As Dick Polman writes today, the Obama Administration put themselves in a box on jobs that will be difficult to emerge from. While the spending cuts in the near term are not all that large, the very real shift to austerity on practical and rhetorical terms means that legitimate job creation programs are right out. And you can see that with the kind of programs the Administration is floating today as boosts to the economy.
White House officials are weighing a proposal to offer tax cuts to employers in return for hiring new workers. The administration considered this idea last year, but it gave way to a broader payroll tax deduction for workers in a bipartisan deal in December.
In addition, administration officials are considering proposing new investments in domestic clean energy as well as renewing tax breaks for companies using renewable energy — particularly wind power — that are to expire this year.
Also on the table is an initiative designed to help the ailing housing market without the need for more public spending. Under that proposal, the government-controlled mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac would rent out foreclosed properties that they own rather than try to sell them at depressed prices. That approach could relieve pressure on the housing market, one of the main drags on the economy.
Former administration officials are pushing other initiatives, such as a program to rebuild and rehabilitate schools as a way to improve education and stimulate the economy. A fan of this approach, Jared Bernstein, a former chief economist for Vice President Biden, calls the program “Fix America’s Schools Today.”
The FAST program is actually a good idea, but there’s no indication that anyone who actually still has a job at the White House is behind it. Fannie and Freddie leasing out their housing stock is nice as well, but really below the minimum of what they could be doing. And then the rest are a bunch of tax breaks, after the first 16-20 didn’t work. We already have a job hiring tax break, in fact.
Then there are the bills that are likely to pass Congress. In particular, you have the patent reform bill, which is actually just another one of these lobby-fests that pit giant corporate interests against one another in a dash for spoils. Zach Carter documents the atrocities on that today. If you asked any of the 800 lobbyists working on patent reform whether or not it would be a job creator, they’d look at you as if you just told them you were made of green cheese.
Next, we have the three free trade deals, and there’s been an agreement to move forward on them:
Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, a Nevada Democrat, and Republican leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky pledged action yesterday to pass the agreements with Colombia, Panama and South Korea. The U.S. Trade Representative’s Office and Republican House Speaker John Boehner praised the compromise, signaling all sides concur on the process.
The Senate leaders agreed that after Congress returns to work, lawmakers will consider “a bipartisan compromise on the Trade Adjustment Assistance program, followed by passage of the three FTAs,” Reid said in a statement on his website. Boehner of Ohio also pledged to move ahead with trade and worker-aid bills. Republicans had balked at the administration’s plan to combine worker aid and the Korea trade deal into a single bill, and that plan was dropped.
It feels like a classic bait-and-switch, with TAA failing and the free trade agreements passing, but even if all goes “well,” you have three corporate written trade deals which will, if anything, cost American workers their jobs. Don’t tell that to Luke Russert, but it happens to be true. Even Nancy Pelosi questions whether these deals will create any jobs, calling the idea “debatable.”
What we have here is actually a poverty of imagination. There are plenty of things that the executive branch can do – power they’ve had since they came into office – to boost jobs. They have $80-$100 billion in unused TARP funds that could be put to productive use, including at least $40 billion dedicated for housing. They could use Fannie and Freddie much more aggressively than this renting idea, creating a kind of modern-day HOLC to buy up homes. They could use authorized programs like TALF to give aid to states or fund infrastructure projects. They could use monetary policy to force bank reserves into the lending sphere; at the very least they could fill the slots on the Federal Reserve Board of Governors, at least one of which has been vacant since the beginning of the Obama Presidency. They could get any of the $30 billion small business lending fund out into the economy. They could use Treasury to legitimately punish China for manipulating their currency. Put these all together, along with ones I haven’t thought of, and you have a “second stimulus” of equal or greater value than the first. And you don’t have to consult John Boehner at all.
This is what people who recognize a crisis when they see one would do. The quarter before Barack Obama became President had an 8.9% reduction in GDP growth. That’s a depression, and it requires bold and relentless experimentation. Instead we get pivots and a focus on jobs, without the kind of innovation that would actually create them. I don’t mean to criticize Nancy Pelosi here, she has a political responsibility, and should be talking about her agenda in contrast to the Republicans. But absent actual action to create jobs, a bushel of talk could only weaken the political position, as people see it amounting to nothing. This doesn’t have to happen this way – a president has a good deal of power. It’s just not being used.





