeois workers who were little middle managers who begrudged unionized workers the gains they made due to jealousy.
And it ain’t gonna get better in this fuck everyone else, I got mine society.
http://host.madison.com/wsj/news/local/govt-and-politics/article_f22629e6-572a-11e0-ab2f-001cc4c002e0.html sorry if this link is redundant, says this move could backfire on Walker et al.
Did you hear about the overworked controller at Reagun National that fell asleep(he was by himself, can’t afford 2 underpaid workers) and 2 planes had to land with no clearance from the tower? Happened yesterday night http://www.nbcwashington.com/news/local/New-Procedures-for-Air-Traffic-Controllers-118681364.html
This has been in the making for many years. The SCOTUS appointment of Bush to the presidency, Bush’s appointments of the really, really hard right Robert’s Court were icing in the cake. The aiding and abetting of our worthless national Democrats were a bonus, too. Welcome to the 19th century.
Heard on the news tonight that GE made something like $15 billion last year and paid no taxes. Is this a great country or what?
what.
I heard that too and wondered at the time if something terrible would’ve happened, would anyone in the media have the nuts to connect it to Reagan. Hell, no.
That would be “ATC Audio: NTSB Investigating Sleeping Air Traffic Controller at Reagan National Airport” (NYC Aviation, Mar. 25th, 2011).
Always preferred Dulles myself over the bus wrecks at BWI and the prospect of the short, icy landing strip upon the Potomac. Heard the apparently even shorter landing strip at Kai Tak Airport, Hong Kong is a real thriller and even more so if you’re flying Singapore Air.
Just read this article from 150 years ago:
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=bremer-swiss-watchmaking
Not here in the USA. But the kind of thing that stimulated unions.
Or maybe the 40 hour work week came from Intelligent Design.
“what” is right. As I sit here with my $10 thousand tax bill because i exceeded my “allowed” income and had my SS benefits taxed at 80 fucking percent. My ass is still bleeding.
I don’t think it’s about Democrats David. Post Citizens United, the KochSuckers have no fear of union dues. It’s class war pure and simple. Trample the working class into the dirt. Keep them poor, ignorant, dependent and finally, obedient.
For the time being, you are right. The Roman politicians kept the masses complacent with bread and circuses; we have fast food and cable TV. But Obama’s failure to prosecute and adequately regulate banksters ensures another, much more catastrophic crisis 8 or 10 years hence, and the economic misery, lack of government services, declining living standards for all except the very richest, dysfunctional health care system, continued fossil fuel dependence in the post peak oil era, incessant wars will bring people into the streets demanding real change–if the insidious, invidious police state doesn’t stifle them.
The Democrats are perhaps a bit saner on domestic issues such as abortion, gay rights and creationism, but equally fascist, corrupt, corporatist, plutocratic, environmentally brown and warmongering. I believe that the next crash will result in change via the election of candidates from other parties. However, much of the damage will have already been done, and America will be left to lick its wounds and try to salvage what’s left of its greatness.
At one time labor pushed the Democratic Party in a progressive direction, when they still had communists and socialists in the labor movement. Now that the best organizers, strategists and theoreticians have been purged the labor movement is led by the nose by the Democratic Party. Is it any wonder they have lost their influence?
They were only able to do that because the union movement had been purged of its best organizers. The ones that recognized it was all about class struggle.
Apparently even at FDL the notion of an organized class conscious labor movement is of little interest. To radical perhaps for “liberals.”
Food-for-thought–
Keiser Report: Freedom Fighters vs Corrupt Corps (E132)” (Mar. 24, 2011)
A partial antidote.
Interview of Chris Hedges: “The only solution for totalitarian love bombs is money, jobs & dignity” (Stacy Herbert, Mar. 25, 2011)
An observation from a reformed Wall Streeter: Warren’s an asshole (a click thru to CNBC, Mar. 25, 2011)
I was involved in a huge strike against UPS in 1974 when Ron Carey was president of Local 804 in NY. Old Ron surrounded himself with goons, literally (one guy went to jail in the 80s), in order to crush the workplace democracy movement we were trying to get going. Even among the people who supported us, talking about class made them uncomfortable.
The guys who were most open to hearing about class struggle were combat vets who UPS had hired to capitalize on government tax breaks for hiring veterans. Little did they know many of them had already been politicized by our experiences in Vietnam.
The next revolution will be a class revolution and the plutocrats and the elites will rue the day they were born.
The radical organizers within the labor movement, like Farrell Dobbs and James Cannon, always knew that their “progressive” allies were as useless as the liberals were to the Bolsheviks during the Russian revolution.
