JoAnne Kloppenburg, the unheralded Assistant US Attorney who just a few weeks ago didn’t seem to have much of a chance in a state Supreme Court election against a longtime Republican stalwart, declared victory today in the election, after all precincts on an initial count showed her leading by 204 votes out of 1.5 million cast. Here is her statement:
“We owe Justice Prosser our gratitude for his more than 30 years of public service. Wisconsin voters have spoken and I am grateful for, and humbled by, their confidence and trust. I will be independent and impartial and I will decide cases based on the facts and the law. As I have traveled the State, people tell me they believe partisan politics do not belong in our Courts. I look forward to bringing new blood to the Supreme Court and focusing my energy on the important work Wisconsin residents elect Supreme Court justices to do.”
I hardly expect Prosser to now concede. But consider the magnitude of this. Only five state Supreme Court justices have been defeated for re-election since the court’s establishment in 1852. Prosser got 55% of the vote in the first round primaries and was sailing to re-election until Scott Walker decided to take away workers’ rights. This election was unquestionably a referendum on him, and it turned a sure thing into a nail-biter that Prosser could easily lose. And this has major implications: Walker’s chief counsel admitted in an email that Prosser was vital to their anti-worker agenda. With the balance of power on the state Supreme Court in jeopardy, that changes how far outside the law Walker and his gang can operate.
And the state Supreme Court race isn’t the only example. Walker’s handpicked candidate to replace him as Milwaukee County Executive got thrashed last night. In the 94th Assembly district, one of three open seats vacated by Republicans who joined Walker’s administration, the primary yielded more votes for Democrats than Republicans. That general election happens in four weeks. And then there are the recall elections. As Democratic Senator Mark Miller pointed out, in the district of Dan Kapanke, whose recall petitions have already been turned in, Kloppenburg won 60-40.
How did Walker respond to this today? By saying that those hippies in Madison don’t count.
Gov. Scott Walker said this afternoon that the spring election results show there are “two very different worlds in this state.”
“You’ve got a world driven by Madison, and a world driven by everybody else out across the majority of the rest of the state of Wisconsin,” Walker said at a press conference in the Capitol.
Walker said he didn’t believe the election was a referendum on his policies, saying the results reinforce Wisconsin’s status as a “purple” state. He attributed other victories by Dem-backed candidates outstate to local factors, while noting that conservative candidates such as Jim Ladwig in Racine also emerged victorious Tuesday. In particular, he said the results in the race for his former post as Milwaukee County executive reflected its status as a “dark blue county.”
Here is an artist’s rendering, based on Kloppenburg-Prosser voting patterns, of how how Walker views Wisconsin.
Obviously he’s going to spin things as best he can. But some things aren’t spinnable. The court battles haven’t gone well for Walker recently and now the electoral battles are shifting too. No wonder Republicans in the state are getting so nervous: they’ve awakened a sleeping giant.




82 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Thanks, David. There are a lot of people who pride themselves on their reflexive cynicism who just don’t realize how big this is. They didn’t understand just how much of an advantage Prosser had in terms of incumbency and allies — when you’ve got the Club for Growth carpetbombing the state with $400K in pro-Prosser TV ads during the primary, and outspending all other primary candidates of all parties combined by a factor of 3, it’s hard to imagine anything that might hurt you.
But then, the Wisconsin Republicans screwed the pooch. Not only that, they did it while jumping the shark. And that’s what gave Kloppenburg her chance.
And I just noticed this in your Twitter feed:
Amazing!
Great news. Should be an inspiration to workers everywhere.
Great Post! PW
I agree, Walker clearly over reached big time.
The Dems in Wisconsin with no help from the DC Dems stood up for the party of FDR.
the Dems of Wisconsin have inspired us all
again thank you Wisconsin
Thanks for the great coverage David. Keep it up. This post should have been top of the front page.
The Badger State rocks the world!
x2
Obama received about 197,235 more votes in 2008 than were cast last night.
1 677 211 Obama, 2008
2 983 417 Prez, 2008
1 479 976 last night, Sup Ct
2,160,000 gubernatorial, 2010
turnout last night was less than 50% of Prez turnout
turnout last night was about 69% of gubernatorial turnout
turnout last night was twice the 20% guestimated 10 days or so ago
Thank you DDay and PW for all your great work on this.
It mattered.
On Wisconsin!
And on the same day it appears that Beck may be saying So, Long, Farewell…what a nice sound.
Congratulations, everyone.
Your statement is right-on and needs to be highlighted for those eyes in DC that see only dimly what is happening around, and in spite of, them: “The Dems in Wisconsin with no help from the DC Dems stood up for the party of FDR.”
