A couple days ago, Dick Durbin was confronted by constituents in Illinois and forced to take a position on the uncontroversial values-based statement that said:
“Social Security and Medicare is based on a promise that if you pay in, you earned the right to guaranteed benefits… cuts to Social Security and Medicare will have a devastating effect on people and our communities… the revenue crisis should not be solved on the backs of seniors, people with disabilities, women and children.”
Cornered by activists, Durbin expressed support for those values, and said he was about to get on a plane to advocate for said values in Washington. Durbin pointedly wouldn’t sign a pledge expressing support for those values, however. Forty-eight activists were arrested at the rally after Durbin left. Here’s what Durbin said:
Durbin returned moments later to voice an endorsement for the values statement, pledging his support to oppose cuts to Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security.
“We’re in this together. We want to make Social Security longer and stronger. We’ve got to keep Medicare where it’s at and stay and stand by Medicaid,” said Durbin, who said the Republican Party believes “we are in this alone.”
It took Durbin all of two days to retreat to friendlier confines, where he made this statement of support for the fake Republican Super Committee offer to “raise revenues.”
Senate Democratic Whip Dick Durbin (Ill.) diverged from Democratic colleagues Wednesday and applauded the Republican offer to raise $300 billion in new taxes as part of a deficit-reduction deal.
Democratic members of the supercommittee on Tuesday had panned the GOP offer as insufficient.
Durbin, the second-ranking Senate Democratic leader, chose to focus on the positive and hailed the latest development as a “breakthrough.” He was worked on a massive deficit-reduction package for more than a year as a member of the Simpson-Bowles commission and the Senate’s Gang of Six.
“The fact that some Republicans have stepped forward to talk about revenue, I think, is an invitation for Democrats to step forward and talk about entitlement reform as well as spending cuts. Therein lies the core of an agreement,” Durbin said.
Let’s be very clear what Durbin was praising. The Republican offer on revenue is to cap deductions for the wealthy, which charitable media outlets are calling a “net increase” in revenue of $300 billion. But the condition the Republicans have laid out is a permanent extension of the Bush tax cuts, which would actually cut taxes overall from current law by $3.6 trillion. So their big “concession” is a giveaway of $3.3 trillion in tax cuts. And according to some reports, it’s worse than that: the plan would CUT the top marginal tax rate from 35% to 28%.
Democrats on the committee saw right through this and immediately turned down the offer. “I have yet to see a real, credible plan that raises revenue in a significant way to bring us to a fair, balanced proposal,” said the co-chair of the committee, Patty Murray, who presumably knows what’s been offered.
And Durbin lauds it! And says that it gives an opening – demands a response – for Democrats to submit a plan on “entitlement reform.” This comes TWO DAYS after he told activists in the streets in Chicago that “We want to make Social Security longer and stronger. We’ve got to keep Medicare where it’s at and stay and stand by Medicaid.” I know his conception of making Social Security longer and stronger probably means cutting benefits through chained CPI. But there’s not a lot of wiggle room on the other two points.
Of course, Republicans seized on this weakness from the member of the Democratic Senate leadership. “My view is exactly the view Sen. Durbin expressed,” Lamar Alexander (R-TN) said to reporters.
We learned this week that the current, meager social safety net for seniors is not enough to keep a substantial chunk of them out of poverty. To Durbin, the way to strengthen these safety net plans is to enter into a bargain with Republicans, apparently one of slashing this safety net further for massive tax cuts. Not one Democrat bought the nonsense that the GOP was willing to “talk about revenue” when they put out this sham proposal. Only Durbin.
At least Joe Lieberman had the decency to retire.
UPDATE: Here’s the walkback:
“Something I said this morning may have been slightly misconstrued. Here’s what I stand by: I believe the fact that Republicans have mentioned the word “revenue” is a breakthrough. Now, I have not endorsed their proposal, nor do I think it’s the endgame by any means. But the fact that they have put revenues on the table is an important step forward.”
Quite a low bar for a “breakthrough,” ay?





67 Comments


Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
dick durbin is a f@#cking weasel. he talks out of both sides of his mouth. he LIES. he’s lost my (formerly democratic) vote.
VOTE GREEN!!!!!
And Dick Durbin fucking over the Dem base, poor and old people, workers, etc., is news…why?
FUCK DICK DURBIN.
. . . one can almost smell the corrupted, putrified empty shell of a soul. Problem is, of course, he’s not unique.
So you’re telling me that Dick’s a dick. I already knew that.
Yes…he has been getting away with it for a long time….it’s good that people are finally taking notice,but this guy has been behind the scene helping to fuck ordinary Americans a good long time now.
Keep voting for ‘em & they are going to keep effing ya,no ands ifs or buts.
