I don’t think we’re making enough out of incompetence as a primary reason we’re mired in a zero-growth decade. For instance, the Federal Reserve, empowered with enormous control over the economy, simply didn’t perform well over the last three years in using unconventional monetary policy to give a boost to the economy. They left the real possible actions that could have driven some economic improvement on the table, and what they did end up doing didn’t have much of an effect.
But the Fed are a bunch of right geniuses compared to the Treasury Department:
Nearly nine months after its formation, a $30 billion government fund to foster small-business lending has yet to pay out a single dime, even as the nation struggles with traumatic levels of unemployment.
Now, Rep. Sam Graves (R-Mo.) wants an explanation. And as chairman of the Small Business Committee, he hopes his sole witness at a hearing Wednesday — Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner — can shed some light on the holdup.
“This isn’t a witch hunt in any sense of the word,” Graves said. “We’re just trying to figure out why the fund isn’t performing as advertised.”
Yes, I would like to know the same thing.
This was one of the few successful bills passed that had anything to do with jobs last year. In theory, it was supposed to use $30 billion to lever up to $300 billion in small business lending through community banks. When it was signed last September, the theory was it could help create 500,000 jobs.
There has not been a lack of effort: 844 businesses have applied for $11.6 billion from the Small Business Lending Fund, according to Politico. It’s just taken nine months to “vet the financial soundness of each bank,” according to Treasury. An official said he expects the money to start going out this month, which is what you would say when cornered like this.
There’s some industry grousing about capital requirements here, but that’s bunk. You’re talking about $30 billion untethered to those requirements. Not that I often quote someone from the American Bankers Association, but this matches with the expected experience at Treasury:
James Ballentine, senior vice president of grass-roots and political operations for the American Bankers Association, said new programs usually experience holdups. His organization’s initial concerns dealt more with implementing the fund properly rather than how quickly it would release money.
Still, Ballentine said, the approval period has dragged on much longer than anticipated.
“When you speak with officials with Treasury, they tell you it will be in a week or two,” he said. “Then a week or two goes by.”
I think we have to include rank incompetence in the mix here. Sure, there are areas where the top officials have perverse incentives, or are just craven in their sellout to moneyed interests. They also may just be bad at their jobs. It happens.
UPDATE: Sen. Jeff Merkley was one of the leaders who got the small business lending bill passed last year. I asked his office about this story today. “Senator Merkley has been extremely frustrated with the slow pace of Treasury in setting up the Small Business Lending Fund – and urged Treasury last month to pick up the pace,” they said. You can read Merkley’s letter to Treasury here. Simply put, Merkley’s office believes this fund should be the highest priority at Treasury, especially with unemployment so high, and he doesn’t see that kind of commitment yet.





44 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Unfuckingbelievable.
My my. Everything that might help the People, whether it is foreclosure relief or household debt relief or small business assistance or consumer protection or job creation or infrastructure projects or what have you is being slow walked in Washington — if not outright prevented from happening at all.
You’d almost think it was ‘policy’, wouldn’t you?
“As with all SBA loans, the process starts with your local banker, so it is important to build a strong relationship with him/her. ”
http://www.petoskeynews.com/business/pnr-sba-programs-can-aid-businesses-with-financing-20110622,0,5479472.story
planted in the local newspaper by a financial consultant firm, SCORE
It would appear that this has been another program, like HAMP, that has been for show simply to stall for time. What exactly Treasury expects to accomplish for their giant corporate overlords through this tactic is truly unclear. My growing cynicism gives me some ideas.
Competition from the smalls that they cannot directly control is bad for their business. It does not give them the reliability they so desperately crave.
Yeah, it’s the policy all right, as in SB folks aren’t in the top 1%.
Geithner is closer to a Financial Sector/Big Bank Lobbyist than he is a U. S. Government employee. He was on board with the “DIRE” prediction and hasn’t done anything but support big business.
The Federal Government is still studded with Bush administration holdovers. I wouldn’t be surprised if one or more of them is simply sitting on his or her butt on this. There isn’t much the administration can do about it, though on individual issues they can push things through if enough pressure is put on them. The problem is that the obstruction in the Bush-filled bureaucracy is systemic; there aren’t enough weeks in a year to get past it.
