We don’t know how it will end yet, but for the moment, what we’re seeing in Egypt is remarkable, in terms of the spectacle of actual accountability for an Arab ruler:
Ousted Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak was complicit in shootings of anti-regime protesters during a period of upheaval in the country, a member of an official fact-checking commission said Tuesday.
“Whether the president gave the official order or remained silent knowing the shooting of protesters would take place, he is responsible for the 846 protesters who died during the January 25 revolution, especially since the killing started from Day One,” said Judge Omar Marawan, the commission’s secretary-general.
This is an official government report, not a human rights group’s study or anything like that. It’s highly unusual, in my recollection, to see this level of accountability. Typically the exiled rulers go off to some tropical paradise and remain outside the reach of the law. But the protest movement in Egypt demanded that Mubarak be brought to justice. And that’s happening. It’s actually happening.
The report described the opening of prisons, clearly a high-level decision, as intentional, providing evidence in the form of video surveillance cameras showing security forces allowing prisoners to flee. It also documented security forces firing at protesters and running them over with vehicles.
This evidence then goes to the general prosecutor in Egypt, for use in the ongoing investigation into Mubarak and the key members of his regime, including his sons. Even Omar Suleiman, briefly the Vice President, has been questioned in the probe.
This is real. Mubarak is under detention now and I would say it’s likely that he will be charged soon.
Egypt has a lot of lessons to teach the United States.




16 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Really when are the trials going to happen here to hold BushCo for lying us into a War and crimes against humanity??
I sure won’t hold my breath!
Yes. It would be nice to live in a country where high government officials and corporate executives aren’t above the law.
Unfortunately, the US has zero willingness to learn
Yes. Just imagine if the U.S. held people accountable for war crimes and white collar crimes. Imagine Dick Cheney and Lloyd Blankfein in orange jumpsuits.
Official report means the Government wants Mubarak to take the fall for the economy and they want to try him.
Murder means all his ill gotten gains are fair game for his victims which would appease the mob.
I wonder if the Army wants to appease the mob by hanging Mubarak out to dry rather than do real reform and create good paying jobs is my worry.
Add Scooter Libby and you got my FDL happy thought of the week vote:)
You have seen this level of accountability? Where? When?
Good on the Egyptians!
However, as nahant, bluewombat, and dakine01 have pointed out … ’tis very unlikely to happen here, and our myths of “exceptionalism” preclude our “learning” ANYTHING from ANYBODY or ANYONE.
America does NOT “do” history, conscience, or humanity.
Why would America do “accountability” when its history since before the beginning of WW II has been to deny that such a thing exists for the brightest and the best as well as politicians and the uber wealthy?
Why, in the good ole YooEssAy, all THREE twigs of government are up to their eyeballs in corruption, complicity, and treason most foul, and most of the public either doesn’t have a clue or doesn’t appear to care.
No, we won’t do “it” ourselves, the rest of the world will have to have a convention in Geneva before power in America is brought to consequence.
DW
Bravo to the Egyptian youth. This is stupendous.
Clearly some people here at FDL just don’t get it. America is the greatest country in the world. Since we’re the greatest, we’re also the greatest example to the world, a shining city on a hill. The idea that we have anything to learn from anyone else is just stoopid. Maybe if they learned from us they wouldn’t be so poor. Instead of wronging their betters all those dirty Arab hippies need to get a job and buy a bunch of shit they don’t need by putting themselves into debt so they can be more like us. Also too.
Gee it would be nice to live in a real democracy like Egypt.
Oh yeah, Libby, Dumbya and a lot more. Build a special prison for them and then privatize it.
Or at least one where no one is above the Law and all who get caught breaking the Law actually gets jail time!!
I honestly hope they don’t hang him…seriously…I hate when that happens. Shudder.
The transition government there has done some odd and disagreeable things since taking over. This isn’t one of them. Well done, Egypt.
I’m currently enthralled with your bee diary :)
Back to it.
Hope you enjoy it.