One of the policy items you hear the Administration tout as part of defending their record is the food safety bill. Food policy experts considered it flawed, but generally a step in the right direction, and the first overhaul of the nation’s food safety system in decades. There’s every reason for the White House to use that as part of their list of accomplishments.
There’s only one thing: as a result of the legislation, the FDA has more responsibility but does not have more money:
“It’s an enormous undertaking,” said Mike Taylor, the Food and Drug Administration’s deputy commissioner for foods, whose job it is to turn the far-reaching law into a coherent set of rules that farmers, food processors and importers can follow and regulators can enforce.
The agency is taking on the expanded mission at a time when Washington budget-slashing means that regulators have little hope of getting additional money and may instead have their budgets cut by Congress.
“We have to have the resources to implement this law,” Mr. Taylor said.
“The stark choice is we either find the resources or we forgo implementing this law the way Congress intended. You can’t build something brand-new without the resources to do it.”
If you think those who aren’t enamored of the Obama record are being unfair, or that they’re overlooking this evidence of progress and focusing too much on budgets or taxes, it has to be made clear that it all comes back to budgets and taxes. The food safety bill doesn’t exist in a world where the FDA has its budget cut to the bone. You might as well leave that out of the list of accomplishments if we’re going to go full austerity.
I mean, one of the major pieces of the food safety legislation is increased inspections. Who is supposed to do that? Drones? Maybe we can make food safety a national security priority and fund it out of the Defense Department, but until then, it’s just a fact of life that hundreds of millions of dollars in new funding, according to the Congressional Budget Office, will be needed to execute the law. If the FDA survives with a minor cut it will be a miracle. And remember, the debt limit deal put caps on all domestic discretionary spending for the next ten years. There are ways to surmount those caps, and there can be shifts in between programs, but it hardly bodes well for an agency like FDA that needs a major injection of funding to carry out a statutory mandate.




46 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
If you people will send me your seafood, chicken, and USDA prime beef I will taste-test if for you and, if it’s bad, then I will get sick not you.
No need to thank me, I’m just a magnamous guy by nature.
Dave, is everybody ignoring you today?????
Who needs the FDA?
Doncha know business will self regulate.
Shuuuuuuuuuure!.
OT: Not really.
I was busy here at home and felt the house wiggle, the ground rumble and it was not nice. Jumped back on the tubes to find that Virginia had a 5.8 earthquake!
I think it must be larger since we felt it down here in South Carolina!
I work in the food ingredient industry.
During the Bush years, he cut back the number of FDA and USDA inspectors to levels the industry had not seen in years.
Then we got little things such as Henaprin and Peanut Corporation of America. People DIED. Reason was that there weren’t enough inspectors.
Republicans are calling for shut down of a new group within the FDA that is the ONLY group testing for the same e. coli bacteria outbreaks that have been happening in Europe.
All to the glee of the tea partiers.
Unbelievable.
from the Center for Disease Control:
And when it comes to the EPA…well:
City Sued Over Plan to Turn Sewage Into Snow
If one Arizona resort has its way, vacationers will soon be skiing over snow made of reclaimed sewage water.
The Hopi Tribe filed a lawsuit Friday in Arizona Superior Court against the city of Flagstaff over their plans to sell 1.5 million gallons of reclaimed wastewater to Snowbowl Ski Resort.
Resort owners say that in light snow years, attendance dropsfrom 150,000 skiers to less than 3,000 skiers. To make up for the shortfall, the resort has plans to pipe sewage water 15 miles uphill to a reservoir until it is needed for making fake snow.
The U.S. Agricultural Research Service admitted in a 2007 study that the effects of using reclaimed sewage effluent for irrigation “are largely unknown.” Northern Arizona University professor of biological sciences Dr. Catherine Propper has determined (PDF) that treated wastewater contains “a wide array of chemical and pharmaceutical compounds.”
