A grand jury in Nevada yesterday indicted two title officers, Gary Trafford and Gerri Sheppard, on 606 counts of robo-signing between 2005 and 2008, a scheme that resulted in the fraudulent filing of tens of thousands of other documents with the Clark County register of deeds. This has the potential to be a groundbreaking case; it’s the first I can think of which actually indicts a robo-signer on criminal charges for fraud. And by going after the title officers, the Attorney General of Nevada, Catherine Cortez Masto, appears to be laying out a strategy to go up the chain and hollow out the entire industry and their illegal document fraud.
According to the Wall Street Journal, the two defendants were employed by Lender Processing Services, the leading foreclosure document processing company in the country, and one under a near-constant state of controversy over the past few years of the foreclosure crisis. In the indictment, Trafford and Sheppard are accused of directing fraudulent notarization and filing of foreclosure documents. This included having their employees forge Trafford and Sheppard’s names on the documents, typically Notices of Default, and then having them notarized. So in addition to a robo-signing scheme, where the notaries and affiants have no underlying knowledge of the documents, this was a forgery scheme. And banks filed these fraudulent documents with the country register of deeds, in violation of existing statutes under Nevada law. These are category C and D felonies, in addition to gross misdemeanors. One woman who worked with Trafford and Sheppard says she signed 25,000 Notices of Default this way.
Understand what was going on. In the interest of speed – and certainly not accuracy – Trafford and Sheppard had other people sign their name on legal documents, notarize them (attesting that the signature was legitimate and the content of which they had no knowledge was legitimate as well), and file them with the register. These are the documents that would be used to kick people out of their homes in Clark County, Nevada, where as many people have been foreclosed upon as anywhere in the country.
The district court judge in the case, Jennifer Togliatti, posted set $500,000 bail for each defendant. Trafford and Sheppard have not yet been arrested, however, according to Masto’s office. A different judge, Carolyn Ellsworth, will hear the case.
LPS hasn’t been indicted, but you can see where this is going. We know enough now to know that this casual forgery and document fraud was official policy for the company. Indictments of Trafford and Sheppard will almost certainly not end there. Everyone who worked for LPS in Nevada will be culpable. Yves Smith writes that busting the low-level managers has ripple effects:
On the one hand, this indictment is not as gratifying, say, as busting Angelo Mozilo. On the other hand, if low level supervisors in bank frauds face the risk of serving time, you are going to find a ton fewer people willing to take that job. Those higher up on the food chain might also have to be a lot more careful and pay the people involved more money, which in turn undermines the basic logic of these abuses, which is cost savings.
In addition, as mob prosecutions have shown again and again, you start by going after the foot soldiers in the hope that they roll people higher up on the food chain.
And at a minimum, this action says that the law and due process matter, and violations, particularly large scale, systematic violations, can and will be punished.
The fact that they are LPS employees also suggests this is just a first step. This could be a way to get at the software that LPS uses to create documents, which would prove pattern and practice. LPS was central to the entire robo-signing scheme across foreclosure mill law firms and mortgage servicers. And they consistently maintain that they worked at the direction of the servicers and with their full knowledge. So that ropes in the servicers as well.
This is a very important indictment, and it shows how methodical Masto has been about going after widespread industry abuse. It’s only just beginning, but bravo for her.
The full indictment is here.




39 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Can one hope for a cascading effect here?
Also I wonder what sort of hold harmless policies were in place between these individuals and their employer. That would not relieve criminal liability, but. . .?
My sister was a Notary. According to her, the built in punishments for Notary fraud are worse than for the people who originated the documents.
If this is true, the people with that Notary seal are in serious trouble.
2005, 2008?
Better late than never?
Sorry, but I don’t see this going anywhere substantive.
I hope I’m wrong.
But if it takes this long to go after the low-hanging fruit, then the rest is highly dubious.
I hope I’m wrong.
You echo my thoughts. While it’s clearly worthwhile going after title officers who engaged in such fraud, my take is also one of disgust bc clearly they are going after the small fry 99%ers.
We have yet to hear one peep about anything resembling “justice” in terms of the 1%er massive fraud, crime & rip-offs at the Banks or Wall St.
Hooray for such as this, but really, it’s pretty pathetic, to say the least. I also won’t hold my breath for much more of the same and/or for any real regulations that would, you know, prevent future/further criminal fraud activities like this (and more).
Thanks for the post, though. Good to have the update.
Agree. These people are the Lyndy Englands of this crime spree. No doubt the MSM will make big news of people going to jail but they are just 99%ers and gladly abandoned by the 1% as fodder for the gullible.
LOL how many years to investigate that they were signing multiple docs. Are you kidding. That should have taken a few months.
Wealthy fund manager avoids felony charges after running over cyclist because of… wealth
“A fund manager for Smith Barney is getting off without felony charges after he allegedly ran over a cyclist with his Mercedes and fled the scene in Eagle, Colorado, because, the DA says, felony charges would be bad for the fund manager’s business.