We’re talking about loans here to what are truly *small* businesses, as opposed to the fiction about S Corps, also called “Small businesses” but which are not. As in the Koch Brothers’ Industries are mostly all considered “Small businesses” which gives them all sorts of tax cuts, tax breaks and incentives, but in truth, these are mega-giant corporations.
But this about loans for the more “mom & pop” style of business, some larger and some quite small. But it’s bascially the peons, not the upper 1%. I was wondering IF this money was getting out to the masses bc I happen to know some for-real small business owners, who are struggling in this economy.
Yeah: the multi-millionaires in the House & Senate just love to bray about how small businesses are the life-blood of the nation, but as we see here, even IF you’re a good little capitalist (and quite likely a Republican voter), it’s all about SCREW YOU, GET LOST, ya loser!
I’ve been saying it for ages: all of these Galtian stand-on-your-own-two-feet Libertarian don’t get it that when the Overlords are out their SCREWING us ALL, it means ALL of us are getting screwed.
Believe in your Ayn Rand-fantasies all you like. The upper 1% is gonna screw you as badly as they’re screwing us so-called “socialist” DFHs. The upper 1% doesn’t give a sh*t about anyone except themselves and maybe a few of their mega-rich buddies.
No surprises, here. Doubt this money will ever get into the hands of any peon, no matter how capitalistic and/or successful that person is with their business.
That is close to $14 million per application. That is NOT small business surely. One does have to wonder just which “small” business applied for these loans but maybe that is the
realistcynic in me.Great minds think alike. I owe you a beverage I do believe.
Likely true, but Obama’s not gonna do a d*mn thing about cuz if it wasn’t burrowed-in Bushites doing it, then Obama would just appoint someone who did the same thing. Obama’s pleased as punch that these “loyal” employees are there doing exactly what they’re doing.
I don’t give Obama one jot of credibility in this regard. Things are going *exactly* to Obama’s plan, which is what the upper 1% want.
Why sure and thankee kindly. I’ll take an iced green tea, if ya don’t mind!!
I’ll bet that some percentage are truely small businesses in every sense of the word, but I certainly would not be surprised if huge businesses also applied for these loans.
As I commented earlier, the super wealthy have their lurks via calling their companies “S Corps,” which gives them all kinds of perks & lurks, and their companies are called “Small Businesses,” when, in fact, they are not. But for TAX & LOAN purposes, that’s how they’re considered. Whot. a. sorprise. NOT.
Love him or hate him, Keith Olbermann did a great report about how this “Small Business” lurk operates:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H_an_w4OFPI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cmsj3QujN_Q&feature=related
Worth watching; very educational. I knew about this before Olbermann’s special report, but I doubt that many citizens are clued into how these wealthy sh*ts have gamed the system. Libertarian, stand-on-your-own-two-feet, my @ss… the super wealthy do nothing to “stand on their own two feet.” They’re all about ripping off the middle and working class to rob our money to put into their overshore bank accounts.
It’s called: wake up, sheeple.
I’d think that it’s more like .001%, if that?
Bingo!
Yep billion dollar businesses getting small business loans, I really loved it when I read about this few yrs ago. Gaming the system, just more corp. welfare.
No, no, no, Rep. Graves, you don’t understand – we WANT a witch hunt for Geithner!
Timothy Geithner knows best. Help Wall Street, not Main Street.
Obama’s thoughts? Do we really care about more talk and no action?
Obama is just holding it back for when he goes into full campaign mode. He’ll make appearances where new funding was just approved to show what a benevolent little king he can be.
Timing is everything. If this program is to implemented at all, the optimal money/image return for prez and concritters has not been reached yet. Timmeh bides his time for his optimal future return.
Upper 1% v. Upper .001%?? Hard to say. One way or another, though, the mega-super-obscenely wealthy have definitely *gamed* the system utterly in their favor, alone. As one comment above indicates, it’s all about corporate welfare, and ends up being a casino, where the wealthy are always the “House.” And as with any casino, in the end the “House” always WINS and wins big.
Perhaps Geithner & O are “timing” things for maximum clout and good PR coming their way, but my guess is that they’re scurrying about trying to figure out YET more ways to rig & game the system, so that the fat-cats get MOST of this money, while the truely small businesses, no matter how successful, get Bupkiss.
And then they’ll pay Rush to rant to his dittoheads about what a giant sucking SOCIALIST Obama is, and how THAT’s what the real “problem” is. And the dittoheads will pee their pants with joy to be *directed* to get angry at the AA in the White House.