68 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
This doesn’t have to happen this way – a president has a good deal of power. It’s just not being used.
And it won’t be, until elites feel the grip of an anti-capitalist movement around their throats. Until the very foundations of the system itself are under concentrated attack, people can and should expect zero help from their government.
I recommend Participatory Economics 101 and Participatory Economics 102.
When you’re ready, there’s the Participatory Economics PhD Program.
The broader payroll tax deductions.isn’t that where obama started defunding Social Security 12/–/10?To leave in place Tax Cuts from the Top down for people with jobs,while Tax Cuts for Business New Hires was droped 12/–/10?
I agree on all levels. This president has not learned how to BE president. One thing you have to give the CHENEY/BUSH white house credit for is that they found ways to “get around” pesky laws. Weretap is illegal? Redefine it. Wiretap is still illegal? Pass FISA. Kidnapping foreign nationals is illegal? Have the AG re-classify them as “undeclared combatants”. You got NO reason to go to war? Change the inteligence reports. Gotta admit, that dick Cheney was pretty bright and W was too, letting Cheney and KBR/Halliburton run the government. His biggest personal chores; 1)not choking on Doritos while watching football games, 2)finding his way out of locked room.
Where does one begin, this is so much nonsense -
- The Trade deals will cause the loss of jobs not the creation of them. They are for the benefit of Wall Street not Main Street.
- This idea of rewarding employers for new hires means that they will just lay off or stop giving hours to the older workers and replace them with new ones and a lower salary scale. I’ve seen this with friends that work low wage jobs. They end up working for about 6 to 9 months till they are out of the program finding that they have to look for another job because they have been replaced.
Until demand picks up and we do something about the farce called “free trade” nothing is gonna happen to the unemployment rate.
The only other point I’d like to make is that it won’t be any better for the next administration after Obama looses in 2012. They will do much of what Obama has done minus the stimulus plus some tax cuts, if Obama doesn’t beat them to the punch, but that won’t help and by then food stamp usage will be in the 30% range for many states (think it just hit there or near there in Ala). The deepest of the red states will be the first to go with poverty exploding in places like Ala, Tenn & Miss if it wasn’t bad enough already. The Rep President replacing Obama will face a recession/depression and Obama will look good. The next leg down in the economy has started and its a roller coaster to hell.
Maybe they’ll do all of this in December so the jobs picture looks rosier next year. Or maybe they’re stupid
MY god these people are dumb.BUSINESSES AREN”T HIRING BECAUSE THERE IS NO DEMAND.From the heaad of the national Small Business Assoc.”We don’t need loans to expand WE NEED CUSTOMERS.”
Take ALL of the subsidizing money and distribute it to all small business and people earning under $250,000…or something like that.
Stop the Wars!
Tax the hell out of all US companies who sell products here that are made overseas.
Make college FREE for every family making under $250,000 and tax everyone making over that amount the difference.
How f’ing stupid do you have to be to keep proposing tax cuts. Tax the life out anyone shipping jobs overseas, and close the damn loopholes already.
Where is the largest block of forclosed homes?Why not give Private Business that Produces Products,that Pay Liveable Wages,that covers Health Care and Secure Retirement, Tax Free to the Product Produceing Business,Jobs For The People,Buyers for the Forclosed Homes.Builds the Economy,Growes the Tax Base and Relief the Stress of The Working Pods and Familys.
The answer? Tax breaks for the tax breaks. Duh.
As Dick Polman writes today, the Obama Administration put themselves in a box on jobs that will be difficult to emerge from.
Another great example of Obama’s *cough* successful approach to politics.
IMO, there will be no jobs while a Dem is President. The repugs have stated it in so many ways that it is clear. They fully intend on Obama being a one termer and will do ANYTHING to make it that way including tearing this country down to the dirt.
2012, 2014, and any other opportunity we have to vote Congress out. I blame the Dem Congress for not standing up and I see that they have no intention of doing so. They are part of the program and are being paid nicely to further the ambition.
The Retardicans and their Corp. backers are making it very clear who really has power “real” power in this country and its apparently not any of us or Barry Zero. They own most of the economy now , so either play by their rules or don’t f*cking eat. That’s the message I’m hearing.
