MINNEAPOLIS – Sen. Al Franken will give a speech tomorrow at Netroots Nation about the need for progressive infrastructure as a firewall to protect the middle class. In this excerpt from tomorrow’s speech, he is unsparing in even subtly questioning the patriotism of those who would threaten the survival of the middle class:
Medicare, and Medicaid, and investment in infrastructure, and public education, and workers’ rights, and civil rights, and equal under the law – these aren’t just good progressive ideas, they’re examples of traditional American values.
And when Republicans talk about destroying these things, they’re talking about turning their backs on the America we’ve built. They’re talking about ripping apart the fabric of our society. They’re talking about a transformation of our country – about undermining our tradition so radically, they might as well be tearing stars off the flag.
I talked to Franken via phone today, as he returned home from a funeral for a soldier killed overseas. His remarks tomorrow are really connected to the fear that we are seeing a flickering out of the American dream. “We have the greatest disparity in income since the 1920s. The middle class dream is fading, and we’re losing the argument on the economy. We need to gain back the initiative, and convince people that it’s ridiculous to be gutting Medicare, to essentially end it, in order to give huge tax cuts.”
But I wanted to ask about how Democrats can deliver that message in a time when the Vice President is engaged in talks to cut federal spending even during a demand crisis. It seems hard to convince people of the importance of your efforts to protect the middle class when the middle class doesn’t feel protected by the actions.
“I think we’ve ceded too much ground,” said Franken of the deficit talks. “When you have a Republican House and a Senate where the Dems can’t get cloture on anything, you’re going to have by definition a compromise. But we’re compromising with people who don’t have compromise in mind. Mitch McConnell said his top priority is to defeat President Obama. They win by country losing.”
Franken said that the ideology of tax cuts to spur a recovery and create jobs is “not based on any evidence whatsoever.” He noted that Clinton and Reagan raised taxes and growth and jobs leapt up afterwards, and that Bush’s tax cuts led to the worst job growth of the postwar era. In addition, we currently have the lowest tax rates in 60 years and we’re not creating jobs. “I’ve seen first-hand now, there’s a lot of self-delusion in the Republican Party,” he said. “If it’s in your interest to believe it, you do.”
Franken lamented the poor choices made in an effort to compromise. “(The Republicans) say we have to compromise, here’s where it starts. They say no tax increases whatsoever. We say, it starts with equal amounts of cuts and increases in revenue. If you’re making a compromise between an unreasonable position that makes no sense whatsoever, and a reasonable one, why are we compromising? What’s to compromise?”
Of course, Republicans are leveraging the default of the US government through denying an increase of the debt limit. “In a game of chicken, the irrational person has an advantage over the rational,” Franken said. This is certainly borne out by the trajectory of the talks.
But I asked why we didn’t use the hammer that Democrats have in the debate: the expiration of the Bush tax cuts. Gridlock, in this case, will lead to that expiration, which would eliminate almost entirely the medium-term deficit. And as Franken said, we had tremendous job growth with Clinton-era tax rates. Democrats could enter the discussion saying that Republicans either compromise, offer some near-term stimulus, or the gridlock will continue, the Bush tax cuts which fall mostly on the rich will expire, and the entire deficit will be filled with revenues.
“There are other things to do,” said Franken, saying that allowing Medicare to negotiate with pharmaceuticals would save a lot of money, drawing down from Iraq and Afghanistan would do the same, and eliminating oil subsidies as well (he pointedly didn’t mention killing ethanol subsidies, which he opposes). Of course, Democrats can simply say that they will abide by nothing that deviates from that current baseline which puts things in balance, and if Republicans disagree on all options, the expiration of the Bush tax cuts will do all the work.
“We’re starting in the middle,” Franken said. “It’s a mistake.”
And of course, this all deviates from the real conversation on jobs, which you cannot do anything meaningful on the deficit without, along with the tax revenue that goes with it. “Erskine Bowles said we can’t grow ourselves out of this. I said, maybe, but we’re not going to get out of it if we don’t have growth.”




43 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Al could stop going to funerals if he stopped supporting several wars.
Liberate your inner liberal, Al. We need a Eugene McCarthy.
Someone please remind me, how did Franken help us on HCR?
Apparently, Franken is like the rest.
“Vote Dem. We kinda suck just a little less.”
Well you have to cut Al some slack because he has to contend with Senator Duck and Cover, Minnesota’s Senator Spineless, Stand for Nothing, Stick up for No One, but always run for cover with a big Smile on your face, Amy Klobuchar.
Let’s give Al some props for voting against the Patriot Act renewal.
Speaking of which, I just read that the administration lobbied Congress for a permanent renewal. With friends like these…
That’s a pretty good description… and her BFF is the junior senator from Colorado who does the same damn thing.
I never thought of Franken as someone who wanted to be a career politician. Maybe I was wrong. If he put six years to good work, he’d probably get another six. If not, why bother with him. Shit or get off the pot, I’d say.