Martin Joel Erzinger will not be charged with a felony because “Felony convictions have some pretty serious job implications for someone in Mr. Erzinger’s profession,” according to District Attorney Mark Hurlbert. ”
““Mr. Erzinger struck me, fled and left me for dead on the highway,” Milo wrote in a letter to the District Attorney. “Neither his financial prominence nor my financial situation should be factors in your prosecution of this case.”
“Milo suffered spinal cord injuries, bleeding from his brain and damage to his knee and scapula, according to court documents,” Randy Wyrick for reported Vail Daily. “Over the past six weeks he has suffered ‘disabling’ spinal headaches and faces multiple surgeries for a herniated disc and plastic surgery to fix the scars he suffered in the accident.””
““In other words, Erzinger has bought his way out of a felony charge, over the strenuous objections of his victim; it’s very unlikely that online petitions will do any good at this point,” Salmon observed. “Just another thing to add to the list of things that money can buy, I suppose.””
Thank you, DDay, for this post.
One hopes that you are correct, that this is building the case from the bottom …
One wonders further, though, if the statutes of limitation will kick in, just in time, to save those at the very “top” (from whom all trickles down, who are serviced by a political class (which includes the “media”) who have tossed out the Rule of Law and embraced, utterly and completely, the whim of tyranny …
DW
Of course it will, DW. the PTB will once again skate and be further emboldened. Huge amounts of campaign donations buy a lot of influence in this country.
There has *always* been one set of laws for the 1%, while the 99% have had to abide by the laws “on the book.”
It’s just becoming more & more obvious to the 99% how screwed up the system is, and how very very SCREWED the 99% is by the 1%.
Nothing new here, sadly, but glad to see the info getting out.
Did the judge post a $500,000 bail … or did they set bail at that level?
This judge didn’t put up the $1,000,000 to keep these two out, did she? Ordinarily I wouldn’t even bother to mention/ask something like this … but with the way things are these days, doesn’t seem that far-fetched any more.
Yes, I thought immediately about Ms. England in this context. Another 99%er who got screwed over whilst her supervisors, esp at the top of the chain of command, got off scott-free. And nary a peep about the unfairness of this in our propogandized 1%er owned “media.”
I think the judge assigns bail. I can not imagine she would have posted the bail that she assigned.
I think that what is “new” is that the truth you delineate has been known to some for many years, but it is now quite nakely obvious to the many.
The mask of tyranny has slipped and they do not even bother with the pretense, any longer.
What will happen, do you suppose when the inevitable (we must imagine) war with Iran begins?
Will the attacks on “the people”, whom this illegitimate governmnet increasingly identifies as the enemy, as “terrorists”, be intensified?
Will the economic screws be tightened, starting when the price of gasoline doubles …?
The elite have no idea, onitgoes, either of what they are doing or the consequences they will, sooner rather than later, most definetly, be facing.
The power- and money-maddened few will play out their violent and destructive hand, for ultimately, brute force is all they know … as they imagine that limitless warfare, at home and abroad, will ensure their deadly rule.
Perhaps, after some ten thousand years of such a pattern, humankind has, at last, had enough?
DW
But don’t worry… if this threatens to make meaningful waves someone in the DOJ or higher will interfere.
Here in Florida, I am on the front lines of the fraudclosure crisis as I defend clients whose homes are in foreclosure. My opinion is the indictment is the beginning of something very substantive. These folks will be “flipped” and will spill the beans on what will prove to be a criminal enterprise. LPS documents were used throughout Florida.
I think it must be hard for people to imagine the level of denial (cover up) that exists in the court system here in Florida concerning these false documents. Only one elected county clerk out of the 67 here in Florida has dared to bring a suit for the failure to pay clerks fees on the fraudulent documents. None of the State Attorneys here ( our elected criminal prosecutors,) have acted against this fraud. Our AG is a close confident of the indicted LPS. The Governor and the Legislature are trying to move to enact a nonjudicial foreclosure system so that the Banks won’t have to comply with the laws regarding affidavits. Senior judges collect their daily $300 dollar paycheck for rubber stamping the Banks requests, (I had a judge sleeping during a hearing yesterday while I argued my motion three feet away) So the fact that an outsider (the AG of Nevada, ) has shined a massive light on the problem, (606 counts!!!) on a Florida based criminal enterprise, should cause every news outfit here in Florida to cover the story. Criminal indictments are significant and prosecutors tend to be followers not leaders when it comes to breaking new ground (former prosecutor here,) . Our AG after this should not be able to run away from the obvious festering fraud no matter how many people she fires and perhaps even our Supreme Court will stop turning the other way. Lastly, maybe someone could clue the President that a crime has been committed.
Hope you are right but what is the statute of limitations that would apply to top tier banksters if it were found they ordered these fraudulent signings?
We did what?
Prove it!
That’s what the higher ups will say.
They will tie up in the courts.
Or use statute of limitations BS.
Or use their connections.
And of course the old American past time: can’t beat ‘em, buy ‘em.
Ya I’m cynical. Can you blame me?
I hope I’m wrong.
Seems the Statute of Limitations ran out on 24,394 instances.