It isn’t really a compliment to be called a progressive if you’re truly aware of the philosophy and politics of that movement.
The New Deal gave me a wonderful childhood, watching my working class parents’ circumstances improve noticeably before my eyes. A society based on the New Deal gave me a start in life that may get me through the coming dark times. Unquestionably, efforts to expand the New Deal to people of color and women fell tragically short.
Progressives created a middle class in this country that was the envy of the world. The fact that some of the people who are helping to destroy the middle class are trying to appropriate the progressive label doesn’t mean Bolshevism is the answer. We need an FDR, not a Lenin.
FDR did great things for this country but don’t fool yourself. He did these things in the face of a radicalized working class that was conducting strikes all over the country and the threat of the class struggle finally being recognized by Americans was real.
FDR did what he did to save the ass of the capitalist class and the capitalist system in this country. The good things he did can be seen as collateral benefits vs. the collateral damage the Reagan era has inflicted on this country.
We have a guy who sold himself as an FDR going as far as to make everyone look forward to a 100 days miracle.
What we need is a Big Bill Haywood, some Molly Maguires, and a very determined Trotsky leading a workers’ army. The problem with progressives is that they want to fine tune the system so that they’re more comfortable. When you come right down to it, they’ll do whatever they have to do to save the system, including jettisoning the poor and working classes.
O/T: I hope other NYers are as disgusted with the Melo trade as I am.
Saw a brief clip of Melo on ESPN the other night. Tell me, is it my imagination, the camera angle, or does he look a little thick around the middle for an NBA superstar supposedly in top shape?
Well said. I think the Molly Maguires and such will make a comeback, but unfortunately, it will be like the IRA or the Basque Separatist movement…a long sniping action at the flanks but no chance of real success.
Yeah, I think Melo’s magic is all in his mind. He might make it to the Hall of Fame but it won’t be because he’s a team player.
I have hope that if enough people get screwed over in this country, if enough young people can’t get anything but minimum wage bullshit work, and if we keep treating our returning veterans like shit maybe a coalition of the fed-up can be formed and this corrupt system that’s been forced on us can be changed. If anywhere needs root and branch regime change, it’s the US.
This isn’t your father’s economy. Besides, the good old days weren’t that good.
I live in a right to work state and don’t belong to a union. My “contract” with my employer renews every morning at 8 AM when I show up for work and they let me in the door.
Heaven forbid that our government workers might have to actually deliver enough value every day to justify their jobs and pensions.
Name me one important advancement that unions have made to society in the past 25 years, other than acting as a funnel of union dues to Democratic campaign coffers.
Well, FDR was a regulator and a stimulator, but we at a point that those things are far from enough, and may be putting the cart before the horse. What we need right now is a Teddy Roosevelt to blow apart the industrial monopolies (and wink-wink near monopolies), then and FDR type can come in and make it stable with regulation.
Worst problem: jobs. Stimulus won’t do it, that’s just taxpayers putting people to work, but it doesn’t grow the economy in a self-reinforcing way. We need the same defense against globalism that our low cost trading partner use – tariffs and non-tariff trade barriers. A 20% or so tariff on incoming manufactured goods would be a big help. Alex Hamilton covered all this in his treatise on “Manufactures” about 1791.
Globalism is the problem, and scaling it back is the solution. Tax policy is pretty much irrelevant to the jobs shortage.
Tax policy is only relevant to dealing with the deficit and debt. Oh, and keeping teachers, firefighters, police, and tax collectors on the job.
Couldn’t we just defeat globalism by buying American? That would avoid the trade wars that would inevitably come from constant tariff-setting, while simultaneously putting more Americans to work producng the goods we want to buy.
Not so simple. You can only buy American for things that are still made here. It will take tariffs to bring back things like rare-earth magnets, LCD panels, washing machines, bicycles, shoes, clothing. All products that were once American-dominated and today are near non-existent in a made-in-America form.
We had a solar panel industry in development, then we gave tax breaks and zero tariffs to those companies, and they all went to China. If we had tariffs, then neither tax breaks nor unions would have chased them out.
Your approach does nothing to grow American jobs. It simply makes imports more expensive. If you and I simply decided we were wiling to put our money where our mouth is, and pay more for every item you just mentioned, those industries would come back to the USA in one business cycle. Our economy would grow overnight. And we’d avoid artificial levelers like taxes and tariffs, which can simply be countered by our trading partners.
I have a company that makes avionics displays for flight simulators. One man shop. This week I had a serious inquiry from a foreign aircraft manufacturer for a HUD (Head Up Display, the thing the pilot looks through to see what’s ahead, while seeing inside-the-aircraft information at the same time). I’ve built them in the past, all sold to foreigners.