Yes, thanks so much David and Phoenix Woman for staying right on top of this for all of us.
Meanwhile, the Spirit of Wisconsin is spreading thanks to all the dedication and hard-work of so many of you. You’re an inspiration to us all.
[Ohio] State Democrats back bill to recall Gov. John Kasich LINK.
Could we plz have a cartoon version of this?
Thanks for that picture of Madison.
Who knew Madison was that big??
David, is anyone on “our” side looking at the Milwaukee results?
It is statistically questionable, given all other results last night. Due to the momentum over the last few weeks, and polling on Walker’s popularity, one would expect momentum going to Kloppenburg.
And in every county with at least 40,000 votes cast (those were the ONLY counties I looked at), sure enough the evidence of the momentum was there. I every one of those counties (except ONE), Kloppenburg either got a larger portion of Barrett votes from 2010 than Prosser got of Walker votes, or was within 4 or 5 percentage points of doing so. These statistics bear out an obvious trend. Yet in Milwaukee county, a county that went for the new Democratic County executive OVERWHELMINGLY, Prosser outperformed to the point of getting 18% more of Walker votes than Kloppenburg got of Barret votes. 18% is MORE THAN 3 TIMES ANY OTHER of those most populous counties, AND is in a county that the D county executive won by more than 20 points.
I’m not a Nate Silver, but this seems statistically significant to me, enough to at least look into.
I hope Wisconsin’s sleeping progressivism has indeed awoken. It and the country, Main Street Americans, those in offices, factories, mills, orchards, farms and barns, street corners, shops, dormitories, apartments and backyards desperately need for that to happen. As with oak trees, mighty accomplishments have small beginnings.
Just as I predicted. NOT.
That’s the way to do it! Go Ohio!
And the wingers have already trotted out John Fund to claim voter fraud.
She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won!
Too late …
She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won! She won!
The Nineties are over. Somebody tell the Establishment. When Democrats turn out, Democrats win.
I’m not sure how much of this was Kloppenburg herself, rather than her being the “not-Prosser” candidate. “We suck less” can actually work when the opposition is overwhelmingly bad. Maybe that’s Obama’s eleven-dimensional chess strategy.
I agree with Fund that there are questions.
Damn those first four words were hard to type. My fingers hurt.
The turnout was phenomenal for a mid season Supreme Court election.
Gov. Walker’s attempt to blame these significant electoral defeats on the DFH’s he claims hail from Madison is cartoonish.
Quite obviously, like many states such as Ohio, Illinois, Pennsylvania, New York, California and Florida, Wisconsin is a complex state with a few urban centers, many small towns and lots of farms.
Equally obvious, Gov. Walker’s budget and legislative priorities attack virtually all those communities. They attack every school, library, public and private office, farm and shop in them, and every employee and self-employed worker and every family member dependent on them. He doesn’t care about budgets or deficits or fair-minded compromises or balancing competing interests. He wants what the Kochs and their peers want; he thinks their interests are the only ones he need attend to.
He’s wrong, but he’s committed. He won’t change his spots any more than Kasich in Ohio will, or their peers in Michigan, Indiana and elsewhere. But they can be defeated. They should be. That won’t change the power and will only marginally affect the wealth of the Kochs and their peers. But it will keep government from promoting only their interests, through actions paid for by everyone else.
If Fund says something that’s obviously true, I’d have to re-think my position and I haven’t seen him do anything here but speculate and fearmonger.
It must be hard for wingnuts to live in a world where they think everyone else behaves the way they feel.
This is how it’s gotta happen; state by state
The world of projection…
Yeah, it’s another form of projection.
And talking to some at the “street” level, i.e. regular non-rich folks deluded into supporting wingnuts, it seems to me that they’ve convinced themselves so thoroughly that liberals cheat, that they then feel it’s OK for wingnuts to cheat since liberals do it.
What a dangerous, dangerous attitude that is.
I’ve run into a few. I try to stay away from them, they are contagious disease bearing individuals; utterly corrupt.
Sometimes I have to take my anti-nausea homeopathic remedy…..really
Whatcha drinkin?
Karl Rove made accusing his opponents of behaving as he does into an art form. It’s one of the campaign and “governance” tricks that got Bush elected. A lot of people believed him. I can’t decide whether that’s sad or pathetic.
AND THE KILLNI’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen David Dayen:
This election result is simply the first battle by what I believe is a truly grassroots progressive movement against the established corporatist political structure that has ruled this state and the country since 1981. There is much more goin on here, Brother David, than simply “Democrats” taking advantage of Republican overreach. The hollowed out Democratic Party structure in Wisconsin, is bein’ refilled by new, young and very progressive people, many of them women. But this new Democratic Party is only a partner in a very large coalition that includes ALL organized labor, teachers, students, cops, firefighters, and even farmers. This movement is in opposition to the corporatist politics of both political parties and particularly the corporatist politics of President ObamaRhama. Something is happening here, what it is ain’t entirely clear…” but is is certainly nothing that our current elected leadership is gunna like and I think they already know it.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMUNITION, WE KNOW WHO THE ENEMY IS AND IT AIN’T US!!!