Lather rinse repeat.
As long as capitalistic small business owners go along with the propoganda that panders to their nutty political leanings & FEARS, they will continue to be robbed & ripped off. They may wish to victimize themselves to teh poorz & minorities, but they’re just being FOOLED again by the PTB. Most annoying. If yer such a frackin’ great capitalist, then go BUY a clue!!!
Didn’t TBTF stress tests take less than 3?
“Small businesses” that are a front for corporations will get the bulk of the lending fund and Treasury is working on how to get the rest of the money to the corporations.
Is it that the folks at the Federal Reserve and the Treasury Dept. are incompetent or might it be that zero-growth is part of the plan? What motivation do they have for making sure this small business lending program is fast and effective?
How does promoting small businesses help a Fortune 500 company?
Are there no benefits to big business from high unemployment?
If I were the CEO of a large public company trying to generate more profit every year, had manufacturing in China or Mexico, and was following an anti-union aganda, why would I want lower unemployment and $30 billion going to potential competitors?
I’d say that’s a safe bet.
Depressions, like the one we are in, are demand-side problems, not supply-side problems. Thus, you can’t fix it by increasing funds available for loans, dropping interest rates, tax cuts, or other measures to increase availability of capital.
In a recession you can count on those already working to:
a) reduce their savings rates or tap their savings (increase consumer confidence via happy talk)
b) take out loans (drop consumer interest rates, ease reserve restrictions, generally loosen credit)
The difference between a recession and a depression is not the severity, it’s the fact that savings are low, savings rates are near zero, and everyone is already carrying as much debt as they are willing and able to service. Credit cycle, not business cycle.
The ONLY thing left is to get jobs to the unemployed. BEFORE there is a business need to hire them. It is not possible for the private sector to pull you out of a credit-cycle depression. Handing money to the private sector will not get them to hire people they don’t need. It increases their profits and cash reserves, but they do not hire people they don’t need.
That leaves government. Yes, government. Specifically INCREASED government spending. Long-term (a decade or more) until the private sector sees sustained demand and can start hiring. Direct hiring by the government, so it can be CONTROLLED and MANAGED, and the jobs go to American citizens who have the option of joining UNIONS.
Not just construction jobs, though the sorry state of our infrastructure shows a great need for those. But jobs for the existing unemployed with their existing skill sets. You’re a teacher? This reservation needs teachers. You’re a programmer? Write some OPEN SOURCE code, here’s a grant. You’re an architect? Design us cities to replace our coastal cities WHICH WE ARE SURE TO LOSE TO RISING SEA LEVELS that DOESN’T NEED CARS. You’re a materials scientist? Here’s some grant money, research better solar panels. You’re a genetic scientist? Figure out which genes control sociopathy and design a test for them. No conceivable job for your current skill set? Here, we’ll PAY YOU to get training, and here’s what we need you to learn (you are GUARANTEED a job after you complete your training).
You will notice that Republicans (and most alleged Democrats) are eager to support supply-side solutions, but run scared from demand-side solutions. They do the same thing with energy.
Supply-side is finished. Over. Caput. ALL the solutions are demand-side. Increasing demand in the case of the economy, decreasing demand in the case of energy.
The Obama administration is Socialist… Corporate Socialist. Isn’t Corporate Socialism and Fascism pretty much the same thing? Seriously.
Yes. Demand is the missing piece. Doesn’t seem to be part of the Washington ideology though.
Yup. One of the great propaganda jokes: “small businesses are the lifeblood of the nation.” In what parallel universe?
My town is like all the rest in the US. The commercial districts are dominated by large, national concerns (e.g. Home Depot, Target, Burger King, BP, etc.). What percentage of retail, manufacturing and services are actually local, small and independent? Twenty percent, maybe? And it looks like whatever percentage there is gets smaller all the time.
Indeed. You are right. It’s all a fucking fantasy. Small business, bootstrap, level-playing-field Libertarianism fits a particular cultural narrative but not any sort of reality that one can put their hands on.
