It looked like SB 5, Ohio’s anti-union bill, would have some hurdles to clear in order to pass. However, in quick-strike fashion yesterday, it cleared them, and the bill will now go to Gov. John Kasich for his signature.
The two houses of the Ohio Legislature approved a far-reaching bill on Wednesday that would hobble the ability of public-employee unions to bargain collectively and undercut their political clout.
They sent the bill to Gov. John R. Kasich, a Republican, who lawmakers said would sign it in the next few days [...]
The bill would bar public employees from striking and would prohibit binding arbitration for police officers and firefighters. It would allow bargaining over wages, but not health coverage and pensions and would allow public-employee unions to bargain only when the public employer chose to do so [...]
James Brudney, a labor law professor at Ohio State University, said the bill effectively crippled collective bargaining. “There’s a kind of mask or illusion element in this,” he said. “The essence of collective bargaining is when you can’t agree on terms of a contract, you have a dispute resolution mechanism, by strikes or perhaps binding arbitration. Here, you have none of that. That’s not collective bargaining. I’d call it collective begging. It’s a conversation that ends whenever an employer decides that it ends.”
The bill changed from the version that passed the Senate. Police and firefighters can still collectively bargain for safety equipment, for example. And workers who strike cannot receive jail time. But other pieces were made even stricter, particularly on decertification and a bar on nonunion employees covered by union contracts from paying fees to unions.
The House passed the bill 53-44, with 5 Republicans opposing. The Senate again passed the bill by 1 vote, 17-16, with 6 Republicans opposing.
Opposition protesters lustily booed from the gallery during the debate, a sign that the public is at odds with its elected representatives on this issue. And they’re going to get an opportunity to make their displeasure heard. In Ohio, you can put a referendum on the ballot for any piece of legislation. This blocks implementation until the outcome of the citizen veto. If the legislature waited until April 6 to pass the bill into law, that referendum would have been placed on the November 2012 ballot. As it is, with Gov. Kasich expected to sign the bill this week, it will go on the November 2011 ballot, alongside multiple municipal elections. And every municipal leader in Ohio, many of them with large contingents of public employees, will have to explain where they stand, in the midst of a re-election, on stripping collective bargaining rights from workers.
This will begin with a rally as early as next weekend. It will be a sustained, seven-month campaign that gives the new, energized progressive alliance in Ohio a goal on which to focus. This will be another battle for the future of the labor movement.




48 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Aren’t there a couple of other nearby states on the platter next? Iowa, and. . .????
Not exactly on the point, but bears passing along in this context…
A real kick-ass piece…
R.I.P. labor.
I think Obama is staying out of these fights in order to cynically gain an advantage in 2012 when a lot of the people who created these union busting laws will be on the ballot. I have nothing to base that on other than my perception that he doesn’t do anything that doesn’t directly benefit him in some way.
I hope everyone who voted Republican last November is proud at what they have accomplished. Electing a bunch of people who want to destroy the very institutions of government…great idea. I do hope that both Walker and Kasich are roundly defeated the next time this comes to a public vote. By then, it may be too late. Screw these people, they are protecting the rich, not protecting the citizens they claim to care so much about.
The narrative is this will lose support for the the Dems. I don’t think that is what is happening at all. It’s just an all out corporate attack on everything the people have or will possibly have.
First they took the family farms and now they’re taking our homes and bulldozing them. It’s just an all out land grab.
Stick the people left in little hamster cages and bring ‘em out to work when needed.
The US is instigating these practices everywhere just like nuclear energy and oil spills
As someone who lived in Ohio for decades I am not optimistic about referendum chances. Ohio has far more low information voters than, say, Wisconsin. I hope I am wrong but many millions of Ohioans are comfortable with mediocrity, just the way it is.
Oh my.
I saw that, and it was excellent! As a woman (although far past childbearing age) I particularly resent their intrusion into my womb and my bedroom.
And for someone at Swim this morning who called Rachel an “obamabot” I noticed that approximately the first third of last night’s show was pretty much anti Obama administration. She used “not true” a couple of times, although she did not use the word “liar” at all. And KO in his last few Countdown weeks took Obama to task pretty fiercely.
Where is the DEMOCRATIC PARTY PRESIDENT?
Golf, Brazil, in a conference call with G.E. execs on how they plan to cut wages of 15,000 workers?
The only “hopey-changey” we have is the hope we get a different President – one who cares about the American population, not just the plutocracy.
Branstad in Iowa assures us that “this is not Wisconsin.” Which is true; Branstad lacks Walker’s enormous brass balls.
Not gonna happen. that’s why they killed JFK and would do it again in a heartbeat.
This country now make the survivalists Reno took out in the 90′s look positively prescient.
We’re on our own
Walker knows even if he is recalled he has been a good boy for the Kocks and will get a plum job complete with hookers
Those corporatists just kill me with laughter. Jonathon Gruber is making a comeback and is telling the truth. Gruber blames it all on RomneyCare. It is LOL sad, and it begins
And then it just gets more and more sad. Gruber is a sad clown. But PhRMA is happy.
That is basically what Snyder said in Michigan – that MI is not WI – no, because Snyder is smarter than Walker and is making emergency financial managers do his dirty work (this includes having the ability to redistrict/merge schools and towns and un-elect officials, as well as break all contracts).
This is where we are heading (and I would suggest reading his 2/9/10 article as well)
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/story/print?guid=CA183FE6-5966-11E0-9F0E-00212804637C
Good morning David and Firedogs,
I have a question on the dates.
April 6th appears to be the key date determining when the referendum would appear on the ballot. If the legislature had waited until after April 6th, then the issue would be on the 2012 ballot, but since they passed it before April 6th, it can appear on this November’s ballot.
