I honestly plumb forgot about the results in the final two Wisconsin recall elections last night. Public Policy Polling, which has been red-hot on election calls this cycle, put me at ease with their Monday poll showing double-digit leads for both Democratic incumbents, Robert Wirch and Jim Holperin. So it dropped off my radar. Lo and behold, the final numbers show that I was right not to worry.
In SD-22, Wirch won handily, by a 58-42 margin over Republican Jonathan Steitz. PPP had it at 55-42 Wirch, so they nailed Steitz’ number. In SD-12, which has a more Republican lean, Holperin won over Tea Party Republican Kim Simac by 55-45 (at press time, Florence County, which is more Republican than the district at large, had yet to report, but the AP called it for Holperin). PPP had it at 55-41 Holperin, so again they nailed one of the two final totals. They really have been outstanding so far this year.
So this means that the Democrats picked up a total of two seats in the recalls, and Republicans will have a 17-16 majority in the State Senate when they return to session. Dale Schultz, the moderate Republican who voted against the anti-union bill that stripped collective bargaining rights, will have a lot of say over what else of Scott Walker’s right-wing agenda gets passed. And the state waits for January 2012, when Walker and the rest of the legislature becomes eligible for recall.
That’s a long way off, and it may or may not be successful. But I think it’s clear that Wisconsin Democrats decided to react to an assault on fundamental rights and values by fighting back. And the electorate rewarded them. None of the Fab 14 Senate Democrats who fled the state in protest were recalled. Two of the Senate Republicans who voted in lockstep with Walker to take away worker’s rights no longer have a job themselves. Despite difficult electoral terrain and a built-in tendency against recalls, Democrats made strides. There’s nothing to be ashamed of here; in fact, it’s a great point upon which to build for the future, with a youth/labor/progressive alliance that has the Democratic Party in the state responsive to its demands.
This doesn’t mean that a lot of damage hasn’t already been done by the implementation of the anti-union law, both on an electoral and a personal level. Public employee unions are fighting for survival, and their members are suffering through wage cuts. In addition, the new gerrymandered redistricting maps will make it difficult to sustain these gains next year, although they may be headed to court, so they are subject to change. Overall, elections have consequences, and Walker and the Republicans have already transformed several facets of Wisconsin.
But extreme policy also has consequences on the flip side, and voters punished Dan Kapanke and Randy Hopper for going along with that agenda. And the coalition to take back Wisconsin should be proud of those efforts, and determined for the future.




30 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
I’m in the Wisconsin Ad market for those 2 seats that were held,and I can
tell you that there were lots of ads for the challengers (and none for the
incumbents) on TV. It made me somewhat nervous to see the lack of attention
given to these contests by progressive media that I use. It is also “discouraging”
to see just how “small” (a few million $) conservative support has been. Why can’t
“we” get progressive donors (e.g. Soros?) to match some of this? Where was
Obama=who could have influenced those elections using just his “bully pulpit” (?).
(I know the answer to that-it just goes to show how anti-liberal,anti-
progressive he is)
May I politely and in as non-judgemental a way as I can suggest the title of post be changed?
The recalls yesterday were not close, about as big a margin as you could possibly expect.
I think I understand that your post iself is about ALL recalls. Some of them were close, i.e. luther olsen that has been unopposed for 16 years really did not do very well. He is vulnerable.
Not trying to criticize, just pointing out the headline made me do a double-take. Am I missing something here?
From what obama stated/did publicly since walker “dropped the bomb”, one might assume that he loved it and just wished more had done this type of dirty work for him.
Bed-hopper randy hopper was done in because he abandoned his wife and children for a lobbyist whore and paid for her “services” (with the direct intervention of walker himself) by getting her a state job with a 35% pay raise over the person that did the exact same job (without sex of hopper) prior to her.
She is done now with her 6-mo position and given her role in losing that seat, may not get another cushy job, but maybe she will.
Close
as in completed, not as in nearly tied.
Gotcha, I will delete/edit my post, but wanted to point out that I read it as that the outcomes were approximately equal with neither side significantly outperforming the others.
OOOPS! my window to edit must be done – no EDIT link. Thanks for your clarification.
Out of 5 elections, the Dems won 4. Yet Walker still has a one vote majority.
He needs to be careful, The Good Guys will be gunnin’ for him come January and the smartest thing he can do is stay off the radar.
Boxturtle (Do you suppose they’re gloating or worrying in Walkers office?)