This does not surprise me in the least. Obama and company have been the most incompetent leaders of our time. They had the country well defined into two camps. The worst of us on the right and the best of us on the left. He simply had to point in a positive direction and the best of us were willing to carry the load. Obama chose the way of going along to get along and the worst of us won without having to lift a finger. Obama is the perfect example of how to fail at leadership. All through out the higher levels of government and especially within his chosen team, Obama is surrounded by “managers”. Those of any ability are crisis managers and no more. Obama “tries” to manage managers. WRONG. Managers require LEADERS to direct them. Massage them. Separate them from the company. Obama has purged the progressives and excommunicated anyone who FOX targets. But the biggest example of Obama’s cowardice is that he has yet to take a real stand about anything he is willing to claim is the right way vs. wrong way to go. He is so insecure that he cannot claim there is a righteous action to take. Torture, internal spying, executive murder, voiding of due process, health car reform, stimulus, medicare, medicaid, Social Security, WIC, Foodstamps,…….
At every turn and every issue, Obama fails to speak truth with power or to power. Obama has to go. He continues to discredit every progressive ideal by silence. What we do hear CONSTANTLY from Obama and the “leadership” is , “it’s not my fault” or “He’s only one guy” or “it’s not my job” or “if you think I am bad, the other guy is worse” or “it is not appeasement – it is reasonable CON-promise”. Leadership the Obama way. Obama has been the priest and the Levite to the people of this nation. It might be time to hope that there is one Samaritan from the other side.
Does anybody remember the letter I posted on one of dakine01′s columns from President Obama with all its completely irrelevant ‘suggestions’ and talk of everything being done to assure me a job?
The letter I had written is relevant to this column here. I was complaining that with the depth of this recession, there was still no real way to get government funding to start-up a research based company (I agree with your suggestions 4cdave among others). The reason is: No matter how much money they allocate, the SBIR (and the STTR program but that’s a university affiliated one, so it doesn’t help the unemployed directly) program, which is the Small Business Innovative Research grant program, still runs on a YEARLY BASIS.
If you have an idea that you wish to develop into a business, you must apply for a phase I grant on January 15th. The grant is dispensed in March, you apply for the next phase 1/2 way through that money, and so forth in 6 month intervals, through the 3 phases. You may not move too quickly from research to prototype to productization, because you will lose eligibility for the other phases, so people actually play with the dates on submission of research papers and stuff to qualify because of all this rigidity, but as you can see, it isn’t set up for little people, it’s set up for institutions or people who work in companies, who are drawing salaries and can afford to wait.
Imagine what happens if you miss that date. If you’ve already filed provisionals (the $110 filing you can do without having to hire a lawyer that puts off having to file for a year on the theory that you will be able to afford to patent by the time the due date comes around), you will now need to come up with a new source of money or lose the invention. If you had plans to hire, they are gone, or you need a new source. You are now at the mercy of venture capital, for which you need a business plan — something which stifles the innovative process if you haven’t completed research, as it asks you to clamp your applications before you know what they are.
The patent system is being re-oriented to people who have money and backing — corporate backing. First to file favors whoever has the biggest pockets and the fastest legal team. The corporations are setting up datamining operations to harvest small inventors out of their inventions, thereby squelching a good number of the start-ups that will actually occur, and moving them strategically to other parts of the globe to maximize profits.
This is not a jobs creation system.
I completely agree with what you say bc I personally KNOW a number of people who are in the position you depict.
It’s next to *impossible* for true “small business” types to get anything off the ground via the presently-structured govt grants programs. They are not workable for many projects that typically require at least several years of consistent funding.
Is this a feature or a bug? Anymore it definitely seems like a feature.
As to science patents: fahgeddaboudit. I happen to know a number of science types who have the skills, knowledge, expertise & even the *business* & legal expertise/training/etc … who wish to work on various bio-tech patents. One friend believes that his small science outfit *may* have something worthwhile to treat Alzheimers, but without adequate funding and back-up, it’s no-go. And BigPharma, so far, ain’t interested.
I’ve seen this a lot. For all that I’m a dreaded socialist, I actually have quite a lot of friends, relatives & acquaintances who are true “small business” types & true entrepreneurial capitalists.
The big “joke” (but not the ha-ha funny kind) is that the USG no longer is even *interested* in supporting small businesses, who DO, in fact, HIRE US citizens to do a lot (not all) of the work.
All these frickin’ so-called “libertarians” have really had the wool pulled over their eyes big-time. The love to come blog here and tsk-tsk at us “stupid socialists.” But what I’m seeing has bupkiss to do with “socialism.” It’s about the super-wealthy shutting ALL of us OUT, including a lot of small-time, but potentially successful, small business types. THEY are getting just as SCREWED as folks like teachers and others who’ve lost their jobs.
