The New York Times Magazine has a great piece today on hydraulic fracturing and the state where I was born, Pennsylvania, home to the Marcellus Shale region and a lot of fracking activity. The story focuses on Amwell Township, in Southwest Pennsylvania, and the toll that fracking has taken on this Appalachian community.
About five years ago, leases began to appear in the mailboxes of residents of Amwell Township from Range Resources, a Texas-based oil company seeking to harvest gas through hydraulic fracturing. “Fracking,” as it is known, is a process of natural-gas drilling that involves pumping vast quantities of water, sand and chemicals thousands of feet into the earth to crack the deep shale deposits and free bubbles of gas from the ancient, porous rock. Harvesting this gas promises either to provide Americans with a clean domestic energy source or to despoil rural areas and poison our air and drinking water, depending on whom you ask [...] What these companies paid was more than many people in Amwell Township, where the per capita income in the 2000 census was $18,285, were accustomed to seeing in their lifetimes, even if the windfall wasn’t the same for everyone [...]
At the fair, Haney ran into her next-door neighbor, Beth Voyles, 54, a horse trainer and dog breeder, who signed the lease with Haney in 2008. She told Haney that her 11 /2-year-old boxer, Cummins, had just died. Voyles thought that he was poisoned. She saw the dog drinking repeatedly from a puddle of road runoff, and she thought that the water the gas company used to wet down the roads probably had antifreeze in it [...] A month later, Haney’s dog, Hunter, also died suddenly. Soon after, Voyles called Haney to tell her that her barrel horse, Jody, was dead. Lab results revealed a high level of toxicity in her liver.
Read on to discover more about the continued animal kill and the diversity of opinion in this conservative region. Stacey Haney, referenced above, found her water unusable and her child sickened with arsenic, presumably coming from the water. The problem has as much to do with how to deal with the wastewater from fracking as the chemicals used in the process. For a few thousand in royalty checks, these residents are seeing a near total poisoning of their environment. And yet some in Amwell Township, motivated by that easy money or right-wing beliefs, still support fracking in their area.
The story notes that there was a planned vote coming this Monday by the Delaware River Basic Commission, composed of four states – Pennsylvania, New Jersey, New York and Delaware – and the federal government. The vote would be on rules governing fracking in the Delaware River Basin, which supplies the water supply for 15.6 million residents, including big cities like Philadelphia and New York. It would allow up to 300 gas wells in the sensitive environmental area. Delaware and New York planned to vote no, while New Jersey and Pennsylvania, governed by Republicans, were likely to vote in favor, certainly Pennsylvania. New Jersey has no fracking wells and would seemingly be motivated only by water quality, but Gov. Chris Christie has been noncommittal. It may have come down to the Obama Administration, specifically the US Army Corps of Engineers.
Via Maddowblog, it turns out that the commission postponed the vote indefinitely:
A multistate agency that has spent years developing regulations for natural gas drilling in the Delaware River watershed abruptly canceled a key vote scheduled for Monday after two members announced their opposition.
The Delaware River Basin Commission said Friday it was postponing a vote on hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, to give the agency’s five commissioners more time to review the draft regulations.
Incidentally, you’ll see the hand of Eric Schneiderman in this. He sued to try and force the commission to engage in an environmental impact study to test the kinds of environmental issues we’re seeing in Amwell Township.
This is a victory for environmentalists who wanted to stop the fracking regulations from taking effect. The commission wanted unanimous support and Delaware’s announcement guaranteed a close vote. If New York and Delaware continue to hold out this will be postponed indefinitely.




13 Comments

Support this site!
Subscribe to the newsletter
Advertise on Firedoglake
Send
us your tips
Make us your homepage
About FDL News Desk
Let me guess? Put off until after the election.
But, look at it this way, he is putting it off to avoid pissing off some constituency.
And what constituency might that be? Environmental groups.
If he planned on deciding in their (environmentalists) favor, in both the pipeline and this one, there would be no need to put off a decision.
However, if he was leaning toward deciding in favor of the pipeline and this, it makes great sense to put it off rather than piss off a big part of his base.
So, I don’t know if this is so much a victory.