Oh, you ain’t seen nothin’ yet. Wait until the free trade deal with Panama happens…..
Now that’s a good suggestion. We should throw some tax credits in there, too…You know, to get that real “bang for the buck,” multiplier, tax-cut bullshit effect going.
OK, these people are fucking idiots. Now that we’ve established that fact, may we please start having a grown up conversation?
I like that.
Yes,on a slideing scale,where the products are made the wages and benifits equal to the USA standard of Middle Class or higher pay Min.Tax.Poverity wages pay a high tax on Imports.
In order to have a grownup conversation, you’d need people in the room that aren’t completely self-absorbed children. That’s impossible inside the beltway.
I’m ready. Our government is a joke. If we want something to change, we have to change it ourselves. Do we want jobs? Then we have to go outside of Corporates and do our own thing. In fact, we have to back door attack every entity because this really is warfare against the citizens.
I know, I know…sigh. Mine was a fantasy solution. LOL
Citizens’ arrest for treason..
General Strike and boycott…that’s the only way I see anymore…they only understand money and power.
He said he was a pragmatist, but he isn’t. He has an agenda to promote. The poor guy is so stupid that he can not get himself out of his own shit.
When he came into office he was so busy trying to be buddies with the Republicans that he did not blame them for any of the mess. It is no longer possible to blame them and say they left him a mess. He owns it now.
The bailouts were not enough and did not go to the right people. Every progressive economist knew it and so did the Nation. William Greider said he would not be able to go back for more money.
Obama does not want to be a leader, he wants to be a negotiator, but is not even good at that. Obama should have said he did not like the Republican way of holding hostage of the raising of the debt, said he had a better plan, but sign it anyway. Then campaign against it. He could have moved on.
I can just hear Obama’s campaign slogan “Vote for the guy who cut Social Security”. He is gone.
Someone wrote a diary the other day suggesting calling Obama and asking him to resign. The Democrats should admit they made a mistake with Obama ask him to resign and start over.
He’s not stupid. He’s bought and paid for…..although, after observing Goolsby on Jon Stewart…tehy stupid too.
He should resign just on the basis of two words: Compromise and Bipartisan, oh yeah and for hiring Rahm.
There is a web site instructing Tea Partiers on how to take over state parties so that all candidates are Tea Party candidates. It is instructive and it is a good strategy. It would take a couple of years.
tea party instructions how to take over the republican party
http://www.wikihow.com/Take-Over-the-Local-Party-Precinct-(U.S.A.)
From Sacromento Bee:
Some folks are finding jobs in America.
http://www.layofflist.org/2011/05/17/99ers-and-the-long-term-unemployed-are-the-elephants-in-the-economic-recovery-room/
One of the best things Washington could do is come clean on the real unemployment numbers and throw it in the faces of the Repugs.
Right now E. Cantor is saying it is just fine for Delta to pocket passengers taxes because it’s just business. If we don’t make it stop, it won’t!
How about a surcharge on corporate profits unless a certain percentage is spent on hiring new American employees?
The problem is…..those who would make such a law….are owned by the very corporations.
Strike and boycott.
Dow back up a bit after falling 350 pts. This feels like fall, 2008.
Who could have predicted a worsening economy after Grand Austerity?
That would be a good thing if somebody made sure it actually happened.
How about corporations that moved off-shore pay me to buy their crap?
“THEY” are NOT going to DO anything about ANY of this.
Strike and boycott
Matt Taibi was pretty good last night on Olbermann talking about tax vacations for US multinationals who bring their money back to the US for “job creation”. Of course, the jobs never happen, but the Corporations go from paying 35% tax to something like 5%.
It wasn’t a crisis until the presidential election was looming./s
”We don’t need loans to expand WE NEED CUSTOMERS.”
But, but, if they don’t get loans, they won’t owe any money. And owing money is the American Way.
in the faces of the Repugs???
The Dems own the unemployment numbers.
They are the ones who have refused to do anything about them since they were swept into power in 2008.
Motherfuckers are bound and determined to prove to themselves that Friedman’s economic theories (aka Trickle Down) work. The neoliberals and neoconservatives wish the unemployed and underemployed would just eat shit and die. That’s their solution to the Lesser Depression.