My question, after all this writing is, what if Kasich waits until after April 6th to sign it into law? Does that impact the 2011, or 2012 referendum date?
I’ve always referred to him as “Governor Braindead”
but I like your analogy.
Recalls, please, not only for these idiot/megalomaniac governors, but also for any legislators who are complicit.
Yeah, I’ve heard “Governor Braindead” a few times. Personally, I’m struck by Branstad’s resemblance to Jerry Mathers with a porn moustache.
link to 2/9 article
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-to-invest-for-the-debt-bomb-explosion-2010-02-09
America has changed into one huge fascist concentration camp. Shame on you, Barack Obama.
People booing from the gallery is proof of the public being at odds with their legislators? Come on, name a single piece of legislation ever debated or passed that didn’t piss someone off; a group of opponents voicing their displeasure isn’t exactly “the public”.
I guess that’s why I crossed over to the dark side when “Gopher” from Love Boat primaried him in the 90′s.
As far as Iowa’s collective bargaining, we teachers have no right to strike and must submit to binding arbitration, so not as much to gut.
Where are the Anti-Rich-Abusers-of-the-System-and-the-American-People bills? We are dealing with an artificially created recession, after all. Why shouldn’t our representatives be asking the wealthy to tighten their belts?
Please read the link at my #16 (and #21)
The fact that the people have been systematically divided, beaten down financially, and lied to is the only reason why you haven’t seen an uprising that would put the French Revolution to shame.
The people are catching on. Fact: the rich need our cooperation far more than we need them.
The link in your comment @ 16 lays out the case for the point I made @ 27.
Frankly, it’s in the interests of the rich to start cooperating to save the system that made them so rich. Without their cooperation, the system will collapse.
Stop acting like voting for Democrats would have stopped this. It might have stopped it for now, but the Ds are no more committed to protecting workers than the Rs are. It’s one big corporate fascist love in among the elite.
Say Ds did win all these governorships. So what? Then we’re having this fight sometime in the future after Republicans inevitably get back into power at some point. It’s the refusal of the Democrats to make this shit unacceptable that creates the problem.
And the reason the Democrats
can’trefuse to stop it is because the same people sign both party’s contribution checks and give them jobs when they leave “public service”.The term “artificially created recession” needs to be repeated again and again, until the average citizen recognizes what has been done to them.
Obama has a problem there. . . he controls an essentially non-unionized workforce (or gelded, where it is unionized), and froze pay there not long ago. He’s doing his best with an unavoidaby low profile for now.
My hunch is that there is, at the end of the day, a bipartisan interest in not doing just that.
I’ve been hearing that for a while now, and reading about the same verbiage being used for how long now?
When all these revolutionaries finally step forward and do something about it, all these “Put their heads on a pike” people who are so so angry?
I think that’s a dream world. Except Romney IS trying to run away, and it likely won’t help him. The healthcare regime in Mass is a Mess, despite what the boosters claim. If there’s anything positive about it, perhaps it would be the emormous pothole dug on Romney’s path to the WH.
Agree. Sad to say, I think things have to get even worse before US citizens actually figure it out… if they ever do.
US citizens have been incessantly lied to since forever, but the marketing & spin & hype over the past 3 decades, combined with the emergence of today’s media 24/7/365, has really done a number on people’s brains & thinking capacity. I have no links; this is just an observation. But I do recall citizens appearing to be much more aware & thinking more critically back in the ’50s & ’60s.
Not no more. Unless or until it gets worse, my feeling is that citizens will roll over and continue to “take it” believing that trashing unions & govt workers is somehow inuring their personal benefit. Sad really.
Thanks for the post & keeping us all updated on the ongoing rapine, plunder & pillaging by the Elites in the Class Warfare.
The Ohio union-busting bill is just another sickening power grab from the Koch-fueled Republicans meant to crush all political opposition — with public employees as collateral damage.
That America needs a reveloution stuff has been sent out in mass email by republicans since the early Bush days. Nothing new.
I do think that might be what the crazy GOP’ers planned.
Nothing else makes sense.
An “artificially created recession” makes us impotent, teachers, police, fire fighters, laborers, unions, etc., impotent, so when the protests get bigger they can bring in the military against us.
But what is their agenda? They must have one and it cannot only be to make us poorer because that results in them getting poorer. Unless they just don’t care because they can make all the money they want in other countries.
What do the GOPer’s think they will “win” by what they are doing to American’s all over this country?
Teachers and public employees showed their true face by calling off sick and getting paid for attending a rally . . . Unions had their place at one time. Have you ever tried to fire a state worker or teacher???
Good luck!! They are going to have to take cuts just like everyone else to satisfy an overwhelming 8 billion debt in Ohio created by Ted Strickland former governor. Wake up people and be glad for what you have and quit being so greedy. Many state workers do not deserve the salaries they are receiving because they are under educated and do not have work place skills.
Not to count the workers who got their jobs by political cronyism and distorted equal employment laws.
Teachers under educated? I can see you don’t know what your talking about.
Do not feed…
Stop all deductions for all, rich and poor, worker and non- worker, church and business, political and non profit organizations. Our debt would be paid quickly and with pain for EVERYONE! FAIRLY!
Yes! As Queen Marie Antoinette might say if she were in power today, “Qu’ils mangent de la brioche.”
What could possible go wrong when supposed leaders close their eyes and keep abusing the people rather than lead them, right?
You come pre-gutted.
I should also include close NASA and cut the military by 60%.
I know a few folks on FDL that live in Ohio. I wonder what’s gonna happen now they can’t unionize.
Right now polls are showing a 60-40% to put collective bargaining back. Time will tell but NOW is the time to get organized and have a good base to work with .
frando55@7 -You must be a teacher! I said many “state employees”!
If the shoe fits wear it . . .
Do not feed.