This whole thing has been 30 years in the sneaky planning, including the Cheney energy thing which forbade regulating fracking (just like some laws deregulated derivatives and forbade any constraints on them). They invaded areas and have now gotten folks too pregnant with dividend checks. Slick piece of stuff — and government which is to protect us just did nothing, not anything.
For a few thousand dollars … and all you have to do is be slowly poisoned, and allow your children and family to be poisoned.
They’re literally taking money to be poisoned slowly.
Gee I wonder if that arsenic has any effects on children during the key years of their mental and physical development?
And the pregnant ladies in that area?
And not a single person will go to jail for it. Not one. It’s all legal. 100% legal. To poison people. And the environment.
When a country allows its own citizens to be poisoned for profit, … well … what can I say at this point? Words … got no words for it.
Nothing new. Same old thing as in the Gulf. Their children, and their families are being poisoned right now. And it will continue for decades as the oil that “magically disappeared” is no in the ecosystem, … dug in like an Alabama tick. Hope those parents don’t their children being poisoned during their key development years. Not that it matters if they do mind. It’s 100% legal. Seriously. No one will see jail time for it. Not now, and not in the future.
It’s just “good business”. It really is not personal. It’s pure amorality. They don’t care. Our families and children can all be slowly poisoned. We can die slow and painful deaths. We and our children can be homeless and starving on the streets. It doesn’t matter. Irrelevant. It’s just “good business”.
What could possibly go wrong?
Mic check coming suckers.
And all of this in the middle of a glut of produced natural gas. Every time I hear the meme of energy independence, I want to puke. Hypocrites and liars. China’s energy, drilled in PA and NY. For the NorthEast, this will become a “Chernobyl” of pollution related deaths and diseases. Where do those Wall Street natural gas traders think their fresh, clean water comes from, anyway. Not from wells in Manhattan! The very continued existence of plans to drill and frack is a gigantic fuck you to Americans everywhere.
Are the five commissioners 2 from NY against, 2 from PA for and the administration seat ready to drill our ass ?
0 controls the decision.
It’s disgraceful. We Americans are an embarrassment to humanity. I’m ashamed to be an American.
I agree with your take on this. It’s sad. But that’s what Obama does. First try to give “them” what they want. Then smell the winds for blowback. If there’s serious resistance, then punt. He is truly a reactionary.
Obama’s environmental record is atrocious. I’m surprised I don’t hear Obots addressing this. (Okay, I’m not really surprised.)
The remaining Obots are the True Believers, absolutely impervious to evidence and reason. This suspension of disbelief seems to a fundamental component of the partisan mindset in today’s America. It is a thought disorder that is inculcated, nurtured and manipulated by the 1% in control of both political parties.
Does the postponement of the vote mean that there will be no drilling or fracking in the interim, or only that there will be no regulations?
Heard that.
Every time I hear people chant “USA, USA, USA”, I am stunned. Every single time.
What the F are the cheering for? Dawg only knows.
Something smells in here, must be somebody passed gas.
Hard to follow this one -
They wanted to allow 300 wells with fracking on day one, and they give up their authority to the state where the well is being drilled so the state controls the rules except when the Commission rules are stronger.
But it is hard to find the “regulations”/rules that might be stronger proposed except for the 2010 version – http://www.state.nj.us/drbc/naturalgas-draftregs.pdf – so those rules may well be unchanged except for now explicitly saying they apply to exploratory wells. If the 2010 rules, there is a bond if things go wrong, rules as to how long bad stuff from drilling and bad stuff to do the drilling can hang around, and requirements for plans for various parts of the process for the commission to approve – but darned if I could find the basis/reason/measurement on which they would reject a plan.
The commission has the right idea as they state they worry about:
Gas drilling projects in the Marcellus Shale or other formations may have a substantial effect on the water resources of the basin by reducing the flow in streams and/or aquifers used to supply the significant amounts of fresh water needed in the natural gas mining process.
On-site drilling operations may potentially add, discharge or cause the release of pollutants into the ground water or surface water.
The recovered “frac water” must be treated and disposed of properly.
Hard to see how an impact statement could be done given the lack of detail in the proposed rules.