I find it a little surprising, after all Wall Street bought and paid for it.
If government spending is out of the picture, the only two demand generators are real business investment in stuff that requires consumption–plant, equipment, supplies, inventory, training materials and services — and upping export while lowering imports.
Reduction of revenues through new targeted tax cuts for new hires and extension alternative energy tax credits has the effect of increasing the deficit, leaving more money in the economy in such a way that it likely goes into spending in that both represent reimbursements.
The feeble voluntary Buy American campaigns would work if there were adequate substitutes for more imported products. But free trade deals are likely to increase imports instead of exports and create more job flight. Especially since the House GOP leadership succeeded in separating out the labor/environmental standards and worker relief portions of the bill.
The Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac proposal is not contributing to growth, just better utilizing government owned assets. It’s a little like the policy of continuing to own AIG until it is a salable asset.
I don’t see how the FAST program gets funding from Congress unless there is an acceptable trade of a hostage to the GOP. What in the budget about equals the amount being discussed for FAST? Which of these hurts the Democratic base most? There’s your hostage.
From the source:
http://www.redstate.com/erick/2011/07/25/the-absolution-i-cannot-give/#comment-118117
http://www.redstate.com/coldwarrior/2011/07/27/some-dos-and-donts-for-redstate-political-activists-based-upon-the-performance-of-our-partys-leadership/
Tax cuts? Tax cuts. Yeah, that’ll work. Oilbummer is completely and resolutely opposed to public works programs or taxing the rich. These small moves would do so much, yet the Wizard of O can’t get past his Raygunite ways.
I noticed that a few minutes ago myself over at the gym. The traders realize that the economy is going nowhere in a hurry and are hedging down. Since there is no bright news on any horizon and some real possibility of big time bad news comi8ng out of Europe, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the DOW at 10,500 next summer. For those of us who still have a little money left, it is capital preservation time, and has been for the last two years. Too bad one can’t preserve his job by just sitting on it, but that’s the way it works.
I don’t think anything you or I do, or Wall Street does, or the Banks do, or the Prez doez, or Congress doesn’t, is going to make a bit of difference because there isn’t enough money left in the bottom tiers of our society to accomplish anything meaningful. This is the result of low taxation. The rich now have the money, and since there is no one at that economic level who has the wisdom or vision to start programs that would improve the lot of the rest of the nation, nothing will be done. Note, also, the direction of the markets: Krugman today was, as usual, informative; the financial markets, gold prices, and oil prices, all seem to be saying that the only direction for the economy is down. It would be nice to think that the current direction isn’t permanent, but for once I think the markets might be talking turkey.
I hope there is some enterprising candidate in Cantor’s district—doesn’t have to have a party affiliation—who will bring this issue to the voter’s attention next year. Might be good for someone to run a video loop of his comments with a Stephanie Miller-sounding Huh! Huh! Huh! response in his district.
As well as the elderly and sick.
Because the government is run by corporations (fascism)…anyone unable to work or purchase is “undesirable” and a “social” burden..a “liability”….we all know where that leads…or do we?
Didn’t they turn down at least 3 job initiatives?
As usual, the Administration has it exactly ass-backwards. Shoveling out tax cuts/credits to business is not the answer. Stimulating demand, is. People need money in their pockets so they can walk into a store and BUY SHIT. If a business owner has no customers or no increase in customers coming into his store, why on earth would he hire a new worker just because he got a tax cut or tax credit? It makes no sense whatever. Will that tax cut or credit cover the salary and benefits for a new worker for a full year even though the business owner has no increase in sales? Hot only no, but HELL NO.
Here’s a dollar, Barry. Buy a fucking clue.
The next Republicans presidents motto will be “look backward, not forward”
Obama will be blamed for the recession/depression and Obama will not look good.
Harvard pumps out a lot of dumb shits. Barry is the prototype.
great idea!
That has been Barry’s motto all along..now Bush looks good…
It’s like we can’t quite as a group/people/citizens truly grasp what reality is. It’s much more comfortable to believe that there’s no way anyone in our Government is corrupted enough to actually let America come to true harm (steal sure, but actually let America itself truly be harmed no way) which is demonstrably untrue!!!! They (not aloud of course) would rather have TV comfort their hectic lives and entertainment media addled minds and not contemplate having to “change” or get out of a comfort zone of well, I’m okay today.everything must be okay then.. I don’t like what I think happens when we truly collapse..