Pissy, isn’t he…
Government isn’t the problem…government bashing is.
Destroyin’ sumpin’ sure takes a lot less time and effort than building sumpin’, don’t it?
Norske! You WI people freaking rock. What a win! Today, for the first time in a long time (as corny as this might look) I’m proud to be American. The people spoke, and they freaking won.
Citizen KrisAinCA:
Bless you Citisen KrisA, but like I been tellin the youngsters here for over 5 weeks now, this isn’t even close to over and if you like how you feel today wait until you take your country back.
All you need is the right match.
Some music from Shostakovich’s 7th for the people of Wisconsin:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lp4444gU8D4
Rise up people—and throw back the fascist oppressors! The people united in common cause for equity and justice can never be defeated!
What an AWESOME reply.
We need to shorten that up just a little and make it fit on a T-shirt.
That’s a GREAT line.
I remember being full of those same feelings in late 2008, and most especially at the inaugeration of 2009 (where I admit tears freely flowed, I was so moved and proud of our country).
There’s nothing wrong with government that the Rs (or their wannabes) can’t make worse.
It’s just a refinement of what’s been going on for millennia. Turn it 180 degrees and convince people with the appropriate propaganda and you’re home free
YEAH!
X2
Me too. What a sap.
How about since the state is so split on the issues the demacrats can take there taxes and cover all these usless programs that you feel we need like planned parent hood, and free lunches and breakfast for the inner city people.I could go on but I wont and the Republicans can keep there taxes and do what they wish with them. im tired of supporting lazy people who think they deserve everything. Not my problem.
It’s a critical question.
PW is absolutely correct, about the Koch brothers’ “carpet-bombing,” Milwaukee County with ads. Part of that was probably a pay-off to the wingnut who runs Journal Communicaitons, the corp that controls the media in S.E. Wisconsin, Steve Smith. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s Editorial Board endorsed Prosser very on Saturday. IMHO, the intense “carpet bombing” began after that. Smith sucks a huge chunk of revenue out of Journal Communications.
Journal Communications CEO paid $2 million in 2010
There was no “R” or “D” designation on the ballot or anywhere else. The attack ads may have been effective in blurring Prosser’s connection to Gov. Wanker and the Koch brothers.
As I was following the election last night, I was pondering what would have happened if Obama was governor of Wisconsin instead of Walker.
Seems to me he would have caved to the Republican legislature and striped the collective bargaining rights, then claimed a great victory for saving jobs.
Any Democratic opposition would have been told to sit down and shut up.
Too early to know what will happen in Wisconsin, but at least battle lines have been drawn and the people are fighting back.
So Scott (piece of shit) Walker takes a hit. Makes my day. Fuck you Scott!
And how about a shout out to David and Charles. You suck. Millions of people hate your guts. It looks like you’re wasting your dirty money in Wisconsin.
Oh. I almost forgot. You can stop looking for your shoes Obama. Wisconsin doesn’t need you. None of us do.
Very very happy to learn this news… esp after fear-mongering of Japanese nuclear melt-downs. At least this is a ray of sunshine.
Best to the good citizens of WI who showed how it’s DONE and done correctly for a change. Here’s hoping for more of the same across the land.
I felt the same way. Hopefully Wisconsin is stronger and smarter than the rest of us. I believe they did the right thing electing Kloppenberg. Hopefully she judiciates according to the rule of law. That would be enough for me. The law is on our side.
Go Bucks! Go Badgers! You’re on the same side of the field in this one.
Sweet!
And it looks like WI Repub #2 is ready for re-call
Turnout for Milwaukee was relatively low. Various explanations have been given. One is merely that Milwaukee voters voted as they usually due in off elections, and hadn’t been mobilized. That would be a party failure.
The silver lining is that that would make the Black Panther ACORN Voter Fraud line hard to push, though they’ll try anyway.
On Wisconsin!
I’m glad Ailes announced it. The tin-foil hat crowd can’t claim left-wing conspiracy.
Congratulations to all of you in Wisconsin!
Word. (Do people still say that?)
on Wisconsin!
Interesting imagery with the Battle for Leningrad contrasting with an election to take back government from leaders going down the path of Fascism.
Nice piece of music.
It’s definitely a personality disorder.