The Dems are just as destructive to ordinary Americans as the GOP.
I get Durbin emails asking for support. The name of my game is reciprocity, which puts Dick in an awkward position to ask for anything.
Why not call Social Security cuts Social Security Cuts ? I mean, they are what they are. Same with Medicare. If these critters are going to cut Meidcare, they should just come right out and say it.
A lot of moderate-to-low information voters don’t know what ‘entitlement reform’ means, though it probably sounds kinda good. Everybody knows what a ‘cut’ is.
Republicans: We’re never gonna raise revenues by taxing the rich.
Democrats: We’ve had a breakthrough! They said “raise revenues”!
What a fucking joke.
man, i’ll say it again
anybody who thinks obama and the democrats are on the american people’s side is just nuts
the democrats are at least as craven and corrupt as the gop but the democratic party’s marketing apparatus knows enough to tell the sellouts to drop a bon mot every so often to keep the rubes on the hook
obama wants this deal MORE than the republicans and the democrats just want a fig-leaf that passes the straightface test with the dc bubble boys in the msm
If it ain’t in writing…
The left must stop implying that there is ANY way for Medicare and SS to continue as they are.
Every honest analysis shows it is not possible even if the “rich” paid much more in taxes. Just
for perspective consider that they are only 234,000 who earn over $1 million and of those only
8,426 earn over $10 million. Way too few to cover health care and retirement for the other
308,000,000!!!!! No one wants to throw the old and poor over the cliff, but to protect the
programs for the future they MUST be adjusted to reflect the changing actuary information.
If Obama had honorable intentions to reduce the deficit, he would have supported the Simpson/Bowles
plan a year ago and America would have been spared this circus. As of now his only strategy for
reelection is to have the committee fail so he can continue blaming the Repubs for his failed agenda.
“We’re in this together.”
Right. Durbin does not work for the constituents who asked him to sign the pledge. He works for the constituents who give him the money he needs to get elected. That he would not sign the pledge should have told the imagined constituents all they needed to know. He gave no promise. He only gave pretty words that allowed him to escape.
Just think, there’s only 51 more weeks for Democratic pols to keep snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.
I hope the hill and district staff of House & Senate Dems have their resumes up-to-date. So too with White House staffers. I’m pretty sure that the law firm of Obama & Obama can’t hire them all back in 2013.
The first rule of political speech: Whatever is said in public, the opposite is true.
The easy solution to keeping social security in the black, till forever, is to raise the cap on wages paid into the social security fund/account.
Absolutely fair and simple. And easy, if it were in the minds if the politicians to do so.
So who should die then ?
What should we expect from “no vote from me for the healthcare bill unless it has a public option” Durbin? I hope he gets detailed, microscopic, intense, every one of his moves, media coverage on this issue.
Reposting my list of current elected officials who have signed on to the OWS principles and have returned their Corp donations.
1.
2.
3.
Please feel free to add any I missed
When con artists play 3-card Monte, they need an “outside man” to perpetuate the fraud. Call Durbin and the Democrats Mr. Outside.
Another solution is to pay back SS for all the times we stole from it in the past to augment the general fund.
It’s an insiders game so Wall Street and private insurers can steal the remaining big sources of public cash. Your acting as if we should take the little tweaks around the edges very seriously and ignore the larceny motivating “reformers” and destroyers.
And then the only way they can replenish the general fund is to quit playing their shell game with the tax cuts. You drive a hard bargain, BS.
I’d really like to know how in hell Mephistopheles keeps track of all his bargains. My guess is he hacked the Wall Street proprietary algorithms.
Funny you shoud say that.
I forgot to tell you the “FDD” bumper stickers came in yesterday. The T-shirts will be here on Tuesday.
As usual…you got ‘em all.
So, the only choice is to cut SS and Medicare? Are those the only two government programs that you’re aware of?
It’s not that complicated if you have Excel. Only 536 individuals to keep track of. Val-Pak has a data base of millions.
And….you can tell a politician is lying if his lips are moving.
I always liked THAT one.
You guys are “overreacting”.
He didn’t say “cut”. He said “reform”.
Military and subsidies: off the table.
Funny, I don’t feel reassured.
I’ll keep that in mind the next time I reform the lawn.
Low bar the guys a Mitt level flip flopper! Can we primary him :)
308 million people on SS and Medicare at the same time? I think not buddy. Nice try. Maybe you should read up on just how the programs work before you spew out falsehoods? Just a thought.
His name is DICK Durbin, I’m guessing?
REFORM is the Democratic Party’s favorite BIG LIE word. I may give them credit for nothing else, but I can credit the R’s for not lying about their plans to cut Social Security and Medicare if not eliminate them altogether.
The reason I will not be voting for Amy Klobuchar next November is that she’ll tell me she wants to “reform” but she absolutely refuses to go on the record about cuts.
