Gilad Shalit, the Israeli Defense Forces soldier who has been under the control of Hamas since 2006, may be freed in a prisoner exchange deal, according to multiple officials.
Officials in the Prime Minister’s Office said that “a brief window of opportunity has been opened that would possibly lead to Gilad Shalit’s homecoming,” adding: “The window appeared following fears that collapsing Mideast regimes and the rise of extremist forces would make Gilad Shalit’s return impossible.”
The officials’ comment came following a report by Al-Arabiya, according to which a deal has indeed been reached between Israel and Hamas geared at the release of the IDF soldier, in Hamas captivity since 2006.
After an emergency cabinet meeting, the deal was made official. In exchange for the release of Shalit, Israel will release a thousand Palestinian prisoners, including reportedly Marwan Barghouti, a leader of the First and Second Intifadas and a major figure in Fatah.
If released, t’s possible that Barghouti could become the figure that unites Hamas and Fatah, rather than Mahmoud Abbas. He ran in the Palestinian Authority Presidential elections back in 2005 before withdrawing in favor of Abbas. But now, Barghouti has a new political party called al-Mustaqbal, and he could be a force in Palestinian politics. The accusations of terrorism from the Israelis would presumably make it very difficult for them to deal with Barghouti as a partner, however.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu did not confirm the release of Barghouti, only that Shalit would be home “in the coming days.”
Notably, Egypt brokered the deal, proving that they remain a force in Middle East politics even after the revolution.
If Barghouti were included it would represent a possible sea change in Palestinian politics. If not, it’s still an example of the two sides actually working together on something, even if only a prisoner swap.
UPDATE: Israeli media now reporting that Barghouti is NOT in the deal.




12 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
5000+ palestinian pristoners including children
Targeting Silwan’s children | Dec 2010 report by @jilldamours about Israeli occupier jailing kids http://t.co/hGpo0FNc
Forgive me if I don’t care about one soldier- not a civilian, a valid target.
He was kidnapped after Israel shelled a family having a picnic on the beach, it killed 8 except for one litte girl. Afterward, Israel bombed the Gaza power plant and shut off water and fuel. This followed a tightening of the siege where the rockets had stopped but Israel didn’t honor it’s side of the bargain in easing the conditions of the siege. They cut the fishing territory down to 5 miles, when under fatah 10 was allowed, but oslo requires 20. it caused a collapse of the fishing industry and added to the hunger and suffering.
Marwan Barghouti is a political prisoner. A jewish Israeli man was his lawyer, the one busted for leaking secrets to Richard Silverstein while working for the FBI, said Barghouti is such a moral giant he reminded him of moses.
Forgive me if I don’t care about one soldier- not a civilian, a valid target.
O_O
What should Hamas do, kill him, chop his head off and parade it around?
It’s too bad the deal does not (apparently) include Barghouti. That would be a major move on Israel’s part. It would mean they’re abandoning Abbas, because Barghouti would be the defacto leader as soon as he reached Ramallah. He has the credibility to sell a peace agreement to Palistine, even if it contains compromises on Jerusalem or the Right of Return.
Boxturtle (Which is why Israel fears him so much)
Were I Hamas, I’d have already traded him for a few truckloads of cement and 2×4′s. Don’t need the hassle of a prisoner, don’t want Israel to have another excuse to come to Gaza and make the rubble bounce.
Yeah, the prisoner exchange is good value for Hamas. But you’re not going to get all your prisoners freed until there’s a peace deal. And my bet is that a majority of the prisoners Israel releases are locked up again before a year is out.
Boxturtle (IMO Gaza needs building materials more than fighters)
Quite the idea, it would also gain Hamas some sympathy points.
Israel prolly can’t release Barghouti. He’s prolly been tortured and Israel wouldn’t want to sully its pristine reputation by having him tell that to the world.
Now, eCAHN, we know that israel and the idf always take the high ground. How could you possibly even entertain the idea of them torturing someone.