Source: http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2011/08/23/resort-sued-over-plan-to-turn-sewage-into-snow/
The drones are literally gold- and silver- plated (Gerald Celente, July 14, 2011). Gold is about $1836 USD per oz on the market (Kitco live). Maybe we should pilfer the drones for the precious metals and fund the FDA?
Congress will change the law before they authorize any additional funding. Mark my words.
The Democratic Party.Some of the dumbest fucks on the face of the earth.
“Dems push extending payroll tax cuts.”
YOU’RE DEFUNDING SOCIAL SECURITY.YOU WILL NEVER MAKE UP THE LOSS IN FUNDING!!!
Are these idiots allowed out of their houses unsupervised?
How far away are you?
I felt it well over 400 miles away. I was eating outside (perfect weather day) at a new restaurant. I felt my chair do something a little funny, turned around to see whether something had bumped into it. Nada. Get home, turn on TV, find out about earthquake, lightbulb goes off!
If you cant afford to eat safe food.. the idea is to get rid of you to lower the earths population to more earth friendly levels.. that’s the plan!
It is far, far more than 400 miles here in SC.
Oh! I wanted to share something with you. I’ll have to go get the link, but want to praise you again on Bee Keeping.
That’s a total lie. Go Hopi Nation!
Actually no. By law the payroll tax cuts are made up from the general fund in the same year in which they are taken.
For our resident Bee Keeper and all concerned about Food Regulation:
http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/united-states/tainted-chinese-honey-pervades-us-stores-60674.html
Guest on cnbc sez that ground is harder in the east than in CA, owing to the latter moving more often. I guess I’d characterize it as looser joints. So the same magnitude earthquake is felt more strongly & over a much wider area than would happen in CA.
I’m going to hop off for now.
I’ll check back later to catch your link. And thanks in advance.
[reply to Peasant Party @ 4]
Depending how deep they are, and what the material is in between, even a relatively modest quake can be felt a long way away.
Indeed! Go, Hopi Nation!
In fact, Go all Native Indians!
Wow & on topic too.
I’m glad I have my own honey.
I’m sending off your link to my bee keeper.
Okay. Well, we have clay, granite, and all sorts of natural forest and ancient ocean stuff under us.
Great! Glad you stuck around long enough to see it. Thanks for bee keeping, Friend. We need all the real farmers we can get.
Well, I guess I may be another world, but I remember the food safety bill and not fondly. First, Obama’s head of food safety is Michael Taylor, or known to some as the “Monsanto Man”. He promotes GMO’s and Monsanto.
I tried to follow the “food safety bill”. There were two versions around when it went to the Senate. It was not possible to determine which was being voted on. I downloaded the text of both and started reviewing them. Out of nowhere, the Senate passes a third (unpublished) version. I believe they said it went through the sub-committee in two days. The Senate and Senate committees are where bills go to die. Interesting that they jumped on this one. As I recall, a lot of the provisions will have terrible consequences for small family and organic farms. There was an article about some of the ridiculous things they were requiring. I’ll try to dig the article up.
This FDA thing reminds me of one of the differences between the Senate and House versions of the health care “reform” bill. The House version included funding for enforcement of the new insurance regulations. The Senate bill didn’t. The Senate bill was the one the President and congressional “leadership” wanted, and it was the one that passed. Go figure.
I’m starting to sense a pattern here.
Maybe I’m wrong about this, but I thought Obama/Benito just appointed the Monsanto Man this month.
I’m not a geologist, so I’m not sure what that means in practical terms. Clay often responds a lot to earthquakes, so if you’re over a lot of it the effect might have been magnified a bit.
I know they were fighting the label stuff and the country of origin stuff. In fact, I wrote letters to my Senators about the labels because of how ingredients react with medications. The jerk, voted in favor of removing it anyway.
Not only do I have my two hives, two swarms have escaped into nature and another one went to my friends who got me into the hobby, whose hive has died all 3 winters they’ve had it, giving me survivor’s guilt. So my one hive to start is now 5 colonies. Doing my part. Never have figured out where the 2 swarms that went off into nature took up housekeeping.