Time for more citizens to wake up and smell the coffee.
Why, yes, they are the same…but, in deference to the incomprehension of many, it’s better to say that now we have Corporatism as the operative philosophy of out political parties.
Using “fascism” or especially “Nazism” invokes the Godwin rule and shuts off further discussion.
So, it’s important to point out that our current pols support corporate interests over any individual and even many national interests, and point out what it means. Over and over and over.
Only after long education of the public can comparisons be made to fascism.
call it what you will, we are definitely into Phase I of Fascism. If those living in denial wish to call it “socialism,” so be it.
You make a very good point, which is worth remembering when talking to others. I agree.
Exactly. And almost all of the truly “small” bus. owners that I know (and I know plenty) are *really* struggling right now… in a big way.
Some are aware of what’s really going on. They’ve got their eyes wide open.
But far too many have been voting Republican for years, live on a consistent diet of Rush Limbaugh’s propoganda, and are STILL *blaming* their trevails on poor people and that dreadful SOCIALIST in the White House.
It is amazing, but as they say: denial is not just a river in Egypt. People really do NOT wish to give up their long-standing, closely gripped belief systems.
Maybe I am a socialist, but I’m all for the true “small” business owner making it… but I don’t see them standing a chance in this world we live in… and it has nothing to do with “socialism” or “poor people” or frickin’ teachers getting a pension… or bc Obama is an African American.
Sheesh…
Let’s call it by it’s correct name – neoliberalism
fiscal policy belongs to congress and law enforcement (see fbi and bankster fraud) belongs to the administration.
the incompetence of congress and this administration is worth more than a mention — so how come they don’t even get that?
It was my intent to emphasize the part about it being corporate as opposed to human/civic socialism. It wasn’t to soft peddle anything. I agree with you. I understand Jawbone’s argument against using language that shuts down discussion, but Corporatism just seems like a euphemism at this point. Neoliberalism does fit. Thanks SouthernDragon.
I’ll try not to rant about fascism at my local street corner, however. I really don’t think the grade schoolers passing by need to deal with that.
just to clarify, SCORE is the Service Corps of Retired Executives, it is a free consulting service provided through the SBA that offers free business counseling services to small businesses and start-ups
I am pretty sure that the big banks and Wall Street firms didn’t wait more than a few days for the trillions of dollars the government pumped to them through the TARP and other bailout measures.
I seriously doubt that any actual small business will get help through this program, especially considering that most of the banks who have applied for money under this program are using the money from the small business lending fund to pay off the money they owe from TARP…the whole thing seems to be a sham.
If we want to really help small businesses, we should focus on contracting programs through the SBA that will actually drive demand, also known as government business, directly to small businesses. The problem is that most small business contracts go to large companies, multinational, and foreign owned firms.
Call your representatives in the House and Senate and demand they support Congressman Hank Johnson’s Fairness and Transparency in Contracting Act, then also support your local small business advocate…
Not spending allocated funds for their intended purpose might be due to incompetence, but that assumes the administration agrees with the publicly state purpose for these funds. It might simply be sabotaging that purpose by refusing to spend. It’s a variation on refusing to investigate or indict obvious criminals because they are among the elite, or a refusal to enforce environmental, anti-trust and employment workplace rules because one’s corporate supporters find them inconvenient.
=== http://globalsell.org/ ===We are specialized in offering all kinds of top brand shoes, jeans, t-shirts, bikini, swimwear, jacket, jerseys, watches, purses, handbags, belts, wallets , sunglasses and hats etc. we are serious and professional jersey supplier,we can offer NFL,NHL,MLB,NBA jerser,the NFL jersey 18usd each,the NHL jersey 38USD each.MLB jersey 18usd each,NAB jersey 18usd each.we have many jerseys of other players, $30 nike shoes,air jordan shoes,nike shox shoes,gucci shoes $33 true religion jeans, ed hardy jeans,coogi jeans,affliction jeans, Laguna Beach Jeans $16 ed hardy T-shirts,Coogi T-shirts,Christian Audigier T-shirts,Gucci T-shirts,Polo T-shirts. $30 coach handbag,gucci handbag,prada handbag, $12sunglasses,$9 caps. accept paypal free shipping
=== http://globalsell.org/ ===
MODERATOR,
Please delete this trash and terminate the originator’s access.
Thank you.