Correction, the façade was that we had both houses and the Presidency, but the reality is this administration started at the right and only feinted to the middle.
I’m ready to let it all come crashing down and build from the ashes, because this incrementalism bullshit is only going backwards.
Here’s Feingold’s speech at NN.
I think it’s time to bring out the tricoteuses.
Yep. Fast or faster, we know where we’re going.
What time is Franken speaking? Does anybody know?
Franken isn’t perfect, but he has backed a lot of good bills.
But more to the particular point of this post, I wish more Dems were saying what Franken is going to say tomorrow.
“I think we’ve ceded too much ground,” in the deficit talks. Ya Think????
Weiner may have been a mess, but at least he’d shout out the truth now and then. Step up, Man, step up.
Yes, at least our wacky R’s Tim and Michelle tell you that they’re going to screw granny. Amy just smiles….and refuses to oppose cuts to Social Security.
“If you’re making a compromise between an unreasonable position that makes no sense whatsoever, and a reasonable one, why are we compromising?”
It’s not compromise Senator, it’s capitulation.
(Franken is up first thing in the morning at 9.)
Senator Franken,
We’re beyond the fear that we’re seeing a flickering out of the American dream. We are seeing it. It is happening. What are we going to do about it?
The sentiments in your speech have to translate into action and results that will make a difference for the middle class.
Thank you.
I’m not signing any more petitions or sending any emails to President Stab-Me-In-The-Back. But I AM in email contact with my Representative…whom I like for her voting record. I continue to warn her that Democrats are losing hope and that she and her fellows better get together and stand up. If we don’t go to the polls at all, she’s going to lose. But if she won’t speak up, then she’s a loser from the get go. Buh bye.
Ya think?????????????? My god are these Poison Ivy League grads so clueless??????????????
Klobuchar seems to make the right noises without doing the right thing, but she’s just a symptom of a utterly corrupt system. Until money is taken out of the elections equation, there’s no end to this economic and political debacle short of complete systemic failure. Really, there aren’t any “fixes” that are going to fix a cancerous system.
There are exceptions, but most Democrats now just pretend to fight, take a dive, and know that they’ll be taken care of if they lose come Nov.
There are far too few in either party with integrity anymore.
If Franken just gives a speech or two and otherwise does nothing, we’ll know where he really stands.
it seems a little of my heart gets torn out each day
today, all over the news, all over the advertisements, things like;
“aarp recognizes the need to reduce payments”
my gawd, it seems as if they are not “winning”, they’ve won
this is even harder to take under obama then it was under bush
Let him say it on CBS, NBC, MSNBC, ABC, NPR. Anything he says at NRN will not enter the consciousness of the masses. It’s safe.
I’d settle for a Hubert Humphrey at this point.
…and that any of them would back it up by actually doing something that would make a difference.
Middle Man to the rescue!
http://images2.dailykos.com/i/user/3/TMW2011_04_06_small.jpg
we didn’t need to cede any ground, all that needed be done;
“we cannot afford the bush redistribution of middle class assets marketed as a “tax deduction”, it has taken too much from the laborers, it has grown our deficits, it has done what everyone knew it would do;
it destroyed jobs, investments into our country and our kids future.”
but no
instead they let the corporatists say whatever they wanted and then they just about agreed with everything the corporatists claimed
tons
tons
tons of trouble we are luke
He was for the public option before he voted for Obama’s piece-o-shit.
Which is why we should let the fake Dems go. I think there would be more push back against a true Repub than the Repub we now have in office. And if the Dems won’t stand up, get rid of all of them and start over.
*heh* Breitbart crashes Netroots Nation, is Confronted …
Franken, Obama, et al can’t find their balls with both hands.. He “thinks” too much has been c@eded months after the fact, and they both think a DEA chief on a reefer madness witch hunt is a fine idea, and clean coal, and safe nukes really are clean and safe. Lunatics.
Franken talks a good fight.
Just Like Obama his actions do not match his words.
Hey, I’d settle for LBJ and I came in opposing him. He escalated the wrong war but had the grace to regret it and not run again AND he gave us Medicare.
What do we have now? Democrats who brag about how many wars they’ve can juggle while they negotiate to slash Medicare and figure out new ways to make the rich richer.
Hey! I’d settle for Nixon and at the rate things are going I’ll be pining for Reagan before long.
Damn you Dearie for literally saying everything I was thinking.
Well said, and better than I could have.
“Shit or get off the pot”!!! Yup.
Because why else is he there?
Either do something or get the F out of the way.
Same goes for Kucinich.
Enough of this “but they’re good guys”.
They are paid to do a job. If they can’t then quit.
Weiner is a total douche. And his pro-Israeli stance where everything is blamed on the Palestinians (http://www.juancole.com/2011/06/top-things-anthony-weiner-has-said-that-are-worse-than-sexting.html) is beyond reprehensible. Not as a D. But reprehensible as a human being.