Today it would cost at least $2K just to apply for the export license, and it would take around 8 months and a lot of review and interviews with the State Department to get it issued. I no-bid the RFQ, and the customer was fairly perplexed that it was not about the money.
I can make things other people want to buy, but my government doesn’t care about the jobs I didn’t create, or about the trade deficit I could have reduced (these things sell for about $500K each).
I am all for buy American, but our government seems to be opposed.
Well, I had an employee who I tried to convince of your proposal. He was adamant that it would always be best for his family if he bought whatever he bought for the lowest price he could find.
I’m sorry to inform you that narrow self interest is trumping enlightened multi-generational self-interest in enough of our population that you are proposing spitting into the wind.
I was a Democrat and a union man back in the 60′s and 70′s.
I look at the Democratic Party and I think – you’re not doing so well since you kicked me out.
I’m not doing so well either. I miss you.
Further comment to 40.
He always shops at WalMart.
I never shop at WalMart.
I go out of my way to buy American, including paying more. Same for buying local.
And I spit into the wind a lot. It makes me feel good, and I can afford it.
:( I feel abandoned, too.
You should see some people on Twitter.
Disappointment? I can think of a lot of harsher words to describe her sellout.
What – has firedoglake or at least this comments section been taken over by Randite doomsayers? Get out and organise, ya bums. Serious – becoming John Galt? Fantasy material.
There was a good diary or two about “lifestyle activism”, and it’s severe limitations, over at openleft a while back, which interested readers can google for. becomingjohngalt’s position is mostly a libertarian fantasy, with some validity in principle, but no validity in the real world. Perhaps when his job gets outsourced, at 2 cents on the dollar of his wages, he will wake up.
I would say, though, that there has to be a balance. I.e., while we should institute protective trade barriers, immediately (at least with respect to countries whose wages and environmental protections are much less thant the US’s), we shouldn’t be so eager to protect American industry – and by extension, American workers – that we put up with grossly inferior products. In the 70′s, American auto manufacturers (or at least GM, I don’t remember well enough) deliberately made their cars poorly enough that the body would rust through in 3 years. We used to call it “getting cancer”. I’m glad that the Japanese kicked their rear ends. And think about how selfish and short sighted the UAW was not to strike over being being party to creating these hunks of junk.
We really need not just protectionism, but a new labor movement. Most of the unions are poodles for the Democratic Party, and far too selfish. Please see my diary American Unions are a Compliant, Selfish Disgrace, Compared to European Unions
The assault against public sector unions could be a springboard into creating not just a less selfish labor movement, but a political renaissance. However, there are clearly signs that Democratic Party or else selfish union cheerleaders don’t want this to happen. See, e.g., my discussion with davidseth at docudharma, starting with “Do I get any thanks for supporting the unions, but just verbally?”
davidseth wants us to line for unions, but won’t even press them to discuss the need and desire for reciprocity to those segments of the American public that don’t even have a job, much less a union job. This, I refuse to do. I support teachers’ unions verbally, and that’s about it, until they demonstrate a concern for more workers than just their union members, and that of some other union’s members. (I’ve read that in WI, they’ve supported other unions.)
=================
On another note, for those pining away for another FDR and strong progressives, please check out what may be the beginning of a strong progressive movement, which began right here at MyFDL. (New Progressive Alliance) I think most union leadership has basically been coopted by the Democratic (corporatist) Party, so if you want to create fertile soil for strong labor, and do more than wish for same fondly on a public blog, perhaps you will volunteer.
Yes, Rachel even had a segment of Presidential remarks on war pre/post election. Somehow she forgot to contrast candidate Obama’s correct understanding of the president’s war-making powers to President Obama’s abuse of them.
If one SOB after another can lie to you without retribution then you got bigger problems than the Union.
The power brokers behind the GOP know full well that many of their most draconian efforts will be pushed back and overturned. But however ruthless they are, they are also smart. (Remember, it’s not the Tea Party crowd that’s in charge).
They know that — like in football — the game is one of inches. If they can move their ideology forward one yard and get knocked back two feet, they see it as a gain of 12 inches. Average democrats, however, delude themselves by thinking they’ve won some sort of victory by preventing them from gaining those two extra feet.
Conservative true believers have been in it for the long haul, beginning with the Goldwater campaign, relentlessly gaining ground an inch at a time. Until liberals understand that and start fighting back with the same patience and consistency, we’re going to lose.
As a Denver Nuggie fan, I’m thrilled with the trade.