Though an ‘outsider’, in 2008 she created the Mortgage Fraud Strike Force in her office to investigate and prosecute fraudulent foreclosure rescue and loan modification scams.
Not that it’s relevant, but she’s married to a retired U.S. Secret Service Agent.
http://www.catherineforag.com/about/
Cynical is a sane state of mind today.
Heard that.
No, tambershall, you are not being cynical, you are realistic.
The true and vicious cynicism is manifest in the behavior of those who “game” the sytem and have destroyed the Rule of Law … hoping to convince all of humanity that the rest of us are as uncivilized, as grasping, and as ruthlessly greedy and destructive as are they.
DW
Agree; a true cynic is someone who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing.
The indictment was under Nevada law, I have no idea what their SOLs are. Here in Fla. for a first degree felony , four years, third degree three years, first degree misdemeanor two years. Case involving fraud, up to one year after the fraud is discovered and possibly up to three years.
I would be satisfied if the prosecutors got the corporate executives of LPS DOCX, the Law Firms the Lawyers, as well as the small fry who had to know that they were committing fraud (essentially the robo signers were saying they were v.p. of BOA by day and a hair dresser at night.) As far as getting top tier bankers, I always thought the way to them is securities fraud which I would bet has a lot longer SOL ( I never practiced Federal criminal law.) You could probably throw in a federal rico act also to get them. The more significant the crime the greater the SOL .
What don’t the PTB’s understand about JUSTICE. This 2003 article shows that even monkeys understand justice. What does that truly say about the powers that be???
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/3116678.stm
The more siginificant the crime … the more likely that political wisdoms will annouce that, “looking forward, policy differences should not be criminalized …”
One imagines that the Big Boyz and Gurlz will simply ” … have done nothing illegal … at the time.”
This is not cynicism, merely a realistic assessment of recent American History … which, “looking forward”, is relatively easy to predict … in the absence of an effective Rule of Law and with an expedient and “astute” embrace of the whim of tyranny – remember, we now have a President who claims the “right” to kill anyone, any time, or at any place … without the messy encumbrance of due process.
Nonetheless, one hopes that you shall be proved correct, BlueFloridian … eventually. One way or another … justice MUST prevail and live, else civil society shall perish and truth will be simply the lie of the day.
DW
But, they were just following orders.
Besides O said they did nothing illegal.
I believe what he said was that “much” of what they did was legal. While seemingly providing an out, it assumes the viewer/reader will fail to realize that MUCH and ALL are not synonyms! Even if MUCH was legal, that means that SOME was illegal. Then the question becomes: why are we (our U.S. DOJ) not prosecuting the illegalities, even though they be a minority of the evil actions?????
The interference is on-going. Pressure has been put on the Attorneys General who are demanding a complete investigation of bank crimes before a general settlement is agreed to. The argument of people like Eric Schneiderman (NY), Beau Biden (DE) and Catherine Masto (NV) is that it is impossible to set the proper penalties for a settlement or know which specific liabilities to waive before anyone has even determined which crimes have been committed and to what extent.
The Obama admin is hoping to sweep this one under the rug for its bankster friends as quickly and cheaply as possible. The problem is that these crimes are big ones. Felony perjury and document fraud are just the tip of the iceberg.
From June of this year:
“Top officials in the Obama administration, like Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, have said they want a quick settlement, too. Bank regulator Sheila Bair, the chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, told a Senate panel last month that a settlement must be reached due to “significant” damages the banks face from “flawed mortgage banking processes [that] have potentially infected millions of foreclosures.”"
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/06/06/foreclosure-fraud-20-billion_n_872207.html
I’m an idiot, the right word is “set.”
You sir are NOT an idiot. Keep up the good work.
But as a friend told me when I tried to explain why I wouldn’t buy a foreclosure, even if it was cheap and I had the money:
But, that’s why you get Title Insurance! If you have Title Insurance, there’s no problem.
GAH! What _do_ you do with NPR dittoheads that don’t want to be disillusioned?
Walk away Diva walk away!
I wonder if this administration can come up with some more reforms. The foreclosure fraud is above 20 billion.
While I am far too cynical about pretty much everything, I have to wonder if this will end up as a RICO action. LPS was involved in a multi-state fraudulent document scheme and there may be other investigations going on. I know for sure that AG Lisa Madigan here in Illinois has a specific investigation going regarding LPS.
I think we’ll start seeing different things now that the MSM (or LSM if you prefer) has started running stories, regardless of their slant. There really is no way to positively spin the vast majority of the criminal activities involved.
I agree – but we finally are getting people – and not companies – into the courthouse. I think that is a great change as few companies ever spend a day in jail! :-)
Indeed people do the crime, not companies. I hope this DA realizes these low level 99%’ers had bosses that told them what to do, and therefore cuts them a deal in exchange for their testimony against the bosses.
Good grief – you are not an idiot -
I look back on many of my own posts and find I “thought” many words that my hands forgot to type – making for a nonsense post.
Your slip did not screw up the information conveyed as it was easily understood.
Stay in there fighting! :-)
I was afraid you’d say that.
It really sucks that some of my dearest friends are NPR dittoheads.
*sigh*