I refuse to vote for someone who I know is trying to trick me and the very worst tricksters are the faux progressives like Durbin and Klobuchar.
We need federal ballot initiatives so when they screw us we can repeal what they did to us.
I hope he/she’s not an actuary!
ba-doom!
good one
well what do you expect from a Dick
I see Durbin is following the Hope and Change Campaign formula. Unfortunately, the definition of change is “flip flop”.
Dick Durbin before he…
love the way the dem leadership is praising and jumping on the media bandwagon on the vote in Ohio as if they had anything to do with it
What exactly are you talking about?
1. SS is solvent through 2038, and will be able to pay %80 for 75 years after.
2. Projected medical costs will blow up Medicare, but by then they will also bankrupt all the private insurance plans too. It is not a budget problem.
Actally I agree. You know that. The “wolves in sheep’s clothing” that pass as democrats are “more worser” than the dastardly, despicable, lying black-heareted bastards (TM) that ARE the republican party.
Valerie on Rev now saying O has huge approval among dems and blacks as proof that he has not lost his base. apparently she goes onto say he works up every day focused on the american people, focused on jobs, focused on fixing this country. LOL
Nice rim shot. We need audio…….. Any know how to load a .wmv file????
The Democratic Party’s role anymore seems to be to guarantee that there is no choice on the ballot.
as a chicago resident, i need one of those.
got one that says fuck rahm?
Durban– You want to talk about my retirement and my health care???!!
Let’s talk about yours then… I suggest that we make twenty times the amount of the cuts in legislator benefits that they do to us! How dare they destroy millions of peoples’ benefits that we’ve already paid for and need.
The whole freakin “political system” is rotten thru the core, as OWS and other Occupy movements already know. The question that remains is: can Americans, particularly twenty-somethings, thirty-somethings, and forty-somethings muster as much courage and fortitude as their counterparts in Tunisia, Egypt, Libya, Bahrain, Yemen, Syria, etc have shown in defeating this evil Wall-Street-CIA-Pentagon entity that controls the US Government?
responding to giatny, there is no actuarial table that describes, quantifies or measures our requirement to take care of our poorest citizens, its a choice we make as individuals and as a society – I know what choice you have made.
see : ‘lend a hand’ – the civilian conservation corps’ (chicago band, as opposed to the now extinct federal program) answer to the Democratic party’s moves to cut programs and benefits for poor and sick Americans – as they continue imperial wars and seek bailouts for banks and finance companies…“This song was written specifically as a reaction to the Democratic party’s embrace of the Republican program to dismantle Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid. I know that I have to lend a hand, with or without the traditional supporters of America’s poorest. Increase empathy – embrace action” – mkultra
http://acmeartscollective.com/acmerecords/2011/09/16/civlian-conservation-corps-demo-of-lend-a-hand/
Lemme see………
“Rahm is a bomb”
“Oh go away go away Emanuuel”
“We don’t need no stinking Rahms”
……..
……..
Here……
“Screw Rahm and the horse he rode in on”.
will that do?????
giving that the cia backed leaders are no in power in libya, egypt etc, i sure hope we can achieve much more than that
Awesome. Lemme know about price, sizes, shipping details.
~
or maybe :
Mayor 1% made $16.2 mil 3 years at an investment bank
Cool. Just like the TROJAN Toady in the Whitehouse, I now have another Dem to vote againt. Dick “‘Bleeding Heart Liberals’ need to take it up the ass” Durbin.
When you vote for the lesser of two evils, the result is still evil.
What do you mean by “At least Joe Lieberman had the decency to retire.” Joe Lieberman is the biggest slime ball around who happen to be still alive. Decency is not a word in his vocabulary. It will be a blessing to Americans if and when he retires.
To describe the reality of corrupt American political system, here are prophetic words of GEORGE CARLIN:
George Carlin – “The American Dream”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsL6mKxtOlQ&feature=player_embedded
Must be something in the water in Illinois. Or is it in the Democratic Party conference room in DC?
That’s funny.
Daley’s ghost in the machine.
Occupy the A-holes office.
He once admitted that bankers own the senate. Now he is proving it.
Congratulations Dick! You’re our Rotating Villain of the week!
As an Illinois resident, I think that the one thing that Durbin has consistently demonstrated for the last two years, is that he is the WH’s whip(ping boy) in the Senate.
He is not playing a rotating villain. Durbin will always have Obama’s back. Always. Even to his own detriment.
More on #N17
Just when it looked like the Democrats were solid and strong holding out for “Real” revenues from Republicans … Durbin hands the GOP this huge gift on a golden platter.
Why doesn’t he just shut up.
How this idiot is next in line for Majority leader is beyond me!