Did I hear you volunteering to harvest by hand in a field for 12 hours a day at $4 an hour?
Jobs aside, people need more Section 8 housing.
In my area, it has almost vanished from the “for rent” pages of the local newspaper.
Someone who I believe knows what he’s talking about told me the reason is that Section 8 housing has to meet a certain code. This used to be no problem; there were urban renewal funds that helped and people had jobs. Now, funds are drying up. People with houses or apartments to rent have no extra funds to make repairs. They may not have jobs at all.
“NO Pets, NO Section 8″ is all you see in the ‘for rent’ section now..
We need more funds for that, and an army of housing rehabbers. There’s jobs and housing right there.
Jane is upstairs.
I find it interesting that there is this big push for hi-tech education, i.e., math, computers, etc., Jobs exist in these areas, but what really is needed is education related to civilized community survival and growth, i.e., infrastructure design, food, water, transportation, engineering, electricians, plumbers, builders, creativity training, etc., etc. The jobs will be with those that initiate and create those services.
You are not going to find a lot of jobs by only studying math, nor are you going to be of much assistance in sustaining or developing local economies…afterall…most jobs are local.
Someone always needs to know how to produce the food, water, and fire.
Not hardly. But he likes the low price of the fruits and vegetables in the store. I think I can safely say that alan1tx wouldn’t last a day picking oranges in either FL or CA.
Nope. You also didn’t hear me pm&c that the government hasn’t built me a job.
I just thought it was an interesting coincidence that unemployment is at 9% and illegal aliens make up 9% of our work force.
That is the plan, take decent middle class jobs and turn them into minimum wage workers.
What a great idea for Fannie and Freddie to rent out foreclosed properties!
Maybe they could rent them to the previous owners or tenants whom they evicted! I’m sure F & F would accept market value. What? Sorry. I thought I heard someone say the tenants and homeowners begged to be able to pay rent in order to stay in their homes. Excuse me? Oh, sorry, I’m hearing things again. This time, I thought I heard someone say some homeowners even offered–and were qualified–to buy their houses back at market value. (You know, market value: that’s the value of the house at the time of purchase.) Why weren’t they given that option? Oh, yeah, right. Moral hazard! Of course. The banks are a moral hazard. Excuse me? It’s the homeowners who are the moral hazard? Oh dear, it’s all so confusing.
You know what is really over the top (I know, there just doesn’t seem to be a “top”)? The WaPo piece quoted above was published just two days after Time published Bulldoze: The New Way to Foreclose, a report about the banks trend to give away or bulldoze foreclosed properties, rather than have them be a blight in their communities. To give you just a little hint about the tone of that piece, allow me to quote the closing thought:
Are you f*$&ing kidding me?
This, my friends, is absolute proof that journalism in the MSM is DEAD. Deceased. Passed on. No more. Expired and gone to meet its maker. Bereft of life. Pushing up daisies. Kicked the bucket. This is an EX profession! (Thanks for the inspiration, Mr. Cleese.)
It’s very clear that both Mr. Stephan Gandel of Time, and Mr. Zachary Goldfarb of the WaPo, are spewing the lines handed to them by the guys being paid by the administration/banks/think tanks/lobbyists. They are copy-writers. There is no main stream journalism.
Thank you for your journalistic integrity, Mr. Dayen. When the so-called journalists working for the corporate “persons” running the country all go up in flames, incinerated by the corporatocracy they serve, may you and your colleagues finally be recognized by all as the heroes you are!
Turn jobs into workers?
I hope you won’t think too poorly of me. I’ve held minimum wage jobs, sometimes 2 or 3 at a time.
It was tried in 2004. 92% of the repatriated money went to dividend increases, executive bonuses, mergers and acquisitions, and stock buy backs. The incentive was established for corporatations to turn around and stash more money offshore and wait for the opportune time for another “one time” tax holiday to be granted. Anyone see how this turns out in the future?
Oh geez….Beck is drawing lines on this chalkboard again.
There are two parties, and alan1tx has two ears-nothing between either. Coincidence?