The hurricane which became tropical storm Irene ended up doing more damage with its precipitation than it did with its winds. In parts of the East Coast, August was already the rainiest month on record prior to the storm. So the waterways were swelled and more prone to flooding. Apparently Vermont got some of the worst of it, with much of the state flooded. And the storm knocked out power to millions of residents as well. The death toll is at least at 21, and that could rise.
So even though the storm dissipated as it moved up the coast, it was still a powerful and destructive force that required a strong federal response, something that would be unquestioned unless your name is Ron Paul. And chief executives of both parties praised that emergency management effort from FEMA.
When asked by ABC’s “This Week” host Jake Tappper whether there’s anything that New Jersey needs from the federal government that it hasn’t been getting, Gov. Chris Christie (R-N.J.) replied, “Not at this point.”
“We have FEMA representatives here at the Regional Operations and Intelligence Center [who have] been working with us. I’m going to be calling [Homeland Security] Secretary Napolitano in an hour or two to make a further request of additional needs. But so far, FEMA has been very responsive,” said Christie.
On NBC’s “Meet the Press,” Gov. Martin O’Malley (D-Md.) also had nothing but praise for the federal response [...]
“Craig Fugate and the people at FEMA, Secretary Napolitano and President Obama — they have been excellent,” said O’Malley. “They have been with us since day one, and actually, before the storm arrived, they were here, and it’s worked really, really well. This is a much better FEMA than the olden days.”
O’Malley was referring to the “olden days” of the Bush administration, when FEMA became a national joke under Michael Brown, who oversaw the agency during Hurricane Katrina. Brown — who embellished his resume to get the high-profile job — and other Bush administration officials were harshly criticized for failing to respond to the devastating storm.
It’s early in the recovery and rescue effort, so this is obviously subject to change. But FEMA has become a very functional agency over the last few years under the direction of Craig Fugate. It never should have unraveled, given the simplicity of the task – provide resources, distribute resources, help the state and local responders. But what we know is that emergency management has not given way to sloth or corruption, and they are performing their duties competently. This is about the least we can expect from our government, but they are passing the test.
A few more things to say about that. For FEMA to keep up the response, they will probably need emergency funding to help out states devastated by the storm, and Eric Cantor has already signaled a fight on that, demanding cuts elsewhere to pay for hurricane relief. Next, the fact that our infrastructure is so brittle that a storm of any type knocks out power is a serious problem, and shows that the money “saved” from not addressing infrastructure is invariably spent later, at a higher cost. Finally, whether you think this Administration is doing a good job or not with emergency management may hinge on whether you think emergencies of this type are growing more frequent with the increase of climate change. Since we’ve made little movement on addressing that challenge over the last few years, it stresses agencies like FEMA that much more.





10 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
The RW commenters on various blogs are claiming that FEMA wasn’t necessary because Irene turned out to just be a Category I and didn’t live up to the hype.
But I think those millions of folks without power, or in towns with rivers filling the main streets–and their downstairs–might beg to differ. Of course, since they’re without electricity, they can’t comment right now.
Just another way to insist (1) the government can’t possibly work and (2) Pres. Obama can’t possibly do anything right. (you don’t have to be an Obamabot to acknowledge the areas of competence. I’m frustrated as anyone with him on a host of issues, but on this issue, he has done just fine).
Well yeah, a strong response in the center of Richandwhiteville. If Irene hit where Katrina hit, the government could have saved millions.
Its nice to see what a federal agency can do when its not run by political cronies. Now if we can just get rid of the Bushies still in the WH and Neo Hoovers Obama hired we might actually get a functioning government.
The fact that the republicans are talking about the lack of need for a federal response to ANY kind of domestic problem (Not counting widespread opposition to policy) is an indication of just how badly Obama has abandoned the playing field to them.
I disagreed with the hype about Irene being a monster storm-threat, but there is a clear need for federal assistance in some areas of her path. That some republicans can speak out against that assistance with such impunity simply points to their belief that they can use Obama to further empower the corporate ownership and control of the U.S. Government…
and as far as I can see, they’re right. Statements like this should be great campaign fodder for Obama and the democratic “leadership” in 2012.
How many people here think they will be?
Thanks. I don’t think so either.
I’m not sure how it works in the Northeast, but I think the Millions without power will be helped by private industry, not FEMA or the federal government.
As far as infrastructure is conserned, I think that’s owned by the utilities too. Should the utilities get govrenment hand-outs to upgrade infrastructure in order to save money later?
And then there’s the question of brittleness. When trees blow down on overhead power lines, they break. Not because they’re brittle, but because they’re vulnerable. It’s the most cost effective way to run electricty. We could trench them all underground, but it’s very expensive and hard to expand.
