As I noted yesterday, the Senate passed cloture, by a 74-8 margin, on the motion to proceed for a four-year extension of key provisions of the Patriot Act. Final passage is expected Wednesday, so for a seminal civil liberties issue that has been in place nearly ten years, we will see essentially one day of debate in the Senate. As Glenn Greenwald points out, there is still bipartisanship in Washington when something like depriving civil liberties in the name of Terror has to get done. We may have killed Osama bin Laden, but we have yet to slay the Boogeyman.
The eight votes against the motion to proceed were Jeff Merkley, Mark Begich, Max Baucus, and John Tester, and GOP Senators Lisa Murkowski, Rand Paul, and Dean Heller. Mark Udall, who sent out a petition on reforming the Patriot Act just yesterday, voted yes on the motion to proceed. So did Senate Judiciary Committee chair Patrick Leahy, who consistently has sought reforms, however minor. However, Leahy and Rand Paul are teaming up to try and add some reforms.
The Leahy-Paul amendment introduced by the Kentucky Republican and the Vermont Democrat would have National Security Letters expire on Dec. 31, 2013. It also requires the Justice Department inspector general to audit the issuance of NSL letters and expands public reporting on the use of such letters under the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act.
“We were so frightened after 9/11 that we readily gave up these freedoms,” Paul said. “Not only would I let these expire, but I think we should sunset the entire PATRIOT Act.”
“You can be opposed to terrorists … but we can do it with a process that protects the innocent,” Paul said.
These really are the bare minimum reforms. But all that this minority of opponents has going for them is time. These three provisions expire on Friday, and Senators like Paul could hold up passage for some time by forcing all post-cloture time to be used. This is basically his plan, and establishment, fear-worshipping Senators like Dianne Feinstein warned him about blood on his hands:
Freshman Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), a vocal critic of the counter-terrorism surveillance law, threatened Monday to “drag out” the process if Reid fails to hold votes on some of the nine amendments Paul introduced or co-sponsored on Monday. Paul, a libertarian-minded tea-party senator, noted that Reid had promised earlier this year to set aside a week’s worth of debate on the bill and allow votes on amendments.
“We’re not going to get the week, but we’re working on still trying to get a discussion and amendments to the Patriot Act. …” Paul told reporters just off the Senate floor. “We’ll just have to wait and see.” [...]
Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), the chairwoman of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, said “it remains to be seen” how Senate leaders will handle Paul’s amendments. But she warned against any political maneuvering that would slow down or derail the bill, which grants a four-year extension to key Patriot Act provisions.
“I think it would be a huge mistake,” Feinstein told reporters. If somebody wants to take on their shoulders not having provisions in place which are necessary to protect the United States at this time, that’s a big, big weight to bear.”
As Glenn notes, that’s truly an ugly response, the kind of establishment bullying we’ve seen for the last decade on measures of “national security.” It’s come from both parties, and anyone who dares not get with the program gets accused of helping The Terrorists.
At best, Paul and Leahy could drag out debate until Friday, the day that these provisions expire. Clearly they don’t have the votes to do much else. But that does start to run out the clock on passage. So we’ll see if they get their votes.




16 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Instead of tweeking and girating the Act, they should go back to the blackboard on it. Start from the beginning and review each and every line of the Act. Decide what it really means, clarify that to the American citizens and cut out most of it.
With the Deficit so huge I see no reason why cuts and duplication cannot be removed from the programs that fall under the Act. In fact, most of it is no longer necessary since the Military has now gained the ability to use the tools and even contract those tools and duties out to private companies. It has warped way beyond our government agencies and is just asking for abuse of funds and liberties.
Dems and repubs agree on gutting our freedom
Dems and repubs agree on gutting SS and medicare
Dems and repubs agree on endless war
Dems and repubs agree on tax breaks for the rich
Dems and repubs agree on bailouts for the banks and corps
Dems and repubs agree on more trade agreements that will impact jobs
Dems and repubs agree on everything that screws us and enriches their bosses
Paul Craig Roberts: “The west prides itself that it is the standard for the world, that it is a democracy. But nowehere do you see democratic outcomes: not in Greece, not in Ireland, not in the UK, not here, the outcomes are always to punish the innocent and reward the guilty. And that’s what the Greeks are in the streets, protesting. We see this all over the west. There is no democracy, there are oligarchies, some of these smaller European countries are not even run by their own governments, they are run by Wall Street… There is probably more democracy in China than there is in the west. Revolution is the only answer… We are confronted with a curious situation. Throughout the west we think we have democracy, we hold ourselves up high, we demonize China, we talk about the mafia state of Russia, we talk about the Arabs and so on, but where is the democracy here?”
To me this signals that they have no real intention of fixing it just like lke what EmptyWheel shows is the truth about how we ended up with Trailblazer. Bin Laden is dead; just kill (procedurall y,let die) the PATRIOT Act!
This is a good example of why some people ought to abandon their knee-jerk antipathy to Republicans and Tea Partiers, and move on specific issues and not on generalities.
yea for Rand calling an end to PA. Very long overdue.
Blessings,
You can read EmptyWheel’s thread-in-progress which touches on how the Lie Factory eased the passage of the PATRIOT Act in the first go-round: “Why Didn’t FBI Investigate AFIP’s Role in Starting the Iraq-Anthrax Rumors?” (May 24, 2011)
Great article on this subject
http://www.economist.com/search/apachesolr_search/lexington%20save%20the%20fourth%20amendment
My guess is the folks who’s favorite term is “bat shit crazy” will tiptoe around this thread.
“Wingnut,” too…
Also Rethugs.
Great guy yeah sure and when he votes to get rid of medicare, medicaid, and SS then what will you say.
I’m very happy if Rand Paul actually does something *useful* for the “small people.” But I wait to see what else he does, too. As an unabashed libertarian, Paul has also expressed the desire to roll back civil rights, as well as get rid of Soc Sec, Medicare & Medicaid, as discussed by joeblue @11.
All very well to chide about calling out “wingnuts” or “teahadists.” Hate to say it, but what’s the likelihood of Paul/Leahy succeeding on this effort??? I give it about 1 in a million chance of passing bc there’s far too much money being made bc of the Patriot Act, plus it’s useful to the PTB to have all that unabashed power & rights to invade our privacy.
Kudos to Paul in his effort, but I’ll wait to see what else he does.
Then he will be a dirt bag and so will all the Democrats who vote with him.
He’s already a dirtbag in my book.
Best speech I’ve heard coming out of the Senate hall so far this year.
The PATRIOT Act Renewal articles are already falling off the front page. JUST HOW IMPORTANT IS PRESERVING AMERICAN LIBERTY TO FIREDOG LAKE? This is a battle, it is not won by moving on after writing a few articles on one day. You have to keep your readers rallied and focused. Is FDL here to accomplish something, or only to give the few real liberal progressives a place to vent and defuse so they don’t bother the establishment?