But at least he got in their faces. He was shouting in their faces.
These same people will continue to talk. And then talk some more. And then … surprise, talk even more.
While the US sinks further and further into oblivion.
I was thinking the same thing: I would settle for Nixon too.
He’s left of O and all these Ds combined.
Even though Nixon started the fall, he would even balk at some of the things these politicians are doing.
“But I asked why we didn’t use the hammer that Democrats have in the debate: the expiration of the Bush tax cuts.”
Good plan! The extended unemployment benefits would have ended immediately as well reducing the deficit. And we would be debating the crushing taxes Obama and Democrats imposed on the middle class and poor.
And Republicans would be demanding tax cuts and budget cuts before hiking the debt ceiling, figuring they would pile the shutdown and other fallout on the Democrats and Obama who killed the recovery and took money out of the pockets of working people.
Obama might have won reelection, but every Democrat would have been attacked as raising taxes and making everyone poorer, and as you would be attacking Obama and Democrats for not doing something about the increasing number of homeless and hungry, Republicans would probably win Congress.
The best outcome would then be better job numbers, greatly reduced deficits, and the Republicans determined to win Congress and the White House to repeat 2001-2006 on tax cuts and ramping up the deficit.
From Polly Toynbee The Guardian, Saturday 1 May 2010
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2010/may/01/precious-vote-apathy-tactical-voting/print
You want to give Al Franken cover for his vote against the Patriot Act?
He voted for cloture when the bar was higher to overcome (60 votes rather than 51).
Here’s a summary of what the America voters wanted and what Obama and the Democrats have done in two and a half years, just focusing four major issues:
1. TARP & Financial Bailout: Over 70% of us opposed the bailout. Obama accelerated it with Geithner and Bernanke – both Bush carryovers embraced by Obama.
2 . Health Care: 72% of us supported “a government-administered insurance plan—something like Medicare for those under 65—that would compete for customers with private insurers.” Supporting Max Baucus, Obama blocked hearings on single payer and chocked off true health care reform.
3. The Debt and Fair Taxes: Washington Post-ABC poll Washington Post-ABC poll, Spring 2011: 72 percent support raising taxes on the rich – including 68 percent of Independents and 54 percent of Republicans. Obama twice ‘bargained’ to extend the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy.
4. Afghanistan: 64% of us opposed expanding the war in Afghanistan and wanted to disentangle from Bush-era ‘War on Terror’ and ‘preventive war’ policies. Today, over 70% of Americans oppose the war. Obama continues it.
So, have the Democrats ‘given too much’? I dont think the Democrats have done the American people any good at all, because the ‘Democrats’ have rejected every thing the American people wanted. So the Democrats havent ‘given to much’, they havent given at all. In fact, the Democrats’ record when compared to what people wanted is such that no one can seriously consider supporting the Democratic Party in the future. The Democratic Party has simply stopped supporting its own principles and standing up for the people who have traditionally supported it.
Havewn’t you learned yet that the Dems are pretty freakin worthless? They scurry like titmice at the first sign of blowback from the Rebaggers.
I agree with Frankens premise that the American dream is flickering out. If he were so adamant about this why didn’t they step up to the plate when the opportunity presented itself. They did not it is either spend on the left agenda or spend on the right agenda. Either way it is spending and debt. Proposed cuts to social programs are not the solution. Cuts to defense, stopping the useless wars and bring all troops home will do the job. Cutting foreign aid and military aid will do the job. investing in our country, rebuilding infrastructure and industry, job creation will do the job. A rising tide lifts all boats. As of this moment in time there is very little real GDP produced in America beyond paper.
Ladies and gentlemen,Hello everybody,
input this URL: === http://globalsell.org/ ===
shirts, bags, hat and the decorations.
you can find many cheap and fashion stuff (jor dan shoes)
(NBA NFL NHL MLB jersey)
( lv handbag)
(cha nel wallet)
(D&G sunglasses)
(ed har dy jacket)
(UGG boot)
and so on..welcome to our website:
( http://globalsell.org/)
we sincerely hope to establish the business relation with you.
Looking forward your visit.
Hello everybody,the good shoping place,the new season approaching,
welcome to this site:=== http://globalsell.org/ ===-
shirts,bags,hat and the decorations.
Air jordan(1-24)shoes $33
UGG BOOT $50
???
Handbags(Coach lv fendi d&g) $33
Tshirts (Polo ,ed hardy,lacoste) $16
Jean(True Religion,ed hardy,coogi) $30
Sunglasses(Oakey,coach,gucci,Armaini) $12
New era cap $9
Bikini (Ed hardy,polo) $18.prada,
We accept payment PYAPAL.
Free Shipping.
You must not miss it!
Thank you!
=== http://globalsell.org/ ===-
=== http://globalsell.org/ ===
Ya think, Al?