I think your proportion is wrong – there were 6 repug recalls and 3 dem. The dems kept all three and the repugs lost 2.
This despite the fact that the entire process was contaminated with fake dem primaries which cost taxpayers millions and sucked money from dem candidates.
I read it as close (narrow margin) at first, too, and then after reading the article, realized it was close (end) instead. Wouldn’t take much to edit that word, dday!
I am waiting for the Walker recall effort to commence!
On rereading, I see that too now, but didn’t realize it when I first quickly read post.
Perhaps, since I am “on the ground” here; I didn’t read as carefully as I should have.
You and badgerbadger deserve a lot of credit along with all the other Wisconsin Progressives on this recall election. Great job!
the morning after last week’s successful recalls, he was all ‘kumbaya, work together, blah blah blah’ running away from his brand as fast as he could
Some are now proclaiming the public doesn’t want it, but I am sure the people (not controlled by Dem party) are going to launch this ASAP as there are websites dedicated to identifying people that will immediately sign petitions.
Disappointingly, PPP released another poll that (I believe factoring in margin of error) essentially says WI residents are equally split on recalling walker.
His approval ratings, as I understand it, are underwater and are not going up.
I do not know why anyone that considers themselves “progressive” would “catapult the propaganda” that interest is waning, but I have seen it and just scratched my head.
The key is in your connection between “extreme policies” and “consequences.” I believe that we are starting to see the downhill slide of the TeaParty agenda(s)–and that’s a good thing. It doesn’t mean, however, that consiberal GOP ideas are all bad, nor that a balanced legislature is, either. Our democracy is designed for compromise (and, rarely, consensus), and we need to find that middle again.
Do any folks in WI (or able to come to Jefferson County) want to jump out of airplanes to protest walker?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
PINK SLIP AND PARACHUTE
Hey badger. do you think the intensity will die down for the Walker recall? You know, it won’t happen for what? another 7 months or so.
and we all know voters have the attention span of gnats.
What do YOU think?
IMHO, it is a GOOD THING we have to wait a bit now. People really are disgusted with BOTH dems and repugs at national level. The budget ceiling fiasco clearly hurt first round of recalls (that came just on those heals).
I would say it won’t die down unless people are dumb enough to let scott walker pretend that his is bipartisan now and is trying to make amends – all propaganda, but propaganda does work.
I am sure that no one is removing themselves from the websites where they signed up to immediately sign petitions to recall walker.
There will be enough votes in Madison-Milwaukee corridor (if waukesha doesn’t cheat) to swing this thing big-time.
I signed up for account at that big orange site. You can’t delete those, but decided to mark mine “defunct”. I never stated anything about not voting for obama nor did nothing more than identify some facts that raise eyebrows for some.
Yes, that community is questioning obama now, but the flaming and discourse for doing so was just too much. Sadly, instead of being a vehicle for meaningful change consistent with taking back the democratic party, the big orange site is still a propaganda tool for DLC and others that are driving obama’s approval rating off the cliff.
Worst of all, they refuse to hold o accountable for anything – you know, he’s always a victim, fully-powerless, and its all the progressive community’s fault…
I am not that far from Jefferson Co. (live in N. Ill.) and would be glad to come to a protest but as far as jumping out of airplanes, my crazy days are over now at 68 yrs. old. Keep us informed on protests and I will be there.
I should be there with video cam, please look for me and say “HI!” (unless it is rainy :( which appears to be forecast for saturday.
Imagine not even the most enraged anti-walker folks are jumpin’ out of planes if the weather isn’t nice though.
oooh, but projects for sunday look good!
Me and my big mouth, I did not see that it was THIS saturday. My wife is having major surgery tomorrow and will be in the hospital through Saturday at least. Sorry cannot be there, but will be there in spirit.
I am looking forward to meeting you in the future. There will be more meetings in the future on the recall and I will attend if you keep me informed.
It can be difficult to keep track of events like this and walker appearances. If you see/hear of anything and see me in thread, please post what you can (and I will try to do likewise).
“When the going gets tough, the tough jump into bed with somebody else in power.”
So it’s a gnat’s whisker remaining there now.
All during that month’s long episode the discipline on both sides was remarkable. So the level of partisanship and seige mentality was in control.
One would hope not so going forward, for the GOP. Just maybe Schultz can be finessed to pull a Jim Jeffords and flip everything on its head.
Weren’t there 9 total?
Will do and thank you!
and Walker who is no doubt breathing a sign of relief gets to do whatever he wants to until January. Great