Here comes the recount
Wow they’re not messing around
Here we have another expression of a key myth of the American Right – that they are the Silent Majority.
Many of them truly believe that almost everyone thinks the way they do (certainly everyone in their social circle does), and votes the way they do. It follows from this that the opposition is just some crazy minority unworthy of consideration, and if the Right loses an election it cannot possibly be because there are more voters on the other side. It must have been stolen.
I talked to and called many people. I hand painted a sign and stuck it on my mailbox post, I voted and I urged others to get out and vote. I had some civil arguments to explain my position with help from people at FDL. I am happy with JK winning with the yet to be officially certified count. If Prosser was a real man, he’d graciously concede. I will still be friends with my neighbors on both sides of the political fence. Wisconsin.
Just got home from work and again way late to this discussion.
Thank you, thank you for all the work you put into the breakdown.
I have to tell you that you definitely made an impression on my thinking that we really need to watch the Milwaukee area in the recount. I smell a rat and with the Journal~Sentinal doing the cheering for Prosser and Koch carpet bombing to borrow PW’s phrase, we need to be very, very, observant on what goes on in that area. (as well as the rest of the state in the recount)
Just thinking here but if Scott Walker thinks Madison is bad, then maybe he should resign and move out of the capitol and go to hell.
Don’t forget to raise a glass to Ian Murphy. All this may not have happened without his contribution.
Undervotes: more voted for the city post than voted for judge. More voter education was needed in Milwaukee. The audit of the vote should tell us a lot.
Desperate pieces of sh|t, grasping at straws. This is perfectly understandable, if true. In fact, I know several people myself who only voted for the Supreme Court race. Why? Because they couldn’t decide who to vote for for Mayor of Madison, and they knew the progressive was going to absolutely trounce the conservative candidate for Dane County executive. Which he did. “Extremely close race for Dane County Executive” my ass.
So, in short, the right-wing trash has got nothing left but lies and misdirection. Expect a recount to add votes to Kloppenburg despite the wingnut tears.
Again, it will be interesting to look more closely at the votes and undervotes precinct by precinct. I am sure plenty of students could do this for a research project.
I don’t know what the audit rules are and when the results will be available for this kind of a look-see, but it could be very instructive.
Amen. Sing it brother (sister?).
It’s a deliberate, calculated form of attack. Hoist the mirror-like shield of Athena and he’ll turn to stone.
Against all odds the battered and starving occupants of Leningrad threw back Paulus’ Sixth Army who were also handicapped by Hitler’s refusal to let them retreat and the German Army leadership’s belief that fighting in the winter would be unnecessary because their triumph was inevitable.
Shostakovich wrote this work in 1942 during the Siege as a way to rally his countrymen to repel the invaders.
It shows you the power of the human spirit and how the determined and brave occupants of Leningrad resolutely refused to surrender despite the odds. We can learn from their example and never surrender to those who would tear down what people of good will seek to build.
Norske,
Good on you old feller for all the work you did for the good cause. We have the same problem where I live. My liberal association is moribund. We used to only have cabinet ministers, now we have nothing. They don’t put people on the street, and think that their election day telephoning will bring them in. It didn’t work last time and it won’t this time. I’ve been urging them to get our candidate on the streets going door to door. You can still do this in Canada, and it works. I see Justin Trudeau with his wife and kids at my bar on a regular basis, and he is always working the crowd.
Anyway, great work. Hope you are recovering from the effort.
Here is something I did not know:
Russ Feingold won his first term in the US Senate representing WI by 32 votes.
As long as FDL and other progressives keep shining the light on the truth about Walker and his ilk, there’s hope.
I live in wisconsin and I actually find it quite distressing how close it was. The unions and other liberal organizations went to herculean efforts to turn out the vote, and Kloppenberg barely won. I don’t think the finances and motivation can be sustained at this level long enough to win. On top of this it came out during the campaign that prosser had let a child molester off the hook, this means 50% of the people in wisconsin hate government employees more than pedophiles.
Paulus surrendered at Stalingrad on January 31, 1943. Is the 6th Army involved at Leningrad?
The turnout was phenomenal, but 7 out of every 12 registered voters didn’t show up.
If 75% of the 740,000 folks who voted for Kloppenburg sign next year, then Walker will be recalled. 540,000 signatures needed.
This mess is far from over. the Dem. can re-call as much as they want and then the republicans can re-call as much as they want the state is split. the main part of the bill was passed on tue. and signed into law with all the cuts with it. FDR. fermly beleaved that no state or gov employee should have the right to strike it was immoral, and most other states dont allow there state employees to have collective bargaining so it time this state gets rid of it to.
when all the republicans are out then we will be living in the USSR! socialist countries allway fail! and thats what the Demacratic party wants is socialism.