BTW, Ms. BearCountry and I feel that DN has changed. There is still some good coverage of stories, but Amy seems to shy away from some themes. It is hard to put it into words, but we don’t listen as much as we used to.
I think refusing to release him has more to do with his being an effective leader than anything he might say about prison conditions. I remember reading an article in Foreign Affairs about 11 years ago characterizing him as a rising young star in Fatah. I wondered then how long he’d stay out of jail – it wasn’t long.
Interesting about democracynow. I hadn’t noticed.
I am doing less online in general. It’s getting harder to find sites where I learn stuff.
In Haaretz, We have in Israel a major media farther to the left than any media in the US or in Brittan, http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/israel-hamas-reach-gilad-shalit-prisoner-exchange-deal-officials-say-1.389404, yet it is not source for most FDL reports – curious.
Bibi had Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman voting no against the deal along with ministers from his Yisrael Beiteinu party, with several Likud ministers in opposition to freeing terrorists in exchange for Shalit. But the deal was approved with Twenty-six ministers voting in favor of the deal, and three ministers – Foreign Minister Avigdor Lieberman, National Infrastructure Minister Uzi Landau of Yisrael Beiteinu and Vice Prime Minister Moshe Ya’alon of Likud – voting against the proposal.
Egyptian officials have also said that the deal also includes accused Israeli spy Ilan Garpal.
The initial phase will see the release of 450 Palestinian prisoners, including 280 with life sentences, with 110 prisoners released to their homes in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, out of whom 55 are Hamas men, with the rest belonging to Fatah and the other Palestinian groups. Released into Gaza will be 131 Gaza residents, many of whom are reportedly top Hamas operatives.
There will be 203 prisoners expelled from the West Bank, 40 of whom will be deported overseas and the rest to Gaza.
In addition, 6 Israeli Arab prisoners who have been serving for many years will also be released to their homes. The deal also specifies the release of 27 female inmates: terrorists Ahlam Tamimi and Amna Muna will be deported, with the rest of the female inmates are expected to be released to their homes.
The second wave of releases will take place in two months time, at which point Israel will release 550 prisoners of its choosing.
Reality has no bearing on your post. Check out what Human Rights Watch has to say about Shalit:
http://www.hrw.org/news/2010/06/25/gaza-allow-access-gilad-shalit
Are you going to claim that Human Rights Watch is a “Zionist” organization? You can also check out Amnesty International.
Perhaps you prefer Hamas’ take on the death of bin Laden: “If the news is true, then we consider it a continuation of the American policy based on oppression and bloodshed against Arabs and Muslims,”“We condemn any killing of a holy warrior or of a Muslim and Arab person and we ask God to bestow his mercy upon him.”
— Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh
Or their take on 9/11 and the fact that Hamas leaders issued statements praising 9/11 while the Palestinians celebrated the death of thousands of innocents
“Allah has answered our prayers,”
— Hamas minister Dr. Atallah Abu Al-Subh “To America,” September 13, 2001, Al-Risala.
Such a wholly disproportionate fuss about a single soldier, a corporal in the IDF captured by the enemy – yet still alive. Whilst 1400 civilians in Gaza lie dead, including over 300 children under the age of 16 and a hundred women, killed by the same IDF – allegedly in ‘self-defense’ during the infamous Operation Cast Lead.
Children who were evidenced as being burned to death by the illegal use of white phosphorus. Hundreds of innocent civilians butchered by a heavily armed attacking force during which many Palestinians were used as human shields. Documented evidence that cannot be erased by propaganda or discredited by those responsible. A terrible, terrible atrocity the perpetrators of which have to be examined by the ICC .
The power of Israel’s state propaganda in persuading the world to focus on just one single captured soldier whilst ignoring the hundreds of Arab civilians, women and children, killed in Gaza, as an act of collective punishment is not only extraordinary but unbelievable.
We know where is the US but where is the UN? Where are the 27 member states of the EU? Where are the voices of the democratic nations of the world?