It is mostly that way in the NE. For example, Con Edison is the much loved power company in NY.
Not about FEMA specifically, but about a local government, my sister reports from just outside Boston:
I too did just fine. Never lost my power or cable (but some in Somerville did). It was a tropical storm by the time it got here and the worst part went through western Mass. The only damage was a HUGE limb mostly came down on the tree in front of my next door neighbors. Less than an hour after the storm, the police came by, called it in (as a non power event), 10 minutes later a cherry picker came by, the limb was cut off, pushed to the side and this morning they came by with a chain saw and its gone.
I know I have mentioned it before but I have been very impressed with the City of Somerville. I get “robo-calls” at least once a week informing me of construction and alternate routes, big events (4th of July fireworks locations and traffic changes), and major storms. They let folks know when the worst part of the storm was projected, who to call in case of emergency, etc.
Glad to hear that everyone made it through just fine!
Gee, sometimes Federal Agencies do pretty good work when they’re not run by a bunch of flunkies from the frat house.
I would just like to say one thing in support of the pre-Hurricane warnings, etc.
I won’t defend the likes of CNN and TWC in hyping the storm, but I would say that the real professionals at the NWS and the National Hurricane Center did as good a job as the science allows them to.
After Irene left the North Carolina coast with barely hurricane winds as a weak category 1 storm, the interior pressure of the storm was c. 950 mbs, the average pressure for a category three hurricane. And that causes alarm with the forecasters.
The impact of the storm was difficult to predict as a result of those readings. There has been much discussion amongst the professional meteorologists as to perhaps redefining a storm’s severity differently than just using windspeed categories.
Eric Cantor is a combination of George W. Bush and Dick Cheney…he’ll sit idly by for seven minutes while people are dying around him then shoot any survivors in the face.
Regarding FEMA, Cantor is just doing a right-wing hit-job variation of what Bush and his administration did during, and in the recovery period after, Hurricane Katrina. To put it simply, FEMA funding was not an issue, but for political reasons the Bush administration deliberately withheld federal disaster aid from Louisiana and the flooded New Orleans in that first critical, deadly week after Katrina made landfall six years ago, making a desperate situation even worse, primarily so that a right-wing smear campaign being waged against Louisiana’s Democratic Party governor, Kathleen Blanco, and New Orleans’ mayor, Ray Nagin, would work better. Remember the right-wing talking point rolled out during those first few days? Look, Gov. Blanco (D-LA) is incompetent. She didn’t ask for federal disaster assistance before Katrina hit (a lie). Mayor Ray Nagin is incompetent, too, right-wingers proclaimed. But then people started to notice the absence of federal disaster assistance in Louisiana (and New Orleans), so this Republican political strategy by the Bush administration backfired, casting them as the incompetent ones, the uncaring ones.
But wasn’t it all FEMA’s fault, with FEMA responsible for federal aid not reaching U.S. citizens stranded and abandoned in Louisiana and New Orleans? This is another right-wing diversionary lie. Before Katrina hit, FEMA disaster coordinators were sent to the three states in Katrina’s projected path, Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama. Has anyone ever heard of any complaint about FEMA’s actions in Mississippi and Alabama? Oh right, these two states had Republican governors, thus they got everything they needed in the way of federal disaster assistance. In fact, much of the federal aid intended for Louisiana and New Orleans was diverted to Alabama and Mississippi, making the FEMA disaster coordinator stationed in Baton Rouge LA quite frustrated and angry, from what I heard. Thus, what happened in post-Katrina Louisiana, specifically post-levee-break New Orleans, was a deliberate political ploy by high-level Republicans in the Bush administration, a plan to build-up the image of Republicans while trashing the image of Louisiana Democrats.
Then there was the recovery period (which is still ongoing). Foreign countries offered tens of billions of dollars (as well as offers of personnel and equipment) to help the U.S. with recovering and rebuilding from Katrina, but the Bush administration turned down their offers. Instead, the Bush administration got the Republican-controlled Congress to allocate close to $200 billion of taxpayer money to cover post-Katrina expenses. The Bush administration then took this taxpayer money and awarded a whole lot of no-bid contracts to crony Republican companies, no Democrats nor Democratic-owned companies need apply. Ohhh, that’s why the Bush administration turned down all that foreign assistance. This would have interfered with their giving all this taxpayer money to fellow Republicans. Some accountability from foreign governments might have occurred if this foreign assistance had been accepted.
Eric Cantor is part of this corrupt Republican culture. He is just continuing the foul legacy of the Bush/Cheney years. Everyone else must fend for themselves, while Republicans take care of the wealthiest and the corporations.