The US government is spending $120B in Afghanistan this year. This is a small, poor country on the other side of the earth with a GDP of about 1/8 of the US annual spending.
What’s the money going for? To pay people like Ms. Alisa Stack, the “International Security Assistance Force Joint Command Deputy Chief of Staff for Stability” (seriously) who presented a briefing at the Pentagon recently.
Apparently they have some health problems over there because one of the few “stability” accomplishments Ms. Stack could describe from her 22 months of service there was:
Well goody for Afghanistan. But how about us?
Of course “national security” isn’t on the table, and we must support the troops, blah blah blah, so we’re supposed to shut up about food safety and health care.
It is my understanding that Virigina, Tennesse, and the Carolinas all have clay based soil types. Other than in the coastal areas, this has dogged farmers for years.
Proud. Very proud of you!
Signed, Hank Kissinger, and please do not worry about me I have my own food taster.
Eh? All you Nanny-State hippies just want big-daddy gov’t to take care of your lazy slacker butts. Stop having your grubby mitts out for the Nanny state to inspect your food & drugs. If you were true, red-blooded ‘merkins, why then, you’d get offa yer lazy slacker butts and do what all great ‘merkins do: Inspect your own g-d*mned food & drugs. That’s what a true Tea Partyin’ libertarians DO and all the time. We don’t wait for no Nanny State to take care of us.
However, prayers to Sky-Daddy are a good thing, also, too, especially when you & your family become mysteriously really sick.
///s
heh… and sadly, too true, methinks.
If there are 100,000 soldiers deployed in Afghanistan at the cost of $1 million per soldier per year the cost is $100 Billion per year. If they were all brought home and payed $100,000 per year the savings would be $90 Billion per year. Extended over a 10 year period the savings would be $900 Billion. That does not factor in the fortune wasted on a like number of private contractors. I realize that this will never happen, but no one even seems to make this argument. Please check my math. I can’t quite believe the amount of savings, not just fiscal, but human as well, on both sides.
The Right Wing won’t be content until every alphabet soup government agency is closed.Surest way to put us on a par with Somalia.
I don’t need to check your math. It’s close enough. And as you say, you are only factoring in the basics of the military, not all the “extras” that go on with private contractors, mercenaries & of course all of our secret agents doing whatever the eff it is that they do at a high cost.
That US citizens aren’t rising up in arms about the *insane* waste in Iraq & Afganistan – just those 2 for starters – is beyond comprehension.
And no: we certainly NEVER see the insane & outrageous costs of the MIC/DoD ever mentioned, do we???
Great numbers. I wonder where most of the $1 million USD per soldier goes?
He was an advisor long before he was given the official title of food safety whatever.
Somalia is every Tea Partiers & libertarians Ayn Randian wet dream.
I just wish they’d all pack their stupid bags and move there, stat!
yet another good question for which you’ll get no answer.
Here are two articles about the food safety bill. Farmers have to poison wildlife and destroy habitat as part of this truly wonderful legislation. This is an addition to my comment 23
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/07/13/MN0218DVJ8.DTL
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2009/07/17/MNB618Q3UU.DTL
I think the Europe thing happened at an organic farm. This law excludes at least some organic operations because the rules are too expensive. My own feeling is, they shouldn’t be exempt. You can get sick from bad food from an organic processor just like you can anywhere else. They should either be for everybody that’s bigger than just a cottage operation, or nobody.
At least we know that the CIA spooks supplement their budgetary needs from the opium trade.
hmmm… yes, there IS that. CIA loves ‘em some drugs and that’s why they’re not legalized. CIA gets more money when the drugs is illegal. CIA was v. happy to have War, Inc, in Afghanistan. After they lost their base of ops in the Golden Triangle, CIA’s been looking for new opium fields for a long time. Been salivating over Aghanistan for a while, I’m sure. It was literally one of the first things that Team USA did once in country… that and NOT capturing Osama bin Laden (woulda been too soon & messed up the whole cash cow thingie).
Crooks and drug dealers in the CIA????? I thought they had a screening process to keep that from happening.